Congress Says NITI Aayog Removed Working Paper that Called For Duty Free Import From US
NITI Aayog. Photo: https://www.niti.gov.in
New Delhi: Congress general secretary in-charge, communications and Rajya Sabha MP Jairam Ramesh has questioned why a working paper put out by the NITI Aayog on India-US trade was withdrawn and went missing from the Aayog's website.
'On May 30, 2025, NITI Aayog put out a Working Paper titled Promoting India-US Agricultural Trade Under the New US Trade Regime. It got reported and also invited some critical comment. Now the Working Paper has gone missing from the Aayog's website. It has reportedly been withdrawn. Wonder why?' Ramesh posted on X on Sunday (June 29).
Later on Monday (June 30), Ramesh accused the Modi government of looking after the interests of American farmers multinational corporations over Indian farmers.
'The NITI Aayog paper called for allowing duty free import of genetically modified maize and soyabean from the US. For the Modi sarkar, the interests of Midwestern American farmers and large Multinational Corporation traders are bigger than that of the maize farmers of Bihar and soyabean farmers of MP, Maharashtra, and Rajasthan. Who authorized the release of this paper and is this a preview of the forthcoming Indo-US trade agreement?' Ramesh posted on X on Monday.
The NITI Aayog paper called for allowing duty free import of genetically modified maize and soyabean from the US. For the Modi sarkar, the interests of Midwestern American farmers and large Multinational Corporation traders are bigger than that of the maize farmers of Bihar and… https://t.co/wvetw6fysS
— Jairam Ramesh (@Jairam_Ramesh) June 30, 2025
The working paper that was removed outlines a roadmap to boost India's agricultural exports to the US while strategically opening select segments to American imports, reported The Tribune.
The paper concludes that India, which has traditionally maintained a trade surplus with the US in agriculture, needs a carefully balanced strategy that combines immediate responses with long-term structural reforms to navigate challenges posed by former US President Donald Trump's tariff hikes.
"India is the largest importer of edible oil in the world and the US has a significant surplus of genetically modified (GM) soybean. India can consider limited concessions on soybean oil imports to address US demands and help reduce the trade imbalance, without harming domestic production," said the working paper.
The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
8 minutes ago
- Mint
JLR margin math wobbles on twin hit from China tax, EU-US trade deal move
New Delhi: Jaguar Land Rover (JLR) is staring at a fresh wave of geopolitical and policy-driven turbulence, with China slapping a 10% tax on most luxury cars and the European Union (EU) proposing tariff relief only for automakers that manufacture in the US. For the Tata Motors-owned brand, which does not have a manufacturing base in the US, these twin developments could complicate recovery efforts and further squeeze profit margins. Starting July 20, China imposed 10% luxury consumption tax on cars priced over 900,000 renminbi. This covers most of the models sold in the Chinese luxury car market. Earlier, only cars priced above 1.3 million renminbi attracted the levy from the Chinese government. The timing of the twin hits could hardly be worse. Just a month ago, Jaguar Land Rover trimmed its growth forecast for the current fiscal year. Now, analysts are warning that these latest trade and policy shifts risk derailing the company's already modest FY26 guidance of 5-7% earnings before interest and tax (EBIT) margin. JLR had banked on reduced tariffs on exports from its Slovakia plant to the US, but that scenario may now be overtaken by events. The EU, which is finalizing a trade deal with the US for lower tariffs, has proposed that auto firms that have manufacturing in that country and export from there should be given some relaxation from 25% tariffs on imports. 'The two combined geopolitical headwinds pose a downward risk to the company's FY2026 guidance of 5-7% EBIT margin, which had only factored in lower tariffs on its exports from Slovakia to the US after the EU-US trade deal," analysts at Kotak Institutional Equities wrote in a 21 July note. Agreeing with a possible near-term pressure on JLR, analysts at Ashika Institutional Equities said in a note on 23 July that the UK-headquartered firm could face challenges on the two fronts, given the latest developments. 'Both developments present strategic challenges for JLR. In China, pricing pressure from new taxes could impact high-end model sales, while in the West, the absence of US manufacturing limits JLR's ability to benefit from policy support, thereby increasing its relative vulnerability in key export markets," the Kotak note said. JLR rivals' BMW and Mercedes stand to benefit the most if EU's proposal is accepted by US as they have plants in the country, from where they export elsewhere. JLR has manufacturing plants in the UK and Slovakia in Europe. In India, it has an assembly plant in Pune, where it assembles several models like Range Rover, Range Rover Sport, Velar, Discovery and Evoque. In FY25, JLR sold 10% fewer vehicles than the previous year in China at 47,200, while Europe saw an 11% decline at 71,700 units. Its biggest market, North America, recorded a 22% jump in sales to 129,000 cars during the year. However, JLR has faced headwinds in the international market since March, when US President Donald Trump announced a blanket 25% tariff on all automobile imports. During April-June, the first quarter of this FY, the maker of Range Rover SUVs sold 87,286 units, 11% fewer than a year ago due to a pause in shipments to the US in April to assess the tariff impact. JLR, which was acquired by Tata Motors in 2008 for $2.3 billion, contributed about 71% to Tata Motors overall revenue in the last fiscal. Analysts have earlier expressed concern that the near-term outlook for the company is weak. 'In JLR, discontinuance of 'Jaguar' ICE models, loss of market share in the China region and imposition of tariffs in the US shall lead to volume contraction ahead," Nuvama Institutional Equities had said in a note on 16 June. The company has acknowledged that its free cash flow will reduce to nearly nil in the current financial year. With the company looking to tackle the negative effects of various headwinds world over, it expects to end the current fiscal year with nil free cash flows. However, the management had earlier said the impact could have been even worse and the measures being implemented to offset the hit are leading to savings. 'The tariff impact will be primarily on Jaguar Land Rover. Tariff has gone up from 2.5% to 27.5%, and under the UK-US FTA, the tariff is 10%. The overall impact would have been 1.6 billion pounds," Tata Group Chairperson N. Chandrasekaran told shareholders at Tata Motors' annual general meeting on 20 June. 'But due to the steps taken by JLR, the impact has gone down to 600 million pounds, which is visible in the margin guidance," he added. At Tata Motors' annual investor day event also in June, the company said JLR will undertake several measures to drive savings, including manufacturing cost reduction, lowering vehicle warranty costs, and improving cost efficiencies in the overall value chain. The measures will collectively lead to savings worth 1.4 billion pounds per annum till financial year 2028, the company said. Jaguar Land Rover declined to comment when asked about the likely impact of the proposed EU-US trade deal and the Chinese luxury tax. The impact of the headwinds reflects in the company's share price. In 2025, Tata Motors' share price is down 8%, even as Nifty Auto has risen by 4%.
The Hindu
8 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Phone assembly domestic value addition is 23%, new report claims
A new study by the Thiruvananthapuram-based Centre for Development Studies (CDS) asserts that the gains from India's mobile phone manufacturing are greater than skeptical analyses have previously assessed. Domestic value addition has already reached 23%, the report claims, compared to single digit estimates elsewhere. Specifically, the report does not agree with the notion that phone assembly is an area of 'trade surplus,' a point contended notably by RBI governor Raghuram Rajan, who said in a brief paper with a colleague, Rohit Lamba, that since India was still importing nearly all components that were being assembled in mobile phone manufacturing, the result was India remaining a net importer in effect. Mobile phone manufacturing — encouraged through Union government schemes like the Production Linked Incentive scheme — has been a much touted success story for Indian domestic electronics manufacturing, fueling hopes of similarly promising results elsewhere. ₹4.1 lakh crore of finished mobile phones were manufactured in India in 2024 according to an industry estimate. The number isn't necessarily indicative of phone assembly as a part of the economy as assembly is usually estimated to only account for 4% of a phone's selling price. The case against India running a phone trade surplus rests on a 'misleading assumption' that imports of the components that go into such assemblies are exclusively going into phones, and then getting shipped back out of the country, C. Veeramani, CDS's director said. 'We used data from the Annual Survey of Industries, and that shows that the actual use of imported components in the mobile phone sector is less than 25%.' Dr. Veeramani reported his findings to the press at an event by the India Cellular and Electronics Association (ICEA), a trade body representing electronics manufacturers; the CDS director's estimates of domestic value addition were even higher, he said, than the ICEA's: 'The Total DVA (direct + indirect) increased to 23%, amounting to more than $10 billion in 2022-23,' the report says. China factor A key recommendation in the report is to focus on scaling assembly operations in the medium term, rather than pressing firms immediately to procure components from local sources. 'We cannot have a robust [electronics manufacturing] strategy keeping China out, that will not work,' Dr. Veeramani said. 'China has to be part of the game and a mindset change is needed there.' If Chinese firms were invested in India, Dr. Veeramani said, they would have no incentive to block movement of capital goods and Chinese nationals to India, something that some phone and semiconductor makers are facing in recent months.
India Today
8 minutes ago
- India Today
Tulsi Gabbard releases documents targeting Obama over 2016 Russian interference
Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard released newly declassified documents on Wednesday that, according to her, reveal efforts by senior Obama administration officials to politicise intelligence findings related to Russian interference in the 2016 US presidential a press briefing, Gabbard claimed the Obama administration deliberately crafted a 'false narrative' suggesting Russian President Vladimir Putin worked to help Donald Trump win the 2016 evidence has emerged of the most egregious weaponization and politicization of intelligence in American history,' Gabbard said. 'This was not an intelligence failure—it was an intelligence fabrication.'New evidence has emerged of the most egregious weaponization and politicization of intelligence in American history. Per President @realDonaldTrump's directive, I have declassified a @HouseIntel oversight majority staff report that exposes how the Obama Administration DNI Tulsi Gabbard (@DNIGabbard) July 23, 2025 She added that the documents show the January 2017 Intelligence Community Assessment (ICA) was 'manufactured' to falsely implicate Russian support for Trump, to undermine his legitimacy even before he took remarks follow the release of a report initially drafted in 2017 by the Republican-led House Intelligence Committee. According to the report and corroborating details from newly released ODNI memos, the intelligence community's conclusion that Putin favored Trump allegedly lacked the same 'professional rigor' applied to other ECHOES ACCUSATIONSPresident Donald Trump amplified Gabbard's claims, calling Obama the 'ringleader' behind what he described as a 'treasonous conspiracy' to delegitimise his presidency. 'We caught them—Obama, Clinton, Susan Rice, and others. They thought it would all be buried in classified documents, but the truth is coming out,' Trump confirmed that the declassified materials have been referred to the Department of Justice and the FBI for further investigation. 'No matter how powerful, every person involved must be investigated and prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law,' she ODNI memo released alongside the report names several former intelligence leaders—including ex-DNI James Clapper, former CIA Director John Brennan, and former FBI Director James Comey—as having played key roles in crafting the disputed OFFICE DENOUNCES ALLEGATIONSIn a rare response, former President Obama's office issued a statement strongly rejecting the claims. 'These bizarre allegations are ridiculous and a weak attempt at distraction,' said spokesperson Patrick Rodenbush. 'Nothing in the document undercuts the widely accepted conclusion that Russia sought to influence the 2016 election, though no votes were changed.'Rodenbush pointed to the 2020 bipartisan Senate Intelligence Committee report, led by Republican Chairman Marco Rubio, which affirmed that Russia interfered with the intention of aiding Gabbard and Trump insist the documents expose a long-running conspiracy, major media outlets including CNN and The New York Times have noted that the newly released report is a revised version of a 2017 GOP-led independent investigations and Senate findings over the past several years have consistently upheld that Russia engaged in efforts to interfere in the 2016 election, though no direct coordination with the Trump campaign was ever Praises GabbardAt a recent appearance, President Trump praised Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard, highlighting her role in releasing documents that allege former President Barack Obama led efforts to manipulate the 2016 election.'Where's Tulsi? She's hotter than everyone,' Trump said, drawing laughter from the crowd. 'She's got the documents. She uncovered that Barack Hussein Obama led a group of people who rigged the election. They cheated—plain and simple.'Trump went on to say that Gabbard assured him there's more to come: 'She told me, 'You've seen nothing yet.' We're very proud of you, Tulsi. What happened wasn't a loss—it was a stolen win.'- EndsTune InMust Watch
