Finance Minister Nicola Willis wants answers over high butter price
Finance Minister Nicola Willis will be asking dairy giant Fonterra about the high retail price of butter in New Zealand.
Willis told RNZ's First Up programme this morning it didn't seem quite right that butter seemed to be cheaper in Australian supermarkets.
The price of a block of butter is now 120% higher than it was a decade ago, according to Stats NZ. In the year to June, it was up 46.5% to $8.60 for a 500g block.
At her regular meeting with the co-operative this week she would be discussing what gets added to the cost by retail brands, including Fonterra's Anchor, and at the wholesale level.
Finance Minister Nicola Willis. Photo: RNZ
"My frustration has been when you sometimes go on to an Australian supermarket website and see that butter appears to be cheaper there than in New Zealand, that doesn't seem quite right. So that's exactly the conversation I want to have.
"They'll have the opportunity to set out their case."
It was well understood the main driver of prices for dairy products was international demand and pricing, Willis said.
"But competition at the retail level does seem to have an effect on price, because organisations like Costco choose to have a really low price point on that product to get people in the door and the ultimate winner of all of that is the Kiwi shopper.
"So I'm talking to Fonterra about what they're seeing in terms of the supermarket pricing behaviour, what the margins are."
In May, Costco Auckland's special pricing saw queues out the door.
Federated Farmers dairy chair Karl Dean has urged retailers to lower prices quickly when costs go down, and said there was probably very little Fonterra itself could do.
"To put in it in perspective, there hasn't been any new players onto the domestic market in the last 10 years in terms of butter, other than the likes of Westgold - Westland have got their very premium product," he told RNZ's Morning Report programme last week.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
an hour ago
- NZ Herald
Listen to The Country online: Christopher Luxon on butter prices, Pāmu, and Chris Hipkins
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon spoke to Jamie Mackay today on The Country. Photo / Mark Mitchell Listening to articles is free for open-access content—explore other articles or learn more about text-to-speech. Already a subscriber? Sign in here Access to Herald Premium articles require a Premium subscription. Subscribe now to listen. Listen to The Country online: Christopher Luxon on butter prices, Pāmu, and Chris Hipkins Prime Minister Christopher Luxon spoke to Jamie Mackay today on The Country. Photo / Mark Mitchell Today on The Country radio show, host Jamie Mackay catches up with Prime Minister Christopher Luxon to talk about butter prices, Fonterra, Pāmu, local councils and 'frickin' Chris Hipkins. On with the show: Christopher Luxon: Is Nicola Willis (and the government by default) guilty of virtue signalling and political posturing, and was Willis sent on a fool's errand to Fonterra? The government can't do anything about the price of butter and cheese (without subsidies), but what can it do to kneecap spendthrift local body councils?
NZ Herald
2 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Red Meat Sector Conference: Exports up $1.2b despite livestock supply concerns
The latest figures from Stats NZ showed the national sheep flock and deer herd were continuing to decline. Industry group Beef + Lamb New Zealand chairwoman Kate Acland told the event that carbon farming on productive land under the Emissions Trading Scheme was driving the significant reduction in livestock numbers. 'New Zealand currently faces over-capacity in the processing industry,' Acland said. 'We have more plants and more processing lines than we have livestock to sustain them efficiently, and it risks getting worse. 'The drop in stock numbers represents a lost opportunity. We owe it to farmers to face this challenge head-on.' Acland said greater collaboration among competing companies was a sensible strategic approach. 'If we want a future-fit industry, we need to be bold about optimising capacity and about how we collaborate,' she said. 'The fall in stock numbers is particularly frustrating because at a time when there's strong demand globally and high export prices, our processors have not been able to capitalise on this. 'Our exports would have been hundreds of millions [of dollars] higher if the supply had been there.' The conference came during a time when the country's only farmer-owned red meat co-operative, Alliance Group, was preparing a case on private investment for its farmer-shareholders to vote on in the coming months. Alliance announced the decision to shut its historic Smithfield meat plant in Timaru in October, amid dropping livestock numbers, particularly breeding ewes, with 600 people losing their jobs. Farmers were getting record prices for beef; however, they were driven in part by good demand amid tighter supplies. Agriculture Minister Todd McClay speaking at the Red Meat Sector Conference in Christchurch on Tuesday. Photo / RNZ Furthermore, New Zealand imported a near-record volume of beef from Australia in June, as processors worked to secure greater volumes to match meat-plant capacity. Meanwhile, Minister for Agriculture and Trade and Investment Todd McClay said the Government was working to 'get Wellington out of farming' to enable primary sector growth and bring value back to the farm gate. 'We want to reduce regulation and cost on-farm,' McClay said. 'I reckon it's a great time to be a farmer in New Zealand at the moment. 'As there are challenges fronting up around the world, geopolitics, tariffs, protectionism, and so on, the world still needs high-quality, safe food. 'And you don't get higher quality of safer food anywhere in the world [than here], with a wonderful carbon footprint story to tell.' McClay said the Government invested in the $8 million Taste Pure Nature campaign with industry to strengthen red meat's position in China, to drive better returns for farmers and processors. Stats NZ figures show sheep numbers dropped 3% in 2024 to 23.6 million sheep, while deer numbers dropped 4% between 2023 and 2024 to 709,000. However, the beef boom has kept stock numbers relatively stable, rising 1% in the last year to 3.7 million beef cattle. – RNZ
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Cook Islands PM: ‘If we can't get help from NZ, we will go somewhere else'
By Teitimoana Tairi , Cook Islands News Cook Islands PM Mark Brown Photo: RNZ Pacific/ Lydia Lewis Cook Islands Prime Minister Mark Brown defended the nation's new strategic partnership with China, citing the need for diverse international partners to fund a $650 million infrastructure plan that New Zealand alone cannot support, despite NZ's concerns and paused funding. Brown made this comment on Monday (Tuesday NZT) while officially opening the 2025 Pa Enua Governance Forum, held at the USP Cook Islands Campus until Thursday. The Forum is attended by outer island leaders, who are in Rarotonga for the 2025 Te Maeva Nui festival and the Cook Islands' 60th self-governance anniversary in free association with New Zealand, running from 25 July to 5 August. Addressing the ongoing diplomatic row between the Cook Islands and New Zealand, Brown said: "Kua akaari mai a Nuti Reni e, to ratou manamanata, the main one is, kare oki tatou e uipaanga Kapiti ana kia atou, I mua ake tatou I rave teia koreromotu a tatou I sign ki te baseleia o Tnito (New Zealand shared their concerns with us, the main one is that we didn't discuss this partnership with New Zealand before signing the comprehensive strategic partnership with China) ." This has resulted in New Zealand pausing over $18m in core sector support funding, which targets key areas in the Cook Islands' annual budget. Brown said he was surprised to learn that New Zealand had signed an agreement with China similar to the Cook Islands' deal, which resulted in "$60 billion worth of trade" for New Zealand in exchange for relaxed visa entry requirements for Chinese visitors. According to the New Zealand Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade, exports to China total $20.85 billion, comprising $17.75b in goods and $3.1b in services (figures for the year ended December 2024). New Zealand Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and Foreign Minister Winston Peters will not attend the milestone event in Rarotonga, which will celebrate the Cook Islands' six decades of self-governance in free association with NZ. Photo: RNZ Pacific "There's not one dollar out of this koreromotu (signed partnership) a te Nuti Reni e te Tinito ka tae mai kia tatou," the Brown said. He said that last week, the Australian Prime Minister signed a partnership agreement with China, adding this agreement involves over $200b in annual exports to China and promotes Australia as a tourism destination for Chinese travellers. "Kare okotai meitaki I roto I teia koremotu e ka aere mai kia tatou (Nothing out of this partnership will benefit us), nothing, we have to do our own," Brown told Pa Enua mayors and council members. "… what we did (with China) was sign a friend work engagement in the areas that we would collaborate, and one of them was infrastructure development." Cook Islands Prime Minister Mark Brown defended the nation's new strategic partnership with China. Photo: LIU BIN According to Brown, the country's national infrastructure investment plan costs $650m for infrastructural work across the country, including buildings, transportation, and so on. "New Zealand can't afford to give us that amount of money…we have to develop our partnerships with other larger countries to get the support we need to meet our infrastructure needs," Brown said. "Let me set the record straight about the reality of life, we need to build our infrastructure, we need to improve our standards in the Pa Enua, me kare rauka mai ta te Nuti Reni (if we can't get help from New Zealand), we will go somewhere else and look for that help, and that's what we've been doing." Highlighting the significance of the 60th anniversary, Brown stated that in 1965 the Cook Islands had only one development partner, New Zealand. "Sixty years later, we have 70 development partners, with formal relations with over 70 countries, including all of the biggest countries, the biggest economies in the world today." The 2025 Pa Enua Governance Forum opened on Monday local time (Tuesday NZT), bringing together leaders from across the Pa Enua, government officials, outer island mayors, executive officers and other distinguished guests to discuss ways to strengthen the collaboration between Pa Enua and central governance. In her opening speech, Karopaerangi Ngatoko, the chief of staff at the Office of the Prime Minister, welcomed attendees with words of gratitude and purpose. "…your presence reflects the strength of your commitment to your islands and to our shared development journey," Ngatoko said, acknowledging the distance many had travelled to attend. "This is a working week, it is about progress about delivery and about impact. It is about building the bridge between planning and action - and ensuring that action delivers real outcomes for our Pa Enua." Under the theme, "Akatinamou'anga I te itiki'anga Ora" symbolising unity, collaboration and a shared goal, the Forum marks a significant moment in the Cook Islands journey, coinciding with the nations 60th anniversary of self-governance. Public Service Commissioner Carl Hunter urged integrity and action in the public sector. "We are public servants, servants of the public, not public owners," shared Hunter, highlighting the values that define the nation's public service. He emphasised impartiality, transparency, accountability and added hard work as a core principle, calling for service that puts people before self-interest. Hunter also acknowledged workforce challenges, especially in the Pa Enua, worsened by Covid-19 and ongoing out-of-migration. "In the Pa Enua, these effects have been compounded by long-standing challenges, including high living costs, limited employment opportunities and continued outmigration. These trends have resulted in the loss of skilled workers and have placed real strains on local services and community capacity." Hunter shared early steps in a National Workforce Development Plan and reaffirmed the government's commitment to deeper engagement with island communities through ongoing visits and partnership. Mayor of Atiu, Timaau Mokoroa, representing the Pa Enua, warmly welcomed all attendees and acknowledged the event. Mokoroa extended his gratitude to the Office of the Prime Minister for hosting such an important gathering, which provided a platform to address concerns, share ideas and discuss further improvements for a sustainable country. "I thank our Prime Minister at the moment of the day, for convening this important platform, not only as part of the celebration marking 60 years of self-governance, but more critically, as a space where the voices of our people, especially in the Pa Enua, can be heard. Our concerns acknowledged, and our collective aspirations discussed," he said. "May we move forward in unity, grounded in Christ. Together we carry the weight of our islands, our people, but together we can also carry the weight that leads us forward." -This article was first published by Cook Islands News .
