Making concessions on benefit cuts 'not enough', says Scots Labour MP
Brian Leishman said "the real Labour thing to do" is "to create a welfare system that looks after people".
Concessions on the UK Government's benefit cuts are "not enough" and the bill should be dropped, a Scottish Labour MP has said.
Brian Leishman said "the real Labour thing to do" is "to create a welfare system that looks after people".
It comes as reports suggested Prime Minister Keir Starmer is considering watering down his welfare reforms because of a major rebellion.
This could include changing the points needed to get Personal Independence Payment (PIP) or backtracking on the measures affecting Universal Credit (UC).
amendment which would bring down the cuts it goes to a vote on Tuesday.
Alloa and Grangemouth MP Leishman said: "Concessions being made on the UC and PIP Bill is not enough because disabled people will still become poorer.
"The government should withdraw the Bill and work with organisations and charities to create a welfare system that looks after people.
" That's the real Labour thing to do."
The bill would make it harder for disabled people with less severe conditions to claim personal independence payment (Pip), with forecasts predicting the overall changes will plunge 50,000 children into poverty.
The amendment supported by the rebels would give them an opportunity to reject the welfare reform bill.
The wording backs the 'need for the reform of the social security system' but criticises the lack of a 'formal consultation' with disabled people and warns of the impact on poverty levels.
They also hit out at their own Government for not publishing an 'assessment of the impact of these reforms on health or care needs'.
The Scottish Labour sceptics are Richard Baker, Scott Arthur, Euan Stainbank, Brian Leishman, Lilian Jones, Tracy Gilbert, Elaine Stewart, Kirsteen Sullivan and Ferguson. Maureen Burke, Martin Rhodes and Irene Campbell have since added their names.
The Record understands there are other MPs who have not signed the amendment who may not back the cuts in a vote next week.
There are 11 Scottish MPs in the UK Government - plus two other MPs who are 'mission champions' - who would almost definitely have to resign from their roles to rebel.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
'Our energy bills went up 400% but one change reduced them from £10k to £2k '
Youngsters at Westminster House Youth Club have a lot to teach Westminster. They've already slashed their energy bills from £10k to £2k after starting solar revolution Nunhead Youth Club saves money by installing solar panels "There's 96 photovoltaic solar panels on the top of the roof here," says Jayden Ntiamoah, our guide to Westminster House Youth Club's solar revolution. "Before they came in, bills for the club were quite high at £10,000, but now they've been reduced to £2,000. So, it's just a great thing not only environmentally, but also economically for the club and socially for us, the kids who can go on more trips." He laughs. "I hope I've said that right – photovoltaic." Jayden is 14-years-old. He's been at the youth club in Nunhead in SE London – which he describes as a 'safe haven' – since he was nine. "We're aiming to achieve reaching zero on the bills by adding batteries and enhancers and optimisers to maximise the energy we get," he explains. "Saving the club money that can go towards things we wouldn't be able to experience otherwise." Listening intently is the MP for Peckham, Miatta Fahnbulleh, whose constituency encompasses Nunhead. The 45-year-old is also a minister in the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, which has put clean power and low prices at the heart of Labour's energy revolution. So, she's proud to see a tiny charity in a deprived corner of her constituency leading the way. "This is the future," Fahnbulleh tells me. "It's giving me a lot of inspiration being here. It gives me a bit of fire in my belly seeing it in action like this. It's amazing hearing the young people talking about it because they get it. It's tangible. We talk about a solar panel rooftop revolution – and here it is, and it has been really quickly cost-effective. It's an actual, visible symbol of both helping people with the cost of living and helping us with the challenges of the future. The things I'm really passionate about." Next week sees the first anniversary of the first Labour government in 14 years, and Fahnbulleh's first year as an MP. "Government is hard, policy is hard, change is hard," she says. "But when people tell you, you can't do this – the social capital isn't there to move this – somewhere like this shows you what it looks like when you get it right. Look at what they have done here despite a Tory Austerity government. What more could a place like this achieve with arms around it – a rocket booster from government?" The government is putting £12 million into local authorities and community-led energy groups in the UK and £9.3m to power schemes in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland via the Great British Energy Local Power Plan. Fahnbulleh says that for constituencies like hers, that could be transformational. Nunhead's rapid gentrification stands in stark contrast to the deep poverty in which many local kids still grow up. As Ace Gordon, 15, explains: "As a young black boy, growing up in this type of environment, where most black boys are labelled, this club has helped me. I don't want to say that I would have gone down the wrong path – but if I'd never come to this youth club, it could have led me to a bad place." Westminster House charges just £35 a year for an incredible array of opportunities more befitting of Westminster School, the elite public school which founded the charity in 1888. The club moved to Nunhead in 1949, where as well as a daily after school club, they provide everything from homework support to Vitamin D, food, Duke of Edinburgh schemes and arts, beach and nature trips. "During the cost-of-living crisis our energy bills went up 400 per cent," says the charity's director, Katie Worthington. "But we couldn't increase the price to the young people. So, we had to think of innovative ways to tackle that. At the same time, we had done a survey of all our young members, and what came out of that was that among their other worries – things about school, or will I get a girlfriend – they were really worried about the environment. "So in all honesty, my motivation was financial, the young people's motivation was the environment. But we've all learnt and grown and changed. For example, we now plant things. We never did that. We collect rainwater, we never did that. You plug your phone in, you go to get it, and it's not charged because someone's already switched it off at the wall. Because we think now – all the time." Katie admits she's now become obsessed with getting the bills down to zero and into profit. With the panels funded by the Southwark Community Energy Fund and generous private donors, Westminster House has now applied for funding for a 51-kilowatt battery, and optimisers. "We're only really beginning," she says. Up on the roof admiring the solar panels with Fahnbulleh is Joe Fortune, General Secretary of the Co-operative Party. The party of the UK's co-operative movement – a sister party to Labour – has just released a new joint report with the Labour Climate and Environment Forum, 'Power in our Communities', as part of its Community Britain campaign. "Projects like this show what is possible when clean energy is rooted in the community," Fortune says. "Community-owned energy puts power, literally, in the hands of people, giving them a stake in our clean energy future. Every community should have the opportunity to benefit from the power of ownership." Speaking at the launch of the report Energy Secretary Ed Miliband spoke of "a new vision of community wealth and power". "The case for climate action won't come from Westminster," he says. "It will come from communities across our country, who know clean power means lower bills and wider benefits to regenerate their local area. This is what taking back control really looks like." Westminster House youth club is full of young ambassadors for the solar revolution. As Jayden and Ace, Grace Haynes, 14, and Turvane Douglas, 15 speak about the difference made by the panels. Peckham has always shaped Fahnbulleh through her family's deep links into the Sierra Leonean community that supported her family when they arrived as refugees. Today, she finds herself inspired by the passion and determination of some of her youngest constituents. "All across Peckham I see things like this happening," she says. "There has been a lack of investment – yet across the constituency I see a lot of hope. Great British Energy will support the solar revolution in public places and community buildings, helping with funding and working in partnership with local people. The thing we hear in place after place, whether it's hospitals or people's homes is that it's possible to do this – to go on this journey. It really sells itself – we just need to get the word out."
Scotsman
an hour ago
- Scotsman
How a UK national ID card would 'stop the boats'
Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... The long days of summer bring another high tide of small boats across the English Channel, despite renewed efforts by the Labour government to stem the numbers. Some 17,000 have already made the crossing this year with the Prime Minister admitting the situation is 'deteriorating'. For the first time, immigration has been ranked amongst the top five concerns for Scots even though numbers coming here have traditionally been much lower. According to the polls, no politician can afford to ignore this issue. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad With a falling birth rate, Scotland has specific migration needs but they can only be met through a system that is regulated, transparent and understood. Migrants abandon a people-smugglers' boat after it was punctured with a knife by French police to stop them attempting to cross the English Channel from a beach at Gravelines, near Dunkirk (Picture: Sameer Al-Doumy) | AFP via Getty Images Social media surveillance Everyone who comes to this country, legally or illegally, does so for their own personal reasons. It might be the search for a better life and the opportunities available in a safe and secure country. It might be the pull of our language. It might be a welfare system more generous than elsewhere but there is another vital factor as well. The UK is one of the few countries in the world without a system of national identity cards. In some places, they are voluntary, in others mandatory, but the argument against them is out of date. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Civil liberties organisations used to fear the level of surveillance and control this would allow over individual citizens. That day is gone. Now Mark Zuckerberg knows what you think via social media, while Jeff Bezos has the lowdown on what you buy. Marks and Spencer probably knows your inside leg measurement. We're also one of the world's most surveilled countries with more than five million cameras on buses, in shops and offices, and even in our own doorbells. So what difference would identity cards make? Right now some estimates suggest the shadow migrant economy built around casual employment in places like car washes, nail bars, barber shops and fast-food outlets could amount 10 per cent of our GDP. Without a system for verifying identity, shutting it down is a mammoth task requiring the background of every individual to be checked. Biometric identity cards would change that overnight. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Uniform system across EU The lack of a system of identity verification is another unwitting consequence of Brexit. All 27 EU countries how have a uniform system with Portugal and Bulgaria the latest to sign up. The presence of a carte d'identite in France seems to be a key factor in pushing individuals to the Channel and the route to the UK where it's much easier to disappear from the scrutiny of the state. We've been here before. More than 20 years ago, an experimental system of ID cards was introduced but then dropped because of opposition from civil liberty campaigners. However that was long before the migration numbers we see today with the knock-on effects they have. According to former Home Secretary David Blunkett, the small boats scandal would never have happened if the government had persevered with that scheme because the requirement to have an ID card to work, claim benefits or receive healthcare would have been a big disincentive to people coming here in the first place.
Glasgow Times
an hour ago
- Glasgow Times
Mobile phone use in East Renfrewshire schools could be restricted
Parents, carers and staff have raised concerns about the use of smartphones in schools, which can 'facilitate bullying', councillors have said. There are plans to hand out questionnaires from August, which will help to refresh guidance on how phones can be used while at school. Cllr Katie Pragnell, Labour, said she has been 'contacted by a number of parents, carers and staff who work within East Renfrewshire schools' and there are 'some concerns about the use of mobile phones in our schools'. She added: 'I think it's really important that we consider this issue fully as there is evidence emerging, particularly on the impact mobile phones have on young people's mental health, especially as they are going through a quite vulnerable stage of puberty and adolescence.' Cllr Kate Campbell, Conservative, added: 'I am very aware from what I've heard from parents and pupils, it's not just receiving and sending texts, smartphones facilitate bullying. READ MORE: 'Very sad': School announces death of 'loved & respected' teacher 'They are being used for bullying, so we must really look into how they are used.' At an education committee meeting earlier this month, councillors were updated on work around the use of mobile phones in schools. Consultation has already been carried out through pupil council and head pupil meetings, parent council chair meetings and staff forums. Education officials have also audited current practice in secondary schools. They reported: 'Our next step will be to design and implement a fuller consultation, which will involve designing a questionnaire which will be issued to parents/carers, pupils and staff in schools. 'The results of this consultation will inform how we update guidance for schools in East Renfrewshire.' READ MORE: Glasgow restaurant visited by Celtic & Rangers star to temporarily close An official told councillors that they would engage with stakeholders on the content of the questionnaires and aim to 'have it ready for launching early August when schools come back'. Cllr Gordon Wallace, Conservative, said one of four rules on smartphones suggested in the book 'The Anxious Generation' by Jonathan Haidt is phone-free schools. It proposes storing phones, smart-watches and other personal devices that can send or receive texts in phone-lock pouches during the school day, he said. Cllr Wallace added: 'I appreciate to suddenly fire that out to our youngsters who really spend an awful lot of their time on smartphones, that would be a big ask. 'I do appreciate the value of going out to consultation on this, but I don't think there's any question in anybody's mind, the impact that smartphones are having on our youngsters. 'That's not to say that we must do without them but we need to find a way through this for the benefit of our young people.'
