Trinamool urges Election Commission to use 2024 as base year for voter list revision
West Bengal is scheduled to go to elections in 2026.
'The voters enrolled till 2024 should remain irrespective of any condition,' Trinamool MP and party Chief Whip in the Lok Sabha, Kalyan Banerjee, told presspersons after the meeting.
Mr. Banerjee said that while the ECI stated its objective behind the SIR is to ensure that 'no voter is left behind,' certain recent circulars reflect an approach of 'eligibility first and inclusion later'.
He said the party raised concerns over the requirement of birth certificates for verification. 'They [ECI] said those who already are voters will remain voters. If any inclusion is made after this, it will be based on evidence,' Mr. Banerjee said.
A 5-member delegation comprising Smt. Chandrima Bhattacharya, Shri Kalyan Banerjee, Shri Firhad Hakim, Shri Aroop Biswas, and Shri Prakash Chik Baraik met with the @ECISVEEP today.
They submitted constructive suggestions and raised key concerns to safeguard and strengthen the… pic.twitter.com/XpQwBavP95 — All India Trinamool Congress (@AITCofficial) July 1, 2025
The Trinamool delegation also flagged what it termed the arbitrary inclusion of large numbers of voters in electoral rolls just ahead of elections, citing examples from Haryana and Delhi. 'Only new voters between 18 and 21 years of age should be added ahead of the polls. But how can people aged 50–60 suddenly be part of the bulk voter list? And how can the number of new inclusions rise to 40,000?' Mr. Banerjee asked.
The party also expressed concern about the delayed release of voter turnout data.
West Bengal Minister and MLA Firhad Hakim, who was part of the delegation, raised the issue of central forces allegedly entering polling booths and influencing voters.
'We proposed to them that if central forces are there, State police should also be present inside the booth. No forces should enter the area where polling is done inside the booths,' Mr. Hakim said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
4 hours ago
- Indian Express
Yogendra Yadav writes on Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls: An attack on the right to vote
Welcome to the most audacious attempt at mass disenfranchisement of Indian citizens. The nationwide Special Intensive Revision (SIR) announced by the Election Commission of India (ECI) — to be rolled out first in Bihar and then in the rest of the country — is exactly that. In effect this is, as critics have alleged, a move at votebandi, following notebandi (demonetisation) and deshbandi (lockdown). Dumb at best and diabolic at worst, this draconian policy shift could end up taking away the only right that crores of ordinary Indians have had — the right to vote. Sounds alarmist? Over-the-top political rhetoric? Just take these three steps with me and then judge for yourself. Step one: Let us set aside the common impression that the SIR ordered by the ECI is just an overdue and thorough re-examination of the existing electoral rolls (ER, commonly called 'voters' list'). Such an exercise was carried out in Bihar just six months ago. Lakhs of names were added and deleted, with no significant complaints from any quarter. What the ECI has just ordered is a de novo, fresh writing of the voters' list, first in Bihar, then in other poll-bound states, to be followed by the rest of the country. This step is unprecedented. In the garb of an older exercise called Intensive Revision, which was discontinued after 2003 following the computerisation of the ER, the ECI has unleashed something altogether new and disruptive. For the first time, the onus of being on the voters' list has been shifted from the state to the citizen. Those who fail to submit fresh enumeration forms by July 25 will automatically be left out of the draft rolls. Worse, for the first time, every person would be required to provide documentary proof of their citizenship to qualify to be on the voters' list. This is indeed the National Register of Citizens (NRC) through the back door. Step two: Let us cut through a smokescreen created by ECI, namely that documentary proof will be required from a very small number. The ECI's order is quite clear: Every voter will have to fill out the enumeration form with a current photograph, signatures, some basic details, plus proof of citizenship. Those who had their names on the ER of 2003 (presuming the exact name and residence have not changed) have a shortcut. They can attach a copy of the page carrying their name in the ER-2003. That will be accepted as proof of their citizenship. The ECI has claimed that 4.96 crore people (63 per cent of those currently on the ER) will be able to take this shortcut, leaving less than 3 crore to prove their eligibility. Rahul Shastri ('Voter verification drive in Bihar: too little time, too many hurdles', Data Point, The Hindu, July 1, 2025) debunks this bizarre claim as the ECI did not take into account the number of deaths, migration and shifting of residence since 2003. He demonstrates that the correct figure is closer to 3.16 crore. That leaves an overwhelming majority (about 4.74 crore out of 7.9 crore on the current ER) who carry a high burden of proving their citizenship with the help of proofs of date and place of birth. They fall into three categories. Those above 38 years of age (born before July 1, 1987) who were too young then or for any other reason (mismatched names, shifting of residence due to marriage or otherwise) do not find their names in the ER-2003 will have to attach proof of their own date and place of birth. Those between 20 and 38 years of age (born between July 1, 1987, and December 2, 2004) will have to attach two proofs: Their own and that of their mother or father. Finally, those between 18 and 20 years of age (born after December 2, 2004) will have to attach three proofs: Their own and that of both their mother and father. While the parents' name on ER-2003 would serve as a proof for them, the applicant will still have to attach his/her own proof of date and place of birth. Step three: Let us face a stark truth — the kind of proof the ECI is demanding for this exercise simply does not exist with a majority of the people. And it is not their fault. The state never supplied them the papers it demands of them today. If you ask any ordinary household for identity papers, they would offer one of the following: Aadhaar, the ECI's photo identity card, ration card or MGNREGS job card. None of these would be accepted by the ECI to enrol someone as a voter. Instead, the ECI has come up with an 'indicative (though not exhaustive) list' of 11 documents that would be required. Shastri has investigated the availability of each of these documents in Bihar for the relevant period. Of these, six either do not apply in Bihar or are negligible in numbers. Four of those remaining have very little coverage: Birth certificate: 2.8 per cent; passport: 2.4 per cent; government service/pension ID: Less than 5 per cent; and caste certificate: About 16 per cent. That leaves the matriculation/education certificate (around 35 per cent for all adults and around 45 per cent for the relevant group of those aged between 20 and 40 years) as the only widely available and acceptable document from this list, which is also a requirement for most other documents. For all practical purposes, therefore, matriculation has become an informal requirement for being a citizen and a voter. Shastri estimates that around 2.5 crore people (nearly one-third of the current adult population in Bihar) who are required to prove citizenship may not have any of these documents. In reality, the number could be larger if you take routine operational failures (temporary absence, inability to do paperwork, failure to locate certificates, official goof-ups etc.) into account. Even if these are overestimates, and if the actual exclusion is around 1 crore, less than half of the robust empirical estimates, we are still looking at the largest exercise in denial of voting rights. Now you decide: How is this not an exercise in mass disenfranchisement? Creating discriminatory, though indirect, barriers of wealth and education is exactly how disenfranchisement of African Americans was practised in the southern US. In Bihar, as in the rest of India, the burden of exclusion based on educational qualifications would fall disproportionately on women, the poor and Dalit-Adivasi and Bahujan communities. This is against the letter and spirit of the Indian Constitution. Now ask a further question: Why did the ECI suddenly announce this ridiculous timeline for SIR in Bihar? In the 30 days between June 25 and July 25, the Bihar government is to contact about 1 lakh booth-level officers (more than 20,000 are yet to be appointed), train them for SIR, get them to connect to lakhs of booth-level agents of all political parties, educate the public about this exercise, distribute enumeration forms to each household and help them with a copy of ER-2003. Not just that, they are also supposed to collect the completed form from each house (visit thrice if necessary), upload these to the internet, verify the certificates and give their recommendations. All within the month (of which a week has passed) when Bihar is in the midst of the monsoon and floods! So, unless the ECI has a magic wand, we should expect a withdrawal of this order, drastic changes in the list of documents allowed (as announced on June 30) or a postponement of the Bihar assembly elections. Finally, you may ask: If such a drastic change was needed, why did the Special Intensive Revision not feature among the 21 initiatives listed by the new CEC just last month and reported in the media on May 30? Why did the ECI not mention this grand proposal in its meeting with heads of various national parties held last month and over 4,000 consultations held all over the country just before that? What changed the ECI's mind in just 25 days? A sudden phone call? Or chai pe charcha? In other words, who is the 'sir' behind this SIR? The writer is member, Swaraj India, and national convenor of Bharat Jodo Abhiyaan. Views are personal
The Hindu
4 hours ago
- The Hindu
The Hindu Morning Digest: July 2, 2025
Trump says Israel has agreed to finalise 60-day Gaza ceasefire, urges Hamas to accept deal U.S. President Donald Trump said on Tuesday Israel had agreed 'to the necessary conditions to finalise' a 60-day ceasefire in Gaza during which efforts will be made to end the U.S. ally's war in the Palestinian enclave. 'Israel has agreed to the necessary conditions to finalize the 60 Day CEASEFIRE, during which time we will work with all parties to end the War,' Mr. Trump said on social media.'The Qataris and Egyptians, who have worked very hard to help bring Peace, will deliver this final proposal. I hope, for the good of the Middle East, that Hamas takes this Deal, because it will not get better — IT WILL ONLY GET WORSE.' Confusion reigns as Bihar's Special Intensive Revision of rolls gets underway The Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of Bihar's electoral rolls that began on June 28, the first intensive revision since 2003, is scheduled to conclude on September 30 with the publication of the updated voter rolls. The process, however, has got off to a bumpy start courtesy of the immense confusion among voters about the exercise. Chandra Mohan Singh, 65, a resident of Mahmada village in Bihar's Saran district and a voter from booth no. 240, is an exemplar of this confusion. Given a form for the special intensive revision of the State's electoral rolls on Monday, it still remains blank. Asked about the purpose of the form, he says, 'It is given to me to find out whether I am dead or alive.' A more focused Quad will help deliver better, says Jaishankar India has 'every right' to defend its people against terrorism, and the partners of the Quad grouping should 'appreciate' that, said External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar in Washington D.C., where he participated in the Quad Foreign Ministers-level meeting on Tuesday. Mr. Jaishankar said a 'more focused Quad' will 'help deliver better', while Australian Foreign Minister Penny Wong, in her opening remarks, made the mention of the March 28 earthquake in Myanmar where the Quad partners mobilised 'quickly' to help the affected communities. Pharma factory blast: Evidence suggests dust explosion, say experts about the blast Safety protocols in pharmaceutical industries of the city have come into sharp focus yet again in the context of the latest blast in the manufacturing facility of Sigachi Industries in Pashamylaram on Monday in which dozens were killed. While the Factories Department is still collecting evidence, experts who have observed the footage of the blast site conclude that it is a 'dust explosion'. They contend the version of the Factories Department, which, based on prima facie evidence, explains it as the 'Boiling Liquid Expanding Vapour Explosion' (BLEVE), a technical term to mean that the pressure build up inside the reactor led to the blast. Sivaganga custodial death case transferred to CBI; Stalin assures full cooperation in probe The investigation into the alleged custodial death in Thirupuvanam police station in Sivaganga district was transferred to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) within a day after it was transferred to the CB-CID. Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M.K. Stalin recommended the transfer and further made a promise that his government would extend full cooperation to the investigation by the central agency. Judiciary should not override executive's decision to deport a foreign national: Home Ministry The Union Home Ministry's (MHA) appeal against a Jammu and Kashmir High Court order to repatriate a 62-year-old housewife who was deported to Pakistan post Pahalgam terror attack said the 'judiciary should not override' the executive's decision to deport a foreign national. It said the High Court order was constitutionally impermissible and unsustainable, as it directed the enforcement of a judicial writ beyond the sovereign territory of India to Pakistan, where she was deported and was thus ultra vires. Drive on to identify persons with multiple voter IDs: Chief Election Commissioner With the special intensive revision (SIR) of electoral rolls underway in Bihar, Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar on Tuesday said that a person is entitled to vote only in the Assembly constituency where he or she is ordinarily a resident and not in one where they own a house. Government officials have begun distributing enumeration forms to all registered voters in Bihar from Saturday. The SIR exercise began on June 25 with the printing of the forms and is scheduled to end on September 30 with the publication of the updated voter rolls. 31 dead, 151 injured in monsoon-related disasters in Nepal At least 31 people died and 151 others were injured in monsoon-related disasters in Nepal within a month since the onset of the rainy season on May 28, officials said on Tuesday. Between May 28 and June 30, the country experienced 682 incidents linked to the monsoon, including floods, landslides, lightning strikes, and windstorms, National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Authority (NDRRMA) Suresh Sunar spokesperson said. Justice Department says 2 Chinese nationals charged with spying inside the U.S. for Beijing Two Chinese nationals have been charged with spying inside the United States on behalf of Beijing, including by taking photographs of a naval base, coordinating a cash dead-drop and by participating in efforts to recruit members of the military who they thought might be open to working for Chinese intelligence. Djokovic passes Muller test to reach Wimbledon second round Seven-time Wimbledon champion Novak Djokovic was made to work hard after a strong start as he began his bid for a 25th Grand Slam title by beating unseeded Frenchman Alexandre Muller 6-1 6-7(7) 6-2 6-2 to reach the second round on Tuesday. The sixth seed, who is aiming to equal Roger Federer's haul at the All England Club and move past Margaret Court in the all-time list of major champions, will take on British wild card Dan Evans in the next round. Kylian Mbappé makes his Club World Cup debut in Real Madrid's win over Juventus Kylian Mbappé jogged, clapped his hands together and waved to a crowd of excited fans before checking into the Club World Cup for the first time. From there, the Real Madrid star didn't need to do much for his club to advance past Juventus into the tournament's quarterfinals. Gonzalo García, who had started Madrid's four matches while Mbappé dealt with an illness, scored what turned out to be the winning goal on a header Tuesday afternoon before subbing out of the match.
Time of India
5 hours ago
- Time of India
EC yet to hear from oppn after Congress plea for 'urgent' meet
NEW DELHI: Congress had approached Election Commission on June 30 seeking an "urgent" meeting "any time after 4 pm on July 2" between the poll panel and a delegation comprising 10 opposition parties to discuss the ongoing special intensive revision (SIR) of rolls in Bihar . However, EC, despite writing back to each of the 10 parties to indicate availability of their representatives at 5 pm on July 2, is yet to hear from them. EC sources said the "July 2" meeting with the multi-party opposition delegation thus stood deferred as no confirmations were received. Sources told TOI that while the mail received from All India Congress Committee (AICC) for the multi-party delegation's appointment with EC was unilateral, the commission sent its response the same day to each of the 10 parties - Congress, RJD, TMC , DMK, Samajwadi Party, NCP, JMM, CPI, CPM and CPI(ML) Liberation - seeking their confirmations for a meeting at 5 pm on July 2. However, not one of the 10 parties had responded to EC's mail till late on Tuesday, as per EC sources. Even so, a TMC delegation met EC on Tuesday as part of its ongoing consultation with parties on all election-related issues. During this, the former suggested that 2024 be used as the base year for SIR, set to be taken up in Bengal ahead of elections next year.
