logo
Spanish Catastrophe Insurance Is World-Leading. How Will It Deal With Escalating Climate Change?

Spanish Catastrophe Insurance Is World-Leading. How Will It Deal With Escalating Climate Change?

Forbes2 days ago
A resident of Chiva, Spain cleans the outside of her home after flooding in November 2024. ... More (Photographer: Angel Garcia)
When Andriy Drohorub, his wife, and their two daughters left Ukraine for Spain in June 2024, they were seeking a safer life. Two months later Drohorub bought a ground-floor apartment in the village of Alfafara. There was so much to do—learning Spanish, trying to get his medical credentials recognized, looking for online work in the meantime—that he didn't have time to buy insurance. Because he didn't need a mortgage, he wasn't required to take out home insurance.
The family had only been in their new home for four months when, in late October, intense rainfall led to flooding in southern and eastern Spain. The violence of the gushing water was intense. Windows blew out, chunks of the walls peeled off, and furniture was knocked over. Mud and debris accumulated everywhere. 'The house was completely destroyed,' Drohorub reports.
It could have been even worse. An elderly neighbor died, one of at least 232 people to die in the floods caused by the weather phenomenon known as DANA (Depresión Aislada en Niveles Altos). Emergency alerts came too late for many.
In the aftermath, as the family sought to rebuild their lives again, Drohorub wasn't able to obtain government help. He had to take out a loan to make repairs. He's grateful to rescuers, police, and volunteers who helped the family with furniture and appliances. 'The people here are very friendly and close-knit, but the state has a lot of bureaucracy and everything is very slow,' Drohorub feels. Though the apartment isn't back to 100%, it's now liveable again.
One question is whether insurance could have helped the family get back on its feet earlier, and without turning to debt.
How Spanish Catastrophe Insurance Works
The Consorcio de Compensación de Seguros (CCS – Insurance Compensation Consortium) is the Spanish system for protecting insured people from extraordinary risks. It was set up in 1941, after the turmoil of the Spanish Civil War. CCS is a public company run by government officials and representatives of private insurance companies.
Anyone with life, accident, property, or business interruption insurance is covered under CCS. This encompasses 140 million policies. The consortium is funded by a 0.15% charge on the gross premiums, which insurers are required to collect. For a car owner, this amounts to about €2 a year. For the owner of a €200,000 home, this would be €14.
Though small, this surcharge embeds a kind of solidarity among all insurance policyholders in Spain, believes Francisco Espejo Gil, the assistant director for research and international relations at CCS. Whether they're in a flood-prone part of Spain or not, everyone pays the same. He refers to this as 'a community insurance at a national scale.'
In Espejo's view, everybody wins: insurers have a secure market (albeit with less flexibility). Individuals have guaranteed coverage for extraordinary events (as long as they're covered for ordinary ones). And public emergency budgets are kept in check by an insurance system that most people opt into (about 80% of residential properties are covered, according to Espejo). This isn't a system just for the rich or just for the poor—most groups are covered.
However, it's not a perfect system. Some home and car owners are disappointed and confused by low appraisals of their damaged property. Some are angry at delays in processing claims. Espejo says that CCS aims to pay about 80% of the total losses in the first four months of an extraordinary event. According to him, that target is normally achieved for small to medium events. Of course, the Valencia flooding was a very large and devastating event.
CCS has now paid out almost all of the home and car claims, but the processing rates are lower for industrial and civil infrastructure, which involves more complex assessments.
Cascading Climate Risks
Then there's the threat multiplier of climate change. DANA has been the costliest event in CCS' 70-year history. CCS paid out more in DANA claims than in the next 10 most expensive events combined. 'This was a very serious outlier in terms of frequency and intensity. Truly we are witnessing an intensification in both hazard and exposure,' Espejo says somberly. The flooding didn't break CCS, but with losses amounting to €4.5 billion, it came close to the probable maximum loss of over €5 billion.
A man sits behind a pile of mud in Paiporta, Spain, following flooding in November 2024. ... More (Photographer: Jose Jordan)
Espejo, a meteorologist, explains, 'The Mediterranean Sea is reaching sea surface temperature of nearly or above 30° in the summer, and that's a weather bomb. For each degree that the temperature of the air rises, the capacity of the atmosphere to hold water vapor rises by 7%.' A hotter sea and a more humid atmosphere mean a greater capacity for heavy rain, flash floods, and widespread damage. 'Very likely this is going to be the future not only for Spain, for all of us in central and southern Europe.'
María José Sanz Sánchez, the scientific director of the Basque Centre for Climate Change (BC3) in Bilbao, warns that 'even the best insurance schemes in the world, like the Spanish one,' may struggle as extreme climate-linked events increase.
Along with the intensity and frequency, the unpredictability of extreme events is growing. Cathal Carr, founder of the reinsurance company OAK Re, says that companies like his would generally look at the previous 50–100 years' worth of data to model risks. This is no longer sufficient.
CCS may also need to change course. It covers agricultural insurance and catastrophic risk insurance. The aim of the latter is to provide a buffer against catastrophes both natural (earthquakes) and human (terrorism). Increasingly, the division between a 'natural' disaster and one caused by humans is becoming blurrier. Over CCS' existence, extreme daily rainfall in September–December in central and southeastern Spain has become twice as likely, and 12% more intense, due to human-caused climate change.
Most CCS claims have been related to floods. CCS stopped covering hail in the 1980s, though it continues to be a threat. A hailstorm affected Valencia around the same time as the floods last autumn. So far, wildfires are not yet included, but could be part of CCS coverage in the future if the damages increase.
When determining what to cover, CCS distinguishes between climate hazards (for example, it does not cover heatwaves) and hydrometeorological hazards (for example, it does cover drought). The consortium's perspective is that these have different implications for insurance. In practice, however, the effects are interlinked, particularly as climate variability intensifies.
Espejo likes to explain the distinction by specifying that private companies 'cover water damages when the water comes from the roof and we cover water damages when the water comes by the door.' In other words, hail damage is covered by the private market, which is free to apply risk-reflective premiums. Crop insurance for droughts falls under CCS' purview.
The 0.15% surcharge will probably need to be raised if extraordinary events increase, Espejo acknowledges. This would mark a change. In the 21st century, the charge has only been lowered (in view of the health of the insurance market).
An even more complex question is whether having a reliable catastrophe insurer discourages individuals and communities from reducing risk in the first place. 'We have to make a choice,' Espejo responds. 'And our choice is to favor the availability and the existence of insurance,' rather than leaving people vulnerable through less affordable or accessible insurance.
Global Fragmentation
While climate-related disasters have led to insurer pullouts in vulnerable areas like California, CCS has ensured a stable base for insurance companies, which continue to be profitable in Spain in spite of its climate exposure. Compared to other European countries, the combined ratio of Spanish insurance is generally much lower (more profitable) and more stable, says Ekaterina Ishchenko, a director at Fitch Ratings, a credit rating agency, in Madrid.
'I think in general it's quite positive for particular countries' insurance sectors to have a scheme like that, but that's of course based on the political will,' Ishchenko comments. In Spain, 'I think that it has demonstrated that it works really well for the sector and for the country.'
France has a similar system, but Germany does not. 'I think Germany is a bit behind on this front,' comments Alberto Messina, a senior director at Fitch Ratings in Frankfurt. 'There's been political discussions again, which obviously usually intensify right after an event occurs, and then perhaps fade away a bit after that.'
Overall, Messina believes, 'The direction of travel is towards the Spain model. And I think the spirit based on which other countries are moving is essentially not to do a favor to the insurers, but to protect businesses and customers, in the sense that it's just cheaper and safer to prevent as opposed to wait for the event to occur and then rebuild from scratch. So I think that's what they're trying to achieve now, in order to build resilience and business continuity and avoid disruptions.'
There are both logistical and ideological reasons that not all countries will adopt a Spain-style model for catastrophe insurance. In some places, people living outside of flood risk zones, for instance, might balk at the idea of paying the same insurance surcharge as people in more vulnerable areas.
Though it may not be palatable everywhere, this goes back to that idea of solidarity that animates CCS. Sanz, the Valencia-born climate scientist, believes that the general principle behind CCS is very much needed in an era of spiralling climate impacts. That is, everyone has to contribute and share the risk.Reporting for this story was supported in part by a press trip organized by the Provincial Council of Bizkaia.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Outdoor workers demand protection as cruel heat bakes southern Europe
Outdoor workers demand protection as cruel heat bakes southern Europe

Associated Press

time11 hours ago

  • Associated Press

Outdoor workers demand protection as cruel heat bakes southern Europe

Cruel heat is baking southern Europe as the continent slips deeper into summer. In homes and offices, air conditioning is sweet relief. But under the scorching sun, outdoor labor can be grueling, brutal, occasionally even deadly. A street sweeper died in Barcelona during a heat wave last month and, according to a labor union, 12 other city cleaners have suffered heatstroke since. Some of Europe's powerful unions are pushing for tougher regulations to protect the aging workforce from climate change on the world's fastest-warming continent. Cleaning the hot streets Hundreds of street cleaners and concerned citizens marched through downtown Barcelona last week to protest the death of Montse Aguilar, a 51-year-old street cleaner who worked even as the city's temperatures hit a June record. Fellow street sweeper Antonia Rodríguez said at the protest that blistering summers have made her work 'unbearable.' 'I have been doing this job for 23 years and each year the heat is worse,' said Rodríguez, 56. 'Something has to be done.' Extreme heat has fueled more than 1,000 excess deaths in Spain so far in June and July, according to the Carlos III Health Institute. 'Climate change is, above all, playing a role in extreme weather events like the heat waves we are experiencing, and is having a big impact in our country,' said Diana Gómez, who heads the institute's daily mortality observatory. Even before the march, Barcelona's City Hall issued new rules requiring the four companies contracted to clean its streets to give workers uniforms made of breathable material, a hat and sun cream. When temperatures reach 34 C (93 F), street cleaners now must have hourly water breaks and routes that allow time in the shade. Cleaning work will be suspended when temperatures hit 40 C (104 F). Protesters said none of the clothing changes have been put into effect and workers are punished for allegedly slacking in the heat. They said supervisors would sanction workers when they took breaks or slowed down. Workers marched behind a banner reading 'Extreme Heat Is Also Workplace Violence!' and demanded better summer clothing and more breaks during the sweltering summers. They complained that they have to buy their own water. FCC Medio Ambiente, the company that employed the deceased worker, declined to comment on the protesters' complaints. In a previous statement, it offered its condolences to Aguilar's family and said that it trains its staff to work in hot weather. Emergency measures and a Greek cook In Greece, regulations for outdoor labor such as construction work and food delivery includes mandatory breaks. Employers are also advised — but not mandated — to adjust shifts to keep workers out of the midday sun. Greece requires heat-safety inspections during hotter months but the country's largest labor union, the GSEE, is calling for year-round monitoring. European labor unions and the United Nations' International Labor Organization are also pushing for a more coordinated international approach to handling the impact of rising temperatures on workers. 'Heat stress is an invisible killer,' the ILO said in a report last year on how heat hurts workers. It called for countries to increase worker heat protections, saying Europe and Central Asia have experienced the largest spike in excessive worker heat exposure this century. In Athens, grill cook Thomas Siamandas shaves meat from a spit in the threshold of the famed Bairaktaris Restaurant. He is out of the sun, but the 38 C (100.4 F) temperature recorded on July 16 was even tougher to endure while standing in front of souvlaki burners. Grill cooks step into air-conditioned rooms when possible and always keep water within reach. Working with a fan pointed at his feet, the 32-year-old said staying cool means knowing when to take a break, before the heat overwhelms you. 'It's tough, but we take precautions: We sit down when we can, take frequent breaks and stay hydrated. We drink plenty of water — really a lot,' said Siamandas, who has worked at the restaurant for eight years. 'You have to find a way to adjust to the conditions.' The blazing sun in Rome Massimo De Filippis spends hours in the blazing sun each day sharing the history of vestal virgins, dueling gladiators and powerful emperors as tourists shuffle through Rome's Colosseum and Forum. 'Honestly, it is tough. I am not going to lie,' the 45-year-old De Filippis said as he wiped sweat from his face. 'Many times it is actually dangerous to go into the Roman Forum between noon and 3:30 p.m.' At midday on July 22, he led his group down the Forum's Via Sacra, the central road in ancient Rome. They paused at a fountain to rinse their faces and fill their bottles. Dehydrated tourists often pass out here in the summer heat, said Francesca Duimich, who represents 300 Roman tour guides in Italy's national federation, Federagit. 'The Forum is a pit; There is no shade, there is no wind,' Duimich said. 'Being there at 1 p.m. or 2 p.m. in the summer heat means you will feel unwell.' This year, guides have bombarded her with complaints about the heat. In recent weeks, Federagit requested that the state's Colosseum Archaeological Park, which oversees the Forum, open an hour earlier so tours can get a jump-start before the heat becomes punishing. The request has been to no avail, so far. The park's press office said that administrators are working to move the opening up by 30 minutes and will soon schedule visits after sunset. ___ Wilson reported from Barcelona, Spain, Gatopoulos from Athens and Thomas from Rome.

Texas lawmakers investigate flash floods as death toll hits 137
Texas lawmakers investigate flash floods as death toll hits 137

Yahoo

time17 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Texas lawmakers investigate flash floods as death toll hits 137

By Brad Brooks (Reuters) -Texas state lawmakers met during a special session on Wednesday, to address for the first time the deadly flash floods that hit the Texas Hill Country this month, killing at least 137 people. Senator Charles Perry, chairperson for the joint Senate-House committee investigating the preparation for and response to the flooding, said the committee did not want to assign blame, but sought "constructive policy solutions which will remit future loss of life." Texas Governor Greg Abbott included the investigation on the agenda of a special legislative session that opened on Monday. Abbott said on social media that the death toll from the July 4 flash flooding ticked up to 137, and a man and a girl remained missing. Nim Kidd, chief of the Texas Division of Emergency Management, was the first person lawmakers called to testify. He described the vast state's emergency response system as fragmented. Under the system, each of 254 counties maintains control over ordering evacuations. Such an order was not given in the hardest hit areas earlier this month. Kidd told lawmakers that to improve preparation for natural disasters, he needed better in-house radar systems, better communications systems to warn local leaders and residents, and more resources for evacuations or to assist residents who shelter in place. The high casualty toll ranked as one of the deadliest U.S. flood events in decades, raising questions about the lack of flash-flood warning sirens in hardest hit Kerr County. Many have expressed concern about vacancies at National Weather Service offices due to staffing cuts under President Donald Trump. The legislative committee investigating the floods will next meet on July 31 in Kerr County. The committee will write a report to be forwarded to the full Texas Senate and House to inform possible legislation during the month-long special session.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store