Man jailed for arson of two cars and a house in which the owners were sleeping
Seán Byrne, of Cushlawn Way, Tallaght, who was intoxicated and said he couldn't remember the incident, pleaded guilty at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court to damaging the two cars and the house by fire on October 20, 2023. He did not know the owners.
The court heard that Gardaí were called to a car on fire in a driveway in Tyrconnell, Inchicore at 3.15am on the morning in question. The owner woke to a loud bang, looked out his window and saw his car on fire.
A neighbour's CCTV footage showed a man entering and exiting the car and Gardaí recognised Byrne from the footage.
Judge Orla Crowe was told that Byrne was seen getting into the first car for a few seconds before getting out, and that shortly after that, it went on fire. It was unclear how he started the blaze. The other car then caught fire, and the front of house sustained heat damage from the two fires.
The court heard that the cars, which belonged to a couple who lived in the house, were both written off. Their house insurance paid out more than €21,000 for heat damage to the front of the property.
The court heard that when Gardaí came upon Byrne later, he was highly intoxicated and gave a false name. They seized two backpacks and a bicycle that he was seen using in the footage.
When he was sober, Gardaí found him pleasant and easy to deal with, and his condition had drastically improved since, the court heard. He has more than 70 previous convictions.
Defence barrister, John Griffin BL, said that his client had no recollection of or explanation for the incident, which showed no planning or sophistication.
'It was a matter that went wrong,' he said. 'It could have gone much more wrong.'
Counsel said that his client had suffered from drug and alcohol abuse for most of his life and used to steal food from shops and sell it to feed a heroin addiction. He has spent a lot of his life in and out of prison.
'He does very well in prison. He comes out a very fresh, healthy man,' defence counsel said, explaining that Byrne had purposely gone into custody following this offence in order to come clean.
'Thankfully nobody was hurt, be it because the people were alert or thanks to the fire brigade,' he said.
Judge Crowe described it as a very unusual case, in which no accelerant was used.
She imposed a sentence of four and a half years, but suspended the final nine months for two years, provided Byrne engage with the probation service after his release.
Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
5 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Teen born in prison learns fate after stealing €360 worth of clothes
A youth described as 'failed by the State' – born in prison, predisposed to addiction from infancy, and having spent his life in care – has been spared a custodial sentence for theft. The harrowing background was revealed when the now 18-year-old pleaded guilty to stealing €360 worth of clothes from a sportswear outlet in Tallaght, Dublin, on November 24 last. He cannot be named because he was 17 at the time of the offence and a juvenile when charged. At the Dublin Children's Court sentence hearing, Martin Dwan BL, defending, referred to the contents of a pre-sentence probation report and another from his guardian ad litem (GAL), a specialist appointed by a court to represent the best interests of a child in legal proceedings. Counsel detailed the teen's background, telling Judge Brendan Toale that the youth had been born in prison because his mother had been in custody and had serious addiction issues. He was also born with foetal alcoholism, and Mr Dwan emphasised the youth's "tragic start in life", likening it to a "heavy millstone around his neck". From infancy, he was in care, but at the age of six, he was placed in a foster home with a family, remaining there for a decade, where he had "stability and a good nurturing life". However, the youth was "taken out" of that placement and later relocated to care homes around the country, lacking parental guidance. The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week Mr Dwan quoted another judge, who dealt with one of the youth's earlier cases, that he was "absolutely failed by the State in that regard". An eleventh-hour GAL report was drafted when he turned 18 and reached adulthood, as Tusla implemented an aftercare plan. The youth listened intently but did not address the proceedings. The court heard that due to his mother's drinking problems, the teen was predisposed to addiction. Mr Dwan elaborated about how the teen went on to attend child and adolescent mental health services with issues including PTSD. The court heard that some problems coincided with the ending of his long-term foster placement; the teenager connected with his family and started to come to garda attention, while abusing alcohol and drugs, which he had a predisposition to from birth. At one stage, the substance abuse induced psychosis, resulting in the teen being hospitalised. Judge Toale noted the pre-sentence report assessed the young man as being at moderate risk of reoffending. He also noted the contents of the GAL report and what he termed the "extraordinary background" to the case, and placed the teenager on supervised probation for six months. During that time, he must not reoffend and must comply with the directions of his probation officer to divert him from further offending; otherwise, the case could be reopened and a harsher penalty considered. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
Irish Examiner
5 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Two of three men who appealed jail terms for carrying weapons as part of ongoing feud have sentences upheld
A claw-hammer, a hurley, a slash-hook handle and three sledgehammer handles were seized by Mallow gardaí in the investigation of a feud between two families which 'sullies the name of Mallow and frightens members of the public'. Three men who were prosecuted for having this stash of weapons in a car on March 18, 2023, appealed against jail terms imposed on them at Mallow District Court. However, the sentences were affirmed, with the exception of one man having the last month of his sentence suspended. Detective Garda David Forsythe said at Cork Circuit Appeals Court on Tuesday that gardaí received an anonymous call from a concerned member of the public that members of the O'Brien family in Doneraile were on their way at lunchtime that day as part of a planned attack on the home of the O'Flaherty family on Connolly Road in Mallow. Gardaí intercepted an orange BMW being driven towards River Valley, Mallow, Co Cork, and because of a smell of cannabis they indicated personal searches together with a search of the car were going to be carried out. The five occupants of the car cooperated, as weapons, including the hammer, hurley and implement handles, were found in the car. Det Garda Forsythe said there was no sign of the feud between the families abating and recently the conflict broke out in a physical altercation at Mallow courthouse, which disrupted court proceedings for a period and spilled out on the street. 'From a Garda point of view, it is quite time-consuming trying to keep a lid on these things. It is quite serious for people living in Mallow — it sullies the name of Mallow and frightens members of the public. 'Gardaí received a call that day that members of the O'Brien family in Doneraile were going to launch an attack on the O'Flaherty family in Mallow. 'The evidence is that it is still ongoing,' Det Garda Forsythe testified on Tuesday. Barristers Brian Leahy and Liam M O'Brien asked for the sentences to be suspended or community service orders imposed instead of the jail terms, stressing there was no evidence against them causing any damage to the O'Flahertys' property and that their only offence was of being in possession of the implements. However, Judge Boyle affirmed the six-month sentences under appeal by 37-year-old Kevin O'Brien and 49-year-old Richard O'Brien — both of Ballydineen halting site, Doneraile, Co Cork. In respect of the five-month sentence appealed by 21-year-old Kevin Barry, of Inchnagree, Buttevant, Co Cork, Judge Boyle suspended the last month of the sentence. All three appellants were then taken into custody to commence their sentences on the single charge of possession of the weapons on the day in March 2023.
Irish Daily Mirror
6 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Three people hospitalised with serious injuries following horror two-car crash
Three people have been rushed to hospital with serious injuries following a two-vehicle road traffic collision in Co Antrim. The Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) received a report that a Seat Arona and Honda Civic were involved in a collision near the Ardmore Park junction in the Finaghy Road North area of south Belfast at approximately 1.30pm on Monday afternoon. The driver of the Honda Civic, a man in his 30s, was injured in the collision, as was the other driver, aged in his 70s, and his passenger, a woman in her late 60s. The emergency services were called to the scene and all three individuals were taken to hospital for treatment for their injuries which, at this time, are serious but not believed to be life-threatening. The PSNI has said it is trying to establish "the circumstances leading up to this collision" and is appealing to anyone with any information to contact them. A PSNI spokesperson said: "Police are investigating the circumstances surrounding a two-vehicle serious collision in the Finaghy Road North area of south Belfast on Monday afternoon, 14th July. "Around 1.30pm, it was reported that a Seat Arona and Honda Civic were in collision near the Ardmore Park junction. "We are investigating the circumstances leading up to this collision in this residential area. We would appeal to anyone who was in the area, who may have witnessed this or the events leading up to it, to contact us. We are particularly keen to speak to the driver of a third car, possibly white in colour, seen in the area at the time of the collision. "Any dash-cam or doorbell footage covering Finaghy Road North or the surrounding area would also be useful to our enquiries.' The number to call is 101, quoting reference number 850 of 14/07/25. You can also make a report online here. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here. The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week
