AerCap can recover over $1 billion, UK court rules in case over jets 'lost' in Russia
The court ruled broadly in favour of leasing companies in a multi-billion-dollar legal dispute with insurers, following a mammoth trial of one of the biggest insurance disputes ever heard in London which concluded in February.
The lawsuit had focused on almost 150 jets and some engines, previously with a total value of up to $4.7 billion, though settlements - including on the first day of the trial in October - have whittled the numbers down.
Judge Christopher Butcher said in a summary of his ruling that the aircraft were lost and "that loss occurred on 10 March 2022, when a piece of Russian legislation banned the export of aircraft and aircraft equipment from Russia".
That meant the lessors could recover from their "war risks insurers", rather than under a broader all risks clause, as the cause of the loss was "an act or order of the Russian government", Butcher said.
The judge also ruled that insurers were not prevented by EU or US sanctions from indemnifying the claimants for the loss of aircraft which had been leased to Russian airlines.
AerCap's law firm Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer said the judgment secured $1.035 billion for AerCap, "in addition to substantial recoveries achieved in prior settlements".
The $1.035 billion sum is, however, less than AerCap's claimed losses of over $2 billion had it been able to recover under its all risks policy.
Butcher said in his ruling that Dublin-based AerCap had received just over $1.3 billion from six settlements between August and December 2023 with lessees and a Russian insurance company.
AerCap, Dubai Aerospace Enterprise (DAE), Merx Aviation, KDAC Aviation Finance, Falcon and Genesis had led the claims against a string of insurers, including AIG, Lloyd's, Chubb and Swiss Re.
KDAC settled all its claims during the trial, Butcher said in his ruling, while AerCap, DAE and other lessors have periodically disclosed partial settlements.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Provisional liquidator for steel fabricator working for blue chip construction firms
The High Court has appointed a provisional liquidator to a steel fabrication firm providing products for blue chip construction sector companies. Farleng Engineering Ltd, of Laraghcon Farm, Lucan, Co Dublin, is insolvent and does not have enough money to discharge debts to creditors, Mr Justice Brian Cregan was told by Ross Gorman BL, for the firm, which petitioned the court for the appointment. Until recently, it had 42 full time employees. Counsel said the company had unusually twice been through examinership, the first in 2021 and the second in April last when the Circuit Court appointed an examiner. This protection was removed in late June after a potential investor withdrew interest and the examiner recommended the appointment of a provisional liquidator, he said. A liquidator can only be appointed by the High Court. READ MORE Among the reasons why the decision was taken was that the company was owed in excess of €230,000 for work in progress and another €446,000 in retentions much of which related to projects that have been completed. The liquidator could commence trying to recover this money. Counsel also said one of the key reasons was to ensure that the employees can avail of a collective redundancy process which can only commence when the liquidator has been appointed. Until that happens the workers are 'in limbo' and cannot obtain social welfare or start a new job. The firm also has several hundred thousand euro worth of assets, including plant, machinery and tools which are depreciating assets and which need to be sold as soon as possible. In the petition seeking the appointment of the provisional liquidator, the company, which was incorporated in 1999 and leases its premises in Lucan, said it operates in the construction sector providing specific steel fabrication for data centres and pharmaceutical manufacturing site construction. The 2021 examinership was successful with reasonable profitability recorded for the last three-and-a-half years. However, it has suffered significant cash flow issues for reasons including the impact on working capital due to big contract delays. It was also impacted by general delays in customers paying up and variances between what the firm claims and what is assessed by the customers' quantity surveyors. A planning issue also arose with Fingal County Council sending a warning letter last March stating the company may be in breach of planning regulations by changing the use of an agricultural building to light industry and the laying of a concrete surface without permission. The company believes a liquidator can explore the possibility of the acquisition of the business by a number of investors who have expressed interest in it. Mr Justice Cregan said he was satisfied to appoint Padraic O'Malley of JW Accountants as provisional liquidator. He adjourned the application to the end of the month.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
EirGrid says average home pays €9.75 per-month for its services as it pitches investment plan
National electricity grid operator EirGrid says the average home pays €9.75 a-month for its services in a plan seeking go-ahead to invest in its system. Regulators are proposing to allow EirGrid and fellow State company ESB Networks invest an initial €14.1 billion over the next five years to overhaul the systems that bring electricity from power stations to more than two million customers. Eirgrid's submission to the Commission for the Regulation of Utilities (CRU) calculates that it could need between €4 billion and €7.6 billion to expand the electricity grid to meet growing demand and take on more renewables, among other things. The company calculates that its operations amount to €117 a-year, €9.75 a-month, from the total average household electricity bill, which it estimates at slightly more than €1,900, including VAT. READ MORE That comes to around 6 per cent of what Irish families pay every year for electricity, according to its figures. EirGrid and ESB Networks combined sought the CRU's backing for investment plans totalling €19 billion from next year to 2030. The commission said this week it would allow them €14.1 billion initially, but could increase this up to €19 billion should both companies show that they are meeting targets and budgets. This could cost the average customer from €6 to €16 a-year extra for electricity, the CRU calculates. Michael Behan, Eirgrid's chief financial officer argued on Thursday that the review of its spending plans was an opportunity to invest in the Republic's future. 'Investment in our grid infrastructure and the capacity and capability of EirGrid to fulfil its critical role is fundamental to unlocking greater energy independence and security, as well as supporting national and regional economic growth,' he said. Its plans include updating existing power lines, putting in new overhead and underground lines, upgrading existing substations and building new ones. The CRU has allocated EirGrid €2.6 billion of the €14.1 total allowed to the two companies. The commission intends monitoring their progress, only allowing them exceed the initial investment that it has approved if they show they are meeting targets and keeping their plans on track. EirGrid and ESB Networks sought approval for the investment in a process dubbed 'Price Review 6″. Both will have to increase their charges to help pay for their expansion plans, adding to customers' bills. Households and businesses cover network costs through a standing charge on their bills that is separate from the actual cost of their electricity.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Public finances boosted by another spike in corporate tax receipts
The Government's financial position has been boosted by what Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe described as 'a sharp increase' in corporate tax in June. Exchequer returns for the first six months of the year show the business tax generated €7.4 billion last month, which was €1.5 billion or 25 per cent up on the same month last year. June is the second most important month of the year for corporate tax - behind November - as it reflects payments from companies with financial years ending in December, which include Google, Meta, Microsoft and Intel, all of which have big operations here. After a fall-off in receipts in May, there had been concern that US trade policy uncertainty might be affecting the profitability of these firms. READ MORE But the latest figures, published by the Department of Finance, appeared to dispel those concerns with corporate tax receipts - on a cumulative six-month basis - up 7.4 per cent on last year at €13.1 billion and ahead of the department's own forecasts. Nonetheless Mr Donohoe warned the month-to-month changes highlighted the volatility of corporate tax. 'Corporation tax receipts in June have seen a sharp increase, which follows a sharp decline last month,' he said. 'This serves as a reminder of the extreme volatility in this revenue stream, and of its inherent unsuitability as a basis for permanent spending commitments,' Mr Donohoe said. 'That is why we have established the Future Ireland Fund (FIF) and the Infrastructure, Climate and Nature Fund (ICNF) to set aside some of this potentially temporary revenue to help further protect us in the future,' he said. 'Last month, Government transferred some €3 billion into the two funds, and when the remaining transfers are made towards the end of this year, there will be around €16 billion in the FIF and ICNF," Mr Donohoe said. The latest exchequer figures showed overall tax receipts were €49.5 billion in the first six months of the year, up by 4.5 per cent on the first half of last year. When once-off tax revenues of €1.7 billion arising from the European court ruling against Apple are excluded, the department said 'underlying' tax revenues stood at €47.7 billion, which was a 6.7 per cent up on last year. On a cumulative six-month basis, income tax receipts of €17.4 billion were 4.3 per cent ahead of last year, reflecting the ongoing strength of the labour market with headline unemployment remaining at a low of 4 per cent. June was a non-VAT-due month and therefore monthly receipts 'relatively modest,' the department said. Cumulative receipts from the transactions tax for the six-month period came to €11.6 billion, up by almost 6 per cent on last year's total at this stage. Total expenditure for the first half of the year amounted to €50.9 billion, up by 8.2 per cent on 2024 and ahead of the department's profile by 0.7 per cent. The Irish Fiscal Advisory Council, the Government budgetary watchdog, is warning that overruns in day-to-day public spending are likely to top €2 billion this year. The department noted that year-on-year capital spending levels have increased substantially, with capital spending up 22.5 per cent overall. Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers said: 'Today's figures show a significant increase in capital expenditure which underscores Government commitment to investing in the infrastructure our community needs and which is critical to enhancing our economic competitiveness,' he said. At a headline level, an exchequer surplus of €4.5 billion was recorded in the first half of the year.
