Open letter to Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi: Please explain the HIV numbers
Dear Minister Motsoaledi,
We write to you in response to your 15 May 2025 press statement and subsequent remarks in Parliament on the current status of the national HIV, Aids, and TB campaign.
You stated that since the launch of the Close the Gap campaign, 520,700 people have been initiated on HIV treatment, reaching 'more than 50% of the target'. You also stated that 5.9 million people were currently on antiretroviral therapy (ART). However, at the campaign's launch on 25 February 2025, you reported the same number on HIV treatment — 5.9 million. This raises a critical question: If more than half a million people have started or restarted treatment, why has the total number of people on treatment not increased?
If both figures are accurate, this would mean that approximately 520,000 people have been lost from care over the past few months — a deeply concerning and unprecedented level of attrition. We respectfully request that you provide the underlying data and clarify the current total number of people remaining on HIV treatment.
There are several reasons why we are concerned:
Static treatment numbers: As noted, the number on treatment was reported as 5.9 million in both February and May 2025. If 520,700 people have been initiated or re-initiated during this period, the same number must have exited care — a scenario that requires urgent explanation.
Slow growth in the number of people on treatment: According to official statements, the total number of people on HIV treatment increased by only 100,000 between March and December 2023 — from over 5.7 million to 5.8 million. The claim that the cohort has now grown by more than 500,000 in a matter of months contradicts recent trends.
Declining lab numbers: National Health Laboratory Service data reported by the Daily Maverick and Reuters, show notable declines in viral load testing and early infant diagnosis in March and April 2025 compared with the same months in 2024. These indicators should increase alongside meaningful growth in treatment uptake — not decrease.
In light of these concerns, we believe it is essential that you provide a transparent accounting of the current number of people on treatment and the metrics being used to assess progress under the Close the Gap campaign. Specifically, we request data demonstrating that the programme is on track to meet its stated goal: increasing the number of people on treatment from 5.9 million to 7 million.
We share your commitment to a strong and effective HIV response, especially in this period of financial and operational strain. Like you, we believe it is vital that accurate and complete information is shared with the public and Parliament at this critical moment. DM
Anna Grimsrud is an epidemiologist with a PhD in Public Health and writes in her personal capacity. Sibongile Tshabalala-Madhlala is openly living with HIV and currently serves as the National Chairperson of the Treatment Action Campaign (TAC). Change is a coalition of more than 1 500 people from civil society organisations in South Africa and around the world — people living with HIV, activists, community health workers, researchers, programme members, epidemiologists, clinicians, economists, and others. Change stands for Community Health & HIV Advocate Navigating Global Emergencies.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
12 hours ago
- The Citizen
Health minister calls for bold action as TB vaccine nears reality
Minister of Health Dr Aaron Motsoaledi has stressed the urgent need for innovative solutions to combat tuberculosis (TB), a disease that has historically affected not only South Africa but countries around the world. 'We are here because we believe that TB – a disease that has shaped the history and health of our country and indeed, the whole world – can be ended. Not through words alone, but through action, partnership, and innovation,' he said on Thursday. The minister was delivering the keynote address at the country's TB Vaccine Preparedness Workshop in Johannesburg. The workshop aims to advance policy and decision-making for the introduction of TB vaccines. Protecting the most vulnerable Addressing policymakers, scientists and community leaders, Motsoaledi said the upcoming phase will introduce preventative TB vaccination measures, which will also support the fight against HIV and Aids. For over a century, South Africa has relied on the Bacille Calmette-Guérin vaccine to protect children from TB, but the minister pointed out that there has been no tool to protect adolescents and adults. 'These are the very groups most at risk of getting sick and transmitting TB,' he said. With several new TB vaccine candidates in the late stages of clinical trials, the most promising options are expected to be available in the next few years. The workshop positioned South Africa as one of the first countries ready to deliver a new generation of TB vaccines to the most vulnerable populations, including adolescents and adults. Ending 'slavery' of disease The minister expressed confidence that upcoming trials would yield positive results, potentially leading to a new vaccine for older age groups. TB remains a leading cause of death from infectious disease and a major contributor to poor health both locally and globally. 'Imagine the day when we announce the availability of the vaccine for tuberculosis,' he said, likening it to 'the day of true freedom from slavery' for those affected. Motsoaledi described the disease as a form of 'devastating slavery' that fuels poverty and premature death. 'South Africa is not waiting for the world to act. We are preparing – intentionally, early and inclusively.' Commitment to readiness The minister used the country's first national gathering on TB vaccine readiness to reaffirm South Africa's leadership in the global fight against TB and HIV. 'When South Africa wins against TB and HIV and Aids the world will win the war,' he said. He noted that throughout his tenure, he has sought to elevate TB on the global health agenda, recalling his 2018 address at the United Nations calling for world leaders to act. 'While global attention has often turned to emerging health threats, South Africa has remained focused on the enduring challenge of TB,' he said. He also acknowledged the devastating impact of TB on communities already battling HIV. Systems, trust and investment 'Today's discussions remind us that vaccine introduction is not just about science – it is about health systems. It is about trust. It is about readiness.' Motsoaledi emphasised the importance of preparing the health sector for the rollout, saying the agenda highlighted key areas such as evidence generation, delivery systems, and supply chain readiness. 'Investment in human life means everything,' he said, calling for strong financial backing and stakeholder support. He urged participants to build community trust and advocate for broad acceptance of the new vaccine. 'We must walk the path with our people,' he said. – Breaking news at your fingertips… Follow Caxton Network News on Facebook and join our WhatsApp channel. Nuus wat saakmaak. Volg Caxton Netwerk-nuus op Facebook en sluit aan by ons WhatsApp-kanaal. Read original story on
The Citizen
19 hours ago
- The Citizen
World Brain Day: More than 40% of dementia cases can be prevented
World Brain Day: More than 40% of dementia cases can be prevented The World Health Organization estimates that 57 million people globally live with dementia, with this number expected to reach 153 million by 2050. A total of 60% of people with dementia live in low- and middle-income countries, but this will rise to 71% by 2050. Welma Geldenhuys, senior social worker of the Association for Dementia and Alzheimer's of South Africa in Pretoria, said that for the association, World Brain Day is about creating awareness for communities and families of how to let people with dementia live lives of dignity and quality. 'At the association, this is something we truly advocate for,' said Geldenhuys. Overall, around 45% of cases of dementia are potentially preventable by addressing 14 modifiable risk factors at different stages during the life course. These include things such as not completing secondary education, social isolation, and depression, as well as several medical conditions such as hypertension, obesity and diabetes. 'We need to get the word out that it is important to get a professional diagnosis of the illness by an expert medical professional because the right treatment and medication can be administered,' explained Geldenhuys. Diet might also be an important aspect to look at in addition to these 14 factors, and has a key role in reducing the risk of chronic diseases that affect dementia risk. Speaking ahead of World Brain Day, Dr Patty Francis, president of the Neurological Association of South Africa, said dementia is no longer an inevitable consequence of old age, but 'the result of decades-long exposure to modifiable risk factors'. Dr Francis said the brain is highly sensitive to long-term physical, emotional, and environmental stressors. 'The rise in dementia in our region is deeply concerning, considering that we carry high burdens of HIV, hypertension, diabetes and stroke, all of which are linked to increased dementia risk,' she said. 'The most powerful message we can share this World Brain Day is that dementia is not just about ageing, it's about lifelong brain health. What we do in our 30s, 40s and 50s has a direct impact on our risk later in life.' Although addressing risk factors at an early stage of life is desirable, there is also a benefit from tackling risk throughout life; it is never too early or too late to reduce dementia risk. 'Dementia does not happen overnight. It often starts with decades of unmanaged risk factors such as high blood pressure, physical inactivity, obesity, smoking, poor sleep, alcohol abuse, and hearing loss, all of which silently damage brain tissue. When addressing these, research shows dementia could be prevented or delayed in up to four in 10 cases.' 'Every stage of life offers an opportunity to protect your brain,' said Dr Francis. 'From maternal nutrition to childhood immunisation, and from midlife stress management, to staying socially connected in older age. Preventions start early and are lifelong.' While dementia presents differently in each person, common warning signs include: – Memory loss that disrupts daily life – Difficulty performing familiar tasks – Language problems such as difficulty in speaking or writing – Confusion with time and place – Trouble understanding visual images – Misplacing things and losing the ability to retrace one's steps – Decreased or poor judgement – Personality or mood changes – Withdrawal from work or social activities – Problems with reasoning or problem-solving. Other red flags include trouble with planning and organising, poor co-ordination and control of movements, and confusion and disorientation. 'It's important not to dismiss symptoms as just getting older,' Dr Francis said. 'Even in younger adults, persistent cognitive changes should be assessed by a neurologist or specialist physician.' Some forms of dementia are amenable to therapy, such as HIV-related dementia or deficiency in vitamin B12. While there is currently no cure for Alzheimer's disease, early diagnosis and treatment can significantly slow progression and improve quality of life, with options, including: – Medication to manage cognitive symptoms and behaviour – Cognitive rehabilitation – Occupational therapy – Management of underlying conditions like hypertension or diabetes. Dr Francis said new drug developments, such as anti-amyloid therapies, are promising but remain costly and limited in availability in most low- and middle-income countries. 'In South Africa, our most urgent need is access to early screening and specialist care, particularly in under-resourced communities. 'We also need to destigmatise dementia, so families feel supported, rather than isolated,' she added. 'This World Brain Day, we are calling on all South Africans to prioritise brain health from the earliest stages of life. 'Healthy brains build healthy communities and the power to prevent dementia starts with awareness, education and action.' If you suspect someone you know is showing signs of dementia, you can get support and guidance from your local GP or community clinics for referral to specialists, or Alzheimer's South Africa. A workshop on dementia will be held on August 20 at the Sungardens Hospice in Lynnwood, Pretoria, by Alzheimer's South Africa from 09:00 to 13:00. More information is available from Welma Geldenhuys, who can be called on 082 821 4862, or visit the ADASA website on Do you have more information about the story? Please send us an email to [email protected] or phone us on 083 625 4114. For free breaking and community news, visit Rekord's websites: Rekord East For more news and interesting articles, like Rekord on Facebook, follow us on Twitter or Instagram or TikTok.
The Citizen
2 days ago
- The Citizen
Motsoaledi urges innovation to end TB
Minister of Health, Dr Aaron Motsoaledi, has stressed the urgent need for innovative solutions to combat tuberculosis (TB), a disease that has historically affected not just South Africa but also countries around the world. 'We are here because we believe that TB – a disease that has shaped the history and health of our country and indeed, the whole world – can be ended. Not through words alone, but through action, partnership, and innovation,' he said on Thursday. The Minister was delivering a keynote address at the country's TB Vaccine Preparedness Workshop held in Johannesburg. The workshop is aimed at advancing policy and decision-making for the introduction of TB vaccines. Addressing policymakers, scientists and community leaders, Motsoaledi stated that the upcoming phase will introduce preventative TB vaccination measures, which will also enhance the ongoing fight against HIV and Aids. For over a century, South Africa has relied on the Bacille Calmette-Guérin (BCG) vaccine to protect its children from TB, but the Minister pointed out that there has been no tool that can protect adolescents and adults. 'These are the very groups most at risk of getting sick and transmitting TB.' With several new TB vaccine candidates in the late stages of clinical trials, the most promising options are expected to be available in the next few years. This workshop positioned the country as one of the first that is ready to deliver a new generation of TB vaccines to the most vulnerable populations, including adolescents and adults. The Minister expressed confidence that the upcoming clinical trials would yield positive results, potentially leading to a new vaccine for older age groups within the next few years. TB is a leading cause of death from an infectious disease and a major contributor to ill-health in South Africa and globally. 'Imagine the day when we announce the availability of the vaccine for tuberculosis,' he said, likening it to 'the day of true freedom from slavery' for those suffering from the disease. Motsoaledi described the disease as a form of 'devastating slavery' that exacerbates poverty and leads to premature death. 'South Africa is not waiting for the world to act. We are preparing – intentionally, early and inclusively.' The Minister has used the first national gathering dedicated to the TB vaccine readiness platform to reiterate South Africa's commitment to lead by example in the global fight against TB and HIV. 'When South Africa wins against TB and HIV and Aids the world will win the war,' he said. He told the attendees that through his tenure as Health Minister, he consistently sought to elevate the profile of TB on a global scale. Motsoaledi recalled his 2018 address at the United Nations, where he rallied for world leaders to commit to addressing the TB crisis. 'While global attention has often turned to emerging health threats, South Africa has remained focused on the enduring challenge of TB,' he said. He also acknowledged the disease's severe impact on communities already struggling with HIV. 'Today's discussions remind us that vaccine introduction is not just about science – it is about health systems. It is about trust. It is about readiness.' He also used the platform to emphasise the importance of preparing the health sector for the rollout of the TB vaccine. The agenda for the workshop highlighted key thematic areas crucial for readiness, including generating evidence for policy and investment, strengthening delivery systems for TB vaccines, and ensuring manufacturing and supply chain readiness. 'Investment in human life means everything,' he said, stressing the need for robust financial backing to ensure effective vaccine deployment. The Minister took the time to urge stakeholders to foster community trust and strong advocacy to ensure widespread acceptance of the TB vaccine upon its introduction. 'We must walk the path with our people,' he said. –
