'Reductive perspective': Indian-origin woman who slammed Zohran Mamdani's glorification now calls Mira Nair 'Hinduphobic'
An Indian-origin Hindu woman, Indu Viswanathan, who found New York mayoral candidate
Zohran Mamdani
's glorification after his surprising primary win nauseating, said Mamdani's mother
Mira Nair
is Hinduphobic.
Viswanathan said in Nair's movies, the Hindu characters are riddled with prejudice and there is no exploration of Hindu identity or society in a complex or humanized way.
"If she's not flattening Hindu characters and the richness of Hindu philosophy, she's erasing Hindu perspectives and voices entirely. When she speaks publicly, she reflects the same reductive perspectives on Hindus and Hinduism," she wrote.
"Hindu characters in her films often play roles of gatekeepers of patriarchy, bigotry, or repression, while liberation is shown through Western ideals or rejection of Hindu norms.
Her films rarely feature devout or joyful Hindu spiritual life, nor showcase the diversity or depth of Hindu theology," the post read.
Earlier, Vishwanathan accused Mamdani of distorting facts, manipulating identity politics and cited his statement that there are no more Muslims left in Gujarat, as an example. "Mamdani's lie isn't accidental or something that can be dismissed. It is central to the larger fabrication of his own victimhood status in the world," she said adding that there are over 7 million Muslims in Gujarat.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
40분 후, 영어가 다르게 보일 겁니다. 직접 확인해보세요
스티븐영어
지금 시작하기
Undo
"And if he's willing to erase 7 million members of his own community of Gujarati Muslims for political expediency in New York, what does that mean for 200,000 Hindus living in New York? What does it mean for the 5 million Jews living here? Shouldn't we all be concerned when a public figure casually erases entire communities to score rhetorical points?" she wrote.
Since the election and after Andrew Cuomo conceded the election to Mamdani, Mamdani has been at the center of many racial, political attacks. Republicans called for deporting him as he became a US citizen only in 2018. Mamdani also drew flak for identifying himself as Black in the application form of Columbia University, where he didn't get the chance to study.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
28 minutes ago
- News18
Beyond Being Mira Nair's Son, How Zohran Mamdani Is Enticing Asians: Bangla, Chai & Filmy Drama
Zohran Mamdani, the Indian-origin Democratic nominee running for mayor of NYC, has been hogging headlines for a while now. If elected, Mamdani will become the first Muslim and South Asian mayor of New York City. Embracing his roots, Mamdani has actively incorporated cultural elements into his campaign, using Urdu and Bengali in outreach efforts and even donning a traditional South Asian kurta during public appearances. Appealing to the Indian community in New York City, Zohran Mamdani's campaign leaned heavily into music, imagery and emotions of Indian films to connect with them. In one of his most talked-about campaign videos, the politician was seen recreating a scene from Amitabh Bachchan's 1975 film Deewar. 'Aaj mere paas buildingein hai, property hai, bangla hai, bank balance hai, gaadi hai. Tumhare paas kya hai?" The video shows the Bollywood superstar's iconic dialogue, further cutting to Mamdani, who imitates Shah Rukh Khan's signature pose and says, 'Aap."
Time of India
32 minutes ago
- Time of India
Shocking poll shows majority of Canadians now see America as a threat
More Canadians than ever before now view the United States as a top threat to their country, even as many still consider it Canada 's most important ally. A new global survey by the Pew Research Center shows 59 percent of Canadians believe the US poses a threat, up sharply from just 20 percent in 2019. At the same time, 55 percent still call the US their closest ally, highlighting the complicated emotions many Canadians feel about their powerful neighbor to the south. 'Canada stands out. The change in views toward the US here has been significant,' said Janell Fetterolf, senior researcher at Pew. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Build Your Dream Villa Near Bengaluru Airport Sumadhura Group Learn More Undo With US President Donald Trump pushing new tariffs and hinting at annexation rhetoric, even suggesting Canada could become a US state, Canadians are feeling uneasy. Economic friction and fear Live Events Canada was an early target of Trump's aggressive trade tactics. He imposed steel and aluminum tariffs tied to fentanyl trafficking concerns in March, then rolled them back days later for goods meeting the Canada-US-Mexico Agreement (CUSMA) terms. He also floated massive tariffs on copper (50 percent) and pharmaceuticals (200 percent). A July 21 deadline looms for finalizing a new Canada-US economic and security agreement. If no deal is reached, Ottawa has warned it will respond with counter-tariffs, possibly hitting the auto sector, a move the Canadian Automotive Parts Manufacturers' Association strongly opposes. 'Counter-tariffs hurt Canadian jobs too,' the association said in a statement. Views shift across the globe Pew's study, conducted across 24 countries from January to April, shows the US was labeled a top economic threat by many. Russia was named the top security threat in Europe, while China was seen as both across the Asia-Pacific region. In Canada, 75 percent said the US is an economic threat, and 53 percent said it's a national security threat. Meanwhile, Americans remain largely positive about Canada, with 74 percent holding a favorable view, according to a separate Pew poll conducted in March. What's next? Prime Minister Mark Carney has walked a diplomatic tightrope. He's emphasized trade diversification, increased defense spending to reassure allies, and avoided confrontation with Trump at last month's G7 summit in Calgary. Canada and the US share the world's longest border, deep economic ties, and cultural connections, but more Canadians now wonder if a best friend can also be a threat.
Economic Times
35 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Bharat Bandh News Updates: All India strike today, public services likely to hit as over 25 crore workers may participate
09 Jul 2025 | 06:41:34 AM IST Bharat Bandh Live Updates: More than 25 crore workers engaged in sectors ranging from banking, insurance, postal to coal mining, highway and construction are expected to go on a nationwide general strike on Wednesday, potentially disrupting services across the country. A forum of 10 central trade unions and their associates has called for a general strike or 'Bharat Bandh' to "oppose the anti-worker, anti-farmer and anti-national pro-corporate policies of the government".In a statement, the forum has called for making "the nationwide general strike a grand success", and said preparations have been taken up in earnest by unions in all sectors of formal and informal/unorganised economy."More than 25 crore workers are expected to take part in the strike. Farmers and rural workers will also join the protest across the country," said Amarjeet Kaur from All India Trade Union Singh Sidhu from Hind Mazdoor Sabha said that banking, postal, coal mining, factories, state transport services will be affected due to the forum had last year submitted a charter of 17-point demand to Labour Minister Mansukh Mandavia, the workers' union forum said in its latest further said that the government has not been conducting the annual labour conference for the last 10 years and continues to take decisions in contravention to the interest of labour force, attempting to impose four labour codes to weaken collective bargaining, to cripple unions' activities and to favour employers in the name of 'ease of doing business'.The forum also alleged that the economic policies are resulting into more unemployment, rising prices of essential commodities, depression in wages, cut in social sector spending in education, health, basic civic amenities, and all these are leading to more inequalities and miseries for poor, people of lower income group as well as the middle government has abandoned the welfare state status of the country and is working in the interest of foreign and Indian corporates, and it is so evident from its policies being pursued vigorously, the forum unions have been fighting against "privatisation of public sector enterprises and public services, policies of outsourcing, contractorisation and casualisation of workforce", it four labour codes that have been passed by the Parliament are meant to suppress and cripple the trade union movement, increase working hours, snatch workers' right to collective bargaining, right to strike, and decriminalise violation of labour laws by employers, the statement said. Show more
