German court dismisses Peruvian farmer's climate lawsuit against RWE
The upper regional court in Hamm rejected the argument by the farmer and mountain guide Saúl Luciano Lliuya that his home was at direct risk of being washed away by a glacial flood.
Lliuya initially filed a case against RWE in 2015, backed by the non-profit Germanwatch, to make the company contribute to local flood defences in line with its share of planet-heating pollution. The German electricity company is one of the world's biggest greenhouse gas polluters but has never operated in Peru.
Lliuya's case was at first thrown out by a lower court in Essen, where RWE is headquartered, but the appeals court in Hamm later found it to be 'admissible'. Climate campaigners hailed it as a development that would open the door for fossil fuel companies to be held liable in civil courts for global harms.
The court said it would not be possible for Lliuya to appeal against Wednesday's ruling.
Lliuya's home sits in the Andean town of Huaraz, large parts of which were wiped out in 1941 when Lake Palcacocha overflowed and triggered floods that killed thousands of people. A hearing in Hamm in March centred on the direct risk of a glacial lake outburst flood resulting in damage to Lliuya's property.
Climate campaigners have increasingly taken polluters to court for their role in heating the planet, several of which have resulted in courts ordering greater efforts to cut pollution.
Similar cases that are ongoing have been filed in Belgium by a cattle farmer targeting the French oil giant TotalEnergies, and in Switzerland by four Indonesians targeting the cement maker Holcim.
More details soon …
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
3 hours ago
- Reuters
Peruvian informal miners suspend talks with government due to disagreements in negotiations
LIMA, Aug 1 (Reuters) - Informal miners in Peru suspended talks with the government and may resume protests due to disagreements in negotiations, one of the protest leaders said on Friday. CONFEMIN union leader, Maximo Franco Bequer, told reporters the government refused to alter an August 17 deadline for miners to move explosives into formal "powder magazines." He said 20,000 miners who cannot meet the deadline would be excluded from a government program to formalize their work. The miners, located in the Cusco region, had suspended their two-week-long protest on July 15 that had blocked a major copper transit route used by mining firms MMG ( opens new tab, Glencore (GLEN.L), opens new tab and Hudbay ( opens new tab. Informal miners in Peru operate with temporary permits under a program created over a decade ago that the government has been trying to end. The miners say the stricter regulations to formalize their work and operate legally are too onerous and would likely leave them without employment. The union expects to meet in the coming hours to decide on new protests.
Reuters
2 days ago
- Reuters
Trump imposes scaled-back copper tariff, US prices plunge
July 30 (Reuters) - The United States will impose a 50% tariff on copper pipes and wiring, President Donald Trump said on Wednesday, but details of the levy fell short of the sweeping restrictions expected and left out copper input materials such as ores, concentrates and cathodes. U.S. Comex copper futures plunged 19.5% after the announcement, quickly unwinding a premium over the London global benchmark that had grown in recent weeks as traders had assumed U.S. copper mines would see a financial benefit from the tariff. Trump first teased the tariff in early July, implying that it would apply to all types of the red metal, ranging from cathodes produced by mines and smelters to wiring and other finished products. Yet in a proclamation released by the White House, the administration said the tariff will apply only to semi-finished copper products and other products that copper is heavily used to manufacture, starting on Friday. "Copper is being imported into the United States in such quantities and under such circumstances as to threaten to impair the national security of the United States," Trump said in his proclamation. The tariffs will exclude copper scrap and copper concentrates, mattes, cathodes and anodes, some of the main products of copper mines and smelters. The move is essentially a boost to Chile and Peru, two of the world's largest copper miners. "The newly announced copper tariffs are far from universal tariffs that markets were concerned about," said Gracelin Baskaran, director of the critical minerals security program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. "It's less punitive than markets initially expected." The measure came after a U.S. investigation under Section 232, which Trump ordered in February. The report was delivered to the White House on June 30 by Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, according to the proclamation. Trump said he may still impose further tariffs, and has asked Lutnick to provide an update on the domestic copper market by June 2026. At that point, Trump will evaluate whether to impose a phased universal import duty on refined copper of 15% starting in 2027, and of 30% starting in 2028, he said. Along with tariffs, the order calls for steps to support the domestic copper industry, including requiring 25% of high-quality scrap produced in the U.S. to also be sold within the country. Freeport-McMoRan (FCX.N), opens new tab, the largest U.S. copper producer, said it would comment after it reviewed Trump's order in detail. Chile's Codelco, the world's biggest copper producer, praised the exclusion of cathodes as a positive for the company and for Chile, which is the top supplier of refined copper to the U.S. BHP ( opens new tab, which operates the world's largest copper mine in Chile, and Antofagasta (ANTO.L), opens new tab, which ships copper from Chile to the U.S. and wants to build a U.S. copper mine, did not immediately reply to requests for comment.
Reuters
4 days ago
- Reuters
Peru mulls green light for $6 billion in mining projects
LIMA, July 28 (Reuters) - Peru is considering whether to give the green light to a wave of new mining projects worth a combined $6 billion in investments, President Dina Boluarte said on Monday, as her deeply unpopular government seeks to boost revenues from the industry. The government is evaluating the authorization of 134 exploration and exploitation projects, Boluarte said in a traditional Independence Day address to Congress. Officials in Peru, the world's third-biggest copper producer, are in talks with informal miners who launched protests in late June, blocking a transport corridor used by major miners including MMG ( opens new tab and Glencore (GLEN.L), opens new tab. Miners have paused that protest and corridor blockade during negotiations over a potential new law for the sector. Among informal miners, tensions escalated after over 50,000 were removed from a formalization scheme, leaving just 31,000 that the government is seeking to bring in line with regulations by year end. Boluarte said the government was working on starting a private mining fund to give small formal miners access to better financing. As she spoke, police used tear gas to disperse hundreds of protesters marching toward Congress. Some carried cardboard coffins, a reference to the dozens killed during unrest early in her term. Recent polls put Boluarte's approval ratings at between 2% and 4%, among the lowest for any world leader. In the address, the president also announced a deal with Ecuador's state oil firm Petroecuador to connect Ecuadorean oil fields to a Peruvian pipeline, allowing transport to Peru's Talara refinery. While Peru's economy has rebounded from a recession triggered by anti-government unrest, poverty levels remain near 30%. Boluarte, whose term ends in 2026, took office in late 2022 after her predecessor, Pedro Castillo, was ousted and arrested for attempting to illegally dissolve Congress. She faces an investigation over the deaths during subsequent protests, for which she denies wrongdoing. Her cabinet sparked further outrage in July by doubling her salary. "The icing on the cake is raising their salaries and colluding with those with power to keep plundering the country's natural resources," said protester Milagros Sanchez, a public school teacher. The Andean nation has been mired in political instability, with six presidents since 2018. The next general election is scheduled for April 2026.
