USL liable to pay entry tax under Madhya Pradesh local area rule, holds Supreme Court
Supreme Court
on Monday held that
United Spirits
(
USL
) is liable to pay entry tax under the Madhya Pradesh Sthaniya Kshetra Me Mal Ke Pravesh Par Kar Adhiniyam 1976, which levied such tax on the entry of goods into a local area for use, consumption or sale.
Upholding the Madhya Pradesh High Court's decision which favoured the state, the bench of Justices J B Pardiwala and K V Vishwanathan said that '…it is clear that the appellants (USL) by the sale to the warehouse caused to be affected the entry of goods and the entry was occasioned on the account of the sale into the local area for consumption, use or sale therein.'
It is also not disputed that USL is a dealer as defined under the Madhya Pradesh Value Added Tax Act, 2002, the SC said, adding that the company's only contention that the State warehouse was also a dealer 'makes no difference' since it cannot be disputed that the company certainly occasioned the entry of goods and the levy of entry tax on them, which could always be passed on, was perfectly justifiable in law.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Why These Barefoot Sandals are a Must for Summer 2025
Foot Secrets
Learn More
Undo
According to the judges, we have no manner of doubt that there were two independent transactions, one between USL (manufacturers) and the State Warehouse and the other between the State warehouse and the retailers. 'Hence, it will be difficult to accept the contention of the State that the role of the State is only supervisory and the warehouses didn't purchase beer and IMFL from the manufacturer,' they said.
However, the top court said that this does not resolve the issue in favour of USL as under Section 3 of the M.P. Entry Tax Act 1976, the incidence of taxation is on the entry in the course of business of a dealer of goods specified in Schedule II, into each local area for consumption, use or sale therein. The further requirement is that such tax was to be paid by every dealer liable to tax under the VAT Act who hasd effected entry of such goods.
Live Events
USL had contended that no direct sales could be made by the manufacturer to the retailers and there was "no privity of contract" between them and the retailers and it was the state government warehouse which sold the goods to the retailers. It is the warehouse which caused the movement of the goods into the local area, it argued.
However, the State government contended that it neither purchased nor sold liquor. The HC had correctly found that the warehouses neither purchased or sold liquor and that the department only supervised the sale made by the manufacturer to the retail contractors.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
21 minutes ago
- Time of India
JSW Cement cuts IPO size to Rs 3,600 cr; public offer to open on August 7
JSW Cement, part of Sajjan Jindal-promoted diversified JSW Group , is set to launch its truncated Rs 3,600-crore initial public offering (IPO) on August 7. The total size of the issue, however, is lower than the earlier proposed issue of up to Rs 4,000 crore, according to the latest RHP .. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like This Could Be the Best Time to Trade Gold in 5 Years IC Markets Learn More Undo The IPO will open for public subscription on August 7 and closes on August 11, while the anchor investor bidding date would be August 6 for JSW Cement, according to the Red Herring Prospectus (RHP) filed on Friday. The initial share sale comprises a fresh issue of equity shares worth Rs 1,600 crore and an Offer for Sale of shares worth up to Rs 2,000 crore by investor shareholders. As a part of the OFS, private equity giant Apollo Management , through its affiliate AP Asia Opportunistic Holdings Pte Ltd, will be offloading shares worth Rs 931.80 crore, Synergy Metals Investments Holding Ltd will sell shares worth Rs 938.50 crore, and State Bank of India ( SBI ) will divest shares valued at Rs 129.70 crore. Live Events Synergy Metals Investments Holding is an arm of Synergy Metals and Mining Fund, a private equity fund set up by a former executive of steelmaker ArcelorMittal, Sudhir Maheshwari, in 2015. As per draft papers, the company will utilise proceeds worth Rs 800 crore to part-finance a new integrated cement unit at Nagaur, Rajasthan, and Rs 520 crore on prepayment or repayment of outstanding borrowings availed by it. The rest would be used for general corporate purposes. The Mumbai-based company had earlier planned to raise Rs 4,000 crore. At the time of filing papers, JSW Cement said it intended to raise Rs 2,000 crore from a fresh issue of equity shares and an offer for sale (OFS) of Rs 2,000 crore by investor shareholders. However, the size of the fresh capital-raising has been cut by Rs 400 crore from the fresh issue, as per the latest RHP. In August 2024, JSW Cement filed preliminary IPO papers with Sebi, and later in September, the regulator kept the company's proposed initial share-sale on hold. On January 6, this year, the regulator finally gave its observation to float the IPO. As of March 31, 2025, JSW Cement's total borrowings stood at Rs 6,166.6 crore. On the financial front, the company's revenue from operations for FY25 stood at Rs 5,813.1 crore against Rs 6,028.10 crore in FY24, and Rs 5,836.72 crore in FY23. The company reported a loss of Rs 163.77 crore in FY25. Its profit was Rs 62 crore in FY24 and Rs 104 crore in FY23. As of March 31, 2025, JSW Cement had an installed grinding capacity of 20.60 million metric tonnes per annum (MMTPA). According to the CRISIL report, JSW Cement is India's largest manufacturer of ground granulated blast furnace slag (GGBS), an eco-friendly product produced entirely from blast furnace slag (a by-product of the steel manufacturing process), with a market share in terms of GGBS sales of 84 per cent in FY25. The company presently operates manufacturing operations at units based at Vijayanagar in Karnataka, Nandyal in Andhra Pradesh, Salboni in West Bengal, Jajpur in Odisha and Dolvi in Maharashtra. JSW Cement through its subsidiary Shiva Cement operates a clinker unit in Odisha. JM Financial Ltd , Axis Capital Ltd , Citigroup Global Markets India Pvt Ltd, DAM Capital Advisors Ltd , Goldman Sachs (India) Securities Pvt Ltd, Jefferies India Pvt Ltd, Kotak Mahindra Capital Company Ltd and SBI Capital Markets Ltd are responsible for managing the company's IPO process. The company's shares will be listed on the BSE and NSE. PTI
Mint
33 minutes ago
- Mint
Lenders Win Reprieve in UK Motor Finance Case From Top Court
A group of lenders won a major reprieve in a pivotal UK car finance case, after the country's top judges agreed that banks should only pay compensation in the most serious cases of motor finance misselling. The Supreme Court on Friday overturned most of a lower court ruling that last year had sent shares in affected banks spiralling. The decision also throws into uncertainty a compensation program that analysts previously estimated would cost the banks tens of billions of pounds. The Financial Conduct Authority said it would confirm before markets open on Monday whether it would go ahead with its plans. 'We will be working through the weekend to analyze the judgment and determine our next steps,' an FCA spokesperson said in a statement. 'If we do decide to propose a redress scheme, we'll consult widely.' The ruling was issued after the London stock markets had closed to prevent any market disruption, Judge Robert Reed said. Lloyds Banking Group Plc and Close Brothers Group Plc American depositary receipts were up more than 4% at 6:30 p.m. in London. The court said car dealers can act in their commercial interests, and dismissed most of the arguments that dealers selling loans for the banks must obtain consumers' informed consent to charge commission. The dealer 'was not a fiduciary: that is to say, a person entirely committed to acting in another person's interest without any interest of his own,' Judge Reed said. 'On the contrary, the car dealer was at all times pursuing its own commercial interests in achieving a sale of the car on profitable terms.' The judges upheld one of the Court of Appeal's rulings, saying a case brought by one of the claimants — Marcus Johnson — stood out because of several factors including the high level of commission the consumer was charged and the fact that the customer was expected to read a lengthy legal contract to understand the size of that fee. He also wasn't told that his lender, FirstRand Ltd., had the right to refuse the loan in the first place. 'I am delighted for him,' said Kevin Durkin, a lawyer for Johnson. 'It's a really good win for the consumer because they have got an angle and a route into court now.' Peter Rothwell, head of banking at KPMG, said affected banks will still need to continue preparations to compensate eligible customers. 'But they can do so with greater confidence that it will focus on discretionary commission arrangements and cases where there is a breach of the Consumer Credit Act as a result of an unfair relationship, rather than all historic commissions.' Professional services firm BDO said the judgment could still result in redress of between £5 billion and £13 billion, or more, with clarity needed from the FCA about its next steps. Before Friday's ruling, analysts had estimated that the total bill for compensation could top £30 billion. Close Brothers and FirstRand appealed the case to the top court after previous judges said that consumers taking out car loans without giving informed consent about commission were treated unfairly. In a company statement on Saturday, Close Brothers welcomed the ruling on motor finance commissions, calling it a source of legal clarity. There remains uncertainty over potential costs until the FCA confirms whether it plans to consult on a redress scheme, the company added. FirstRand did not immediately respond to a request for comment. The Finance and Leasing Association, an industry body, said the ruling 'properly reflects the role and responsibilities of dealers, lenders and customers, and it has restored certainty and clarity to the largest point-of-sale consumer credit market in the UK.' 'The FCA now has the legal clarity to continue its work to establish if a redress scheme is needed, and of course the thousands of unfounded complaints submitted to lenders by claimant law firms and CMCs can now be removed from the system,' Stephen Haddrill, director general of the FLA, said in a statement. What Bloomberg Intelligence Says: Lloyds and UK peers' £1.7 billion in provisions for covering car-loan risks may be sufficient after the Supreme Court significantly narrowed lenders' legal exposure by reining in a lower court's findings. The ruling is a relief for the sector and allows lenders to effectively avoid a scandal that could cost as much as £30 billion. — Tomasz Noetzel, senior analyst, banks With assistance from Ronan Martin, Adelaide Changole and Christian Dass. This article was generated from an automated news agency feed without modifications to text.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Over 17,000 VA staff depart, US unemployment at 4.2 per cent; is the federal workforce at a tipping point?
As the US labor market shows signs of weakening, with July 2025 marking the slowest job growth in over two years, a quiet but historic exodus is underway inside the federal government. The Department of Veterans Affairs , one of the nation's largest employers, is losing over 10,000 staff through a controversial 'deferred resignation' offer, even as the broader economy cools and unemployment ticks up to 4.2 percent. What started in January as a cryptic 'Fork in the Road' email from the Office of Personnel Management has now led to sweeping staffing reductions across multiple agencies. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Please select course: Select a Course Category Digital Marketing healthcare MBA Product Management Others Data Science Artificial Intelligence Data Science Public Policy CXO Data Analytics Management PGDM Design Thinking Project Management Degree Healthcare others MCA Operations Management Cybersecurity Technology Finance Leadership Skills you'll gain: Digital Marketing Strategies Customer Journey Mapping Paid Advertising Campaign Management Emerging Technologies in Digital Marketing Duration: 12 Weeks Indian School of Business Digital Marketing and Analytics Starts on May 14, 2024 Get Details Skills you'll gain: Digital Marketing Strategy Search Engine Optimization (SEO) & Content Marketing Social Media Marketing & Advertising Data Analytics & Measurement Duration: 24 Weeks Indian School of Business Professional Certificate Programme in Digital Marketing Starts on Jun 26, 2024 Get Details Also Read: Should you keep eggs in the fridge? How improper storage could raise your risk of Salmonella by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like How Much Does It Cost to Rent a Private Jet - The Prices May Surprise You! Private Jet I Search Ads Learn More Undo At the VA, doctors, nurses, and front-line support workers are walking out, raising new fears about essential services and job security, at a time when hiring in sectors like retail and tech is slowing and layoffs are rising. Live Events What is DRP? The Deferred Resignation Program (DRP) refers to a voluntary separation offer made to federal employees under the Trump administration in early 2025. It originated from a now-infamous email sent by the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) in January, titled 'A Fork in the Road.' What the DRP allowed? Eligible federal workers were given a choice: If they replied 'resign,' they would keep receiving full pay and benefits through September 30, 2025, even though they would no longer report to work. If they chose to stay, they faced uncertainty, including potential layoffs or workforce cuts. Although the VA initially claimed that 'mission-critical' staff such as doctors and nurses would be protected, data obtained through Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests by The War Horse show that hundreds of clinical roles have still been approved for resignation. This includes 214 nurses, 35 doctors, and 24 VA police officers. These resignations come on top of broader attrition. Since last September, the VA has lost 2,000 registered nurses and 750 doctors, reversing hiring trends from previous years. Support staff are also leaving in droves The largest categories of staff leaving include 1,355 human resources workers, 1,010 program analysts, and 928 IT employees. Critics argue that losing these employees will strain the system. Even if doctors and nurses stay, they will face more administrative burden as support staff vanish. As of July, VA had reduced staff by about 17,000 through attrition, early retirements, and resignations. Another 12,000 are expected to leave by September. VA Secretary Doug Collins has defended the strategy. He told War Horse that the focus should shift from headcount to outcomes, how many veterans are helped rather than how many staff are hired. US job market shows signs of weakness The problems at VA mirror broader concerns about the US labor market. According to the July 2025 jobs report, the US added just 73,000 jobs, the lowest in over two years. The unemployment rate ticked up to 4.2 per cent, marking a second straight month of decline in job growth. This slowdown is striking. Monthly job gains averaged over 240,000 in 2024. Now, the economy is showing clear signs of cooling, especially in sectors like retail and tech, where layoffs and hiring freezes are becoming more common. To make matters worse, earlier reports for May and June were revised downward, suggesting that job growth had been overstated. The Federal Reserve is closely watching the labor data. Inflation remains high between 2.6 per cent and 2.8 per cent making interest rate cuts unlikely in the short term. But a weakening job market complicates things.
