As Gaza hunger crisis deepens, where do truce talks stand?
Through 21 months of fighting both sides have clung to long-held positions preventing two short-lived truces being converted into a lasting ceasefire.
The stakes are higher now with growing numbers of malnutrition deaths in the Palestinian territory casting a spotlight Israel's refusal to allow in more aid.
With pressure for a breakthrough mounting, Washington said top envoy Steve Witkoff will travel to Europe this week for talks on a Gaza ceasefire and aid corridor.
US officials said he might head on to the Middle East.
As the humanitarian situation in Gaza deteriorates drastically, are the two sides closer to reaching an agreement?
After more than two weeks of back and forth, efforts by mediators Qatar, Egypt and the United States are at a standstill.
The proposal on the table involves a 60-day ceasefire and the release of 10 living hostages in exchange for hundreds of Palestinian prisoners.
Hamas insists any agreement must include guarantees for a lasting end to the war.
Israel rejects any such guarantees, insisting that Hamas must give up its capacity to fight or govern as a prerequisite for peace.
'The cold hard truth is that for domestic political considerations neither (Israeli Prime Minister) Benjamin Netanyahu nor Hamas leaders in Gaza have an interest in seeing a swift outcome and a comprehensive ceasefire,' said Karim Bitar, a lecturer in Middle Eastern studies at Paris's Sciences Po university.
'Both would have to answer serious questions from their own constituencies,' he added.
While Israeli officials have said they are open to compromise, troops have expanded their operations this week into areas of Gaza that had largely been spared any ground offensives since the war began in October 2023.
Israeli media have reported that Hamas negotiators in Doha have been unable to communicate directly with the military leadership in Gaza to approve Israeli pullback maps.
Logistical issues compound existing rifts within the militant group.
There are 'technical aspects which are quite difficult to overcome because there is a growing disconnect between Hamas leadership in Gaza and the negotiators in Doha,' Bitar said.
For Andreas Krieg, a Middle East analyst at King's College London, 'the talks are technically progressing, but in practical terms, they are approaching a stalemate.'
'What is on the table now is effectively just another prisoner swap deal, not a real ceasefire deal,' he said.
Hamas faces a dilemma: it is under pressure to secure some Israeli concessions but 'on the other hand, it faces an increasingly desperate humanitarian situation.'
'The leadership may be debating how far it can compromise without appearing to surrender politically,' he said.
More than two million people in Gaza are facing severe food shortages, with more than 100 NGOs warning of 'mass starvation.'
On Tuesday, the head of Gaza's largest hospital said 21 children died of malnutrition and starvation in three days.
'Humanitarian pressure is mounting fast,' Krieg said, with Hamas facing 'rising desperation among the population, which could force it to accept an interim deal to alleviate suffering.'
But even if Hamas makes concessions, Israel has the upper hand and there can be no lasting ceasefire unless it wants one.
'Unless the United States and Qatar... increase significantly their pressure on Israel, I am afraid that this round of negotiations will fail like the previous rounds,' Bitar said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Saudi Gazette
2 hours ago
- Saudi Gazette
EU fails to agree Israeli suspension from research fund over Gaza
BRUSSELS — A European Commission proposal to deny Israel partial access to the EU's €95 billion Horizon Europe research fund failed to garner the necessary qualified majority support when EU ambassadors met in Brussels on Tuesday to discuss the issue. If agreed, Israel would lose access to €200 millions' worth of future grants and investments in Horizon's European Investment Council (EIC) which specialises in so-called disruptive technologies. But representatives from Berlin and Rome said they need to examine Commission's proposition further. For a qualified majority vote to pass the population weight of either Italy or Germany is required. "Germany wanted to continue dialogue with Israel as opposed to taking action – but we all know the dialogue is not working," a source at the meeting told Euronews. Another diplomat said Germany, which has opposed any sanction against Israel, was now "holding the cards' in relation to the decision. Both Germany and Italy said they needed more time and would let the EU know if they come to a different position in the coming weeks, according to two sources Bulgaria and Czechia were opposed to taking any action, according to the Netherlands, Ireland, France, Luxembourg, Slovenia, Portugal, Malta and Spain all supported the Commission's plan with several saying they would also push the EU for stronger sanctions, potentially in trade, the sources Commission's motion to suspend Israel's participation in Horizon is in response to an EU report finding the country had breached human rights obligations in the EU-Israel Association this finding the two sides came to an agreement that Israel would "substantially" increase access to civilians for food and medicine within the enclave to prevent the EU taking action for the the EU says there has been no material improvement for Palestinians, and according to EU sources, the EU has not been able to independently verify the claims from Israel that it is allowing more trucks of aid to reach the starving officials have so far been prevented from going into Gaza to make their own assessment of the situation."I didn't receive any convincing explanation as to why I couldn't go into Gaza," a senior official the UN and other agencies say humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza worsens by the day, and over 130 people have died from hunger alone; 88 of them children and Monday, two prominent Israeli NGO's B'Tselem, and Physicians for Human Rights, Israel, issued a report claiming Israel is committing genocide in ambassadors met on Tuesday, the death toll for the entire war hit over 60,000 people according to the Hamas-run Gaza Health least 81 people were killed by Israel on Tuesday alone; 32 while seeking aid, the ministry said. — Euronews
Saudi Gazette
2 hours ago
- Saudi Gazette
EU and Arab League reaffirm support for two-state solution, urge Hamas to disarm
NEW YORK — The European Union and Arab League, as well as several other countries, including Britain and Canada, voiced their commitment to revive the two-state solution in a bid to end Israel's devastating war on Gaza. High-level representatives gathered in New York on Monday at an International conference, co-chaired by France and Saudi Arabia, at the United Nations Headquarters. The United Nations conference, which was postponed from June and scaled down from world leaders to ministers, established eight high-level working groups to offer proposals on a broad range of topics with regard to the two-state solution. It resulted in a seven-page declaration, called the "New York Declaration," which sets out a phased plan that urges countries to recognise the state of Palestine, calls for the disarmament of Hamas and envisions the Palestinian Authority governing. "In the context of ending the war in Gaza, Hamas must end its rule in Gaza and hand over its weapons to the Palestinian Authority, with international engagement and support, in line with the objective of a sovereign and independent Palestinian State," the declaration read. The declaration also supports the deployment of a 'temporary international stabilisation mission' under the UN Security Council to protect Palestinians, oversee the transfer of administration to the Palestinian Authority, and monitor the ceasefire. The text condemns the deadly 7 October attack by Hamas, in which the militant group killed about 1,200 people, and took about 250 people hostage. Some 50 of who are still being held. It marks the first condemnation by Arab nations of Hamas. It also condemns Israel's military offensive in Gaza, in which it killed more than 60,000 Palestinians, and its "siege and starvation, which have produced a devastating humanitarian catastrophe." Co-chairs France and Saudi Arabia urged all 193 UN member states to support the document before the start of the 80th session of the UN General Assembly set to take place mid-September. Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu opposes a two-state solution and has dismissed the meeting, citing both nationalistic and security concern. The United States, a key ally of Israel, also boycott the event. France and the United Kingdom have previously expressed their intention to recognise the state of Palestine, which would align them with the 147 UN member states that have already done so. French President Emmanuel Macron announced last week that it would recognise Palestine at the United Nations General Assembly in September, which would make them the first G7 country and permanent member of the UN Security Council to do so. UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer said on Tuesday that Britain would recognise the state of Palestine before September's meeting if Israel did not agree to a ceasefire and a long-term peace process in the upcoming eight weeks. — Euronews
Arab News
2 hours ago
- Arab News
UN investigator says US sanctions over her criticism of Israel will seriously impact her life
ROME: An independent UN investigator and outspoken critic of Israel's policies in Gaza says that the sanctions recently imposed on her by the Trump administration will have serious impacts on her life and work. Francesca Albanese, the UN special rapporteur for the West Bank and Gaza, is a member of a group of experts chosen by the 47-member UN Human Rights Council in Geneva. She is tasked with probing human rights abuses in the Palestinian territories and has been vocal about what she has described as the 'genocide' by Israel against Palestinians in Gaza. Both Israel and the United States, which provides military support to its close ally, have strongly denied that accusation. Washington has decried what it called a 'campaign of political and economic warfare' against the US and Israel, and earlier this month imposed sanctions on Albanese, following an unsuccessful US pressure campaign to force the international body to remove her from her post. 'It's very serious to be on the list of the people sanctioned by the US,' Albanese told The Associated Press in Rome on Tuesday, adding that individuals sanctioned by the US cannot have financial interactions or credit cards with any American bank. When used in 'a political way,' she said the sanctions 'are harmful, dangerous.' 'My daughter is American. I've been living in the US and I have some assets there. So of course, it's going to harm me,' Albanese said. 'What can I do? I did everything I did in good faith, and knowing that, my commitment to justice is more important than personal interests.' The sanctions have not dissuaded Albanese from her work — or her viewpoints — and in July, she published a new report, focused on what she defines as 'Israel's genocidal economy' in Palestinian territories. 'There's an entire ecosystem that has allowed Israel's occupation to thrive. And then it has also morphed into an economy of genocide,' she said. In the conclusion of the report, Albanese calls for sanctions against Israel and prosecution of 'architects, executors and profiteers of this genocide.' Albanese noted a recent shift in perceptions in Europe and around the world following an outcry over images of emaciated children in Gaza and reports of dozens of hunger-related deaths after nearly 22 months of war. 'It's shocking,' she said. 'I don't think that there are words left to describe what's happening to the Palestinian people.' The war began on Oct. 7, 2023, when Hamas-led militants stormed into Israel and killed some 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and took 251 people captive. Israel's retaliatory campaign has killed over 60,000 Palestinians, according to Gaza's Health Ministry, which does not differentiate between combatants and civilians but says more than half the dead are women and children. Nearly 21 months into the conflict that displaced the vast majority of Gaza's 2.3 million people, the United Nations says hunger is rampant after a lengthy Israeli blockade on food entering the territory and medical care is extremely limited.
