Timor-Leste's largest rubbish dump is causing a 'national' health problem
The smoke from burning waste gets so thick at Delfina Martin's home in Timor-Leste, she and her children struggle to breathe.
But she says it's not the only way the country's biggest rubbish dump — only 300 metres from her house — damages her family's health.
"During the rainy season the children have stomach aches, fever, gastroenteritis," she says.
"My mother also suffered from tuberculosis and was treated at the clinic, but in 2014 she died."
Rubbish from the capital Dili, home to about 300,000 people, is transported and dumped in the 23-hectare landfill, about 12 kilometres west of the city.
Unable to find another home, Ms Martin has lived near the rubbish dump in Tibar, a long-established residential area, for more than 30 years.
Flies come into her house from the rubbish dump, spoiling the family's food, she says.
Ms Martin is one of many residents who fear the rubbish dump is wrecking their health.
Her neighbour, Miranda Dos Santos, says the smoke from burning waste has weighed heavily on her.
"I have regular coughs, fevers and stomach pain, and then I contracted [tuberculosis]," she says.
"I underwent treatment at the clinic and took medication for six months."
Timor-Leste's government responded to residents' concerns by vowing in 2012 to relocate the rubbish dump.
But Ms Martin says despite the promise, nothing has happened.
"Hospital garbage is also thrown here, people do not bury anything," she says.
Waste disposal has been one of Timor-Leste's most visible problems.
With scant waste management infrastructure and services, it has mainly disposed of rubbish by dumping and burning at disposal sites, a 2023 analysis from the Secretariat of the Pacific Regional Environment Programme (SPREP) found.
SPREP's study also found no landfills or dump sites in Timor-Leste were up to "modern" standards of waste disposal that minimised their impacts on the environment.
Researchers found many households and businesses were illegally dumping and burning their waste.
Tibar's rubbish dump, which began operating in 1982, is the only controlled landfill in Timor-Leste. This means it is managed with some level of government oversight.
Still, the smell of waste there can be overwhelming, Ms Dos Santos says.
"Sometimes garbage from the trucks falls on the road, but [garbage collectors] are not interested in picking it up," she says.
More than 1,800 people have been treated for acute respiratory infections at the Tibar medical centre over the past year — at least 10 times the national rate.
Timor-Leste's National Director of Health covering the Tibar area, Manuel Albino, says the health impacts of the dump are a "national" problem.
"In terms of public health, the communities in Tibar are at severe risk from the garbage that comes from the capital," he says.
Mr Albino says along with acute respiratory infections like pneumonia, it has caused other common illnesses in the area including diarrhoea.
Nuno Vital Soares, Director of Timor-Leste's Laboratory National Hospital, says the high rates of illness in Tibar are undoubtedly because of substandard water and pollution from the dump.
"The water consumed can have a negative impact on pregnant women. It can be seen from the respiratory tract," he says.
"If the water is contaminated with some chemicals or microbes, there is no treatment for it properly, even if its percentage is small."
The Timor-Leste government says it is aware of the problems, and is trying to address them with new technology and waste disposal practices aiming to reduce contamination.
"Since 2022 until today, we have stopped burning garbage, started reducing the amount of waste," Domingos Godinho, Director of Water, Sanitation and Environment Services at Dili Municipality, says.
He says it uses a new system that prevents rubbish impacting the surrounding environment, including spreading a geomembrane — a large waterproof tarp — along the ground to stop rubbish from contaminating water and soaking into the soil.
But Mr Godinho says the government has abandoned the plan to relocate the rubbish dump because it is too expensive.
"The government saw the high cost and decided to still maintain the Tibar landfill. So now we deploy this big, new project."
But Tibar residents say last month, rubbish started burning once again at the rubbish dump.
Mr Godinho says "unknown people" had burnt waste at the site, but the government has reactivated security at the site to stop it.
"The government guarantees that people will not burn garbage any more," he says.
Environmental experts say something needs to change, to protect residents' health.
Local environmental researcher Augustu Almeida da Silva says there is a need for a solution involving both the government and the community.
And he says it is urgent.
"If it is not resolved, the consequences can reach a point where the whole of Timor will be like a garbage dump," he says.
For now, the rubbish trucks continue to hurtle past Ms Martin's home.
She says she just wants to see action that would protect her family.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

ABC News
19 hours ago
- ABC News
Australia's TGA issues interim report to remove supplements high in B6 from shelves as toxicity cases rise
Major changes have been proposed to restrict access to a common over-the-counter vitamin, linked to a growing number of poisoning cases. Vitamin B6 — often listed as pyridoxine, pyridoxal, pyridoxamine — is present in thousands of products in Australia as an additive, including medicines, multivitamin and mineral supplements, energy drinks and weight loss shakes. 174 reports of peripheral neuropathy, peripheral sensory neuropathy, small fibre neuropathy or chronic polyneuropathy for products containing B6 have been reported to the medicines' regulator, the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA), though medical practitioners predict the true number is significantly higher. "While most of them have no side effects, if you are taking large doses of B6 your risk of peripheral neuropathy goes up." "We know that reported cases of peripheral neuropathy are a massive underestimate of the problem in the community, because so many people are unaware that that vitamins can cause these symptoms." In a new development to improve public safety, several recommendations have been handed down in a report penned by a senior TGA medical officer known as 'the delegate'. Called the 'Interim Decision', the report acts on the advice of the government's Advisory Committee on Medicines Scheduling. Most notably, it calls for the TGA to reclassify supplements containing more than 50mg of B6 as Schedule 3 (Pharmacist Only), by February 2027. The move would affect around 100 products, requiring pharmacists to first speak with consumers before approving a purchase. "Currently, preparations providing up to 200 mg of [B6] ... are available for self-selection without any professional guidance or oversight," the report states, adding "almost 80 per cent of these products provide a dose of more than 2 mg/day, which is above the RDI for pyridoxine, pyridoxal or pyridoxamine. "The daily requirement of vitamin B6 can be easily obtained from the usual Australian diet, and the use of supplemental vitamin B6 provides limited benefit except in people who have a clinically diagnosed vitamin B6 deficiency. A TGA spokesperson told 7.30 the decision, if implemented, "will reduce the maximum amount of vitamin B6 allowed in oral products than currently available for general sale". "The interim decision balances the risks and benefits of using vitamin B6 including the risk of peripheral neuropathy, acknowledging its potential for irreversible harm at higher doses and variability in individual metabolism," the spokesperson said. But, as detailed in the report, the proposed changes only account for around seven per cent of supplements containing B6 — there are more than 1,500 vitamins listed on the Australian Register of Therapeutic Goods, the majority of which are unscheduled and available over the counter. The report also recommended supplements exceeding 200mg should be reclassified as prescription medicines or 'schedule 4'. "It's a good thing that pharmacists will be able to have a really good counselling session with a patient, to make sure the item they're taking doesn't interact with other medications," said Caroline Diamantis, vice-president of the Pharmaceutical Society of Australia. "People used to think that complimentary medicines were completely safe but the more we delve into it the more we understand they do have unwanted side-effects or interference with other medications," she told 7.30. The interim decision also recommends tightening labelling rules, calling for clearer identification of vitamin B6 on packaging and stronger warnings to help consumers avoid accidental overexposure. "Use of ingredient names in labelling is inconsistent and confusing for consumers … and not always described as vitamin B6," the report said. "Of concern is that there are several products on the market where the front of the label provides no indication that vitamin B6 is an ingredient." It suggested changing the language on warning labels to be more direct. "Excess consumption of vitamin B6 can cause nerve damage. Stop use and see a doctor if you experience tingling, burning or numbness," was a suggestion. The report also calls on the multi-billion-dollar complementary medicines sector to take greater responsibility for educating consumers and reducing the risk of vitamin B6 overexposure, noting current labelling places too much burden on consumers to calculate total B6 intake. "Estimating the total daily vitamin B6 intake … is likely to be beyond the health literacy capability of the typical consumer," it said. The CEO of Complementary Medicines Australia John O'Doherty told 7.30: "we'll be carefully reviewing the interim decision and the recommendations of the Advisory Committee on Medicines Scheduling." Mr O'Doherty argued adverse events relating to the use of vitamin B6 are "extremely rare". "Based on a comparison of sales data with the TGA's public Database of Adverse Events, the chance of a reaction is less than one in half a million — this is extremely rare," he said. However, previous 7.30 investigations have found dozens of Australians have had issues from B6 toxicity, with many only becoming aware of their illness after seeing our reports. The TGA delegate also warns the prevalence could be much higher. "The true rate of occurrence of an adverse event cannot be determined from spontaneous adverse event reporting systems due to both general under-reporting and a lack of usage data," its report read. "A low number of spontaneous adverse event reports cannot be considered evidence of the absence a safety issue." Mr O'Doherty however agreed with some of the labelling recommendations, telling 7.30 his organisation has "been calling on the TGA to implement changes that allow labels and advertising to use terminology and ingredient names that consumers better understand." "At CMA's request, this is now under internal review at the TGA", he said. Medical negligence lawyer Nick Mann said the interim decision is a "small step in the right direction" but argued the TGA "can and should" go further. Mr Mann told 7.30 his legal firm, Polaris, is pursuing a class action lawsuit against one of the largest companies in the complementary medicines industry, Blackmores, "as a matter of public interest and safety". "We continue to investigate the potential class action, and given the response, the support and the evidence that's been pouring in ... with over 140 people contacting us to date," Mr Mann said. "Each of them had heartbreaking stories about how their lives have been affected by B6 toxicity, and sadly, many of them continue to be affected long after ceasing supplements containing Vitamin B6. "We've also had at least 10 doctors contact us to tell us about their own experiences with B6, and to let us know that they have discovered B6 toxicity in several of their patients, after taking supplements containing higher than the RDI of the vitamin over weeks and months," he said. The interim decision recommends the changes be made by 1 February 2027 — offering an 18-month implementation period. Watch 7.30, Mondays to Thursdays 7:30pm on ABC iview and ABC TV Do you know more about this story? Get in touch with 7.30 here.

ABC News
6 days ago
- ABC News
Calls for support as Latrobe Valley power workers continue to die from asbestos exposure
Like many men of his generation, Mick Tomkins does not like to make a fuss. The 73-year-old enjoys meeting up with a group of mates to swim at the nearby Traralgon pool most mornings, before a coffee and a chat about the footy. But, like many men of his generation, Mr Tomkins is also living with the insidious legacy of being a power station worker in the 1970s, after being diagnosed with terminal mesothelioma last year. "It was a bit of a shock," he said. Mr Tomkins was just 20 years old when he first took on a role as a subcontractor, helping build the new W station at Yallourn. For the young sheet metal worker, it was the prospect of high-paying work that would support his family. "That construction was an area I really didn't want to go into, but I had a wife and a couple of kids, so I had to get work and they paid very well out there," he said. The power industry was booming, with Mr Tomkins joining around 1,000 other contractors onsite at the time. What workers did not realise was that their job exposed them to asbestos on a daily basis. "The laggers would go in and put the insulation on the pipes, and we would come in and coat them with sheet metal," he said. "Most of that insulation was fibreglass, but then we had sectional asbestos over the pipes. It would not be until 50 years later that Mr Tomkins and his family would discover the damage caused by this exposure. In 2003, after a series of court cases, asbestos was banned in Australia. More than a decade ago, Mr Tomkins and his family started to monitor his condition by getting regular lung compression testing. Then, about three years ago, Mr Tomkins said he started to develop a cough that would not go away. He would soon not be able to walk to the front gate. A CT scan and a biopsy would later confirm Mr Tomkins had mesothelioma. For the stoic father and grandfather, the news, while devastating, was not unexpected. "I didn't panic. In some ways, in the end, I'd sort of half expected it because of the cough," he said. For Pauline Tomkins, Mr Tomkins' wife of 54 years, and their family, it was confirmation of the worst kind. "We just all went quiet, and I just kept looking at the floor," she said. "It was always in the back of my mind, but the trouble is when it is said to you." A 2009 study by Monash University found that former power workers in the Latrobe Valley were contracting mesothelioma at a rate seven times the national average. The proliferation of asbestos among Latrobe Valley workers prompted an apology from the then Victorian premier John Brumby at a regional sitting of the 56th parliament at Monash University's Gippsland Campus on October 15, 2008. "On behalf of the Victorian government and the community, I want to say sorry and to express our regret for the pain and the suffering felt by some former power industry workers and their families where that was caused by asbestos exposure at the former SECV … It is unacceptable that any person, through the course of their work, is exposed to what we now know is a deadly substance," Mr Brumby said. For Vicki Hamilton, the CEO and secretary of the Asbestos Council of Victoria (better known as GARDS), the ongoing legacy of illness for the Latrobe Valley hits close to home. Ms Hamilton lost both her father and grandfather to asbestos-related disease, and said despite the high profile nature of asbestos cases, many people mistakenly believed the challenges were behind them. "I get a couple of calls a month at least from people who know that they're sick and they are going to see a doctor," she said. Ms Hamilton said 140,000 workers were exposed to asbestos between the 1920s and the 1980s. "That affected a whole community, and every person, every second or third person in the Latrobe Valley knows somebody who has an asbestos-related disease," she said. The Asbestos Council formed part of a state government task force established in 2019 to review how asbestos was managed in the Latrobe Valley. In 2022, the task force made 21 recommendations to minimise the risk and harms of asbestos exposure. The recommendations included establishing a statewide centre to manage all asbestos queries, developing targeted awareness campaigns, and mandating training for the handling and removal of asbestos. However, no recommendations had been implemented when the work of the task force culminated in March 2023. Ms Hamilton said more needed to be done as workers continued to come forward with diagnoses. "I'm very lucky, the state government just helped to fund me for part of my money because, without that, we would have been looking at closing within 12 months because that's about the only money we have left." A Victorian government spokesperson said the government was working to prevent or minimise risks associated with asbestos. "Actions underway to address the harmful legacy of asbestos and prevent asbestos-related diseases in Victoria include raising awareness of asbestos risks, prioritising and coordinating the removal of asbestos from Victorian government buildings, establishing convenient disposal points and strengthening compliance and enforcement," the spokesperson said. With legal help, Mr Tomkins was able to make a claim for compensation against his former employer's insurance company. Now, he and his family are taking each day as it comes. Mr Tomkins is balancing his life with treatment, and so far has found success with immunotherapy to keep his cancer under control. "We just take each day now as we go and just do what the doctors say," Mr Tomkins said. "I don't look like I'm dying, do I? "I've had a life, but you know I'd like to still have a longer life actually."

ABC News
10-06-2025
- ABC News
Widow of man killed by Murray Valley encephalitis warns of mosquito bite danger
When Sonia Blackaby set out caravanning with her husband across Western Australia's far north, she never thought a mosquito bite would make it their last trip together. Travelling from Tom Price, 1,450 kilometres north-east of Perth, to the Kimberley two years ago, her husband, Peter, contracted a rare mosquito-borne illness. "We returned home and, within a week of that, he started showing symptoms, which I thought at the beginning was a stroke," she said. Peter Blackaby had contracted Murray Valley encephalitis (MVE), a rare but serious mosquito-borne disease that can cause brain inflammation, coma and death. There is no treatment or vaccine for it. Mr Blackaby was flown to Royal Perth Hospital for treatment, but his condition worsened in the following hours. "He went from showing signs [of life] to being in a coma, non-verbal, unresponsive, quadriplegic, and basically in a vegetative state," Ms Blackaby said. Ms Blackaby's story struck a chord with the West Australian government, which is now offering free insect repellent kits to community groups in areas deemed at high risk of a mosquito-borne illness. "So sporting clubs, caravan parks, other places in the community will always have insect repellent available," WA Health Minister Meredith Hammat said. "There were 12 cases of Murray Valley encephalitis reported since 2023, and five of those have resulted in deaths. "It is serious." Part of the reason Ms Blackaby is speaking out now is that she does not think the existing messaging about mosquito-borne illnesses is cutting through. For years, the government has backed a campaign called "Fight the Bite". But Ms Blackaby said most people she talked to had not heard of MVE. "I still travel with my caravan and I make it my public duty to talk to people and ask if they've heard of MVE," she said. "If I can stop one family from going through what my family went through, it's worth it." The initiative comes as Kimberley residents report increased mosquito activity following recent unseasonal rains. Mosquito traps detected MVE in the West Kimberley earlier this month. Broome resident Robyn Maher said the mosquitoes were "out in force". "On this morning's walk through Minyirr I had a black T-shirt on, and my husband said, 'Your whole back is covered in mosquitoes,'" she said. Ms Maher said free mosquito repellent was a "really good idea". "It's ridiculously expensive. Not everyone can afford food, let alone a can of Aerogard, so that's a really good initiative," she said. Ms Blackaby said everyone living in high-risk mosquito regions like the Pilbara and Kimberley should be applying insect repellent as part of their daily routine. "It just has to become ingrained a bit like 'slip, slop, slap' with sunscreen," she said. "It needs to become something that we're just aware of on the regular, not just a news article that pops up every now and again." The government said it was planning a statewide rollout of the initiative next year.