
Washington's view on annexing Canada — This is a joke, right? Right?
These aren't normal times.
Donald Trump's repeated talk of annexing Canada is almost universally treated as a joke in Washington. Or, maybe, as a negotiating ploy. If it's neither, the U.S. president would face a Himalayan climb to make it a reality.
The consensus in Washington that he can't be serious — right? right? — is reflected in the scant immediate coverage of eye-popping remarks made Friday by Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, who was overheard telling business leaders that, yes, Trump really would like to take over Canada.
Apparently, the U.S. president made a cryptic comment in his Monday afternoon phone call with Trudeau about having read a 1908 treaty setting the Canada-U.S. boundary and finding it interesting. He did not elaborate.
The story was at the bottom of the home page of the New York Times, its site awash in stories about allegedly unlawful actions by the new administration.
It was halfway down the home page on the Wall Street Journal, below routine economic news and wasn't on the Washington Post's main page at all.
Nor has all this talk even come up at recent congressional hearings where Canada featured prominently: one on trade and tariffs, one on minerals.
At the latter, a Democrat mocked Trump for threatening tariffs on a neighbour that has vital aluminum copper, cobalt, graphite, lithium and more.
"The stable genius has decided to start a trade war with [Canada]," said Rhode Island Rep. Seth Magaziner, invoking a phrase Trump once used to describe himself.
There was no mention of making Canada a 51st state and changing the political map of North America and electoral map of the United States.
Republican Sen. Ted Cruz waved off Trump's plan on his podcast this week, calling it "an epic troll… I think he was just yanking [Trudeau's] chain."
WATCH | Trump is serious, Trudeau says:
Trudeau says Trump's comments about absorbing Canada are serious
16 hours ago
Duration 0:20
Following his public remarks at the Canada-U.S. Economic Summit, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau told business and labour leaders that U.S. President Donald Trump's comments about making Canada the 51st state are 'a real thing.' Trudeau's comments were heard over the loudspeakers.
Gargantuan roadblocks
A reason to discount this talk might be the poor politics of it: Canadian statehood is slightly to massively unpopular, according to U.S. public opinion polls.
It seems highly dubious that this unloved, highly complex and deeply controversial plan would gain a critical enough mass of support to win a vote in the U.S. Congress, let alone the extreme longshot of Canada approving it.
Some existing U.S. territories know this from experience. They've been working for decades to get such votes through Congress.
One veteran of the battle says even if there were enough supporters in Congress, the actual votes would be a political minefield.
Lawmakers would have to agree to dilute their own power — transferring about five dozen House seats to Canada, plus, depending on the number of new states introduced, two, four, or six Senate seats.
"That would fundamentally change the balance of power within that body," said George Laws Garcia, executive director of the Puerto Rico Statehood Council.
"So is that something that Congress is going to just jump into? I don't think so."
And there's little time: Trump's party has a razor-thin House majority and could lose it in the midterms in 23 months. If he keeps talking about unpopular ideas like annexing Canada, Trump might unwittingly expedite that process.
Weighing Trump's endgame
The bits of evidence, however, that Trump is dead serious about territorial expansion are starting to accumulate into a hard-to-ignore mountain.
He mentioned it in his inaugural address. He keeps talking about it — in the context of Canada, Panama, Greenland and now Gaza.
His Middle East envoy is a property developer and Trump is talking about building properties in Gaza after moving residents elsewhere; Trump's son-in-law Jared Kushner mused about something similar months ago.
There's enough evidence to suspect that Trump is no longer satisfied by his current station as a two-term U.S. president — and that he has imperial ambitions.
Which might not be surprising given that two biographies of the man, including one written by his niece, include the words "never enough" in the title.
But some people who study U.S. global hegemony still aren't buying it.
One analyst of imperialism in U.S. history tells Canadians he has no expectation of sharing a nation in his lifetime.
"As pleased as I'd be to be your compatriot, I wouldn't wager much on it happening," said Daniel Immerwahr, professor at Northwestern University, and author of How to Hide an Empire.
He says he believes Trump delights in shocking people — in saying outlandish things, either for fun, or in pursuit of some goal.
WATCH | Threats and jabs from Trump:
Trump's escalating rhetoric against Canada
1 month ago
Duration 2:42
That goal, he said, might be a new trade deal with Canada, or his desired outcome in Gaza, or a new security arrangement in Greenland and the Panama Canal.
He's not ruling out the possibility Trump is serious, however. If so, Immerwahr says, he's seeking no less than a return to the global order as it existed before the Second World War.
In that view, gone is the world where the U.S. usually hid its hard power and used soft-power instruments like trade, aid and global institutions to exert its massive influence and achieve desired outcomes.
This would be a return to the world where great powers threaten the territory of their neighbours — Immerwahr says, mentioning China, Russia and, now, the U.S.
The Gaza annexation talk might be similar, says Stephen Wertheim, an analyst of U.S. statecraft and strategy at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. He expressed doubt that the MAGA faithful are clamouring for a Middle East nation-building exercise with so much destructive potential.
The idea of annexing Western Hemisphere territory, he says, harkens back to the 19th century and the Monroe Doctrine, as Trump alluded to in his inaugural address by talking about expanding the U.S.
But whatever Trump is doing, it's still a watershed moment.
"To the extent Trump is using threats of annexation merely as negotiating ploys, we're pretty much in uncharted territory," said Wertheim, author of the book Tomorrow, the World: The Birth of U.S. Global Supremacy.
WATCH | 'We'll own' Gaza, Trump says:
Can the U.S. really take over Gaza? | About That
2 days ago
Duration 12:10
President Donald Trump's proposal for the U.S. to take ownership of Gaza and relocate two million Palestinians has sparked widespread condemnation from world leaders. Andrew Chang breaks down how international law, the question of Palestinian statehood and geopolitical stability challenge Trump's idea.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Winnipeg Free Press
21 minutes ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Turkey and Britain sign preliminary deal for Eurofighter Typhoon jets
ANKARA, Turkey (AP) — Turkey and Britain on Wednesday signed a preliminary agreement for the sale of Eurofighter Typhoon fighter jets to Turkey, a significant step in Ankara's efforts to modernize its air fleet. Turkish Defense Minister Yasar Guler and his British counterpart, John Healey, inked a memorandum of understanding during a defense industry fair in Istanbul, Turkey's Ministry of National Defense said. NATO member Turkey has long aimed to buy 40 Eurofighter jets, which are built by a consortium of British, German and Italian companies. Germany reportedly initially opposed the sale but later reversed its position. Britain led negotiations on behalf of the consortium. A Turkish defense ministry statement said the memorandum takes the two countries 'one step closer to a full agreement on the Typhoon.' 'Both Ministers welcome signature as a positive step towards bringing Turkey into the Typhoon club and share a mutual ambition to conclude the necessary arrangements as soon as possible,' it added. Turkish officials have said that they are still negotiating over pricing and technical terms, saying that they have received an initial offer and expect to submit a counter-proposal. Monday Mornings The latest local business news and a lookahead to the coming week. Turkey is also seeking to return to the U.S.-led F-35 fighter jet program, from which the country was ousted in 2019, following its purchase of Russian-made S-400 missile defense systems. The U.S. said the systems posed a risk to the F-35s. Turkey is also developing a domestic fifth-generation fighter jet, the KAAN, which is slated to be operational in 2028.


CTV News
21 minutes ago
- CTV News
Prime Minister Mark Carney set to visit birthplace in N.W.T.
The house where Prime Minister Mark Carney grew up is shown in Fort Smith, N.W.T., on Saturday, Jan. 27, 2024. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jason Franson FORT SMITH — Prime Minister Mark Carney is set to stop today in the town where he was born as he travels across the Northwest Territories. Carney also spent his early childhood in Fort Smith, located south of Yellowknife along the Alberta boundary, before he moved with his family to Edmonton. He is scheduled to talk to locals in Fort Smith about affordability and food insecurity, and discuss wildfires with community leaders, before heading to Inuvik in the territory's northwest corner. He is set to co-host the Inuit-Crown Partnership Committee on Thursday with Natan Obed, president of Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami, a national organization representing Inuit. It will be Carney's second meeting with Indigenous groups on Ottawa's major projects bill. The legislation would give Ottawa the ability to fast-track projects deemed to be in the national interest by sidestepping some review requirements. This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 23, 2025.


CTV News
21 minutes ago
- CTV News
Canada should follow U.K.'s move to lower voting age to 16, says senator
A voter leaves a polling station after casting a ballot in the federal election in Calgary on Monday, April 28, 2025. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh OTTAWA — Now that the British government has vowed to lower its voting age to 16 by the next general election, one Canadian senator says it's past time for Canada to do the same. The U.K. announced last week that it would lower its voting age from 18 to 16 in a bid to strengthen British democracy and restore trust in politics. Sen. Marilou McPhedran said the issue has been her 'top parliamentary priority' since she joined the Red Chamber. She said lowering the voting age to 16 would be good for democracy and that the only arguments against it are 'based on stereotypes.' McPhedran said decisions being made in Canada now will affect younger generations and that extending voting rights to younger people is 'logical' and 'about fairness.' She added that about a third of 16-year-olds in Canada have some form of employment and are already taxpayers. Sixteen-year-old Jaden Braves and the organization he leads, Young Politicians of Canada, want to see the federal voting age lowered to 16. He told The Canadian Press that Canada 'has to stop living in the shadow of other countries' innovation that's progressing faster than ours.' 'I think we need to stop being the country that waits for somebody else to take leadership on something we clearly have the chance to progress forward on,' he said. 'Hopefully we'll learn some lessons soon.' Braves lamented the many bills that have been introduced in Canada over the past 20 years to lower the voting age that ultimately failed to pass. McPhedran's most recent bill to lower the federal voting age to 16 was introduced at the end of May. She said it's her priority to get it to second reading and into committee when Parliament resumes in September. 'What happened last time was prorogation and an election,' she said. Prorogation killed the bill after it reached second reading in the Senate. 'But this time our push is to ensure that young voices, young leaders are heard directly by senators, and I feel quite confident that when that happens, skeptics will turn around,' McPhedran added. McPhedran said she thinks what's happening in the U.K. will 'make a difference' for a number of senators as she continues to push the bill forward. During debates on previous bills, some senators and MPs have pushed back against arguments in favour of lowering the voting age, such as the suggestion that it would increase voter turnout. Some have also questioned the maturity of youth to cast an informed ballot and debated what standards should be used to justify whether to lower the voting age. Britain's voting age last fell in 1969, when the U.K. became one of the first major democracies to lower it from 21 to 18. Many other countries quickly followed suit; Canada lowered its voting age to 18 in 1970. Several countries already have a voting age of 16, including Austria, Brazil and Ecuador. Scotland and Wales allow 16- and 17-year-olds to vote in local and regional elections. Michael Wigginton, a post-doctoral fellow in political science at Carleton University, said the U.K. government's decision represents a 'fairly natural progression,' coming a decade after Scotland started allowing 16-year-olds to vote for members of the Scottish Parliament and in municipal elections. 'Having that sort of local example to point to makes it easier for both politicians and the public at large to feel comfortable that the reform can work for the U.K. Parliament and not have negative effects,' said Wigginton. Efforts are being made across Canada to lower the voting age. In 2021, young Canadians filed an application at the Ontario Superior Court of Justice to challenge the voting age, arguing that the Canada Elections Act is in violation of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and is unconstitutional. Toronto recently passed a motion allowing 16 and 17-year-olds to vote in polls at the neighbourhood level on planning and policy issues. And a provincial committee looking at ways to boost democratic engagement in B.C. is examining a lower voting age. Wigginton said that while he doesn't expect Canada to immediately adopt a voting age of 16, having the U.K. as an example will 'definitely push the issue into the spotlight more and increase the chances of it happening it the future.' 'What I see is most likely is that one or more provinces will adopt a lower voting age first and then the federal government may eventually follow suit,' he said. With files from The Associated Press This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 23, 2025. Catherine Morrison, The Canadian Press