Russia has committed flagrant human rights abuses in Ukraine since 2014, rules ECHR
The court's grand chamber unanimously held that between 11 May 2014 and 16 September 2022, when Russia ceased to be a party to the European convention on human rights it had committed 'manifestly unlawful conduct … on a massive scale'.
Pro-Russian armed groups entered the Donetsk and Luhansk regions of eastern Ukraine in 2014 and Russia began its full-scale invasion of Ukraine on 24 February 2022.
In its judgment, published on Wednesday, the court said there was evidence of widespread and systemic use of sexual violence, accompanied by acts of torture, such as beatings, strangling or electric shock. Civilians and prisoners of war were subjected to mock executions, the severing of body parts and electric shocks, including to intimate areas of their bodies, the court said.
Finding repeated violations of the convention, many of which had taken place over a period of more than eight years, the court said: 'These actions seek to undermine the very fabric of the democracy on which the Council of Europe and its member states are founded by their destruction of individual freedoms, their suppression of political liberties and their blatant disregard for the rule of law.
'In none of the conflicts previously before the court has there been such near universal condemnation of the 'flagrant' disregard by the respondent state for the foundations of the international legal order established after the second world war.'
Ukraine hailed the judgment as 'historic and unprecedented', saying it was an 'undeniable victory'. Russia did not participate in the proceedings and said it would ignore it.
Violations identified by the court included:
Indiscriminate military attacks
Summary executions of civilians and Ukrainian military personnel
Torture, including the use of rape as a weapon of war
Unlawful and arbitrary detention of civilians
Unjustified displacement and transfer of civilians
Intimidation, harassment and persecution of all religious groups other than adherents of the historically Moscow-aligned Ukrainian Orthodox church
Intimidation and violence against journalists and new laws prohibiting and penalising the dissemination of information in support of Ukraine
Forcible dispersal by the Russian military of peaceful protests in occupied towns and cities
Destruction, looting and expropriation of property
Suppression of the Ukrainian language in schools and indoctrination of Ukrainian schoolchildren
Transfer to Russia, and in many cases, the adoption there of Ukrainian children
The court said: 'The prevalence of sexual violence and rape by Russian soldiers in occupied territory is especially abhorrent. The evidence shows the extreme violence of the circumstances in which women were raped or sexually assaulted and the intent to terrorise, humiliate and debase them … In addition to the impact on the direct victims, the raping of women and girls in the context of an armed conflict has also been described as a means for the aggressor to symbolically and physically humiliate the defeated men.
'Rape or the threat of rape is also used to drive communities off lands or to heighten terror during attacks. The evidence also attests to the horrific sexual violence frequently perpetrated upon male detainees. The sexual abuse, torture and mutilation of male detainees is often carried out to attack and destroy their sense of masculinity or manhood.'
Sign up to This is Europe
The most pressing stories and debates for Europeans – from identity to economics to the environment
after newsletter promotion
The judges said that sexual violence and rape were deployed in Ukraine after the February 2022 invasion 'as part of a military strategy to dehumanise, humiliate and break the morale of the Ukrainian population, as individuals and as a community, and to assert dominance over Ukrainian sovereign territory'.
The court will decide on whether to order compensation at a later date. However, Russia has previously told the court of its intention not to enforce judgments or pay damages.
A total of 26 signatory states to the convention intervened as third parties in the case and expressed their support for making Russia accountable for violations of human rights arising from its invasion of Ukraine.
The court also found that the shooting down of flight MH17 using a missile supplied and transported to eastern Ukraine by the Russian Federation, resulting in the deaths of all 298 civilians on board, was in breach of the convention.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
26 minutes ago
- Times
‘We tried to free our children, Putin used them as poker chips'
Flanked by men in dark suits, Daria Zarivna was nervous. The stakes could hardly have been higher for her and the rest of the Ukrainian negotiating team as they sat down opposite their American counterparts. Their aim was to save an alliance, and, ultimately, the lives of their countrymen. While President Trump's shift from appearing to support President Putin to announcing additional weapons for Ukraine this week may seem abrupt, Zarivna can testify how the seeds were sown on a spring day in Jeddah four months ago. On March 11, days after President Zelensky was humiliated in an Oval Office shouting match with Trump, Zarivna, an adviser to Andriy Yermak, the Ukrainian leader's chief of staff, joined the rest of the Kyiv delegation in Saudi Arabia. 'We were preparing hard, day and night. We were all focused. We had no idea how it would go,' she said. Somehow, the Ukrainians had to find common ground with a White House team that seemed to have started parroting Kremlin propaganda. There was one topic that Zarivna hoped it would be hard for them to disagree about — returning abducted children to their families. Nonetheless she was relieved when Marco Rubio, the US secretary of state, started speaking: 'The conversation was constructive from the outset. When Secretary Rubio raised the issue, and when he shared facts from my message box, that was a great feeling, and I realised he was deeply across the details,' she recalled. The Kremlin has removed at least 19,546 Ukrainian children from their families for re-education as Russians according to Kyiv, a war crime that has prompted the International Criminal Court to issue an arrest warrant for Putin. Of those taken, only 1,399 have been returned to Ukraine, through volunteers or relatives travelling vast distances, or in agreements brokered by third countries such as South Africa, Qatar or the Vatican.' The March US-Ukraine summit in Saudi Arabia concluded with a brief statement proposing an immediate 30-day ceasefire to Moscow. It also included a commitment to the 'return of forcibly transferred Ukrainian children'. That commitment, the Ukrainian officials thought, could eventually become a test for Putin, and one way to prove to the Americans that Moscow had no interest in peace. • Ukraine hands Russia list of kidnapped children at peace talks During the Istanbul peace talks between the two warring sides last month, the Ukrainian delegation gave their Kremlin counterparts a list of 339 Ukrainian children being held in Russia, Zarivna said. 'It wasn't a full list. It was a test… a small first step,' she said. 'It was a way to see whether Russia is truly prepared to begin the process of returning Ukrainian children.' In public, Russia denied that any of the 339 children had been abducted. But privately, the Russian side 'suggested swapping [the children] like poker chips for Russian prisoners of war,' Zarivna idea of trading children was as abhorrent for the Americans as the Ukrainians, she said, and slowly the Trump administration began to understand the nature of Putin's regime. Following the failed talks in Istanbul, Zarivna visited Washington, taking the issue to Congress and persuading both the House and the Senate to introduce bipartisan resolutions calling for the unconditional return of Ukrainian children. 'Our position is clear: we will not trade children for territory, infrastructure or political concessions. Ever. To do so would only encourage more abductions,' Zarivna said. Zarivna insists she never meant to go into politics, but her clout has grown as Zelensky leans more on Yermak. The two men are accused by opposition figures of monopolising power under martial law at the expense of the country's democratic checks and balances, orchestrating the sacking, sanctioning and arrest of rivals. In a government dominated by the presidential office, Zarivna's influence now extends beyond the ear of Yermak to that of Olena Zelenska, the first lady, with whom she works closely on Bring Kids Back UA, a presidential initiative she runs with the aim of orchestrating the children's return. Over coffee in a Kyiv café, Zarivna batted back a playful suggestion made to The Times by Yulia Svyrydenko, Ukraine's new prime minister, that it is Zarivna who is the most powerful woman in Ukraine. 'I'm not interested in power. I'm interested in creating and I'm interested in building,' the adviser said. 'As soon as you become a political player or political stakeholder, then you have all of these games which I don't want to spend my time on. I like to build a process, find the right people and go on to the next task. This is what drives me. ' Coming from a media and advertising background, Zarivna has been labelled the chief spin doctor, even a propagandist. She has been accused of running Vertikal, a Telegram channel that smears Zelensky's rivals, a charge she flatly denies. Yet it is clear Zarivna believes in the administration and its work. In November 2022, after the liberation of her home town, Kherson, she was filmed close to tears behind Zelensky as the Ukrainian flag was raised again in the city square. • No peace until you return our children, Ukraine tells Putin 'It was one of the best moments of my life. Like when you lost someone who mattered to you, then you managed to return them. I remember all these people came to this main area in Kherson, and they were all so happy and crying. Of course they didn't know then that the drone safari is coming,' she said, referring to Russian drone operators hunting civilians in the streets and posting the videos online, killing a year-old baby there last week. Neighbours 'just disappeared' during the occupation, she says, and Russian troops billeted themselves in her family home, burning mementos from her childhood for firewood. Her grandmother, who stayed behind, emerged from occupation traumatised. In the early days of the war, when Zelensky was pleading with parliaments around the world for support by invoking their own troubled times, Zarivna was involved in the team helping to write his speeches. The process is always driven by the president, she says, but the former comedian still needs an audience. 'He needs somebody to talk to because when he verbalises something, he generates all these great phrases and aphorisms,' she added. 'All the memorable quotes come from him. He's great at finding something in common with people, he's very empathetic.' Her immediate boss, Yermak, complements Zelensky because he prioritises progress over popularity, she said. 'Public image is always a challenge. It's the nature of that job. You can be effective and get things done, or you can be universally liked, but it's almost impossible to be both,' she said.
The Guardian
31 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Ukraine war briefing: Don't bomb Moscow, Trump says, after reportedly giving Zelenskyy the idea
Donald Trump has said Volodymyr Zelenskyy should not bomb Moscow. His statement came soon after the Financial Times (£) reported he had asked Zelenskyy whether he could bomb Moscow, and privately encouraged Ukraine to step up deep strikes on Russia. 'No, he shouldn't target Moscow,' the US president said on Tuesday when asked if the Ukrainian president should attack the Russian capital. Asked if he intended to supply Ukraine with weapons that could reach deeper into Russian territory, Trump replied: 'We're not looking to do that.' Ukraine on Tuesday was waiting for further details of the 'billions of dollars' worth of US military equipment promised by Donald Trump, amid confusion as to how many Patriot air defence systems will be sent. On Monday, Trump said an unnamed country was ready to immediately provide '17 Patriots'. Ukraine is believed so far to possess six functioning Patriot air defence 'batteries' – the truck-based radar and launch systems that fire the missiles. It was unclear if Trump was referring to the launch systems, the interceptor missiles that are their ammunition, or whether he understood the difference. Several European countries said they were willing to buy US arms for Ukraine as outlined by Trump but did not yet know what was being asked of them. Washington officials have suggested that European countries will give up some of their own stocks of weapons for Ukraine and then buy replacements from the US. It would get weapons to Ukraine more quickly, but leave the donor countries waiting for new systems for their own defence. Some US lawmakers voiced concern that Trump's latest deadline – 50 days this time – for Putin to make peace gives him time to grab even more Ukrainian territory. Thom Tillis, a Republican senator from North Carolina, said: 'The 50-day delay worries me that Putin would try to use the 50 days to win the war, or to be better positioned to negotiate a peace agreement after having murdered and potentially collected more ground. Tillis and Jeanne Shaheen, a Democrat from New Hampshire, lead a US Senate group that facilitates work between Congress and Nato. Russian drones and missiles attacked widely separated areas of Ukraine, officials said in the early hours of Wednesday, with at least two people reported killed. National emergency services reported two deaths in drone strikes east of the north-eastern city of Kharkiv near the town of Kupiansk. In Kharkiv itself, the regional governor, Oleh Syniehubov, said at least 17 explosions were recorded in a 20-minute drone attack in which three people were injured. The head of the military administration in the south-eastern town of Kryvyi Rih, Oleksander Vilkul, said an extended missile and drones attack knocked out power and water supplies and caused injuries. The Kyiv mayor, Vitali Klitschko, said air defence units had gone into action in the capital. Earlier, a Russian attack on Tuesday afternoon killed three people in Kupiansk and Sumy, Ukrainian authorities said. Russian officials said a Ukrainian drone attack on the western city of Voronezh wounded 27 people. The Institute for the Study of war assessed that Ukrainian forces recently advanced in northern Sumy oblast; while Russian forces recently advanced near Kupiansk, Borova, and Toretsk. The EU was unable to approve a new package of sanctions against Russia on Tuesday as Slovakia demanded more guarantees that it would not be harmed by a separate EU plan to phase out Russian gas. The EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas said she was 'really sad' the sanctions did not get approved, adding that 'the ball is in Slovakia's court' and she hoped a deal could be reached on Wednesday. Ukrainians celebrated Melania Trump on social media after Donald Trump suggested the first lady played a key role in pointing out to him Vladimir Putin's duplicity, Luke Harding writes. 'I go home, I tell the first lady: I spoke with Vladimir today. We had a wonderful conversation. She said: Really? Another city was just hit,' Trump said. One social media user posted a photo of 'Agent Melania Trumpenko' looking surreptitious in a big hat and wearing a blazer with Ukraine's trident insignia. Others depicted her being presented with a Ukrainian military cap and wearing the blue and yellow of Ukraine's flag.
The Sun
2 hours ago
- The Sun
Putin launches missiles and drones attack in night of hell for Ukraine with dozens of explosions rocking Kharkiv
VLADIMIR Putin has unleashed another night of deadly strikes on Ukraine leaving at least two dead and dozens wounded. Russian drones and missiles attacked several areas of Ukraine with the city of Kharkiv being the worst impacted by the terrifying barrage. 4 4 4 Both deaths came in Ukraine's second largest city, near to the town of Kupiansk, an area which has been under constant Russian attack for months. Kharkiv regional Governor Oleh Syniehubov said at least 17 explosions were recorded in just 20 minutes. Chilling images show the night sky lit up after several buildings were directly impacted amd left up in flames. Putin's evil forces are said to have knocked out power and water supplies across the country. The southeastern town of Kryvyi Rih and the capital Kyiv were also impacted. Kyiv Mayor Vitali Klitschko said air defence units had gone into action but there were no reports of casualties. The latest attacks are set to anger Donald Trump even more after he imposed a strict peace ultimatum on Putin on Monday. He issued a blistering crackdown on Moscow as he pledged to hit Russia with 100 percent tariffs if they don't agree to a peace deal within 50 days. Trump also said he is getting "really angry" with the despot over his incessant bombing of Ukrainian civilians. The US President also agreed to supply weapons to help Kyiv in the war in the hopes of driving Putin to the negotiating table. He vowed to send weapons compromising of "everything" in his arsenal in order to get Putin back into line after weeks of the tyrant incessantly bombing Ukraine. One of the proposed weapons which could be included in the package deal is America's joint air-to-surface standoff cruise missiles (JASSM). But within hours of Trump's tariff threat, Russia launched a fresh blitz across Ukraine, striking sites in Kharkiv, Sumy and Zaporizhzhia. Drones targeted a university in Sumy, wounding a 14-year-old girl and a 19-year-old student, while a missile hit a medical facility in Shostka. In response, Ukraine launched its own drone blitz across southwest Russia, injuring civilians and damaging homes and industrial sites in Voronezh and Lipetsk. 4 .
