Bruce Lehrmann claims police destroyed exonerating evidence and pending rape trial should be abandoned, court hears
Lehrmann's solicitor, Zali Burrows, told Brisbane district court on Thursday that Queensland Police had been unable to access a hard drive that contained extensive case files.
The included audio of Lehrmann taken before his arrest in 2023 and a full download of the complainant's mobile phone.
Sign up: AU Breaking News email
Burrows' claims are to be tested at a hearing on 26 September, with Judge Deborah Richards ordering that Lehrmann would not face a potential trial on two counts of rape until at least 2026.
The 30-year-old appeared by phone for the mention of his case.
Judge Benedict Power previously directed the defence and prosecutors to agree on a nominal start date for the trial.
But Burrows on Thursday said that would be premature for multiple reasons.
'There is an application for a permanent stay of proceedings on the basis of destruction of exculpatory material,' she said.
'The officer in charge of this investigation has lost material that was stored on a personal hard drive that contained materials from the course of the investigation.'
Burrows said the hard drive contained audio recordings involving witnesses and Lehrmann, copies of statements and video recordings.
'(The officer) claims the hard drive malfunctioned for unknown reasons,' she said.
'Defence has sought access to the hard drive for an independent interrogation by our own experts but we are told the hard drive has now been destroyed.'
Lehrmann, who is on bail, is accused of raping a woman twice during the morning of 10 October 2021.
They met during the previous night at a strip club in Toowoomba, west of Brisbane.
The former ministerial staffer to Liberal senator Linda Reynolds was charged in January 2023 and is yet to formally enter a plea.
But his former solicitor previously told a magistrate Lehrmann intended to contest the charges.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
Crown prosecutor Peter Blake-Segovia did not respond to Burrows' submissions about the officer's hard drive or her claims that police were providing her copies of evidence in a 'piecemeal' manner.
Richards said there was no room in this year's calendar for another trial.
'I don't have a calendar for next year yet. You are off the hook for a trial date at this stage,' she said.
Barrister Michael Bonasia, representing the Queensland police commissioner, told Richards his client had been served a subpoena by Burrows for copies of all materials in the case.
'There's an application for any claims of privilege for documents sought under the subpoena,' he said.
Richards ordered a hearing on the subpoena claims on 28 August and a hearing on 26 September for Burrows' application to permanently stay proceedings, which if granted would halt the trial before it started.
'On 29 October … (a date) will be listed for the trial if it's still on foot,' the judge said.
Lehrmann's bail was continued.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Scot accused of his wife's murder had joked to friend about killing her, court told
A Scot accused of murdering his wife while kayaking in Australia previously made a 'quip' about how he would 'kill her and move to Thailand ' if she left him and took half his pension, a court heard. Former Army major Graeme Davidson, who is originally from Glasgow, was charged over the 2020 death of wife Jacqueline in May. Her death at Lake Samsonvale in Queensland was initially put down to accidental drowning but a homicide investigation was launched 18 months later after detectives deemed it to be suspicious. The 56-year-old's lawyers have now applied for his bail in the Supreme Court in Brisbane, claiming the prosecution's case is 'fundamentally weak'. And yesterday the Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC) reported how his lawyer Craig Ederhardt told the court the only piece of evidence the prosecution could refer to in its case was the statement of one of Davidson's friends, relating to an alleged conversation in July 2017. It is reported that Mr Eberhardt said they were talking about another friend, whose wife had left him on the day of his retirement, took half of his pension and one of them had moved to Thailand. Davidson is alleged to have replied, saying, 'oh s*** yeah, I'd kill her and move to Thailand too'. But his lawyer told the court it was 'just a quip' and when put in context is 'not nearly as sinister as it sounds'. He is reported as saying: 'That [statement is] not recorded until eight years after the event. 'One wonders firstly whether it's reliable, secondly whether it's even admissible.' Mr Eberhardt also argued there was no evidence to suggest Mrs Davidson had told her husband she intended to leave him or take half his pension. Australian media reported that his wife had raised the 'idea' of divorce, after she learned her husband had an affair with a local woman during an army posting in Papua New Guinea, which caused 'significant matrimonial upset'. But Mr Eberhardt said this was different to her indicating that 'she was intending on leaving the marriage'. He told the court that Mrs Davidson later told friends that she intended to stay to try and make the marriage work. Police allege Davidson, who moved to Thailand several months after his wife's death and married a local resident, was involved in her drowning while they were kayaking. The court heard how bystanders at the scene allegedly asked Davidson if his wife had any diseases, to which he is said to have replied: 'Unless death is contagious'. His lawyer said his client immediately realised this statement was in 'bad taste' and he should not have said it, telling the court it was a 'distressing' incident involving the death of his wife of 35 years. In an affidavit filed as part of his bail application, Davidson is reported to have described how he began to 'show' off by standing up on his kayak when he and his wife were about 10 metres apart on the water. Mrs Davidson allegedly became 'distressed' and 'used the 'safe word' … designed to let him know that she was concerned about what he was doing'. The court was told Davidson saw his wife 'fall off the kayak' and he went into the water to find her but could not see because of the 'murky' water and grass weeds. Mr Eberhardt said: 'He managed to find her after some period of time, and he dragged her out.' Efforts were made to revive her, but she could not be saved. Davidson is also charged with fraud and attempted fraud relating to allegations he tried to claim almost £500,00 [$1million] in life insurance payouts following his wife's death. The defence is set to continue its submissions next week, when prosecutors are expected to refuse Davidson's application for bail.
The Sun
2 hours ago
- The Sun
PSG star Achraf Hakimi facing rape charge after ‘inviting woman he met on Instagram back to family home'
PSG star Achraf Hakimi is reportedly facing trial for rape after allegedly inviting a woman over to his home near Paris. Prosecutors have signed a final indictment requesting the 26-year-old to be charged in criminal court. 2 If convicted, the Moroccan national faces up to 15 years in prison. The case stems from an alleged incident on February 25, 2023. According to Le Parisien, a 24-year-old woman told police she met Hakimi on Instagram in January of that year. After a month of exchanges, he reportedly ordered her an Uber to his home in Boulogne-Billancourt while his wife and children were away on holiday. Once inside, the woman claims Hakimi kissed her mouth and breasts through her clothes, despite her protests. She alleged he then assaulted her without consent. According to her account, she managed to push him away with her foot before fleeing and texting a friend to pick her up. She went to a police station the same day to 'make a statement of rape,' though she initially declined to file a formal complaint. Messages she later provided to investigators reportedly showed her distress following the encounter. Achraf Hakimi shows what he is made of at PSG training On March 3, 2023, Hakimi was charged with rape by an investigating judge and placed under judicial supervision after being held in custody. He has consistently denied the allegations. The footballer, currently holidaying in Puerto Rico with former teammate Kylian Mbappé, previously claimed the case was a plot against him. 'The truth is that when you are successful and things are going well, you become an easy target for certain people and that taught me that you can't trust many people around you,' Hakimi said this January in a interview. 'They wanted to blackmail me and that's why we filed a complaint and it's going well. The justice system handled things rather well.' His lawyer, Fanny Colin, slammed the prosecution's latest move. 'These requisitions are incomprehensible and senseless in light of the evidence in the case,' she told Le Parisien. 'It establishes the plaintiff's lies, particularly through the psychological assessments conducted on her. 'Achraf Hakimi and I remain as calm as when the proceedings began. 'If these requests were to be followed, we would obviously pursue all avenues of appeal.'
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
PSG defender Achraf Hakimi could face '15 years in prison' as prosecutors 'seek trial for alleged rape after years-long investigation'
Achraf Hakimi could face up to 15 years in prison if convicted over an allegation of rape, after prosecutors in France formally requested that the Paris Saint-Germain and Morocco international be sent for trial before a criminal court. The request, signed on August 1 by the Nanterre prosecutor's office, marks the latest development in a judicial investigation that has spanned more than two years. A final decision on whether the case goes to trial now rests with the investigating judge, who can either approve or dismiss the recommendation. The case stems from an alleged incident on the night of February 25, 2023, at Hakimi's home in Boulogne-Billancourt, a suburb west of Paris. A 24-year-old woman claims she was raped after being invited to the player's residence. She told police that the two had begun exchanging messages on Instagram in January and that Hakimi arranged for a car to bring her to his home. Once there, she alleges he began kissing and touching her without consent and, despite her protests, forced her to engage in sexual acts. She says she eventually managed to push him away and left, later messaging a friend for help. The woman reported the alleged rape to police the following day, although she did not initially file a formal complaint. Messages she sent to friends about the incident were later provided to investigators. On March 3, 2023, Hakimi was placed under formal investigation — the French equivalent of being charged. The allegation against Hakimi, which he denies, was made in 2023. He has continued playing for PSG since then and was part of the team that won the UEFA Champions League in May According to Le Parisien, the final indictment request signals that prosecutors believe there is enough evidence for the case to go to trial, though it does not constitute a finding of guilt. Hakimi has denied any wrongdoing throughout the investigation and maintains the encounter was consensual. He has continued to play for PSG and the Moroccan national team in the meantime. His lawyer, Fanny Colin, described the prosecution's request as 'incomprehensible and senseless in light of the evidence in the case.' She said the proceedings had already highlighted contradictions in the accuser's testimony, particularly in psychological assessments. 'Achraf Hakimi and I remain as calm as when the proceedings began,' she said. 'If these requests were to be followed, we would obviously pursue all avenues of appeal.' The alleged victim's lawyer, Rachel-Flore Pardo, told Le Parisien her client had received this week's development with 'immense relief', viewing it as a sign the justice system is taking her claims seriously. PSG have not commented extensively on the case but have stood by the player, citing 'personal reasons' when he missed training sessions during sensitive phases of the investigation. The club has said it continues to trust the legal process. The investigating judge is expected to decide in the coming weeks whether Hakimi will stand trial.
