Social welfare Ireland: TD says €12 dole rise in Budget 'not feasible' as row deepens
Nearly 13,500 people have been on Jobseekers Allowance for over five years, with nearly 5,000 on the payment for a decade or more, new figures have revealed.
It comes as the coalition is on yet another collision course over whether to increase pension rates and the social welfare rates to the same extent during Budget 2026.
John Paul O'Shea, a Fine Gael TD and Chairman of the powerful Oireachtas Social Protection Committee, stated a €12 dole rise "will not be feasible" in October's budget as he said there is "no reason" why people should be on the payment for more than 12 months.
Last week, Tánaiste Simon Harris suggested that he was "not convinced that you need to see as significant a rise in the dole as you do on the pension, for example, at the time when our country's in full employment and there's lots of supports out there for people getting into work".
However, speaking in Japan, Taoiseach Micheál Martin warned against creating distinctions and said that Fine Gael had never proposed the idea of differing increases.
This is despite senior Fine Gael sources confirming to the Irish Mirror that it was put forward by then Social Protection Minister Heather Humphreys as an option.
New figures provided to the Irish Mirror by the Department of Social Protection confirmed that 46,940 people had been on Jobseeker's Allowance for more than one year.
Some 9,809 people have been receiving the payment for between two and three years, while 5,066 people have been on Jobseekers for three to four years. Another 2,784 people have been receiving the weekly payment for four to five years.
In total, 13,391 people have been on Jobseekers for more than five years. Of these, 8,487 people have been in receipt of it for more than five years, while 4,904 have been classified as unemployed for a decade or more.
Deputy O'Shea, Fine Gael TD for Cork North-West and chair of the Oireachtas Social Protection Committee, told the Irish Mirror that "there is no reason why people should be on Jobseekers for longer than 12 months".
When asked if he agreed with the Tánaiste's suggestion that social protection rates and pensions did not need to be increased at the same rate as part of Budget 2026, he said, "Absolutely".
He continued: "We obviously went and gave everyone on social welfare benefits €12 of [an] increase last year. I don't think that is feasible this year, given the conversations we've had only last week in terms of trying to fund the [third level] student contribution fee as part of Government next year.
"A €1 increase [to social welfare payments] would actually pay for the whole of the entire student contribution fee that's required.
"I don't [know] why we should be prioritising job seekers who are on Jobseekers for over 12 months, and not to mention five years or 10 years, on the basis of the other requirements we have to fund within budget."
At a press conference on Monday following the Government's Competitiveness Summit, Public Expenditure Minister Jack Chambers declined to wade into the potential budget clash between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael.
He said: "[Social Protection] Minister [Dara] Calleary will obviously examine the different supports that exist in the social protection system and how best to prioritise that in the context of Budget 2026.
"One component is obviously Jobseekers. There's Disability Allowance, Carers and obviously pension supports as well.
"It's within that context that he'll have to assess what the relative increases will be as part of next year's budget.
"But it will be in a different fiscal context than we've seen in previous years, and that means every minister will have to prioritise the increased supports they want to see for different areas that they're responsible for."
Join our Dublin Live breaking news service on WhatsApp. Click this link to receive your daily dose of Dublin Live content. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
For all the latest news from Dublin and surrounding areas visit our homepage.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Post
3 hours ago
- Irish Post
Trump's latest tariff threats renew fears for Irish exports
DONALD Trump has reignited trade tensions with the EU by reversing his earlier decision to extend tariff negotiations. In a post on Truth Social, Trump declared there would be 'no extension' beyond today's deadline, raising the risk of steep new tariffs on European goods. Trump had previously signalled August 1st as the cutoff for a deal, but that grace period is now off the table. The EU is scrambling to reach at least a basic agreement to avoid new tariffs — including threatened 50% duties on key imports — though progress has been slow. Ireland is already affected by existing 10% US tariffs on products like butter, whiskey, and some medical goods. While the broader pharmaceutical sector has so far been spared, a recent US review could pave the way for 25% tariffs — a major concern for one of Ireland's most critical industries. Tánaiste Simon Harris has called for a 'zero for zero' tariff deal, but such an outcome looks unlikely. There are reports that planes and alcohol may be excluded from future tariffs, which would offer some relief to Irish exporters. Although the Irish economy hasn't yet seen major damage, the uncertainty is putting investment decisions on hold and weighing on exporters already hit by the weak US dollar and trade friction. Meanwhile, divisions within the EU are complicating the bloc's response. Germany favours a quick deal to protect its car industry, while France is pushing for a tougher stance. The EU has so far avoided retaliatory action, but officials warn that cannot continue if Trump escalates. While markets currently expect cooler heads to prevail, there's growing concern that talks could collapse, triggering a damaging trade war. Ireland's export-heavy economy and reliance on US investment make it particularly vulnerable to these tariff threats. See More: Donald Trump, EU, Simon Harris, Tariffs
Irish Independent
4 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Lack of regulation on drones is like ‘the Wild West', TD tells committee
As the commercial drone company Manna plans to launch a new hub in Dundrum, Dublin, to run in addition to its hub in Blanchardstown, Fine Gael TD Maeve O'Connell described the situation as 'a completely unregulated area' that is 'a bit of a Wild West'. 'We don't really have any limitations on noise, or the number of drones that can fly in effectively open-air space, and we don't have a lower limit that drones can fly at,' she said. Representatives of Manna, as well as the Irish Aviation Authority, Dublin City Council, Maynooth University, and University of Limerick, appeared before the Oireachtas Committee on Transport, where the lack of regulation of drones was highlighted. Fine Gael TD Emer Currie said Dublin 15 is being used as a test ground to launch commercial drone operations nationally, so the decisions the Government is making now will shape how drone technology is going to develop. She said there is no integrated regulatory framework when it comes to commercial drone operations. She said all four councils in Dublin operate under a combined noise action plan. However, drones appear to fall outside this framework. Paul Rutherford, the principal environmental health officer with the noise control unit of Dublin City Council, said the current legislation dealing with noise control is the Environmental Protection Act of 1992. 'Under sub-section 4 it says: 'this section shall not apply to aircraft', so under that legislation we cannot deal with noise complaints about drones,' he said. Jim Gavin, the chief operations officer of the Irish Aviation Authority (IAA), said its remit is the safety and security of drones. 'In relation to noise, there are no specific regulations for noise with the exception of drones that you would typically buy off the shelf with a CE marking,' he said. ADVERTISEMENT 'Those have a specific decibel level. With other drones there is no specific level. However, member states may put restrictions such as a decibel level in particular volumes of airspace.' He said there are strict safety regulations that drone operators must comply with, and the IAA has taken proceedings against a number of operators that have not complied. Bobby Healy, the CEO of Manna Air Delivery, said the firm is a world leader in the sector, and has created 160 jobs in Dublin. He said it has made more than 35,000 deliveries in Dublin 15 since it launched in March. He said the company is awaiting regulatory approval to bring in machines that are 40pc quieter. Mr Healy said the firm operates four drones in Dublin 15, and it would like to expand. 'We fully accept we need to have debate and regulations around the particular use of drones. I have no objection to that, in fact, I embrace it,' he said.
Irish Independent
6 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Cutting Property Tax has ‘just blown a €10m hole in the council budget'
Ahead of budget planning for 2026, Deputy Chief Executive of the Council, Helena Cunningham, said the council is facing a difficult budget for the next year, with higher costs and salaries, a growing population and the rising costs of amenities. Councillors can vote annually on whether to keep the LPT at the base rate, to cut it by up to 15pc, or increase it by up to 15pc. The council's only source of revenue are the LPT, rents rates and parking charges, and the 15pc reduction could see €10.4m reduced from the council's total budget. There are concerns the reduction could mean higher social housing rents and rates on local businesses. Fianna Fáil Councillor Michael Clark voted for a full 15pc reduction as 'homeowners already pay more than their fair share'. 'A modest house in this county can have a higher nominal value than a huge house in a rural area and is taxed accordingly. 'Most of these are family homes, not assets to be flipped, they cannot be easily monetised. 'These are families who might be property rich and cash poor. The tax is a burden on our citizens, we cannot penalise people in the middle of a cost-of-living crisis.' The proposal also found the support of Fine Gael, People Before Profit (PBP), and some independent councillors. The Green Party, who supported maintaining the base rate, called the 15pc reduction 'tokenistic'. ADVERTISEMENT A spokesperson from the party called out the councillors who agreed on the lowest possible amount of LPT, despite warnings from the Council Executive that it will impact essential public services. Robert Jones, Green Party councillor for Dundrum, said: 'Fine Gael, Fianna Fáil, PBP and Independents have just blown a €10m hole in our council budget for 2026. 'We need to be honest with people. A 15pc cut in the Local Property Tax saves the average homeowner one to two euro a week. 'But the cost is far greater – footpaths go unmaintained, playgrounds don't get repaired, and community services suffer. 'Council management have been crystal clear that costs are rising. 'This 15pc benefits those who don't need it, the average homeowner saves a euro or two a week, while renters get nothing. 'Institutions and landlords pocket tens of thousands – this is not a policy, it's a handout. By cutting the LPT, we're simply shifting the burden. 'Instead of a modest broad-based tax on wealth, Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil will now be looking at increasing social housing rents, civic centre fees and rates on local businesses.' PBP councillor Dave O'Keeffe, who also supported the 15pc cut, said he was 'reluctant to get behind the motion based on the people who have put it forward'. 'The parties in government who can't provide affordable housing, rent or social housing have created the situation we are in today,' he said. 'They've now put us in the position of choosing between increasing rent for social housing tenants or increasing property tax. 'The numbers might seem small, but they are only small if you can afford it. I've met families who had to make the decision to turn the heating on or not in winter. 'Five or €10 can mean a lot to them, so I can't get behind raising the tax.' Funded by the Local Democracy Reporting Scheme
