logo
It's not often world leaders display personal frailties the way Rachel Reeves and Keir Starmer did

It's not often world leaders display personal frailties the way Rachel Reeves and Keir Starmer did

Irish Times21 hours ago
A chancellor in tears. A prime minister talking openly about the great pressures of his job. It is hard to think of another time when two top leaders of a
G7
country put
their personal frailties on display
in the way the
UK's
Rachel Reeves
and
Keir Starmer
did this week.
Reeves did so unwillingly, in the painful glare of the
House of Commons
, where she struggled to contain her all too visible distress over something that, at the time of writing, remains a mystery.
Starmer was more controlled, telling weekend newspaper interviewers his recent bouts of political havoc came as he was facing the
firebombing of his London family home
,
Iran
missile strikes and a G7 meeting in
Canada
within days of a
Nato
summit in
The Hague
.
Both cases say much about our complicated and often contradictory responses to a leader who shows vulnerability.
READ MORE
It has long been conventional wisdom that a boss who is prepared to reveal fear, uncertainty or some other form of uselessness is in luck.
It's thought they will be more trusted and respected, especially by younger staff who are said to yearn for 'authenticity', and are therefore more valuable to an organisation.
It helps that some of the world's best known corporate leaders have endorsed this idea. 'I think one of the perhaps most undervalued characteristics of leadership is vulnerability and asking for help,' former
Starbucks
boss
Howard Schultz
told an interviewer in 2017.
When former Expedia chief executive, Dara Khosrowshahi,
left the travel group to run Uber
, he was lauded for telling Expedia staff he was 'scared' about making the move.
There is indeed research suggesting it pays to impart inner wobbles. Yet if it really were obvious, why does the evidence suggest relatively few leaders are willing to own up to any form of weakness?
When author Jacob Morgan surveyed 14,000 employees around the world for his 2023 book Leading With Vulnerability, he asked how many of their bosses showed the qualities of a vulnerable leader.
Only 16 per cent said their leaders had done anything like asking for help, admitting to mucking up or revealing genuine feelings.
I suspect this is because, as with so much else in working life, context is all.
There are times when a leader who reveals any form of feebleness will be penalised, like Starmer has been this week.
As a
BBC
interviewer asked one of the prime minister's allies on Wednesday: 'Don't you think he's coming across as terribly weak?'
Starmer's problem was timing.
Signs of vulnerability can look like damage control, or an excuse, if they come after a leader is already in trouble rather than before.
Chief executives who ignore this lesson risk being less appealing to investors, according to a recent paper by academics in the United States.
They did a series of experiments to see how people reacted after reading an interview with a fictional tech chief executive before an earnings forecast.
In some interviews, the CEO said that although he was good at public speaking: 'When I make a speech, I frequently get nervous – my mouth gets dry, and my hands get sweaty.'
In others, he said: 'I'm good at public speaking, and when I make a speech I'm never nervous.'
It turned out that if the more vulnerable version of the CEO issued good financial news, people were more inclined to find the forecast credible and rate the company an attractive investment.
[
'Worst of any prime minister': Ten moments that defined Labour's first year in power in the UK
Opens in new window
]
If he had bad news, it went down badly. But the response was softened if the CEO appeared more vulnerable.
Crucially, this softer reaction only came when the boss showed signs of vulnerability before the bad news, not afterwards.
This makes sense, and I suspect it explains at least part of the reaction to Starmer this week.
Things are more complicated when it comes to Reeves, and not just because there was an actual market sell-off after Starmer initially failed to back his tearful chancellor, prompting investor fears she would be sacked.
Her wrenching display of distress also came after the bad news of a party rebellion over reforms she had strongly backed. But no one witnessing the harrowing images of her anguish could imagine they were anything but genuine. We live in an age when emotional honesty is rare and valued, even if, as Reeves has shown, it can also be jolting to watch. – Copyright the Financial Times Limited 2025
How the wealthy are buying up land to avoid inheritance tax
Listen |
22:03
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Macron to begin three-day state visit to the UK
Macron to begin three-day state visit to the UK

RTÉ News​

time3 hours ago

  • RTÉ News​

Macron to begin three-day state visit to the UK

French President Emmanuel Macron is due to address both houses of the British parliament later today, as he begins a three-day state visit to the UK. Flight restrictions and road closures will be in place around Windsor Castle, where Emmanuel Macron and his wife Brigitte will be staying until Thursday. It is the first state visit afforded by the UK to a French President since 2008, when Nicolas Sarkozy was invited by the late Queen Elizabeth. Relations between both countries had soured during Brexit but British Prime Minister Keir Starmer has sought to improve the UK-France relationship since coming to power just over a year ago. Both countries have led European efforts to provide security guarantees for Ukraine, should a peace deal be brokered. The effort has been described by the British side as a "coalition of the willing". A meeting of the coalition is due to take place later this week, while Mr Macron is in London. Mr Starmer has also stressed the importance of working closely with France as his government tries to reduce illegal boat crossings. It is hoped progress on this issue can be made during the state visit, with both countries understood to be discussing a "one in, one out" policy which would see deportation of illegal immigrants to France in return for people who have the right to be in the UK. Home Secretary Yvette Cooper has said that France will be introducing new tactics to stop boats that are already in the water. Today, Mr Macron will address both the House of Commons and Lords at Westminster. There will also be a focus on royal events today, which will include a ceremonial welcome at Windsor Castle and state banquet. The three-day visit will culminate in a UK-France Summit on Thursday. Mr Macron's state visit comes before that of US President Donald Trump, which is not scheduled to happen until later this year.

Government fears referendum to give Irish diaspora vote in presidential elections ‘could be lost'
Government fears referendum to give Irish diaspora vote in presidential elections ‘could be lost'

Irish Times

time10 hours ago

  • Irish Times

Government fears referendum to give Irish diaspora vote in presidential elections ‘could be lost'

There is a significant concern that the Government could lose a referendum to extend the vote in presidential elections to Irish citizens living abroad, the Minister of State for Diaspora has said. Neale Richmond said he was personally in favour of giving the right to vote in presidential elections to the Irish diaspora 'anywhere ... if they are entitled to Irish citizenship'. He said it should not just be limited to Irish citizens living in Northern Ireland . [ Should people in Northern Ireland vote in Irish presidential elections? Opens in new window ] 'It is my personal opinion, my party's policy and it is the Government's policy that we will introduce voting for the Irish abroad for presidential elections,' said the Fine Gael TD during a visit to London. READ MORE Mr Richmond noted the Government recently accepted an opposition Dáil motion on the issue. 'But it's a tricky debate,' he said. However, he complained of 'deliberate disinformation from the commentariat', which he suggested had misled some to believe that extending presidential votes could also bring into play voting for the Oireachtas or local councils. He said there is a 'major concern' a poll on giving the diaspora votes for the presidency could be defeated 'if we hold this referendum without a proper debate, without a proper consultation and without letting people know what this means'. In response to the suggestion that there was relative political unanimity on the issue, he said: 'We had relative unanimity on the last two referendums [held last year on expanding the definition of the family and on references to a woman's place in the home] and we lost those spectacularly badly.' The Dublin Rathdown TD said he was not trying to be a 'killjoy' on the issue. 'But as a politician, I don't want to run a referendum and lose it because then you can't have another referendum on this issue for a generation.' Why does Ireland's presidential race still have no one at the starting line? Listen | 42:06 The Minister was speaking at the Irish Embassy in London at the launch of the Global Irish Survey, a Government survey of the diaspora that is available at and will run until the end of August. He said the Government wanted to canvass the views of Irish people living abroad before formulating a new strategy for the diaspora; the existing five-year strategy runs out at the end of the year. Mr Richmond said he hoped a new strategy would be in place by next April. In addition to maintaining connections with people who had recently left the Republic, he said it would also seek to 'go deeper' with second, third and fourth generation descendants. In addition to launching the survey, he was also due to hold talks with Jenny Chapman, the British Labour government's development minister.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store