P.E.I. premier says he would use notwithstanding clause to secure Lands Protection Act
Premier Rob Lantz says he will do whatever it takes to protect P.E.I.'s Lands Protection Act amid concerns about how that legislation would be affected by the governing Progressive Conservatives' proposed bill to eliminate trade barriers between provinces.
"I will never compromise our Lands Protection Act," Lantz said Wednesday in the legislature, as PC MLAs applauded loudly.
"I would go so far as using the notwithstanding clause to protect our Lands Protection Act here on Prince Edward Island."
Section 33 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms — known as the notwithstanding clause — allows for premiers or prime ministers to override rulings on legislation that judges have determined would violate sections of the Charter for a five-year period.
The clause can only override certain sections of the Charter — including Section 2 and sections 7 to 15, which deal with fundamental freedoms, legal rights and equality rights — but can't be used to override democratic rights.
'Critically important'
The PC government's proposed interprovincial trade bill introduced last Friday, would ease the flow of goods to and from other provinces that enact similar legislation, and make it easier for workers in some regulated professions to find employment on the Island.
The opposition parties are concerned the legislation would supersede all other laws, including the Lands Protection Act, which limits non-residential land ownership in the province.
Green MLA Matt MacFarlane said Wednesday that the lands act is "one of our most unique and important pieces of legislation," adding that it is up to the PC government to ensure nothing is removed from the "critically important protections on land."
He noted that Erin McGrath-Gaudet, the province's deputy minister of intergovernmental affairs, said on the floor of the legislature Tuesday that she was only reasonably confident that the Interprovincial Trade and Mobility Act would not negatively impact land protections.
"Islanders expect the premier to ensure, without a shadow of a doubt, that our land protection laws are going to be secure," MacFarlane said.
When asked whether he would commit to reviewing the interprovinical trade bill to guarantee that no part of it can override or weaken P.E.I.'s land protection laws, Lantz said he is committed to doing so.
Federal free trade
Prime Minister Mark Carney said last month that he's committed to removing all federal exemptions under the Canada Free Trade Agreement by July 1.
MacFarlane asked Lantz whether he is willing to gamble the protection of Island land to be first out of the gate when it comes to removing trade barriers between provinces.
"I have heard the federal government — the prime minister and the trade minister — commit to removing federal exemptions from the Canada Free Trade Agreement. I have heard provincial premiers talk about removing all of their party-specific exemptions from the Canada Free Trade Agreement. You haven't heard me say that," Lantz said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
10 hours ago
- CBC
Nova Scotia's first land-for-housing project opens, 4 years after program launched
The Progressive Conservatives are making the first delivery of a promise made four years ago to turn surplus provincial land into affordable housing. Starting shortly after they were first elected in 2021, the PCs opened several calls for bids on land around the province with the intention of tying an agreement to each sale requiring some degree of affordability. A vacant lot on Circassion Drive in Cole Harbour went to non-profit housing developer Rooted — formerly known as the Dartmouth Non-Profit Housing Society — and was the first land-for-housing project to get underway. The project was recently completed and an 18-unit apartment building started taking tenants this month. Tenants in half the units are paying about 50 per cent below market rates. Eligibility is based on income. "This is smart public investment and we're proud to be delivering on it," said Nick Russell, CEO of Rooted, speaking at a ribbon-cutting event at the site Tuesday. According to property records, the province sold the quarter-hectare lot to Rooted for $720,000. The province said it put $4.5 million into the build, including $1.4 million from provincial coffers and $3.1 million from a federal fund the province manages under Canada's National Housing Strategy. Growth and Development Minister Colton LeBlanc said this case shows the land-for-housing program has been effective. But he acknowledged it's had challenges, pointing to the rising cost of construction and red tape that has to be cut through before building can even get underway. "We want to do more, and more of it faster. And as a government, we will do everything within our control to speed up those opportunities, those processes," he said. CBC News has asked the Department of Growth and Development for an update on the program. As of last year, the Circassion Drive project was the only land-for-housing project under construction, with seven others waiting for approvals. Two projects had dropped out after developers found the land to be unsuitable for development. Old apartment buildings purchased The province and Rooted have also partnered on the purchase of two existing apartment buildings on Gaston Road in Dartmouth, with the aim of keeping rents low in all units — 60 in one building and 24 in the other. Rooted is taking the buildings over from for-profit landlord Vida Living. Rents in the two buildings will be about 50 per cent below market rates. "It's about stability and making sure that those tenants feel comfortable and safe and in their communities," said Russell. Russell said the buildings — one of which was constructed in 1970 and the other in 1983 — need some maintenance and retrofitting. He said no tenants will be asked to leave for the work to happen. Dylan Ward, director of development for Rooted, said acquisition is "one of the most practical, high-impact strategies" for non-profits to expand their portfolios and protect affordable housing stock. He said Rooted is looking to do more of it. "What makes acquisition so powerful is that it removes housing from the speculative market permanently," said Ward. "Non-profit ownership ensures long-term affordability, tenant engagement and building improvements without the pressure to sell or price people out," he added. According to property records, Rooted paid $7.8 million for a 60-unit building and $3.1 million for the 24-unit building. Rooted bought the buildings on Gaston Road and will do some renovations with the help of $11.1 million from the province, including a loan of $8.9 million and $2.2 million in grants.
CBC
14 hours ago
- CBC
P.E.I.'s 4 major political parties have candidates in place for Aug. 12 byelections
Social Sharing There's now a full slate of candidates from P.E.I.'s four major parties for two provincial byelections being held this summer. Voters in District 9 and District 15 will go to the polls on Tuesday, Aug. 12. Brackley–Hunter River is former premier Dennis King's old district. The Progressive Conservative leader resigned in February after having served as the district's MLA since 2019. In alphabetical order, the District 9 candidates are: Kent Dollar for the Progressive Conservatives. Nicole Ford for the Liberals. Philip Hamming for the Green Party. Michelle Neill for the New Democratic Party. Charlottetown–Hillsborough Park was left vacant by the resignation of MLA Natalie Jameson, the district's MLA since 2019, who later ran federally for the Conservatives. In alphabetical order, the District 15 candidates are: Dennis Jameson for the Progressive Conservatives Dr. Janine Karpakis for the Green Party Carolyn Simpson for the Liberals Simone Webster for the New Democratic Party No Independent candidates are listed on the Elections P.E.I. site so far. The deadline for candidate nominations is Friday, July 25 at 2 p.m. Elections P.E.I. says advance polls will take place in both districts from 9 a.m. to 7 p.m. on Saturday, Aug. 2; Monday, Aug. 4; and Friday, Aug. 8. The byelection results cannot change the balance of power in the province. Premier Rob Lantz's Progressive Conservatives have a comfortable majority in the 27-seat P.E.I. Legislative Assembly, with 19 seats compared to three each for the Liberals and the Green Party.
Edmonton Journal
16 hours ago
- Edmonton Journal
Jamie Sarkonak: Nanaimo, where complaining about feces-drenched drug zones is all you can do
RCMP Constable Adam Taylor explained to the finance committee that the force is held back by federal rules that allow the possession of up to 2.5 grams of illegal drugs, which prevent them from making arrests. (Federal decriminalization efforts have caused similar front-line problems in Sarnia, Ont., to the great frustration of locals). Article content 'Our stance right now is if they are using it in public and it's not grossly over (the federal exemption), it's what we call a 'no case seizure,'' Taylor explained. 'They are arrested, we search them, we seize the drugs, and if it's a small amount, it's just sent with a request to Health Canada to have them destroyed.' Article content To that, Nanaimo Mayor Leonard Krog asked: 'Is it fair to say … (that) it is practically speaking impossible for the police to arrest folks in a meaningful way for drug use in a public place?' Article content Article content The officer's reply? 'Yes.' Article content The centre, as with many others of its type, does help people. It houses the homeless overnight, and, anecdotally, the city reports that it's connected some individuals with addiction treatment. But, to accomplish all this, it's transformed the surrounding area into a free-range homeless zone rooted to a few indoor service providers. Article content As for whether any of this is improving overdose statistics long-term, it's not optimistic: Nanaimo's rate tripled from 500 in 2016 to 1,500 in 2024, according to provincial data. It's true that 2024 was better than 2023, which saw 2,500 deaths, but plenty more progress needs to be made before the city can declare victory. Article content Similar stories of urban devastation crop up across the country. In Sarnia, in Hamilton, Ont. and in Kitchener, Ont., homeless encampments have become court-entrenched features, with judges ruling that insufficient shelter space renders camp-clearing a Charter violation — with no thought for the general public, of course. In Vancouver, the scene is so bad that Crown prosecutors, whose offices are located in the midst of the maelstrom, are begging to move. Article content Article content In Nanaimo, authorities are now considering moving the Hub in light of resident feedback, but the city's social planning manager wasn't optimistic that a new location could be found. Of course, simply closing the thing isn't an option — it never is. Article content That's Canada, 2025: instead of arresting the people whose crime and chaos destroy community for everyone else, or at least isolating them in facilities for people who can't take care of themselves (which the homeless and addicted can't), we shrug. Whether their problems surface before city councils or courts, the well-being of everyday, society-contributing, city residents remains a low priority.
