Harvard doctors sue Trump administration over censoring LGBTQ+ terms
Keep up with the latest in + news and politics.
The plaintiffs, Gordon Schiff and Celeste Royce are described in the lawsuit as 'two doctors and Harvard Medical School professors who refused to censor their medical conclusions to bend to this political fiat,' adding they filed the suit 'to defend the integrity of medical research and the safety of patients from the government's dangerous, arbitrary, and unconstitutional censorship.'
They sued over the removal of two articles from the government-run Patient Safety Network (PSNet). 'Endometriosis: A Common and Commonly Missed and Delayed Diagnosis' was co-authored by Royce, and 'Multiple Missed Opportunities for Suicide Risk Assessment in Emergency and Primary Care Settings' was co-authored by Schiff. Both articles contained a sentence referencing the transgender, gender-nonconforming, or LGBTQ+ community.
PSNet is run by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ), which is part of the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS).
According to the lawsuit, Schiff received an email from Patrick Romano, a co-editor of PSNet, saying the articles were being removed from the site in response to an email directive from the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) ordering the removal of any content that might be in non-compliance with the White House's executive order on gender identity.
Romano provided further explanation of the decision in a follow-up email to the Editor-in-Chief of the Bellevue Literary Review.
'Per this memo, AHRQ staff were given until 5pm ET Friday to 'Take down all outward facing media (websites, social media accounts etc.) that promote or inculcate gender ideology.'' Romano wrote. 'Based on guidance provided to AHRQ staff, this instruction from OPM was interpreted to include anything with the words 'transgender,' 'nonbinary,' or 'gender identity.' The phrase 'LGBTQ' is problematic because it includes that letter T for 'transgender.'
The doctors are represented by the American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts and the Media Freedom and Information Access Clinic at Yale Law School.
'Good doctors serve and advocate for their patients, whoever they are,' Royce said in a statement. 'We cannot uphold an oath to Do No Harm if our training and research are politicized.'
'This type of wholesale, non-evidence-based removal endangers everyone's safety,' Schiff said in a statement. 'Censoring information about transgender people or anyone a politician does not like, who have documented increased risks of negative health outcomes, is antithetical to the very mission of public health.'
'Our clients were given an impossible choice between removing their article from PSNet entirely or censoring parts of it,' Rachel Davidson, a staff attorney at the ACLU of Massachusetts, said in a statement. 'This is an intentional erasure of knowledge, an attack on the integrity of scientific research, and an affront to the public's need for accurate, adequate health information.'
The suit argues that the government violated the First Amendment free speech rights of the doctors and the Administrative Procedure Act for removing articles without cause. The OPM, AHRQ, and HHS are named as defendants in the suit.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
EndoDiagnosis & ENDOSURE Revolutionize Endometriosis Detection in Canada with 30-Minute Non-Invasive Test
Kelowna, Aug. 04, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- EndoDiagnosis is changing the landscape of women's healthcare with its new role as the sole distributor in Canada for the ENDOSURE Tier 1 diagnostic test for endometriosis. This new diagnostic tool marks a significant shift in how endometriosis is detected and managed, cutting down the average diagnosis time from over eight years to just 30 minutes. In the past, diagnosing endometriosis required invasive laparoscopic surgery. This often meant that patients endured years of pain and a lower quality of life without a proper diagnosis. The ENDOSURE test offers a non-invasive option, boasting 99% accuracy in detecting all stages of the disease in less than an hour. This bypasses the need for surgical procedures. Learn more about EndoDiagnosis and what they offer by visiting their website. EndoDiagnosis Founders – Maria Porcellato, Carolyn Plican, Dr. Mary Ellen Haggerty This development is crucial for addressing a major gap in healthcare. Women suffering from endometriosis symptoms frequently face challenges in receiving the correct diagnosis and treatment. By providing a quick and effective diagnostic tool, ENDOSURE helps healthcare providers make faster, more informed decisions, improving care for those impacted by this chronic illness. Maria Porcellato, CEO of EndoDiagnosis, stated, "We have seen the desperation in patients, clients, and even our own daughters that comes with undiagnosed endometriosis. Our mission centers on empowering both patients and healthcare teams with the decision-support tools they need to make informed decisions about healthcare." The ENDOSURE Tier 1 test is designed for women of any age and provides results on the spot without the need for referrals or lab work. Its non-invasive nature not only spares patients from unnecessary surgical procedures but also enables healthcare professionals to concentrate on therapeutic strategies to manage the disease, preserving both quality of life and fertility. EndoDiagnosis is not just distributing this advanced technology but is also dedicated to ensuring its successful use in clinics throughout Canada. The company offers training and certification for healthcare providers, professional medical education, and awareness programs, along with a provider directory to help patients find testing centers. This initiative places Canada at the forefront of endometriosis care, allowing healthcare professionals to offer their patients both clarity and hope. Carolyn Plican, COO of EndoDiagnosis, stressed the importance of this development, commenting, "This partnership represents more than a business agreement – it's about validating women's experiences and providing the answers they desperately need. When patients understand the root cause of their symptoms, it reduces stress, creates closure, and empowers them to move forward with effective treatment strategies."
Boston Globe
8 hours ago
- Boston Globe
Prominent national Democrats ask Josh Kraft to stop using names, likenesses in unauthorized fundraising push
And, it turns out, Schiff never said Kraft could reach out with that urgent message. The Kraft Schiff's name and likeness is one of at least five the campaign has sent in recent weeks that feature prominent national Democrats who have not publicly weighed in on the Boston mayor's race. At least two of those politicians have now asked the Kraft campaign to stop using their names and likenesses in the email fundraising solicitations. 'Immediately after being informed that the Kraft campaign sent an email we did not approve of in Schiff's name, we reached out to the campaign to ask them to stop,' said a spokesperson for the Schiff campaign. 'While an unfortunate situation, the Kraft campaign let us know that it would not happen again.' Advertisement In addition to Schiff, Kraft fundraising emails featured US Representative Eric Swalwell of California; US Representative Jasmine Crockett of Texas; former North Carolina Governor Roy Cooper, who is running for US Senate; and Shawn Harris, a retired brigadier general and political candidate in Georgia. Swalwell's campaign said he also did not approve the fundraising solicitation, and is asking Kraft to put an end to it. Crockett, Cooper, and Harris did not return requests for comment from the Globe on Monday, but none appears to have publicly waded into the Boston mayor's race. Advertisement The emails sent by the Kraft campaign urged potential donors to financially support both Kraft and the highlighted politician in whose name the email was sent. So-called split list fundraising is not uncommon in Democratic politics; allied politicians often urge their donors to back like minded candidates in an effort to increase their ranks and forge connections. Typically, those fundraising solicitations come from politicians who have explicitly endorsed one another, or at least signed off on the shared fundraising push. It would be highly unusual, if not unheard of, for a political candidate to send such an email in a contested election if she had not already endorsed one of the candidates, political operatives said. Related : For example, in the last month alone, Mayor Michelle Wu's campaign has sent email blasts from US Senators Ed Markey and Elizabeth Warren, as well as US Representative Ayanna Pressley. All three are vocal supporters of the mayor, and the emails sent in their name directed donors to give exclusively to Wu. Political and campaign finance experts called the Kraft campaign's recent fundraising blitz unorthodox, or even potentially misleading for donors, while Wu, whom Kraft is seeking to unseat, argued it could be illegal. In a letter on Sunday, Wu campaign treasurer Robert Binney called on the state Office of Campaign and Political Finance to investigate. Advertisement 'Even assuming a donor managed to decipher the fine print, these voters would reasonably assume that leading national figures like Senator Schiff and Representative Crockett are supporting Kraft's campaign for Mayor, which we believe to be untrue and an obvious attempt to deceive voters,' Binney wrote. 'At best these practices are highly deceptive and negligent, at worst they are illegal violations of our state campaign finance laws.' A spokesperson for the Kraft campaign defended the legality of the fundraising push, and said the unauthorized emails were 'an error on the part of our vendor.' 'Our vendor is responsible for the approvals process with all candidates involved. As a result of today's inquiries, we have been made aware that what we thought was an isolated incident in failing to seek approval was much larger,' said the spokesperson, Eileen O'Connor. 'As a result, we are moving to shut down the links and terminate our agreement with the consulting firm.' The OCPF complaint from Wu's campaign is 'lacking on both substantive and legal grounds,' O'Connor added. 'Michelle Wu is desperate to distract voters from her broken campaign promises and failures on so many pressing issues.' Related : The Kraft campaign has also The email featuring Schiff was sent on July 20. When Schiff's team reached out the next day, they were quickly told it would not happen again. But more than a week later, on Aug. 2, Kraft's campaign sent an email that appeared to come from Swalwell, another well known California Democrat. Advertisement 'As the senior-most Democrat on the House Homeland Security Committee, I've seen a lot,' the email begins, before railing against a Trump appointee and the actions of the administration. 'Chip in today,' the email urged, linking to an Swalwell also did not approve of the email sent in his voice, a spokesperson told the Globe Monday. 'We were not aware that they did this. We did not approve, nor would we have,' said Lisa Tucker, a spokesperson for Swalwell's campaign. Tucker said Swalwell's team had reached out to the Kraft campaign to ask that the joint Act Blue link be shut down. Tucker said Swalwell has offered a 'partner toolkit' for a year and a half 'and have never had something like this happen.' Typically, allied candidates who want to fundraise alongside him would seek permission directly, and the Swalwell campaign would approve of any fundraising emails before they are sent, she said. 'This is definitely making us reexamine our process to make sure this doesn't happen again,' Tucker said. Other emails featuring prominent national Democrats were sent on July 30 and Aug. 1, according to screenshots obtained by the Globe. Kraft is seen as Wu's closest rival in the mayor's race this year, though a recent Suffolk University/ Boston Globe poll Advertisement So far, Kraft has been a strong fundraiser. As of the end of June, Related : The fundraising emails raise serious questions about the Kraft campaign's tactics, said Jack Corrigan, a campaign finance lawyer and longtime Democratic operative who has donated to Wu this campaign cycle but does not work for her campaign. The emails — at least some of which were sent without permission of the high profile Democrats — imply an endorsement, and for donors, that could be 'deceptive,' Corrigan said. 'Even if it's legal,' he said, 'it's questionable.' Tal Kopan of the Globe staff contributed to this report. Emma Platoff can be reached at
Yahoo
13 hours ago
- Yahoo
New study reveals endometriosis affects far more than reproductive health
Scientists have uncovered strong links between endometriosis and a wide range of other health conditions, including cancer, Crohn's disease, and migraines, thanks to advances in big data research. Endometriosis is a painful and often overlooked condition that affects an estimated one in ten women globally. Despite its prevalence, diagnosis can take years, and treatment options remain limited. Now, a new study reveals hundreds of connections between endometriosis and other diseases, adding to a growing body of evidence that shows it is not just a reproductive disorder but a 'multi-system' disorder affecting the whole body. Related Could gynaecological disorders raise your risk of heart disease? New research suggests they might Women who had traumatic childhoods are at higher risk of this debilitating gynaecological condition These issues 'ranged from what we already knew or suspected, like infertility, autoimmune disease, and acid reflux, to the unexpected, like certain cancers, asthma, and eye-related diseases,' Umair Khan, one of the study's authors and a researcher at the University of California - San Francisco (UCSF) in the US, said in a statement. For the study, Khan and his colleagues analysed more than 43,000 patient records collected at six health centres, using algorithms developed for the project. They sifted through the patients' medical histories to spot patterns between endometriosis and other health problems. Some patients had migraines, bolstering previous studies suggesting that migraine drugs might help treat endometriosis. In all, they found more than 600 correlations, Khan said. 'This is the kind of data we need to move the needle, which hasn't moved in decades,' Dr Linda Giudice, one of the study's authors and a physician-scientist in the department of obstetrics, gynaecology and reproductive sciences at UCSF, said in a statement. 'We're finally getting closer to faster diagnosis and, eventually, we hope, tailored treatment for the millions of women who suffer from endometriosis,' Giudice added. Related One in 10 women worldwide suffer from endometriosis. Why do we still know so little about it? Australian online programme teaches GPs to better understand chronic pelvic pain Devastating toll on lives For those living with endometriosis, the impact is far-reaching. 'The impact on patients' lives is huge, from their interpersonal relationships to being able to hold a job, have a family, and maintain psychological well-being,' said Giudice. Current treatments mainly focus on hormone therapy to suppress the menstrual cycle or surgery to remove affected tissue. In more severe cases, patients may undergo a hysterectomy, the surgical removal of the uterus. Yet even then, relief is not guaranteed. Not everyone responds well to hormonal treatment, which can bring harsh side effects. The condition can flare up after surgery, and some women continue to suffer pain even after a hysterectomy. Researchers hope that the new findings will help improve the diagnosis and treatment of the mysterious disease. 'We now have both the tools and the data to make a difference for the huge population that suffers from endometriosis,' said Marina Sirota, one of the study's authors and a professor of paediatrics at UCSF. 'We hope this can spur a sea change in how we approach this disorder'.
