A girl and her father wash up in mysterious shelter by the sea, where they meet a trio of philosophers
Get Starting Point
A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday.
Enter Email
Sign Up
With a setting as fascinating and surreal as The Sea, it's slightly disappointing that the alternating biographies of Arendt, Spinoza, and Du dominate the book. Lina's narration takes a distant backseat to the philosophers' trials, tribulations, and travels. These biographies are supposed to be instructive to Lina's quest to learn why she and her father have come to The Sea without her mother and brother. But this plotline feels largely inert because while readers are reminded of the dangers of totalitarianism and the tragic toll of forced migration and exile, Lina is like us: a passive receiver of familiar messages.
Advertisement
Arendt and Spinoza, in particular, take center stage. We follow Arendt through the formative traumas of her life, including her imprisonment by the Gestapo for researching antisemitism, and eventually, her perilous escape from Nazi-controlled France into Spain. Once in Spain, she travels to Lisbon and boards a ship to America, where she eventually settled and became renowned as an author and thinker. Spinoza's life story follows a similar arc. His pantheistic opinions lead to his expulsion from the Portuguese Jewish community in Amsterdam. Spinoza's philosophies cross over into Arendt's storyline, because her work was strongly influenced by his.
The backstory of Lina's father's involvement in the creation of The Sea is delivered to the reader whole, via flashback, again without Lina having to do very much. This revelatory section happens in a futuristic China where hundreds have died in a Tiananmen Square-like 'catastrophe.' Lina's father finds himself working for a company named Days and Months Technology Corp Ltd., and with a name like that, it's easy to tell that this firm is up to no good.
Advertisement
Lina's father's backstory only makes The Sea more fascinating, and this reader wanted to understand the mechanics of its construction. The payoff, however, stops well short of explaining the science fiction, and Lina's father's betrayal will feel expected for anyone familiar with the Cultural Revolution. The Lina storyline, already hampered by a lack of movement, gets bogged down by repetition and a penchant for mysterious philosophical statements from her neighbors that, unfortunately, recall the musings of Yoda. 'You must let go of your fear
,'
Du Fu's father tells himself at one point. Meanwhile, one of the scholars instrumental to the design of the Sea says, 'The deeper you fall into the architecture of the system…the closer you come to reality.' It's a sentiment Bento and Lina will repeat. 'Time never goes missing,' Bento proclaims. 'I think the structure of reality can be no other way.' While the musicality of such sentences is pleasing, their meanings remain elusive.
Fans of books like Mohsin Hamid's '
Though one can't help but admire the breadth of Thien's imagination, it's the child's story by the sea that this reader wanted more of.
Advertisement
Leland Cheuk is an award-winning author of three books of fiction, most recently '
THE BOOK OF RECORDS
By Madeleine Thien
Norton, 368 pages, $28.99
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
12 hours ago
- Boston Globe
Norwegian teens learn survival skills and husky care in ‘Folktales'
'There's a great thing for a young person to learn, which is: You're not the center of the world. That was kind of my takeaway. Nobody in these woods gives a [hoot] about my teenage problems.' Advertisement Decades later, Grady and her filmmaking partner, Get Starting Point A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday. Enter Email Sign Up While Ewing and Grady captured many aspects of the school's operations, the film focuses on the paths of three students, each in their late teens. They are Hege, who is struggling with her father's sudden death; Bjørn Tore, a self-described 'nerd' who has been told he tends to annoy others; and Raimon, a young man from the Netherlands with an utter lack of self-confidence. Advertisement Hege and Odin in "Folktales." Lars Erlend Tubaas Øymo The school staff encourages the students to figure things out on their own – both physical challenges and emotional – and trusts that they will. 'Try to fall in love with your heart,' says one of the classroom instructors to Raimon. The sled dogs are a big part of the story. Each student is assigned to their own husky, and the bonds they forge are poignant. 'You are more than good enough for that dog just the way you are,' says the trainer. 'The dogs teach us to be more human.' On a Zoom call to discuss the film, Grady is using her phone while she walks her tiny dog Morty in a park near her home in Brooklyn. Morty is a Chiweenie – half Chihuahua, half Dachshund. 'She saw a squirrel a half-hour ago,' Grady explains when she toggles out of selfie mode to show the dog, whose back is turned to the camera. The dog is still distracted. The distractions of youth underscore 'Folktales,' as the students worry about how they appear to others and what their lives have in store for them. The latter question, especially, has been a recurring theme throughout much of the two filmmakers' work together with their production company, Loki Films, which they founded in 2001. Among the many films they've made, 'Jesus Camp' (2006) — about young Christians attending a summer camp in North Dakota — was nominated for an Academy Award for best documentary. Advertisement 'What are the events or the moments in your life where you're just open enough to hear something and believe it, and follow a path?' asks Ewing. 'All of us have had those moments — a parent, a teacher, something you saw overhead that illuminated something about who you want to be. 'What makes you tick?' she continues. 'Do you choose door A or door B?' Many viewers have noted that 'Folktales' introduces audiences to a setting that's clearly archaic, in which young people learn about a traditional culture that predates cell phones by millennia. Ewing and Grady say they're not sure what to believe in the ongoing debate about the digital natives' preoccupation with their phones, and how harmful that may be. Bjørn Tore and Tigergutt in "Folktales." Tori Edvin Eliassen 'We've filmed many young people over a couple of decades,' says Grady, who has a 14-year-old son. Many of the challenges of maturation are eternal, she says, 'which is kind of a motif of the film — the cycle of life, over and over. 'But being a 20-year-old in 2025 is specific. When my son comes of age like [the subjects of her film] in six years, it could be again a different world.' Ewing recently hosted her brother's family at a place she has in upstate New York. Off-road, their car got stuck in mud, and everyone had to get out in the snow and try to free the tires from the rut. Her 12-year-old niece, who had been doom-scrolling all weekend, was elated by this unexpected predicament. 'She was running around the car going, 'This is amazing!'' Ewing recalls. ''This is real life!' It was, like, the greatest moment of her entire weekend. Advertisement 'And I thought, 'Huh. Maybe we are gonna be OK.'' 'Folktales' opens and closes with references to the Norse mythology of the Norns, the three goddesses who shape human destiny and care for the holy 'tree of life.' According to the film's version of the legend, the Norns can bestow gifts, including access to knowledge, wisdom, and storytelling ability. Each of the young adults featured in the film earned some measure of those gifts at the Folk High School, the filmmakers say. Not surprisingly, it reminded Grady of her long-ago Outward Bound adventure. 'These things don't break you like a horse,' she says. 'But they do break you a teeny bit.' James Sullivan can be reached at .
Tom's Guide
16 hours ago
- Tom's Guide
This wild Pedro Pascal movie just got an HBO Max release date
HBO Max is adding new movies all the time, and next month, it's adding "Freaky Tales." Now, if you're like me, you've quite possibly not even heard of this movie. Which was surprising — it was a Sundance film, distributed by Lionsgate and stars a pair of actors I love in Pedro Pascal and Ben Mendelsohn. It even has a bunch of punks fighting Nazis! In short, I should have been all over this movie. But somehow it escaped my notice and most everyone else's, because it reportedly only brought in $400K at the box office. But those who have seen this wild comedy have loved it. It currently has an 89% "hot" rating from audiences on Rotten Tomatoes, even though critics were a bit more muted in their praise. You'll get to judge for yourself on Friday, Aug. 8, when the movie hits HBO Max. Or, if you're someone who prefers linear HBO to the streaming service, it'll air at 8 p.m. ET the next day (Saturday, Aug. 9) on the premium cable channel. In the meantime, here's what "Freaky Tales" is all about and why this wild comedy needs to be added to your watchlist. The most important thing to know about "Freaky Tales" is that it doesn't follow a typical plot structure. Instead, there are four vignettes that are loosely interconnected, only really all coming together at the end. It's based on real events and real locations in 1987 Oakland, California. The first chapter, "Strength in Numbers: The Gilman Strikes Back," focuses on a pair of young punks, Tina (Ji-young Yoo) and Lucid (Jack Champion), who are at an Operation Ivy concert that comes under attack from Nazi punks. Get instant access to breaking news, the hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips. HBO Max gives you tons of hit shows and movies, from HBO Originals to A24 movies and more. "Don't Fight the Feeling" is the next story, picking up at the same point as the start of the first chapter, but instead focuses on Barbie (Dominique Thorne) and Entice (Normani), who perform as the hip hop duo Danger Zone. They don't go to the Operation Ivy show, but instead are roped into performing with the rapper Too Short. "Born to Mack" is where Pedro finally arrives. He plays Clint, a career criminal who is looking to get out of the game. When he's asked to pull a job during a Warriors basketball game, that desire to leave crime behind is put to the test. Finally, there's "The Legend of Sleepy Floyd." This is where the story finally starts to come together. Sleepy Floyd (Jay Ellis) is a star for the Warriors, and it's his house that Clint is supposed to rob. But instead, "The Guy" (Mendelsohn), sends the Nazi punks to rob it and things go horribly wrong. As I mentioned earlier, audiences are loving this movie for the most part. Critics are a bit harsher on it, and after combing through the reviews from both parties, this seems to come down to critics judging its (admittedly) loosely connected chapters failing to come together properly in the end. Ultimately, if you want a wild comedy that doubles as an impressive period piece, then "Freaky Tales" seems like it's worth watching. It doesn't necessarily stick the landing narratively, but the acting of its loaded cast is sublime, and its recreation of 1987 Oakland has been masterfully done by all accounts. Even Deadline praised the period elements of the movie in its review, saying, "What does work for 'Freaky Tales' is the film's gritty visuals immediately immerse the audience in the look and feel of late-'80s Oakland." Follow Tom's Guide on Google News to get our up-to-date news, how-tos, and reviews in your feeds. Make sure to click the Follow button. Malcolm has been with Tom's Guide since 2022, and has been covering the latest in streaming shows and movies since 2023. He's not one to shy away from a hot take, including that "John Wick" is one of the four greatest films ever made. Here's what he's been watching lately:
Buzz Feed
a day ago
- Buzz Feed
Connor From Jubilee Video Lost Job, Asks For Money
By now, you've surely seen clips of the viral Jubilee video where progressive journalist and author Mehdi Hasan debated 20 far-right conservatives. It was disturbing, to say the least. And one of the most controversial participants was Connor, a self-proclaimed fascist... ...who brought up Nazi theorist Carl Schmitt to defend his stance, and then refused to condemn Nazis. The clip was shared and discussed widely across social media. During an appearance on the Rift TV podcast, Connor gave an update, saying, "Unfortunately, I lost my job as a result. No one really is to blame for that. It's just the culture that kind of exists currently, surrounding the manner in which you're canceled for voicing a ... heterosexual, Christian, sort of moral belief." On the podcast, he said he condemns "the persecution of anyone, Jews included," but didn't want to "play" Mehdi's "game" because it was a "loaded question." After losing his job, Connor began crowdfunding on a GiveSendGo page with the title: "Fired for my Political Beliefs." He wrote, "Voicing fully legal traditional right wing political views results in real consequences. This is cancel culture and political discrimination on full display." At the time of publication, Connor has raised $36k and received 975 prayers??? Okay. People who gave donations also wrote comments supporting Connor and asking God to bless him. As you might imagine, the internet is having a field day with all this. Here's what people are saying: The entire video is up on Jubilee's YouTube page. For those of you who watched it, how did it make you feel? What are your thoughts or concerns? Share in the comments or in the anonymous form below.
