logo
Furious India eyes response to Pakistan after Kashmir attack

Furious India eyes response to Pakistan after Kashmir attack

France 2424-04-2025
New Delhi suspended a water-sharing treaty, announced the closure of the main land border crossing with Pakistan, downgraded diplomatic ties and withdrew visas for Pakistanis on Wednesday night, just over 24 hours after gunmen killed 26 men in Indian-administered Kashmir.
And then on Thursday, New Delhi said it had suspended visas services "with immediate effect" and ordered all Pakistani nationals to leave the country, with the exception of remaining diplomats.
Experts say that a military response may still be in the pipeline, with some speculating that a response may come within days while others say weeks.
New Delhi accuses Islamabad of supporting "cross-border terrorism" -- claims Pakistan denies -- and police in Kashmir identified two Pakistani nationals among the three alleged gunmen.
India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi vowed on Thursday to punish all those responsible "to the ends of the Earth".
Relations between the nuclear-armed neighbours have sunk to their lowest level in years and some fear New Delhi's diplomatic moves may just be an opening salvo.
"This attack is going to take... relations a long way back to the dark days," said International Crisis Group analyst Praveen Donthi.
"Given the Narendra Modi government's security approach, they might resort to kinetic (military) measures in the next couple of weeks, because they believe in projecting a strong security state."
Pakistan held a rare national security meeting on Thursday after New Delhi's punitive diplomatic measures.
'Escalation'
The killings have shocked India because they were a dramatic shift targeting civilians and the area's vital tourism industry, rather than more common smaller-scale attacks against Indian security forces.
Hindu pilgrims have been targeted in the past, but direct attacks on the tourist trade that underpins much of the local economy are much rarer.
"A major attack in a tourist area does constitute a break from the past," said Ajai Sahni, a counter-terrorism expert at the New Delhi-based Institute for Conflict Management.
Sahni suggested there had been "an unwritten contract" not to attack the general tourism trade "because virtually everyone" in Kashmir is directly or indirectly dependent on tourism.
For New Delhi, the 3.5 million tourists who it says visited Kashmir in 2024 -- mostly domestic visitors -- illustrated what officials called "normalcy and peace" returning to the troubled region after a massive crackdown in 2019.
"One of the reasons this attack might have happened is because the government started linking the numbers of tourists... to this narrative of normalcy," Donthi said.
"The militants finally changed their attack. Usually, they don't attack tourists and civilians... And this is going to mark an escalation in the conflict."
The 2019 crackdown followed Modi's decision to cancel Kashmir's partial autonomy and impose direct control from New Delhi.
US-based analyst Michael Kugelman said he believed the shift meant India would therefore also likely respond with military force.
"I would argue that the combination of the scale of this attack as well as the targeting -- the fact that civilians were hit -- that suggests to me that there is a strong likelihood of some type of Indian military retaliation," he said.
"I don't necessarily think that such a response would come quickly. I suspect that New Delhi will want to take some time, some days to review a range of possible retaliations."
'Covert options available'
India has taken its time to respond to past attacks.
The worst attack in recent years in Indian-run Kashmir was at Pulwama in 2019, when insurgents rammed a car packed with explosives into a police convoy, killing 40 and wounding 35.
Indian fighter jets carried out air strikes on Pakistani territory 12 days later, a raid that came against the backdrop of campaigning for India's general elections.
Action taken by India so far is limited.
The now-suspended Indus Water Treaty shares critical water between the two countries -- but is more a paper agreement and India has no major means of restricting flow downstream to Pakistan.
The closure of the border crossing at the Attari-Wagah frontier is also significant, although there are rarely large numbers who cross.
The border crossing hosts a hugely popular evening ritual, where crowds gather to cheer on soldiers as they goose-step in a chest-puffing theatrical show that has largely endured through innumerable diplomatic flare-ups.
Sahni said any potential military response was "ill-advised".
"There have been military responses in the past," he said.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Modi pushes further India-Africa cooperation on Ghana visit
Modi pushes further India-Africa cooperation on Ghana visit

France 24

time14 hours ago

  • France 24

Modi pushes further India-Africa cooperation on Ghana visit

In a speech to Ghana's parliament, Modi highlighted a major rail project that opened in the west African nation last year, financed by the India Export-Import Bank. He also underlined his country's expanding diplomatic development and business footprint in Africa. "Over 200 projects across the continent enhance connectivity, infrastructure and Industrial capacity," Modi said. On the political front he welcomed "the establishment of Ghana-India Parliamentary Friendship Society in your parliament". Modi's visit is the first to Ghana by an Indian leader in three decades. But India's rival China remains the most important backer of infrastructure across the continent, a position only strengthened as the United States and other Western powers slash aid programmes. In a meeting Wednesday, Modi and Ghanaian President John Mahama agreed to deepen security and mining ties. In November 2024, the Indian prime minister visited Nigeria, discussing trade and security at a time when Indian companies had expressed interest in investing in Nigerian industries including steel. The Indian prime minister also on Thursday called for a greater global diplomatic role for both his country and Africa, warning that "the world order created after the Second World War is changing fast". Global South's voice Modi noted that the African Union had been admitted as a permanent member to the G20 while India held the rotating presidency of the bloc. Progress on worldwide challenges including climate change, diplomacy, "terrorism" and pandemics "cannot come without giving voice to the Global South", he added. India, the world's most populous country and a nuclear-armed power, has close ties with Russia but is often in rivalry with China. Resource-rich Ghana is Modi's first stop in a tour that will take the Indian premier to four other countries in Africa, the Caribbean and South America. The visit to Accra came as he made his way to Brazil for a summit of the BRICS group of emerging economies on Sunday and Monday. Highlighting his own country's economic development aspirations to become a "developed nation by 2047," Modi said "India remains a committed partner in Africa's development journey." © 2025 AFP

IMEC: Can the ambitious trade corridor from India to Europe succeed?
IMEC: Can the ambitious trade corridor from India to Europe succeed?

Euronews

time18 hours ago

  • Euronews

IMEC: Can the ambitious trade corridor from India to Europe succeed?

The India-Middle East-Europe Economic Corridor (IMEC) is one of the most ambitious modern connectivity initiatives. It aims to create a modern transport and trade corridor linking India to Europe through the Middle East, leveraging ports, rail networks, highways and digital infrastructure. The project aspires to reshape global trade maps, offer alternatives beyond the Suez Canal, and enhance Europe's energy and supply security. For Greece, IMEC represents an opportunity to upgrade its role as a key gateway to Europe. Greek ports, particularly Piraeus and Thessaloniki, have the potential to become key centres for transferring goods and distributing them further into Europe. At the same time, Greece can act as an energy hub, contributing to the diversification of energy sources and supply routes. However, IMEC also faces significant challenges: geopolitical tensions, competition from other trade routes and countries, the need for large infrastructure investment and policy coordination. These challenges were discussed in detail at the event titled 'IMEC from potential to partnership,' held by the Balkans & Black Sea Forum "Executive Roundtable 2025," with the participation of ambassadors from the involved countries, analysts, experts, and industry stakeholders. The main conclusions are: The IMEC Corridor needs clear guidance and funding. The project started as an Indian initiative, which was then embraced by the EU and Saudi Arabia. However, unlike other similar initiatives, India has not set up a specific implementing body for the project, nor has it committed funds. Most speakers agreed that the projects will need to be funded through India-EU partnerships, and that the contribution of Saudi Arabia and the US will be crucial. The US is generally positive about the project but sees it as part of a larger strategic framework related to the implementation of the Abraham Accords. As the speakers pointed out, it is unlikely that India, mainly due to a different mindset, will commit funds and establish a mechanism for the implementation of the IMEC, as China did for the 'Belt and Road' Initiative. The Indian government emphasises that countries themselves must adopt the project and develop national plans for its implementation. The corridor will require coordination in the development and operation of the necessary infrastructure. The project is easier for the ports, but for the railway, there are many challenges. For example, there is a need to secure investment funding, build the necessary railway lines (some of which cross regions with significant geopolitical instability), establish a customs union, and set up a dedicated sales office. As one of the speakers said: "Every corridor is only as strong as its weakest point." For Greece, the big challenge is the port of Piraeus. Greece is trying to emerge as the main gateway of the Corridor to Europe (competing with Italy and France). However, the fact that the port of Piraeus is managed by a Chinese company raises questions about how willing and able it will be to serve as the final point of the IMEC. Alternatively, as some speakers noted, the port of Thessaloniki could play this role. The second major challenge relates to the railway network, which is underdeveloped both within Greece and in its connections with neighbouring countries. As was emphasised, without a strong and interconnected railway network, the potential to fully utilise the IMEC is significantly limited. The military conflicts in the Middle East are 'freezing' plans for the Corridor's development. Although tensions have eased in the past 24 hours, the broader Middle East region remains an area of high tension and conflict, which raises questions as to whether and how the necessary infrastructure will be shielded. As for Cyprus, whose participation in the project was confirmed during the recent visit of Noreda Modi to Nicosia, it was noted that Cyprus could become a regional hub for managing administrative and operational issues, building on its experience in this field and its membership of the EU. And what will be the role of the Palestinians in this project? "The Palestinians should be part of the project," noted the speakers, for example with rail links to Jordan through the West Bank. However, such a prospect requires permanent peace in the region.

India Hindu pilgrimage begins in contested Kashmir
India Hindu pilgrimage begins in contested Kashmir

France 24

timea day ago

  • France 24

India Hindu pilgrimage begins in contested Kashmir

Last year, half a million devotees took part in the Amarnath pilgrimage to a sacred ice pillar located in a cave in the forested Himalayan hills above the town of Pahalgam. Pahalgam is the site of an April 22 militant attack during which gunmen killed 26 mostly Hindu tourists. New Delhi said the gunmen were backed by Pakistan, claims Islamabad rejected -- triggering a series of tit-for-tat diplomatic measures that escalated into a four-day conflict. It was the worst standoff by the nuclear-armed nations since 1999, with more than 70 people killed in missile, drone and artillery fire on both sides, before a May 10 ceasefire. But pilgrim Muneshwar Das Shashtri, who travelled from Uttar Pradesh state, told AFP "there is no fear of any kind". "Our army is standing guard everywhere. No one can raise a finger towards us," he said. India has ramped up security for the event, deploying 45,000 troops with high-tech surveillance tools overseeing the gruelling trek to reach the high-altitude cave dedicated to the Hindu deity of destruction Shiva. "We have multi-layered and in-depth security arrangements so that we can make the pilgrimage safe and smooth for the devotees," said VK Birdi, police chief for the Muslim-majority territory. At Pahalgam, soldiers have turned a tented base camp into a fortress encircled by razor wire. Troops in newly deployed armoured cars, or from gun positions behind sandbags, keep a close watch -- efforts boosted by facial recognition cameras. "High-quality surveillance cameras have been installed at all major points along the route," said Manoj Sinha, the Indian-appointed top administrator for Jammu and Kashmir. All pilgrims must be registered and travel in guarded vehicle convoys, until they start out to walk. Camouflaged bunkers have been erected in the forests along the route, where dozens of makeshift kitchens provide free food. Electronic radio cards pinpoint their location. Pilgrims can take several days to reach the cave, perched at 3,900 metres (12,800 feet) high, around 30 kilometres (18 miles) uphill from the last easily motorable track. "Whatever the attack that was carried out here, I am not afraid. I have come to get a glimpse of baba (the ice formation)" said Ujwal Yadav, 29, from India's Uttar Pradesh state, undertaking his first pilgrimage to the shrine. "Such are the security arrangements here that no one can be hurt." Sinha has said that "public confidence is returning", but admits that pilgrim registration had dipped by 10 percent this year.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store