US government asks court to detain George Gibney until Irish extradition case is concluded
George Gibney
, was facing such serious criminal charges in
Ireland
he had an incentive to flee if granted bail and should remain in custody pending his extradition, the
United States
attorney for the Middle District of Florida has said.
In a submission to the United States district court in Orlando, Gregory W Kehoe has urged the court to deny Gibney (77) access to bail as 'he cannot meet his burden of showing that he poses no risk of flight or danger to the community'.
Gibney (77) was arrested in Florida on Tuesday on foot of an extradition request from Ireland, where he is facing 78 charges or indecent assault, and one charge of attempted rape. The alleged victims were aged between eight and 14 or 15 years when they say they were abused by Gibney, who was their swimming coach in South Dublin at different times between 1971 and 1981.
'Gibney is a flight risk and a danger to the community,' said the legal submission, obtained by The Irish Times, seeking his remand in custody in Florida until the extradition request has been full disposed of. 'As an initial matter, Gibney is alleged to have sexually assaulted at least four minor girls, abusing his authority as their swimming coach, over a period of several years. The seriousness of the offences for which Gibney is charged in Ireland heightens his risk of flight.'
READ MORE
George Gibney: why did it take decades for the alleged sexual abuser to face new charges?
Listen |
19:02
George Gibney was arrested on Tuesday in Florida after a Garda request was made to the US State Department to extradite him to Ireland to face charges relating to alleged historical child sex abuse.The 77-year-old former swim coach, who avoided trial on sexual abuse charges in 1994 after successfully challenging his prosecution in the High Court, is now accused of 78 counts of indecent assault and one count of attempted rape relating to four girls; and the alleged attempted rape of one of the girls.All four were minors, aged between eight and 15, and were coached by Gibney.They made complaints to the Garda between 2020 and 2022 after the BBC and Second Captains podcast Where is George Gibney? was aired in 2020.But why did it take over 30 years for Gibney to face fresh charges - and what happens next?Irish Times crime and security editor Conor Lally explains the background.Presented by Bernice Harrison. Produced by Declan Conlon
It said, in the case of elderly suspects facing extradition, their advanced years carries an additional incentive to flee in a bid to avoid justice. 'This is particularly true given that Gibney is more than 70 years old and thus faces the real prospect of spending the remainder of his life in jail,' the submission said.
It said the circumstances of Gibney previously avoiding going on trial in the Republic – in the 1990s – should also be taken into consideration and, it said, adds to the case for his being denied bail.
'In relocating to the United States after the first set of allegations was dismissed, Gibney was able to evade the investigation of these allegations in Ireland,' Mr Kehoe's submission states.' Accordingly, allowance of bail in any amount would not guarantee the fugitive's presence in court and would invite the possibility of embarrassing the United States in the conduct of its foreign affairs.
[
Why has it taken so long to arrest George Gibney in the US to enable extradition?
Opens in new window
]
'Either Gibney's danger to the community or flight risk would be enough, standing alone, for the court to deny any forthcoming application for bail.'
In 1993 Gibney appeared before the courts in Dublin charged with 27 sexual crimes. However, he took a High Court challenge to his prosecution and was successful. The court effectively ruled, in 1994, the allegations were too old, and many details too vague, to warrant a prosecution.
Gibney left Ireland, settling in the US in 1995, and remained there for the past 30 years, residing in Florida in recent years. However, between 2020 and 2022 the BBC published a podcast, Where is George Gibney? It prompted the four women now accusing him to come forward and give statements to the Garda.
A fresh criminal investigation was launched, with the DPP directing in May, 2023, he should face 79 charges. Last October the Irish embassy in Washington formally made a request to the US authorities to arrest Gibney for the purpose of extraditing to the Republic to stand trial. He was detained by US marshals in Florida on Tuesday and remains in custody there.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Judge upholds anti-immigration activist Philip Dwyer's conviction over trespassing
Philip Dwyer trespassed at a direct provision centre for International Protection (IP) applicants at Inch in Co Clare where residents were besieged by protesters outside the property, a court has heard. At Ennis Circuit Court on Monday, Judge Francis Comerford upheld the district court conviction imposed on Dwyer, a prominent anti-immigrant activist, for trespassing at Magowna House on May 18th, 2023. Described in court by his counsel Anne Doyle BL as a citizen journalist, Dwyer (56) of Tallaght Cross West, Tallaght, Dublin 24 was appealing the district court trespass conviction imposed in March. Judge Comerford also affirmed the district court fine of €500. Dwyer told the court he was at Magowna House to ask questions as a journalist. READ MORE The judge said Dwyer 'might be entitled to make inquiries and go to someone's door, but he went well beyond it here. I have to doubt about that'. At the time, there were protests at Magowna House, where 29 IP applicants were being accommodated and there were blockades on local roads, which were attracting media attention. Judge Comerford said a group of people came to seek refuge 'and were brought by the State to a relatively isolated, rural location where they were alone and away from a lot of resources and facilities'. 'And in effect, they were besieged in the premises they were brought to. It was made absolutely clear to them that they weren't welcome.' He said there were 30 or 40 people protesting their presence. Judge Comerford said the big difference between Dwyer and the protesters outside was that he came inside the property whereas the others did not. Judge Comerford said he accepted the evidence of the Magowna House manager at the time, Ahlam Salman, who said Dwyer's presence on the property made her feel 'afraid'. Video footage made by Dwyer was played to the court where he can be heard saying that he has arrived at a 'people trafficking centre'. In the footage,Dwyer can be heard saying 'These are all foreign people telling me what I can't do in my own country'. He addressed a Ukrainian man wearing a fluorescent jacket asking 'Do you think Irish people are stupid? Do you think we are all idiots? I wouldn't blame you to be honest with you.' After seeing some men, believed to be IP applicants, staying at the centre, Dwyer asks: 'Why are these people covering their faces . . . This is Ireland. This is my country.' Counsel for the State, Sarah Jane Comerford BL said to Dwyer that his words 'had a menacing undertone'. . In response, Dwyer said: 'I wasn't menacing to anybody.' He said: 'I 100 per cent stand over those comments. We all have to respect one another. I tried to be respectful when I went in there.' He said: 'I was treated very badly. I was treated with hostility … I felt quite intimidated as well. That is part of the job." 'I have thousands of viewers, sometimes hundreds of thousands.' Counsel for Dwyer, Anne Doyle BL, said she was not instructed by her client not to enter any mitigation concerning penalty. She said this was because 'my client stands by his actions',
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Teenager jailed for role in Tristan Sherry death further sentenced over sawn-off shotgun
A teenager jailed for violent disorder during the melee in which Tristan Sherry was beaten to death has been sentenced to a further three years and eight months in prison after he was caught 'red-handed' burying a sawn-off shotgun, ammunition and more than €55,000 worth of drugs for the Hennessy crime gang. The Dubliner (18), who cannot be named because he was a minor when he came before the courts, previously pleaded guilty to a number of offences at Tolka Valley Park, Blanchardstown, Dublin 15, on May 7th and 8th, 2024. Among the charges were possession of a side-by-side shotgun, possession of cannabis and diamorphine for the purpose of sale or supply to another and possession of a drug named phenacetin, in circumstances giving rise to the inference that it was connected to a drug-trafficking offence. He was also charged with the possession of ammunition. READ MORE Sentencing the youth to five years in prison with the final one year and four months suspended at the Special Criminal Court on Monday , Ms Justice Karen O'Connor said the defendantwas 'essentially caught red-handed'. However, she said the court had to be conscious of the evidence that he was 'acting under the influence' of others at the time who were 'no doubt older than him'. She also noted his pleas of guilty were mitigating factors in the case. The judge noted evidence at a previous sentencing hearing that the defendant had been acting 'at the behest of the Hennessy organised crime group'. She said the fact he was only 17 at the time was a 'significant factor' which the court had to consider. The judge noted the defendant had a 'challenging upbringing' and has been described as a 'vulnerable young man'. She said the sentence imposed on Monday would run consecutive to the jail term he is currently serving, meaning he will serve a total sentence of five years. The Special Criminal Court previously heard that on May 7th, 2024, an undercover drug unit in Blanchardstown observed the teenager digging in the ground. When the gardaí approached, they saw the butt of a shotgun sticking out of the earth. Eight drug packages wrapped in black clingfilm were beside the hole. The scene was preserved, and the following morning gardaí discovered further drug and ammunition packages. In a separate matter, the Special Criminal Court previously found the teenager guilty of violent disorder at Browne's Steakhouse in Blanchardstown on Christmas Eve, 2023. During a trial last year, the court heard that gangland figure Jason Hennessy snr was celebrating with about 30 people, including the defendant. Tristan Sherry and a second gunman entered the restaurant with their faces covered and hoods up. Hennessy snr suffered a fatal gunshot wound as he grappled with Sherry, but he managed to drag the gunman to the ground. Others in the party piled in on Sherry, stamping on his torso and head, stabbing him repeatedly and using various objects to beat him to death. Three people were convicted of murder arising out of the assault on Sherry. The defendant in this case initially hid under a table, but when he emerged he engaged in violence against Sherry for about five seconds.
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Garda whistleblower claims financial penalisation after voicing concerns about equipment
A senior Garda officer claims he has been financially penalised, with his pay cut by half while he has been on sick leave, because he made protected disclosures outlining concerns about Garda practices and equipment. Detective superintendent Brian O'Reilly has taken his case against An Garda Síochána (AGS) to Dublin Circuit Civil Court in a bid to have his full remuneration reinstated. He claims Garda Commissioner Drew Harris has breached protections for whistleblowers enshrined in legislation by penalising him after he had made protected disclosures. Det Supt O'Reilly claimed in his protected disclosure that leather holsters issued to gardaí for their firearms, made and supplied by an equine saddlery in Kildare, may have been responsible for the serious accidental self-wounding of a garda on protection duty. The injured garda was on duty at the residence of the Israeli ambassador in Dublin on June 11th, 2020. That incident was followed six days later by the murder of Detective Garda Colm Horkan, who was shot and killed by an individual who disarmed him by taking his gun from his holster. That person was later convicted of Det Garda Horkan's capital murder. READ MORE Rosario Boyle SC, appearing with Conor Duff BL, for Det Supt O'Reilly, on Monday told the court her client had suffered 'dire' consequences at such a large reduction in remuneration. This had resulted in difficulties paying his mortgage, it was claimed. His pay has been reduced to 50 per cent of what it ordinarily would be, as the illness that has forced him out of work is classified by AGS as an 'ordinary' sickness rather than 'injury from duty'. Ms Boyle said that in January, the gardaí's executive director, people and development, Yvonne Cooke, rejected Det Supt O'Reilly's application for his absence to be classified as 'injury from duty'. She did so on the basis of a report by a detective chief superintendent asked to investigate the cause of the illness-injury. She also considered the views of An Garda Síochána's chief medical officer. Conor Power SC, for the Garda Commissioner, told Judge John O'Connor there was no proof to suggest Det Supt O'Reilly's absence from work had been categorised in such a way because he made a protected disclosure. He said Det Supt O'Reilly's stance was 'this has been refused to me, therefore it's penalisation because I made a protected disclosure'. Judge O'Connor has said he will endeavour to deliver a judgment by the end of the month, with the case listed for mention on July 25th. Det Supt O'Reilly made his protected disclosure about the holsters in June 2021, saying he had 'ongoing significant concerns'. In the second half of 2022, he raised further concerns internally about plans for a 'defective' leather pistol holster to be tested by Garda armourers at the request of Garda Commissioner Drew Harris. Det Supt O'Reilly said he raised these concerns as he believed they were not qualified. He believed efforts were made to undermine him, including excluding him from decision-making, and to force him out of his position as acting head of the Garda National Technical Bureau. In late 2022, having placed a circular about 'defective' holsters on the Garda portal, he declined a request from management to withdraw it, he claims. In April 2023, Det Supt O'Reilly began a period of sick leave which, he says, was brought about because of his work. In July of that year, he was informed he was being placed under investigation for breach of discipline. This related to his claimed actions around the commission of a second report by Garda management on the leather pistol holster.
