US judge in brokerage antitrust case faces recusal bid over political donations
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services in a court filing, opens new tab on Monday said ethics rules require the recusal of U.S. District Judge Stephen Bough, whose wife is an attorney and at-large councilmember for Kansas City, Missouri.
Howard Hanna is among several defendants in the lawsuit, which was filed by home sellers in 2023 and accused brokerages of conspiring to inflate the commission that sellers pay in residential real estate sales.
The donations from plaintiffs' lawyers to the judge's wife 'create an appearance of impropriety' for the court, Howard Hanna said. The company has denied violating U.S. antitrust law.
Howard Hanna declined to comment. Lawyers for the plaintiffs did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Bough did not immediately respond to a similar request left with his chambers.
Howard Hanna's legal team at WilmerHale includes former Bill Clinton-era U.S. solicitor general Seth Waxman.
Pittsburgh-founded Howard Hanna markets itself as the country's largest family-owned real estate brokerage, employing 15,000 sales associates in nearly 500 offices. The firm said it ended 2023 with more than $37 billion in closed sales volume.
The lawsuit against Howard Hanna and other brokerages was filed by plaintiffs lawyers who had just won a landmark class action jury verdict in Bough's courtroom in a related antitrust lawsuit.
Since that October 2023 verdict, home sellers have secured more than a billion dollars in settlements with major brokerages and the real estate industry's chief trade group. The verdict spurred a wave of similar lawsuits against brokerages around the country.
Bough had disclosed the donations from members of the plaintiffs' team in the earlier class action.
'The ethics rules make it abundantly clear if I know someone is donating to my wife, then I need to put them on the conflicts list,' Bough said at a hearing last year in that case.
He said at the hearing that he had just learned that one of the members of the plaintiff's team had donated to his wife. The judge also said some of the large defense law firms in the Kansas City area donated to his wife.
At the hearing, Bough said he would be 'more than glad to step down,' but none of the parties asked for his recusal at the time.
The case is Don Gibson et al v. National Association of Realtors et al, U.S. District Court for the Western District of Missouri, No. 4:23-cv-00788-SRB.
Home listing service ends antitrust lawsuit against US realtors' group
Judge approves US realtor group's $418 mln sales commission settlement
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
4 hours ago
- Reuters
India to maintain Russian oil imports despite Trump threats, government sources say
NEW DELHI, Aug 2 (Reuters) - India will keep purchasing oil from Russia despite U.S. President Donald Trump's threats of penalties, two Indian government sources told Reuters on Saturday, not wishing to be identified due to the sensitivity of the matter. On top of a new 25% tariff on India's exports to the U.S., Trump indicated in a Truth Social post last month that India would face additional penalties for purchases of Russian arms and oil. On Friday, Trump told reporters he had heard that India would no longer be buying oil from Russia. But the sources said there would be no immediate changes. "These are long-term oil contracts," one of the sources said. "It is not so simple to just stop buying overnight." Justifying India's oil purchases from Russia, a second source said India's imports of Russian grades had helped avoid a global surge in oil prices, which have remained subdued despite Western curbs on the Russian oil sector. Unlike Iranian and Venezuelan oil, Russian crude is not subject to direct sanctions, and India is buying it below the current price cap fixed by the European Union, the source said. The New York Times also quoted two unnamed senior Indian officials on Saturday as saying there had been no change in Indian government policy. Indian government authorities did not respond to Reuters' request for official comment on its oil purchasing intentions. However, during a regular press briefing on Friday, foreign ministry spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said India has a "steady and time-tested partnership" with Russia. "On our energy sourcing requirements ... we look at what is there available in the markets, what is there on offer, and also what is the prevailing global situation or circumstances," he said. The White House did not immediately respond to requests for comment. Trump, who has made ending Russia's war in Ukraine a priority of his administration since returning to office this year, has expressed growing impatience with Russian President Vladimir Putin in recent weeks. He has threatened 100% tariffs on U.S. imports from countries that buy Russian oil unless Moscow reaches a major peace deal with Ukraine. Russia is the leading supplier to India, the world's third-largest oil importer and consumer, accounting for about 35% of its overall supplies. India imported about 1.75 million barrels per day of Russian oil from January to June this year, up 1% from a year ago, according to data provided to Reuters by sources. But while the Indian government may not be deterred by Trump's threats, sources told Reuters this week that Indian state refiners stopped buying Russian oil after July discounts narrowed to their lowest since 2022 - when sanctions were first imposed on Moscow - due to lower Russian exports and steady demand. Indian Oil Corp ( opens new tab, Hindustan Petroleum Corp ( opens new tab, Bharat Petroleum Corp ( opens new tab and Mangalore Refinery Petrochemical Ltd ( opens new tab have not sought Russian crude in the past week or so, four sources told Reuters. Nayara Energy - a refinery majority-owned by Russian entities, including oil major Rosneft ( opens new tab, and major buyer of Russian oil - was recently sanctioned by the EU. Nayara's chief executive resigned following the sanctions, and three vessels laden with oil products from Nayara Energy have yet to discharge their cargoes, hindered by the new EU sanctions, Reuters reported last week.
Daily Mail
6 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Football star exposes 'darker side of the NFL' that top players are struggling with: 'Nobody will admit it'
Pittsburgh Steelers star Breiden Fehoko has shed new light on the financial risks taken by many players in the NFL. The defensive tackle, who returned to the Steelers earlier this week, claimed he has seen teammates blow their entire salary before the start of the season. Many of the NFL's top players are on multi-million dollar contracts and yet Fehoko insists some are effectively 'broke' by week one. The 28-year-old's comments came during a social media Q&A, when he promised to be 'transparent' with fans. Earlier this week, one supporter asked him about 'a darker side of the NFL (that) no one talks about'. Fehoko said: 'I watched teammates spend a year worth of salary ($600k ish) some even more post-taxes and have nothing right before the start of the season. 'Nobody will admit it but there's guys in the league on big contracts right now that are figuratively broke. Liquidating assets as we speak.' Fehoko signed with the Los Angeles Chargers as an undrafted free agent in 2020 before joining the Steelers in April 2023. He has since had several spells with Pittsburgh over recent seasons and on Friday, the 28-year-old announced he was signing with the Steelers once more. According to Spotrac, the nose tackle has earned $2,056,130 in the NFL. He has not played a game since the 2022 season. Active NFL players who have spent at least three seasons on an active, inactive, injured reserve or PUP (physically unable to perform) roster - for at least three games - are entitled to benefits that include a pension and health insurance for five years after retirement. They also earn a 'Credited Season' if they are 'released injured and receive an injury settlement or grievance for the equivalent of three or more regular season games,' according to the NFL Players Association. But many football stars run into financial problems. The American Bankruptcy Institute claims nearly one in six files for bankruptcy within 12 years of hanging up their cleats. That figure is based on analysis on roughly 900 players who were drafted between 1996 and 2003 and 'whose careers began and ended between 2000 and 2013.'
Reuters
7 hours ago
- Reuters
Brazil's Azul secures $650 million investment commitment
SAO PAULO, Aug 2 (Reuters) - Brazilian airline Azul said it signed an agreement with certain stakeholders for a $650 million investment in a future capitalization deal, according to a late Friday securities filing. The airline's so-called "backstop commitment agreement" must be approved by the U.S. court overseeing its bankruptcy proceedings, the filing said. In May, Azul filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in the United States after months of trying to restructure mostly pandemic-era debt.
