logo
Supermarket price wars ‘chilling prospect' for farmers, says MP in regulator bid

Supermarket price wars ‘chilling prospect' for farmers, says MP in regulator bid

Independent19-03-2025
Supermarket price wars are a 'chilling prospect' for food growers, an MP has said amid efforts to join up regulation covering shops and farmers.
Alistair Carmichael said the farm-to-fork pipeline needed 'direct action' from the Government and warned that 'without it, we risk losing domestic food production and any notion of food security'.
He urged MPs to back his Food Products (Market Regulation and Public Procurement) Bill, which secured its first reading on Wednesday, days after Asda bosses indicated the chain was planning to set up a grocery price war.
The chain's chairman Allan Leighton vowed last week to 'undertake a substantive and well-backed programme of investment in price, availability and the shopping experience', amid efforts to regain customers' trust in the brand.
Mr Carmichael told the Commons: 'For farmers, that is a chilling prospect.
'If supermarkets are about to embark on a race to the bottom, then we can be pretty sure that it will be farmers, not company executives or shareholders, who will be expected to take the hit.'
The Liberal Democrat MP for Orkney and Shetland said it was 'not for' Parliament to 'pick a winner in a fight between supermarkets', but he warned that 'any supermarket that thinks it can rebuild its balance sheet on the back of Britain's farmers might find themselves in front of the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Select Committee', which he chairs.
Mr Carmichael said his Bill, if agreed to, would require co-ordination between two existing watchdogs – the Groceries Code Adjudicator and the Agricultural Supply Chain Adjudicator.
It will next be listed for debate on June 20.
He previously described 'a bit of regulation at one end and a bit of regulation at the other and no wiring between the two and nothing actually even to join together the two bits of regulation'.
Supermarkets backtrack on the commitments they make to farmers without a reason and say 'we don't want your product any more', Mr Carmichael told the PA news agency, adding: 'That farmer or processor will probably have gone to some expense to market and batch and package their product in such a way that the supermarket demands but they'll pull the rug out from underneath you.'
He also said that if supermarkets decide to cut milk prices 'everybody then passes that on down the line to the family farmer, and the farmer essentially at the end of the day is left having to shrug his shoulders and just take the hit'.
The Groceries Supply Code of Practice (GSCOP) promotes 'fair dealing' and discourages supermarkets from demanding changes to their supply chains without 'reasonable notice'.
Mr Carmichael said farmers 'take it' because complaining to the Groceries Code Adjudicator, who is supposed to enforce the code, could mean they struggle to 'get back in' with the supermarkets and suffer 'bad long-term consequences'.
A new regulator could have built-in protections, including the power and resources to proactively investigate suspected breaches without the need for farmers to complain.
Asked whether shoppers will face higher prices amid efforts to pass a bigger share of sales to farmers, Mr Carmichael said: 'I don't think the people who can afford to be impacted by this are the consumers.
'I think that the people who are doing rather nicely out of this are the supermarkets and indeed some of the processors and distributors as well.
'So if you're going to find a way of improving the lot of the farmer you have to do it in a way that doesn't actually work to the detriment of the consumer, and that's why you've got to have a regulator that is big enough and has sufficient resource to be taken seriously by supermarkets.'
The MP said subsidies since the time of the Second World War have meant the food market had already experienced significant Government interventions.
Several organisation leaders have indicated their support for the proposal, including at the National Farmers' Union (NFU) and the Food, Farming and Countryside Commission.
Dr Charlie Taverner, farming futures policy lead at the Food, Farming and Countryside Commission, said: 'In our new report Paying the Price, we found that consolidation, driven by decades of government policy to cheapen food, means farmers have little bargaining power and big corporations have a disproportionate influence on government policy.
'This long-term squeeze on farming profits, with farmers' incomes having barely risen in 50 years, has had major costs to our health, the planet and rural communities.
'Alistair Carmichael's idea of a farm-to fork watchdog is exactly the kind of bold thinking our report recommends.'
NFU president Tom Bradshaw called for a 'policy which doesn't undermine' farmers, adding: 'Strengthening farmers' position means making our food system more resilient and provides a trading environment that remains competitive and innovative.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Donald Trump: The highs and lows of his relationship with Scotland
Donald Trump: The highs and lows of his relationship with Scotland

The Herald Scotland

time13 minutes ago

  • The Herald Scotland

Donald Trump: The highs and lows of his relationship with Scotland

Though Trump has said he "feels Scottish", his relationship with the country has had its ups and downs. Here are the highs and the lows. Read More: Trump's Scottish connection The President is connected to Scotland by blood, his mother, Mary Anne MacLeod, was from Stornoway. Born in the village of Tong in 1912 to Malcolm, a crofter and fisherman, and Mary Ann hers was a tough upbringing, the Hebrides at the time being described by historian James Hunter as "where I always considered human wretchedness to have reached its very acme" and by the President as "serious Scotland". She grew up speaking Gaelic, only learning English when she went to school, but Tong didn't have much to offer a young woman. Mary became one of the roughly half a million Scots who emigrated between 1919 and 1938, with over three-quarters of those heading to North America. The day before her 18th birthday, May 11 1930, she arrived in New York City under immigrant visa 2669191. As she arrived on the RMS Transylvania, Mary would have passed the Statue of Liberty on her way to the immigration centre on Ellis Island. Records show she had never visited the U.S before and was carrying the sum total of $50. Inscribed on the statue, the first thing new immigrants from Europe would see, is a poem which concludes: "Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free/the wretched refuse of your teeming shore, send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me/I lift my lamp beside the golden door." Those lofty sentiments clearly haven't rubbed off on the President who declared in October last year: "We're a dumping ground. We're like a garbage can for the world. Every time I come up and talk about what they've done to our country I get angry and angrier." A few years later Mary met property developer Fred Trump and the rest is history. Donald, who was born in 1946, may have been named after her maternal grandfather, who died at sea aged 34 but he's visited Lewis just twice in his life, once as a toddler and once for around 90 minutes on the way to one of his golf courses. Highs Donald Trump with The Wee Red Book at Turnberry (Image: Colin Templeton) While most of Trump's dealings with Scotland and in particular the Scottish Government have been adversarial, there have been some moments of harmony along the way. When the future President first purchased the land which would become Trump International Aberdeen, he was welcomed with open arms by First Minister Jack McConnell. The Scottish Labour leader invited Trump to become a 'Globalscot', a network of overseas Scots and friends of Scotland who served as business ambassadors. McConnell said: "Donald has shown me a real passion for Scotland. He is a globally recognised figure who can help us to promote Scotland. I am delighted that he has taken up my offer. This is a good bit of business for all concerned." Indeed, the First Minister wanted to go further by making him a 'platinum member' of the Globalscot club, a unique status which would have been reserved only for The Donald. Such was the love-in, Green MSP Patrick Harvie quipped: "It's beginning to look embarrassing that the leader of the government is behaving like a teenager with a crush." Things continued in much the same vein with McConnell's successor, Alex Salmond - at least initially. In 2007 Aberdeenshire Council rejected planning permission for Trump's golf course and, rather than submitting a new application, the Apprentice host announced he would look elsewhere. In an unprecedented move, the Scottish Government called in the proposal, saying it "raises issues of importance that require consideration at a national level". Trump had met with Salmond the day before. Holyrood eventually approved the proposal, with Trump saying: "I hardly know [[Alex Salmond]], but what I know is that he's an amazing man. "Alex Salmond and I have virtually never even talked about this job but I know for a fact that he - and anyone else who's representing Scotland, unless they're the enemy - wants billions of pounds to come into Aberdeenshire and Scotland." It was on the way to a public hearing about that golf course in Balmedie that Trump visited his mother's croft on Lewis - for a grand total of 97 seconds - and declared "I do feel Scottish". In 2010, Trump was given an honorary degree by Robert Gordon University in Aberdeen raising a chuckle when he was introduced as "the highest-paid speaker in the world" and replied "not today". Speaking of his mother he said: "She was very thrifty. The Scots have this reputation for watching the dollars, so she really had a natural business instinct. "She loved everything that this great place stood for and she'd be very proud today." Lows Donald Trump at Turnberry (Image: Colin Templeton) Trump would not have such an easy relationship with Scotland for long, indeed he was stripped of that degree in 2015. The process of building that first golf course in Aberdeenshire was long and controversial with one local farmer, Michael Forbes, refusing to sell his land to the billionaire. An exasperated Trump ultimately offered £450,000 and a £50k per year job for the small farm. The response? "He can take his money and shove it up his arse." Trump did, of course, finally get his course built but was soon on a collision course with the Scottish Government over one of his pet peeves - wind turbines. As well as objecting to them aesthetically, the President appears to genuinely believe that the noise made by the rotating blades causes cancer. When permission was granted for a wind farm off the coast of Aberdeenshire - in full view of his new course - the future leader of the free world was apoplectic. He wrote a furious letter to Salmond asking: "Do you want to be known for centuries to come as 'Mad Alex - the man who destroyed Scotland'?" So incensed was The Donald he appeared before the Scottish Parliament to give evidence, drawing laughs from the public gallery when asked for his evidence of the negative impact of turbines and responding: "I am the evidence." "He came, he saw, he blustered," said CBS News. Trump threatened to withdraw all investment in Scotland if the plans went ahead, but ultimately decided to expand his portfolio with the acquisition of the Turnberry course in South Ayrshire. He abandoned the Republican primary in 2016 to open the course, where he famously predicted that the UK would vote for Brexit, stunning the political pundit class with his foresight. As he told The Sun: "I predicted Brexit. I was cutting a ribbon for the opening of Turnberry - you know they did a whole renovation, it is beautiful - the day before the Brexit vote. 'I said, 'Brexit will happen'. The vote is going to be positive because people don't want to be faced with the horrible immigration problems that they are being faced with in other countries. I said Brexit will happen, and I was right.' The only slight flaw in this story is that Trump arrived in Ayrshire the day after the vote when the result had already been announced. He did not meet with Salmond's successor, Nicola Sturgeon, on that visit with the First Minister later telling ITV: "I expect the people of the United States will have the good sense not to elect him." The two may not share much in common, but it appears prognostication skill is one of them. Sturgeon was forced into something of a climbdown with what the White House described as "a short congratulatory call" and a letter, though the First Minister made clear she would "not maintain a diplomatic silence" in the face of "abhorrent comments". When Trump was defeated by Joe Biden in 2020, she offered a "cheerio" and "don't haste ye back", with the businessman commenting on the former First Minister's own travails on a trip to Turnberry in 2023 as he said "she has not been a great person for Scotland". John Swinney then caused a stooshie of his own when he urged American voters to back Kamala Harris in November's election, only for Trump to win in a landslide. Son Eric Trump said: "My father adores Scotland, and you have a First Minister coming out and just being fairly nasty in the days leading up. 'I mean, who did that benefit? Did that benefit Scotland?" The First Minister is expected to meet with Trump on his short visit to Scotland - things may be a little frosty.

Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds dismisses 'daft' wealth tax - 'be serious'
Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds dismisses 'daft' wealth tax - 'be serious'

Daily Mirror

time14 minutes ago

  • Daily Mirror

Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds dismisses 'daft' wealth tax - 'be serious'

It is the first time a Government minister has explicitly ruled out a wealth tax since plans to cut disability benefits were gutted, leaving Chancellor Rachel Reeves with a battle to balance the books The Business Secretary has hit out at "daft" demands for a "magic wealth tax" to plug holes in the public finances. ‌ Jonathan Reynolds rubbished speculation that Chancellor Rachel Reeves could balance the books after U-turns on disability benefit cuts and winter fuel with a levy on the wealthiest Brits. ‌ Ms Reeves has refused to rule out a tax on wealth, which has been backed by Labour figures, including former leader Lord Neil Kinnock and Wales's First Minister Eluned Morgan. ‌ But Mr Reynolds dismissed the idea and told supporters to "be serious", in comments likely to anger some on the Labour left where support is growing for the move. It is the first time a Government minister has explicitly ruled out a wealth tax since Keir Starmer was forced to gut his plans to cut disability benefits last month. ‌ The Chancellor has been left to make up the shortfall, while battling sluggish growth and higher than expected borrowing. Experts believe she may be forced to put up taxes in the autumn if she wants to avoid making cuts to public services - triggering calls for a new tax on wealth. But Mr Reynolds told GB News: "This Labour Government has increased taxes on wealth as opposed to income - the taxes on private jets, private schools, changes through inheritance tax, capital gains tax. ‌ "But the idea there's a magic wealth tax, some sort of levy... that doesn't exist anywhere in the world. "Switzerland has a levy but they don't have capital gains or inheritance tax. "There's no kind of magic (tax). We're not going to do anything daft like that. ‌ "And I say to people: 'Be serious about this.' The idea you can just levy everyone... What if your wealth was not in your bank account, (what if it was) in fine wine or art? "How would we tax that? This is why this doesn't exist." The Chancellor recently told the Mirror that ordinary workers won't see their VAT, income tax or national insurance contributions rise. And Ms Reeves signalled a lack of enthusiasm for a dedicated wealth tax, saying she had already asked the wealthiest and businesses to pay more in last year's Budget, which included a £40billion tax raid to fund cash-strapped public services like hospitals and schools.

Ex justice secretary demands UK pay for Trump's visit
Ex justice secretary demands UK pay for Trump's visit

The Herald Scotland

time28 minutes ago

  • The Herald Scotland

Ex justice secretary demands UK pay for Trump's visit

The Alba Party leader made the comments as Mr Trump has said he is looking forward to meeting First Minister John Swinney with the pair expected to meet during the president's four-day trip to Scotland, which is expected to begin on Friday evening. Mr Trump will visit both of the golf clubs he owns in the country - Turnberry in South Ayrshire and Menie, near Aberdeen, in the coming days. He is also due to meet Prime Minister Keir Starmer during his visit. Before boarding the presidential plane Air Force One to fly to Scotland, the US President told journalists: "The Scottish leader is a good man, so I look forward to meeting him." He also said he has a "lot of love" for Scotland. READ MORE: Billed as a private visit, the trip comes ahead of the state visit, expected to take place in September, when Mr Trump will meet the King. Despite that, the president's visit will prove a huge logistical challenge for Police Scotland, with the national force calling in support from the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI). Earlier this week, both the Scottish Police Federation, which represents rank and file officers, and the Association of Scottish Police Superintendents raised concerns about the pressure being put on policing by the arrival of the US leader. In a statement Mr MacAskill said: "We are seeing our police service drained, front line policing undermined and officers burned out as a result of the pressures being put on Police Scotland to police the Trump visit to Scotland. "The private visit is only taking place because Sir [[Keir Starmer]] wanted the visit to take place away from Parliament. Therefore it is only right and proper that full cost reimbursement for the massive policing costs of the Trump visit should be met from the coffers of the UK and not the Scottish Government. 'The UK Government met the core costs when world leaders came to Scotland for the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting (CHOGM) and that is the very least that should happen now. 'But this private trip is only happening because the UK Government have invited Trump to the UK and so they should meet the full costs. 'We must not have the double whammy of our police services being stretched while at the same time the Scottish Government having to pick up the massive costs of policing the Trump is why the UK Government must meet the full costs for the visit and the disruption which they have imposed on Scotland.' Speaking to the PA news agency ahead of the visit on Friday, Mr Swinney said the meeting will be "an opportunity to "essentially speak out for Scotland" on international issues such as Gaza, as well as trade and the increase of business from the United States in Scotland. "There are clearly also significant international issues upon which the people of Scotland have a view and want to have that view expressed by their First Minister," he said. "That relates to the awfulness of the situation in Gaza and the unbearable human suffering that is going on in Gaza. "I want to make sure that those concerns and those views are expressed to the president of the United States. "We have that opportunity, and I intend to take that opportunity to make sure that Scotland's voice is heard." Mr Swinney also urged all of those set to protest against the president's visit to do so "peacefully and to do so within the law". The UK Government was approached for comment.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store