logo
Like Gukesh now, a young Vishy Anand too faced criticism and was once dismissed by Soviet stars as a ‘coffee house player'

Like Gukesh now, a young Vishy Anand too faced criticism and was once dismissed by Soviet stars as a ‘coffee house player'

Indian Express09-07-2025
Over the last six months, almost on cue as India's D Gukesh started to make an audacious bid to ascend to the world champion's throne at the incredulous age of 18, there has been plenty of withering criticism flung in his direction. Almost like his entire chess style has been run through an X-ray machine by a team of unflinching experts determined to find every single problem with it. As chess legend Susan Polgar noted recently, 'Some have doubted his worthiness as a World Champion, and believed that he was just a lucky winner against an off-form Ding Liren.'
The latest salvo fired at Gukesh, right before the SuperUnited Rapid and Blitz Croatia tournament, came from Magnus Carlsen, the five-time world champion and the foremost authority on the sport. The world no 1 questioned the reigning classical world champion's credentials in the faster time controls of rapid and blitz, saying that he would approach the three games against him as if he were 'playing one of the presumably weaker players in the tournament'.
His reasoning for this was: 'Gukesh hasn't done anything to indicate he's going to do well in such a tournament. It remains to be proven that he's one of the best players in such a format. This is a very strong field that we have. Players like Gukesh have a lot to prove. In the course of 27 rounds, things usually show.'
Throughout the world championship battle in November and December last year, Carlsen cast a constant shadow on the battle between Ding Liren and Gukesh with his scathing analysis of the games and the players' decisions on the board. At one point, he remarked: 'This looks like the second round or third round of an open tournament, not a world championship.' He wasn't the only former world champion constantly providing no-holds-barred critique of Gukesh's moves at the Singapore event. Vladimir Kramnik, the curmudgeonly former world champion, famously declared that it was the 'end of chess as we know it' on the day Gukesh made history by becoming the world champion at the age of 18.
It must be noted that some of the critique is understandable. Before the recently-concluded event in Zagreb, Gukesh had limited rapid and blitz experience. And each time he ventured out of the comfort zone of classical chess, like at Freestyle Chess events, he suffered. But the criticism of Gukesh seems a little too direct, in-your-face. Maybe a little like the Australian cricket team under Ricky Ponting sledging their opponents.
The teenager himself doesn't care much, though. As verbal knives continued to be sharpened against him after he became world champion, Gukesh coolly responded to the criticism by saying: 'When you reach the World Championship, you are bound to face criticism, and people are free to say whatever they want.'
He's taken the same approach over the past few months. After Carlsen's comment about treating him as one of the weaker players in the field at Zagreb, the Indian responded: 'I understand why (Carlsen) would think so, my rapid and blitz results in the past have not been great. But nobody knows what's happening behind the scenes. Only I know that.' Gukesh had a hint of a smile when he said that. Just a day before, he had handed the world no 1 a defeat in the rapid format after all.
The criticism that Gukesh has been getting in the past one year is nothing new. Just over four decades back, in the start of the 90s, when another young buck from Chennai was on the rise in the sport, he too would get acerbic comments from Soviet Union players, who thought that they had a monopoly on success in the sport.
'In 1991, at my first international tournament, in Reggio Emilia in northern Italy, a Russian grandmaster condescendingly told me I could at best be a 'coffee-house player' because I had not been tutored in the Soviet school of chess,' Viswanathan Anand had written in an article for TIME magazine in 2008.
Of course, 1991 was the year that Anand beat Soviet Union stars like Garry Kasparov, Anatoly Karpov, Gata Kamsky and Viktor Korchnoi. He won the Reggio Emilia title as well that year, leaving behind nine Soviet players like Kasparov and Karpov. That Reggio Emilia event started in 1991 and ended in 1992. And over the course of the tournament many things changed. The Soviet Union disintegrated into many different nations. And Anand went from being described as a 'talent' by the Soviet players to being called other uncharitable things. Because now the boy from India who played classical games at blitz pace was a problem.
After nine of them saw the only non-Soviet player emerge as the champion at Reggio Emilia, the Soviets pulled out their old playbook: to undermine the player and his achievements. Reggio Emilia was a Category 18 tournament, which back then meant that it was an event with the strongest field ever assembled. After Anand's win, Karpov tried to talk down the strength of the event itself, by saying, 'The thing about categories is that, I never find that very interesting.' A sentiment he probably wouldn't have shared with the world had he won the event.
As Anand recently recollected in a conversation for the New In Chess podcast, a few months after that event he was in Dortmund for a tournament and had dinner with another non-Soviet player. Anand told him how Korchnoi had been saying that 'Anand doesn't think but just plays some tricks'. At this, the other player is said to have remarked, 'Korchnoi praises me to the skies. That's because he beats me all the time. You should enjoy it (the criticism) while it lasts.'
Anand said that while people around him were offended by the comments being made about him, he was not too unnerved. 'I'd done it myself a few times to others,' he recounted on the podcast.
The change in tone from his rivals did come with realisations. 'It was at this point that I realised that 'talent' is a word people use to describe you when they want to express good-hearted empathy. It merely reflects that you are not yet a threat to their dominance or their prize fund flow. It's when they trash-talk you — like they did after my surprise coup in Italy — that you know you're respected. Maybe even feared,' Anand wrote in his autobiography 'Mind Master'.
The 'coffee house player' jibe — used for someone that's not professional about the sport and experiments a lot — wasn't the only pejorative that Anand heard about himself in his earliest days. He's been paid some creative backhanded compliments. Like when Anatoly Karpov, after the 1998 World Championship, told a journalist, within crystal-clear earshot of the Indian and his wife Aruna: 'Vishy's a nice guy. But he just doesn't have the character for a big win.'
This 'nice guy' stereotype is also something that all Indian world-beating prodigies like Gukesh, R Praggnanandhaa and Arjun Erigaisi today can be accused of. Fabiano Caruana recently noted how the new generation of players (spearheaded by the Indian trio) were playing 'at their level, but he didn't find them scary yet.' (As an aside, Caruana, a player with the most stable quality of chess without too many fluctuations recently lost thrice in three games to Gukesh at the SuperUnited Rapid and Blitz tournament).
In his autobiography, Anand spoke about this 'nice guy' stereotype: 'There are people who thrive in an atmosphere of combat, tension and conflict, but that hasn't been my strongest suit. Generally, my best results come when I am happy and my mind is not occupied with external diversions. This has perhaps led people to assume I am a pushover,' Anand wrote.
Anand also pointed out that when he became world champion in Tehran in 2000, the chess world was 'dismissive' of his first world title. 'I wasn't entirely certain whether they adopted this stance to get me ruffled or they genuinely believed that I was undeserving of this distinction.'
All of these emotions — being praised as a talent and then being trash-talked publicly, avoiding verbal conflict, seeing the world be dismissive of his success — that Anand experienced in the early 90s, Gukesh is probably feeling now. And just like Anand was advised in 1992, the best thing for the teenager to do is to enjoy the criticism while it lasts.
Amit Kamath is Assistant Editor at The Indian Express and is based in Mumbai. ... Read More
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

'You cannot replicate what he does': England legend heaps massive praise on Rishabh Pant
'You cannot replicate what he does': England legend heaps massive praise on Rishabh Pant

First Post

time18 minutes ago

  • First Post

'You cannot replicate what he does': England legend heaps massive praise on Rishabh Pant

Rishabh Pant has impressed former England captain David Gower with his fearless batting. Pant amassed a healthy figure in the series and could not held back from taking the attack to the opposition even when he was batting with an injured foot. read more The courage Rishabh Pant showed the other day in Manchester has won the hearts of millions across the world. Former England captain David Gower is also largely impressed with India's wicketkeeper batter, so much so that he has claimed that what Pant does on the field, 'others can only dream of and takes incredible to another level.' Gower, who is touted as one of the finest left-hand batters to have graced the game, could not stop raving about Pant, who trudged to the middle with a broken foot on Day 2 of the STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Talking about the grace that left-handers carry, Gower keeps Brian Lara in the highest regard in this department, but spoke highly of Ben Duckett and Rishabh Pant, who have been brilliant with the bat in the series in England. 'Tongue-in-cheek…we have always said left-handers are the best. For some reason when you look at left-handed batsmen it seems to be more graceful than right-handed. I've watched a lot of great left-handers from my days growing up, Gary Sobers for one, Brian Lara of course probably the best of those when I was first starting to grace commentary boxes and describe these things,' Gower told PTI. 'Now we have a guy called Ben Duckett, he has a very different style to mine but incredible to watch. Every time I look at him bat you're kind of wondering what happens next and you cannot forget, especially in the context of this series, Rishabh Pant.' Gower said the series would be poorer in Pant's absence if the Indian star is ruled out of the remainder of the series. 'I'm actually so sorry that he's injured, and if this foot thing is terminal (and he is out of the series). There is a man who does the things that only others dream of. Some people call them nightmares, but he's an absolutely brilliant, extraordinary player to watch. Gower gushes about Pant According to Gower, the characteristics Pant possesses are hard to find, and one either has it or not. 'So, you cannot replicate what he does. You cannot ask a young player, say age 15-16 to bat like Rishabh Pant, go on try that because that would be probably fatal to their career. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'But when you've got someone like that who plays this most extraordinary version of the game, you cannot but admire it. He takes incredible to another level,' said Gower.

Root surpasses Ponting, next in sight is all-time leading run-getter Tendulkar
Root surpasses Ponting, next in sight is all-time leading run-getter Tendulkar

News18

time42 minutes ago

  • News18

Root surpasses Ponting, next in sight is all-time leading run-getter Tendulkar

Manchester, Jul 25 (PTI) The prolific Joe Root on Friday surpassed Australian legend Ricky Ponting's tally to become the second highest run-getter in the history of Test cricket and next in sight of the England batter is Indian icon Sachin Tendulkar who continues to head the list. On the third day of the fourth Test against India here, Root first leapfrogged legendary Indian Rahul Dravid and South African great Jacques Kallis' aggregate of runs in a space of eight balls and then went past Ponting by steering the ball behind point for a single as the Old Trafford crowd gave him a standing ovation. Ponting had scored 13378 runs in 168 matches at an average of 51.85, while Tendulkar continues to top the list with 15921 runs. It was apt that Ponting was in the commentary box when Root went past him. The 34-year-old Root began his Test career with a 73-run knock on debut during England's tour of India back in 2012 at Nagpur. 'Congrats, Joe Root. Magnificent," a delighted Ponting, doing commentary alongside Ravi Shastri, hailed the Yorkshire man. Root is playing in his 157th Test. It was some sight as England skipper Ben Stokes, who was also in the middle, raised his bat even before Root could take off his helmet and acknowledged the cheers and applause from the crowd and the players Earlier, Root entered the history books by breaking the record of most Test centuries against India with his 12th hundred against the Asian giants, against whom he has played in 34 Tests so far. Overall, the ton at Old Trafford was his 38th in red ball format as he joined former Sri Lanka star Kumar Sangakkara at fourth place in the list of centurions in the game's longest format. Tendulkar (51), Jacques Kallis (45) and Ponting (41) are ahead of him in the hundred's list. PTI AH AH UNG (This story has not been edited by News18 staff and is published from a syndicated news agency feed - PTI) view comments First Published: July 25, 2025, 21:00 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

How Many Tests Does Joe Root Need To Beat Sachin Tendulkar's Most Runs Record?
How Many Tests Does Joe Root Need To Beat Sachin Tendulkar's Most Runs Record?

News18

timean hour ago

  • News18

How Many Tests Does Joe Root Need To Beat Sachin Tendulkar's Most Runs Record?

Joe Root has surpassed Dravid, Kallis, and Ponting to become the second-highest run-scorer in Test cricket. How many Tests does he need to go past Sachin Tendulkar? Joe Root is on a record-breaking spree and the biggest record left for him is India great Sachin Tendulkar's for most runs ever in Test cricket — 15,921. On Friday (July 25), he became the second-highest run-scorer in the format with 13380 runs, going past Rahul Dravid (13288), Jaques Kallis (13289), and Ricky Ponting (13378) in the same innings of 121* (201), at Tea in the fourth Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy Test at Old Trafford. The question begs itself — can Root be the one to break Tendulkar's currently 12-year-old record, which many thought would never be touched, which Virat Kohli, Kane Williamson and several other greats couldn't come even close to? If he can, how many Tests would he need to do so and etch him at the top of the world? It's difficult to say exactly, but Root has averaged 89 since the start of 2024, and according to CricViz (a sports analytics company), if he maintains that rate, he will need only 29 more Tests to pass Tendulkar and become the format's leading run scorer. Considering England play at least a dozen Tests every year (they played 17 in 2024), he'd need about two and a half years to reach the feat. To put how quick Root is in context, the 17 Tests in 2024 yielded 1556 runs for him. Of course, this is the best-case scenario. Apart from the difficulty of maintaining a purple patch like this for that significant period, Root would also need to keep himself fit. He's 34 and will turn 35 this December, and though he's fit, it'll become progressively arduous for him to maintain fitness, just like Tendulkar, Kallis, and Ponting also faced. However, Tendulkar played 200 Tests, and Ponting 168, while Root is still at 157. Ponting's prediction for Root's records Earlier in the day, Ponting had tipped Root to break his record. He was also asked about the Englishman's chances of going past Tendulkar. 'There's still a fair bit to go," Ponting told ICC. 'What is he, 35? Doesn't look like his passion for the game is going anywhere. His run-scoring passion has probably gone up over the years. Can he chase down Sachin? Let's see. He might as well do that," he added. First Published: July 25, 2025, 20:59 IST Latest News Indian-Origin Man Among 12 Arrested For Child Trafficking Ring World World Two People Killed After Plane Crashed Into Italian Highway | Video Bollywood Did Alia Bhatt Just Confirm Her Alpha Spy Cameo In War 2? Here's Why Fans Think So Agency feeds Rs 100 core drug cartel busted by Delhi Police spans across continents Agency feeds Over 25 drown daily in Bengal, half are children: Survey latest news

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store