Open letter to Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi: Please explain the HIV numbers
Dear Minister Motsoaledi,
We write to you in response to your 15 May 2025 press statement and subsequent remarks in Parliament on the current status of the national HIV, Aids, and TB campaign.
You stated that since the launch of the Close the Gap campaign, 520,700 people have been initiated on HIV treatment, reaching 'more than 50% of the target'. You also stated that 5.9 million people were currently on antiretroviral therapy (ART). However, at the campaign's launch on 25 February 2025, you reported the same number on HIV treatment — 5.9 million. This raises a critical question: If more than half a million people have started or restarted treatment, why has the total number of people on treatment not increased?
If both figures are accurate, this would mean that approximately 520,000 people have been lost from care over the past few months — a deeply concerning and unprecedented level of attrition. We respectfully request that you provide the underlying data and clarify the current total number of people remaining on HIV treatment.
There are several reasons why we are concerned:
Static treatment numbers: As noted, the number on treatment was reported as 5.9 million in both February and May 2025. If 520,700 people have been initiated or re-initiated during this period, the same number must have exited care — a scenario that requires urgent explanation.
Slow growth in the number of people on treatment: According to official statements, the total number of people on HIV treatment increased by only 100,000 between March and December 2023 — from over 5.7 million to 5.8 million. The claim that the cohort has now grown by more than 500,000 in a matter of months contradicts recent trends.
Declining lab numbers: National Health Laboratory Service data reported by the Daily Maverick and Reuters, show notable declines in viral load testing and early infant diagnosis in March and April 2025 compared with the same months in 2024. These indicators should increase alongside meaningful growth in treatment uptake — not decrease.
In light of these concerns, we believe it is essential that you provide a transparent accounting of the current number of people on treatment and the metrics being used to assess progress under the Close the Gap campaign. Specifically, we request data demonstrating that the programme is on track to meet its stated goal: increasing the number of people on treatment from 5.9 million to 7 million.
We share your commitment to a strong and effective HIV response, especially in this period of financial and operational strain. Like you, we believe it is vital that accurate and complete information is shared with the public and Parliament at this critical moment. DM
Anna Grimsrud is an epidemiologist with a PhD in Public Health and writes in her personal capacity. Sibongile Tshabalala-Madhlala is openly living with HIV and currently serves as the National Chairperson of the Treatment Action Campaign (TAC). Change is a coalition of more than 1 500 people from civil society organisations in South Africa and around the world — people living with HIV, activists, community health workers, researchers, programme members, epidemiologists, clinicians, economists, and others. Change stands for Community Health & HIV Advocate Navigating Global Emergencies.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mail & Guardian
an hour ago
- Mail & Guardian
Poultry sector recovering, prices not expected to increase
South Africa's poultry sector is recovering from a devastating outbreak of bird flu and has capacity to meet local consumer demand. (Madelene Cronje) South Africa's The department of agriculture rolled out mass inoculations earlier this month to protect the industry from highly pathogenic In 2023, millions of birds had to be culled, hampering production and driving up poultry and egg prices. The inoculation campaign kicked off with the vaccination of 200 000 broiler breeders at poultry producer Astral. The birds represent 5% of the company's total breeding stock, the department said. Industry experts have welcomed the inoculation drive. 'We had two cases of HPAI in the country, but both were contained and did not spread with minimum losses in terms of production,' said Izaak Breitenbach, the chief executive of the South African Poultry Association. 'We still have an additional one million birds per week slaughter capacity. We currently slaughter about 21.5 million birds per week.' That number reflects normal production levels, which may rise slightly toward December because sales typically increase in the second half of the year. Breitenbach said the industry also has the capacity to exceed this demand if needed 'The industry can cover an increase in demand of about 10% with local production in the short term and probably more in the long term.' Agriculture economists said the success rate for the inoculations will depend on how well future outbreaks are contained. (Graphic: John McCann/M&G) 'There are great expectations that South Africa's recent efforts to vaccinate poultry against avian flu will lessen the likelihood of another devastating outbreak similar to the one that occurred in 2023. Particularly in light of the seasonal influenza outbreak, which usually starts in April and peaks in September each year,' said Thabile Nkunjana, of the National Agricultural Marketing Council. 'However, the initial vaccination is reportedly for at least 200 000 broilers, which is extremely small compared to the size of the industry as a whole. As a result, there is still a chance of an outbreak related to South African poultry production, as well as a current risk of disruptions in the poultry supply, which frequently results in prices that have a negative impact on consumers The layer side of the poultry industry, which raises chickens specifically for egg production, is still producing at lower levels comparable to those before the 2023 outbreak, Nkunjana noted. 'If an outbreak were to occur, the industry would likely experience the same level of pressure as it did in 2023, and egg prices would probably rise once more,' he said. Experts warned that the cost of bird feed could hamper poultry production. Prices have increased on the back of climate conditions as well as international supply. 'Initially feed costs rose when world prices increased sharply in the aftermath of the pandemic and associated supply chain challenges, challenging weather in some key production regions and Russia's invasion of Ukraine,' said Tracy Davids, the executive director for commodity markets and foresight at the Bureau for Food and Agricultural Policy. 'When world prices came down, South African prices stayed higher due to the summer drought of 2024. So, feed costs have increased much more than meat prices over the past five years, making life difficult for all livestock producers, but particularly poultry that use feed very intensively. It's the biggest cost component in the sector.' With feed prices declining and the partial lifting of the ban on Brazilian chicken imports earlier this month, the prospects for the sector are looking positive, Davids added. The ban was implemented after Brazil also reported disease outbreaks, but was lifted to support South African consumers' food security, alleviate cost pressures, and help stabilise the supply chain, said Nkunjana.
The Citizen
4 hours ago
- The Citizen
Healthcare crisis: SA loses nearly 6 000 doctors and nurses a year
The department of health attributed part of the problem to nurses and doctors' reluctance to work in rural areas where they are assigned for community service. South Africa's public healthcare system is hemorrhaging medical professionals at an alarming rate, with nearly 6 000 doctors and nurses resigning annually from state facilities. Recent parliamentary data reveals the devastating scale of the brain drain crippling the country's health sector. Nurses and doctors resignations: provincial breakdown Official figures from the Persal system show that between 2013 and 2025, South Africa lost 12 745 doctors and 58 897 nurses from public health care facilities. Combined, this represents an average of approximately 5 900 doctor and nurse resignations per year over the 12-year period from 2013 to 2024. When including pharmacists, other health care practitioners, and administrative personnel, the total number of health care workers who have resigned since 2013 reaches a staggering 124 123. The crisis peaked in 2021 and 2022, when the country lost 1 340 and 1 350 doctors respectively, alongside 6 171 and 5 592 nurses. The data, provided by Health Minister Dr Aaron Motsoaledi in response to a parliamentary question from DA MP Michéle Clarke, paints a grim picture of a health care system under severe strain. Gauteng province has been hit hardest, losing 3 351 doctors since 2013, followed by KwaZulu-Natal with 2 609 resignations. Provincial breakdowns reveal the widespread nature of the crisis. Since the 2021-2022 peak, Gauteng has lost 1 206 doctors, while KwaZulu-Natal shed 599 medical professionals. The Western Cape recorded 433 doctor resignations, Eastern Cape 356, and Limpopo 322. For nursing staff, Gauteng led with 4 697 resignations since the peak years, followed by KwaZulu-Natal's 4 353 and Eastern Cape's 2 631. The Persal data has not been updated since January 2025, meaning current losses may be even higher. However, in January this year, 53 doctors resigned across the country, while a total of 113 nurses resigned. ALSO READ: Will review of public sector doctors working in private hospitals lead to better healthcare or brain drain? Nurses and doctors rural placement complications The department of health previously attributed part of the problem to young nurses and doctors' reluctance to work in rural areas where they are assigned for community service. Many prefer urban placements, leaving underserved communities without critical health care services. 'We find that we have openings in deep rural areas for community service, where there's not even a cellphone network, but they tell us they can't work far from home,' said department spokesperson Foster Mohale. 'They come with all sorts of excuses – mother is sick or other reasons. So, it's a very complicated process.' The department said this reluctance has left many qualified doctors unemployed rather than accepting rural postings. Some, after living in the rural areas, opt to resign rather than continue to live in the poverty-stricken regions. ALSO READ: Unemployed doctors 'too choosy' over where they work, says government Junior doctor unemployment compounds crisis The health care staffing crisis has been further exacerbated by widespread unemployment among junior doctors. In January 2025, the South African Medical Association wrote an urgent letter to President Cyril Ramaphosa highlighting that 'over 1 800 junior doctors, having completed their mandatory community service' remain unemployed despite severe shortages in public hospitals. The association warned that 'with only 0.3 doctors per 1 000 people in the public sector, well below the World Health Organisation's recommendation of 1 per 1 000,' South Africa's health care system is critically understaffed. The letter described a system where 'many departments in public hospitals are dangerously understaffed, forcing existing health care workers to shoulder unsustainable workloads'. Sama estimated that R2 billion annually would be needed to create posts for medical officers and registrars, warning that 'many are forced to volunteer, work without pay in the public sector just to maintain their skills and hope for eventual employment. This fuels emigration, exacerbating the brain drain and further weakening our health care system.' Remunerative work outside the public service controversy adds pressure The crisis has been compounded by debates over remunerative work outside the public service, which allows health care workers to take on private practice during off-duty hours. Motsoaledi blamed the misuse of remunerative work outside the public service for doctor absenteeism and lateness in public facilities. Former South African Medical Association board chair Dr Angelique Coetzee warned that restricting remunerative work outside the public service could backfire. She believes stricter policies could improve public health care by ensuring 'fewer doctors spending time in private practice, more focus on public health care'. However, she cautioned that overly restrictive measures could worsen the exodus. 'If it's removed or heavily restricted, some doctors might resign, worsening your shortage of medical professionals in your state hospitals, leading to an increased patient load per doctor, again, negatively affecting patient care,' Coetzee said. ALSO READ: Motsoaledi explains why state-employed doctors skip work or often arrive late International brain drain crisis The South African Family Practice (SAFP) in 2024 highlighted how brain drain extends beyond national borders, with skilled professionals migrating to developed countries. According to research by Indiran Govender from the SAFP, in 2024 'there were more than 23 400 health professionals from South Africa residing and working in the United Kingdom, New Zealand, the United States and Australia'. Govender noted that 'about 11.13% of South Africans with higher education indicate that they are seriously considering emigrating to another country'. The Fellowship of the College of Family Physicians of South Africa degree is widely recognised internationally, making it easier for specialists to emigrate. 'South Africa is argued to play a central role of 'victim' as well as 'executer' in this process,' Govender wrote. The country exports doctors to richer nations while importing health care workers from poorer African countries. Push and pull factors Multiple factors drive health care workers away from South Africa's public system. Poor working conditions, inadequate infrastructure and below-market salaries push professionals toward private practice or overseas opportunities. 'Health facilities in South Africa are characterised by poor working conditions, and the salaries are sub-par,' according to Govender. Urban areas continue to attract medical professionals away from rural communities, creating health care deserts in underserved regions. Political instability, crime and economic uncertainty add to the exodus. READ MORE: Public hospitals built but lack doctors to serve Urgent interventions needed Experts argue that South Africa requires comprehensive reforms to stem the health care brain drain. Recommendations include improving working conditions, upgrading infrastructure and developing incentive programmes for rural service. 'The government should increase accountability in public health institutions, as facilities are characterised by mismanagement and corruption, which undermine the efficient functioning of the health sector,' Govender suggested. Increased training capacity and better retention strategies are also critical. Without decisive action, the country's universal health coverage plans and broader development goals remain at risk. READ NEXT: Motsoaledi announces 1 650 new health care jobs and R1.3bn to be spent on hospital equipment
Mail & Guardian
6 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
Aid cuts, including by UK, undermine progress on fight against superbugs
Antimicrobial resistance silent pandemic that already claims more than 1.3 million lives every year. File photo A recent global economic model warns that antimicrobial resistance (AMR) may cost the world economy up to This escalating threat coincides with a decline in international support for AMR surveillance. The Low- and middle-income countries, including South Africa, are likely to bear the heaviest burden because of under-resourced health systems, limited surveillance capacity and growing barriers to effective treatments. AMR arises when microorganisms evolve mechanisms to withstand the effects of antibiotics intended to eliminate them. As resistance spreads, infections that were once easily treatable become increasingly difficult, and sometimes impossible, to cure. This silent pandemic is already responsible for more than By 2050, resistant infections could reduce global GDP by up to 3.1% and push millions into poverty as a result of the cost of prolonged illness and ineffective treatment. Health systems, especially in countries already facing a high burden of disease, are at risk of being overwhelmed. The But Experts caution that even partial reductions in funding may accelerate the spread of AMR in high-risk regions. Such cutbacks can delay the detection of resistant pathogens, disrupt surveillance efforts and weaken public health responses. The consequences are clear: more infections, higher mortality rates and mounting pressure on already overstretched health systems. AMR does not respect borders. Resistant bacteria can emerge in one location and spread globally through travel, trade and migration. Inadequate surveillance in one part of the world increases vulnerability everywhere. Many low- and medium-income countries face compounded problems: limited access to diagnostics, overuse or misuse of antibiotics in both clinical and agricultural settings, as well as underinvestment in water, sanitation and hygiene infrastructure. Surveillance programmes supported by international aid help fill these gaps by enabling early detection and informed response. Cutting funding now undermines global preparedness just as AMR risks are accelerating. While AMR is a long-term challenge, the window for effective action is narrowing. Delaying investment now will probably increase the cost and complexity of response in the future. According to recent economic analyses, every dollar spent on AMR containment today could save up to $20 in future health and productivity costs. Continued investment in surveillance, laboratory capacity, workforce training and antimicrobial stewardship is essential for all countries and for global health security. Multilateral partnerships, sustained funding, and equitable access to innovation are critical pillars of any effective AMR strategy. What can be done? Given the recent decline in global funding, it is essential to explore alternative strategies to sustain and strengthen AMR efforts. Reinforce multilateral funding: Donor countries should explore shared funding mechanisms to sustain critical AMR programmes beyond bilateral commitments. Strengthen regional cooperation: Regional AMR surveillance networks can improve resilience and facilitate data-sharing, even in the face of international funding cuts. Mobilise domestic resources: Prioritise public health investment in laboratory systems, data infrastructure, and training to reduce reliance on fluctuating aid flows. Promote responsible antimicrobial use: Stewardship programmes in human and veterinary medicine are essential to slow the development of resistance. Invest in research and equitable access: Support for the development and fair distribution of new antibiotics, vaccines, and diagnostics must remain a global priority. AMR is one of the most urgent and complex public health issues of our time. Progress made in the past decade, through global collaboration, investment and capacity-building now stands at risk. At the very moment when stronger action is needed, international funding is contracting. The decisions made now will shape the trajectory of AMR for decades. Reducing support is not just a financial recalibration; it is a choice that may have irreversible consequences for millions of people worldwide. The global community must act decisively to protect hard-won gains, support countries most at risk and uphold the shared responsibility of safeguarding the effectiveness of life-saving medicines. Dr Jose L Balcazar is a senior microbiologist at the Catalan Institute for Water Research (ICRA-CERCA), Spain.
