Unemployment, poverty and inequality
Capitec CEO Gerrit Fourie argues SA's jobless rate is as low as 10% and not 32,9% as stated by Stats SA – is he right? Dineo Faku of the ST reports that many don't think so. Stats SA argues their quarterly labour force survey includes the self-employed. Peter Bruce warns that 'you ignore the gut of Fourie at your peril, with 24 million customers he knows a lot more that Stats SA does'.
Clearly few have read the work of GG Alcock 'Kasinomics Revolution' who has made a career out of studying informal entrepreneurial endeavour across the townships of SA. His finding are that 'real' as opposed to 'official' unemployment does not exceed 12%.
For 30 years our unemployment, poverty and inequality conventional wisdoms, trotted out by all and sundry, have remained the same:
SA's unemployment is amongst the highest in the world
55% of South Africans live in poverty
South Africa is the most unequal society in the world.
There is no question that over the past 30 years many of the unemployment, poverty and inequality numbers have changed significantly. I am going to argue that Gerrit Fourie is more right than wrong and that the 'official stats' are more wrong than right.
1. Conventional Wisdom: SA has the highest unemployment in the world at 32,9% with youth unemployment at 45.5%:
GG. Alcock, his book Kasinomics Revolution has comprehensively researched the size of the informal sector. Here are some numbers:
Spaza shops account for R190-billion across 100,000 outlets.
The fast food sector accounts for R90-billion across 50,000 outlets.
The beauty sector accounts for R10-billion annually.
The taxi sector accounts for R50-billion a year across 250,000 vehicles.
The multi-sector is worth around R18-billion per year.
Savings stokvels are worth R44-billion per year.
The backroom rental sector in townships is worth R20-billion annually.
The spaza shop rental economy is around R25-billion per year.
And there are a multitude of other businesses in these sectors including:
Kasi building, renovations, gates, burglar guards, chrome gutters etc.
Services — plumbing, electricians, catering and event suppliers tent, toilet and chair hire.
Alcohol — taverns and shebeens.
Cultural — muti, livestock, sangoma, inyanga, unveilings, funeral.
Financial — mashonisa, stokvel, masicwabisane.
Youth unemployment at 45.5%
Mamapudi Nkgadima of Africa Response Survey writes 'To solve South Africa's dismaying youth unemployment challenge we must end the pervasive narrative that South Africans, and particularly young unemployed South Africans, are reliant on the government.
It's quite simply not true, as a recent African Response survey has revealed. Among the respondents who classified themselves as unemployed and looking for work, 41% are earning up to R15 000 a month through income-generating activities such as baking, building and hairdressing. What this shows is that many of our young people are resilient and inventive about making ends meet. We need to reinforce that and build their confidence so that that attitude catches on.'
The EY Global Shadow Economy Report 2025 confirms ours is at 26% amongst the highest globally.
Based on these numbers alone it would seem that the informal sector could be approaching R1 trillion (25% of GDP) per annum where +/- 8 million people are involved in income generating activities.
Reality Check: If these numbers are representative real unemployment is somewhere between 10 and 15%
Conventional Wisdom: 55% of South Africans live in poverty
There are three categories of poverty (The Economist):
Abject poverty: defined as 'a wretched life where people lack education, healthcare, proper clothing, hygiene, access to fresh water and shelter, and enough food for physical and mental health.'
Moderate poverty: A measure of being poor, 'poor' being defined as between a lower-bound and upper-bound poverty line,
Relative poverty: A measure of inequality, what the GINI co-efficient sets out to do.
The World Bank ranks poverty on the basis of income. In South Africa (SA), the national poverty lines are measured as the minimum amount of money you need to afford basic necessities like food and other essentials. The poverty lines are categorised as follows: the food poverty line (FPL) is R796 per month, the lower-bound poverty line (LBPL) is R1,109 per month (R4,436 for a family of four) and the upper-bound poverty line (UBPL) is R1,634 per month (R6,536 for a family of four). In 2024, it was estimated that 13.2 million people in South Africa lived in extreme poverty, according to Statista. Additionally, approximately 55% of the South African population, or 30.3 million people, lived below the national upper-bound poverty line.
But these numbers do not include government transfers, subsidies and the like — see below (using 2023 figures).
If you were to estimate the monetary value of the distributed 'income and consumption' of the above for a family of two parents/or guardians, one pensioner, and two children it would be as follows:
Child grant at R530 x2= R1,060
Pensioner foster care x 1 = R1,,180
Old age pension x 1= R2,080
Free schooling x 2 = R1,200*
Free food at school x 2 = R1,000*
Subsidised school transport x 2 = R400
Subsidised water = R300*
Subsidised electricity = R300*
Subsidised housing = R1,200*
Total = R8,720 per month per household, before any earned income is added!
* Here are my estimates of the monetary value of these benefits/subsidies as consumption.
Therefore, to claim that 55% of South Africans live below the upper-bound poverty line and that 22% live in extreme poverty cannot be defended in terms of the numbers above.
Reality check: If the above numbers were included in the calculation of poverty, would it change the 'stats'? I would submit that 10% of our population would be defined as living in abject poverty (Economist) with 35% living in moderate poverty (poor).
Conventional wisdom: South Africa is the most unequal society in the world.
The GINI co-efficient, the measure of inequality, is defined as 'measuring the extent to which the distribution of income or consumption among individuals or households within an economy deviates from a perfectly equal distribution. A Gini index of 0 represents perfect equality, while an index of 1 implies perfect inequality'.
Our score, which hasn't changed over 30 years, is between .61 and .65 and states that our income inequality is among the 'worst in the world'.
Definitions
Would it be fair to argue that the distribution of 'income or consumption' includes all the income a household receives no matter the source, both earned and unearned; and that consumption is of all that is used by the household, whether as a result of government transfers and free services, or personal choice.
SA over the past 30 years
According to the 2024 South Africa Survey published by the Institute of Race Relations, expenditure on social services has risen from R63-billion (1995) to R1.27-trillion (2023), a 1,900% increase in nominal terms (at 5% inflation over 30 years R63-billion would have risen to R272-billion — a 330% increase).
The number of formal houses has trebled in the last 30 years, 60% of which are owned.
So do the sums!
8 million people working in the informal sector with 41% of unemployed youth hustling at R15 000 per month.
Government transfers have increased from 2,046702 recipients in 1996 to 18,829716 in 2023.
Child support grants increased from 0 in 1995 to 13,147937 in 2023.
There are 15 372 000 formal housing structures, 90% of which have access to electricity and water (with four people to each household that would account for 61488 000 citizens with permanent shelter.
A family of two kids, two guardians and a Gogo would access approximately R8,000 in government transfers.
CONCLUSION
So the question is, why are reputable organisations, think-thanks, research houses, political parties, NGO charities, labour unions and Stats SA constantly reminding us that we are the most unequal society in the world, that poverty remains stubbornly high at 55%, and that unemployment is on the rise at 32.9%?
Is it a government agenda, aimed at justifying BBBEE, Equity legislation, grants and a welfare state – all in the pursuit of justifying the National Democratic Revolution?
Is it a think-tank agenda, aimed at proving that 30 years of ANC rule has delivered nothing?
Is it an NGO agenda, sticking to the 'old' numbers to justify their 'current' needs?
Is it a labour union agenda, using apartheid legacy 'numbers' to defend non-CPI related wage demands?
Is it a Stats SA agenda aimed at justifying the spend on government transfers and grants?
I'm not for one minute suggesting that unemployment, poverty and inequality are not fundamental challenges bedeviling transformation and hampering redress in South Africa. But I am suggesting, as does Gerrit Fourie, that the numbers reflect our changing reality and that there has been positive upward movement which the official stats do not represent.
We need more people like CEO Gerrit Fourie, author GG Alcock, researcher JP Landman, think-tank The Institute of Race Relations who are doing the research, digging up the facts, calling out the numbers to shout louder and change our current conventional wisdom madness. DM
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
3 hours ago
- IOL News
FlySafair strike: Top alternative airlines for South African travellers facing flight cancellations
We look into alternative airlines for South Africans to use. On Monday morning, domestic carrier FlySafair was forced to cancel at least 26 flights after receiving last-minute notices from pilots that they would not report for duty. The company said the disruption is regrettable but largely out of its control. This is pilots are planning a stay-away for up to two weeks. 'What we are experiencing is industrial action on the part of our pilots. Unfortunately, our hands are tied,' said Kirby Gordon, Chief Marketing Officer at FlySafair, speaking from OR Tambo International Airport. 'We are issuing refunds and rebooking where we can, but negotiations remain tense.' The airline claims pilots already earn between R1.8 million and R2.3 million per year, placing them 'within the top 1% of earners in the country.' It is believed that FlySafair pilots down tools due to a pay dispute, sparking widespread flight cancellations and renewed debate around pilot remuneration. This begs the question: What other airlines can South Africans use?
IOL News
5 hours ago
- IOL News
FlySafair pilots' strike ground flights, sparking social media outrage
The ''tools down'' protest by FlySafair pilots has plunged operations into chaos, grounding flights and sparking a storm of outrage across social media. The chaos was triggered by failed wage talks, leading pilots to stage a tools-down protest that left scores of travellers stuck at airports nationwide. In a statement, FlySafair said that while most of their services remained on schedule, several flights were cancelled due to pilots who had initially agreed to work but later informed the airline, at the last minute, that they would no longer be flying. 'FlySafair confirms that operations continue largely as scheduled today, but unfortunately, a quantity of flights have had to be cancelled today. ''These flights were assigned to pilots who had confirmed their availability to fly, but who, late last night, reported that they would not fly. ''All other flights are operating as planned, and affected customers have been contacted directly using details provided at the time of booking. Should there be further disruptions, customers will be notified promptly. 'We thank our teams both on the aircraft and on the ground for their tireless commitment and hard work to ensure that disruptions are minimised as far as possible.' Social media erupted with backlash as frustrated users voiced their anger over the sudden cancellations. One user argued that companies thrive by rewarding employees with a share of profits instead of relying on unions, encouraging a culture of 'perform or exit.' FlySafair apologised for the disruption experienced by their customers and the wider public, assuring that they are working to resolve the situation swiftly. 'We deeply regret the impact this situation is having on our loyal customers and the broader flying public. Our goal remains to reach a reasonable resolution quickly, restore trust, and continue building the airline so many South Africans rely on.' Meanwhile, IOL reported that FlySafair said its hands were tied, after the company received last-minute updates from certain pilots informing the carrier that they would not make it to work on Monday morning, forcing the cancellation of at least 26 flights. In an interview with IOL at the OR Tambo International Airport in Kempton Park, Kirby Gordon, Chief Marketing Officer for FlySafair, said the interruption of flights is regrettable and has left some passengers stranded. "What we are experiencing at the moment is that we have an industrial action on the part of our pilots; they have embarked on a stay-away strike which started today. They have deemed it to happen for two weeks. "Unfortunately, we had a number of commitments from a number of pilots to be able to cover our schedule today. Late last night, we received information from several of them that they would be unable to fulfil their duties. ''As a result, we have had to cancel 26 of 174 flights today. So there have been cancellations and we apologise very deeply to our customers who have been stranded. Unfortunately, our hands are tied in this regard, because of the industrial action that is going on," he said. As an intervention, Gordon told IOL that Flysafair teams were assisting customers, and in some instances giving refunds. He said the negotiations with Solidarity are still ongoing. "We continue to approach them (the negotiations) with good faith. At this stage, we are still quite far apart. Unfortunately, the unions' demands are very high. They have been speaking about a demand of a 10 percent increase in salaries," said Gordon. "When one considers the full cost-to-company, that's more than 20.1 percent, which at the back of R1.8 to R2 million salary, which puts pilots within the top one percent of earners in this country, you can understand that it is just an untenable position. Earlier, IOL reported about the long queues formed at the FlySafair counters on Monday morning as the airline grappled with industrial action. In an interview with IOL at OR Tambo International Airport, Solidarity's deputy general-secretary, Helgard Cronje, said operations have been impacted by the labour impasse between FlySafair and the union, which Solidarity said has resulted in workers being blocked from working. Solidarity is the union representing FlySafair's pilots. Cronje told IOL that on Thursday, Solidarity gave FlySafair notice for a one-day strike, basically to get them back to the negotiation table. One student who opted not to be identified said he was scheduled to travel to Cape Town, but his flight has been cancelled. He has been put on standby for a flight on Tuesday. 'I have been told that there is no flight today and I must come tomorrow (Tuesday). I am not guaranteed a flight; they said I am on standby. I was told to return to the OR Tambo International Airport at 6 am. This has been frustrating,' he said. Additional Reporting by Jonisayi Maromo
Daily Maverick
5 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
FlySafair responds to pilot strike: majority of flights operating, economic context clarified
FlySafair has confirmed that while the majority of its operations remain intact, approximately 12% of scheduled flights have been cancelled today. This follows a late-night withdrawal of availability by several pilots who had previously confirmed their participation in scheduled flights. All affected customers were notified via SMS using the contact details provided at booking. Customers are encouraged to consult the Travel Updates page on for the latest information. Airport teams remain on standby to assist with rebookings, refunds, and alternative arrangements. 'We regret the disruption caused to our customers and are doing everything possible to support those affected,' says Kirby Gordon, Chief Marketing Officer at FlySafair. Dispute overview: a matter of economic sustainability The current industrial action stems from a pay dispute between FlySafair and Solidarity, the union representing a portion of the airline's pilot workforce. While the union has publicly framed its demand as a 10.5% increase in base salary, the full package, including flight pay, bonuses, and other benefits, amounts to a 20.1% increase in total cost to company. By contrast, FlySafair's current offer includes a 5.7% increase on base salary, which is 1.5% above inflation. When fully costed, the offer equates to an 11.29% increase in total cost to company. The airline maintains that this is a fair and responsible offer, particularly in a macroeconomic environment where most businesses are offering increases of 4% or less. 'We must balance competitive pay with the responsibility we have to our 1,700 employees, the affordability we offer South African travellers, and the long-term health of the business,' says Gordon. FlySafair captains currently earn between R1.8 million and R2.3 million annually, placing them in the top 1% of earners in South Africa. Many earn more than members of the airline's Executive Committee. The airline argues that the union's demands are not only economically unsustainable but also risk undermining the long-term affordability of air travel for South Africans. Pilot utilisation and regulatory compliance Concerns have been raised about pilot workload. However, FlySafair captains averaged 63 hours of flight time last month, well below the regulatory maximum of 100 hours set by the Civil Aviation Authority. For comparison, a standard full-time employee typically works around 160 hours per month. The airline maintains that its pilot utilisation is efficient, compliant, and in line with global aviation norms. Labour relations and escalation The union initially called for a one-day strike, strategically timed to coincide with the end of the school holidays. In response, FlySafair issued a defensive lockout, a standard labour relations mechanism. Due to the nature of airline rostering, this meant affected pilots would not be rostered for seven days. Solidarity then escalated the action to a two-week strike. FlySafair has not rejected CCMA intervention and continues to engage with the commission and the union in good faith. The airline emphasises its commitment to constructive dialogue and resolution. Broader impact and strategic outlook FlySafair acknowledges the disruption caused to customers and is working to minimise the impact. The airline also highlights its responsibility to its 1,700 other employees, whose livelihoods are linked to the company's financial sustainability. 'This is not a position any business wants to be in. We are committed to resolving this matter constructively and quickly, while protecting the long-term viability of the airline and the affordability of air travel in South Africa,' says Gordon. DM
