Tensions erupt in House over DeSantis-backed Hope Florida program's $10M windfall
Rep. Alex Andrade, who chairs the House Health Care Budget Subcommittee, didn't like the answers.
'I'm more stunned, than anything else, by the responses, the demeanor, the flippancy (toward) the serious questions we have,' Andrade, R-Pensacola, told reporters after the hearing. 'This is an endemic problem in state agencies right now and it's something that we've got to work on.'
Shevaun Harris, the secretary of the Agency for Health Care Administration, had struggled to answer questions on a series of issues related to Hope Florida, a program spearheaded by First Lady Casey DeSantis that tries to connect Floridians receiving welfare and Medicaid with other services to help move them off government assistance.
Andrade and other members of the panel expressed alarm over $10 million that went to the Hope Florida Foundation as part of a settlement between AHCA and Centene, a large provider of services under Florida's Medicaid managed care plans.
Under state law, money from settlements must be reported by state agencies to the Legislature, but this wasn't.
As Harris explained, the overall settlement was $67 million, with $57 million going to AHCA. It had to do with overpayments related to pharmacy benefit managers, she said, but the other $10 million was a donation from Centene to the Hope Florida Foundation, so the money never came to AHCA and was therefore was not state funds reportable to the Legislature.
The settlement was reached in October; Harris didn't take the helm at AHCA until February. 'The settlement agreement had a lot of attorneys involved, taking great care to make sure everything was done appropriately,' she said.
But Andrade, an attorney, maintains the funds are taxpayer money and the settlement violates state law: 'The reference to that $10 million not being taxpayer dollars I find offensive,' Andrade said at one point in the hearing.
He noted the settlement was for repaying overpayments from the state's Medicaid program. 'At what point did it suddenly become not taxpayer money?' asked Andrade, a state representative since 2018.
Andrade also raised concerns about Hope Florida getting preferential treatment in the state's Medicaid Managed Care contracts. Specifically, health care insurers must cooperate with Hope Florida as part of the contract.
Another gripe from the committee was the alleged lack of transparency surrounding Hope Florida.
'I still don't get a clear response over who is responsible for Hope Florida,' said Rep. Marie Woodson, D-Hollywood. 'We need to have some names.'
Harris explained that the Hope Florida program uses state employees at many different agencies to help connect those in need with services throughout state government and with nonprofits, including churches, who can provide food, clothing and shelter for those in crisis.
That means there is no executive director of the Hope Florida program, she added.
But the Hope Florida Foundation, which is a nonprofit, is a separate entity. She said that group has a board and later in the hearing said its chairman is Josh Hay, CEO of Indelible Solutions, a Tallahassee-based management consulting firm.
As a nonprofit, the Hope Florida Foundation is required to file tax forms with the IRS that are required to be made available upon request by members of the public, but reporters from the Miami Herald/Tampa Bay Times Tallahassee Bureau have said they were turned away after making such a request at the Department of Children and Families headquarters in the capital.
The heightened scrutiny of Hope Florida comes as Casey DeSantis is said to be considering a run for governor in 2026 to replace her husband, Gov. Ron DeSantis, who is term-limited. DeSantis has pushed lawmakers to codify Hope Florida, which was started by Casey DeSantis in 2021, into law.
At one point in the hearing, Harris said the Hope Florida program was simply trying to help those in need and implied lawmakers weren't sharing that goal.
'I'm not sure why we're here," Harris said. "And I understand there are questions being asked and we're doing our best to be transparent to answer but it does feel like we're not aligned in this overall goal of helping families.
'It's kind of sad, genuinely," she added. "This is the goal of helping individuals get back on their feet. I don't know what's wrong with that.'
'I'm going to take umbrage at that claim,' Andrade replied. 'We're a separate government body tasked with oversight and direction of state agencies and we discover that state agencies are redirecting money secretly, at the eleventh hour, in a legal settlement without giving us any notice? And the accusation is that we don't care about helping Florida families? I take personal issue at that insinuation, Secretary.'
Gray Rohrer is a reporter with the USA TODAY Network-Florida Capital Bureau. He can be reached at grohrer@gannett.com. Follow him on X: @GrayRohrer.
This article originally appeared on Tallahassee Democrat: Hope Florida under fire for lack of oversight, $10M settlement
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Forbes
3 hours ago
- Forbes
How Healthcare Is Becoming Less Affordable Under The Trump Administration
Ryan Chelsea-Clinton Community Health Center located in the Hell's Kitchen, New York City, provides ... More high-quality, affordable, and comprehensive healthcare services to children, adults, and seniors. (Photo by: Deb Cohn-Orbach/UCG/Universal Images Group via Getty Images) It has been just six months since President Trump has started his second term as Commander-in-Chief, and there have been profound changes in the healthcare landscape across America. His legislative and regulatory agenda could accelerate the decline in healthcare affordability across the United States. Here's how health services and accessibility could be compromised for millions of Americans. Medicaid Cuts More than 10 million Americans will lose healthcare insurance coverage through Medicaid over the next decade as part of the 'One Big Beautiful Bill', according to the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office. These millions of Americans are among the most vulnerable population in dire need of healthcare, as Medicaid supports children, the elderly, pregnant women and those with disabilities. Without health insurance, individuals may be reluctant to seek care when sick, they may not go to the doctor's office for routine checkups, and they may not be able to fill drug prescriptions to curb serious diseases. When getting emergent care, these individuals will not be able to afford the large health bills they receive since they are uninsured as Medicaid will not contribute to picking up the tab. Rollback Of Affordable Care Act Subsidies President Joe Biden allowed for federal subsidies and premium tax credits for middle- and low-income families who bought state health coverage on state insurance marketplaces as part of the Affordable Care Act. This aid decreased medical bills and lowered insurance premiums for the 24 million Americans that benefit from this plan. These subsidies are in jeopardy and could expire in December if congress does not renew them. If congress does not act, millions of Americans could be forced to lose healthcare coverage altogether or be pushed to switch to higher deductible health plans that would require them to pay more out of pocket costs before receiving financial support. These changes will not just affect low-income families. The cost to middle-class and working families will be stark- some households earning around $65,000 could see annual health costs rise by over $2,300, and approximately 4.2 million people could lose health insurance altogether, according to the Washington Post. Rising Out-Of-Pocket Costs Healthcare costs that were once paid by health insurers could be shifted increasingly to individuals. As an example, consider COVID-19 vaccines that have traditionally been covered by the federal government or health insurers at no cost to the consumer. New federal guidelines for COVID-19 vaccines will allow health insurers to halt coverage of the vaccines, so patients themselves will have to cover the cost. As an example, Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and the CDC have stated that COVID-19 vaccines will no longer be recommended for pregnant females. Health insurers are usually obliged to cover vaccines that are recommended by federal regulatory bodies. However, with the new federal recommendations, health insurers will be exempt from covering this service to select individuals, which will effectively shift the cost to Americans if they want to stay protected from COVID-19. Increased Drug Costs President Trump has announced an intent to impose tariffs in the range of 25-200% on pharmaceuticals to incentivize drug production in the United States. If implemented, this policy would be problematic since 80 percent of generic tablets consumed by Americans are manufactured outside the U.S. according to The Hill. Even a 25% tariff would increase U.S. drug prices by nearly $51 billion. This, of course, would have devastating consequences for millions of Americans. Not only would this make healthcare even less affordable than it already is, but health outcomes would deteriorate. Many Americans would forego buying medicines, thereby exacerbating sickness and illness. Nine out of 10 people over the age of 65 rely on prescription drugs to maintain their well-being, according to the American Association of Retired Persons. Although the Trump administration has touted executive actions that seek to improve health transparency and reduce drug costs, the broader legislative and regulatory agenda being imposed will make healthcare significantly less affordable to the average American. Many American families could lose health insurance, face higher premiums and pay greater out-of-pocket costs in the years to come.
San Francisco Chronicle
6 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
No, California is not guaranteed to remain an abortion haven
The sudden closure of five Planned Parenthood clinics in Northern California last week reveals a sad, stark truth: California is not the national 'haven' for abortion rights that it has aspired to be since the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in 2022. No state could be under Republican rule in Washington, or while federal law trumps state law, the Supreme Court majority opposes abortion rights and clinics are reliant on federal money to survive. There are few options to fix this problem, even in California, the world's fourth-largest economy. The state barely covered its budget deficit this year, and it has holes to fill as federal funds for public universities, education, transportation and other sectors were slashed in the recently passed budget. Plus, the state needs federal dollars to help rebuild Los Angeles after the devastating wildfires there earlier this year. Ten million Americans are expected to lose their health insurance because of nearly $1 trillion in Medicaid cuts over the next decade in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, according to the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office. Meanwhile, the wealthiest Americans will receive a disproportionate share of the tax cuts funded by those reductions, according to the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities. 'It's an illustration of the limits on what any state can do (on abortion access) if the federal government is hostile,' said Mary Ziegler, a professor of law at UC Davis and leading scholar on abortion rights. 'It's more of a reminder that there isn't really a real sanctuary. California has limited power over a lot of this.' It is the latest example of how California is in the political crosshairs of what President Donald Trump's former top adviser Steve Bannon famously described as his 'muzzle velocity' philosophy of launching a lot of disruptive policies and spurious attacks simultaneously. California is withering under the incoming fire. The people hurt most by the closure of those clinics will be the poorest Californians, as 80% of the people who used services at those clinics were Medicaid recipients, according to Planned Parenthood Mar Monte, the umbrella organization for the shuttered clinics. Planned Parenthood doesn't just provide abortion services. The majority of people go to Planned Parenthood clinics for contraceptive services, sexually transmitted infection testing, pregnancy testing and gynecological services. One in 10 (11%) female Medicaid beneficiaries ages 15 to 49 who received family planning services went to a Planned Parenthood clinic in 2021, according to the nonpartisan Kaiser Family Foundation. California has the highest percentage (29%) of Medicaid recipients in the country who go there for health care. This wasn't the way it was supposed to go. California was supposed to be a haven for abortion rights after the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade. Shortly after the decision, Gov. Gavin Newsom joined the governors of Washington and Oregon to create what he called 'the West Coast offensive. A road map for other states to stand up for women.' A diverse coalition of abortion rights advocates formed the California Future of Abortion Council. It proposed more than 50 recommendations for policymakers to improve abortion access in the state. In the year after the decision, Newsom and the Democratic-controlled Legislature created more than a dozen new laws and invested more than $200 million to increase access across the state. In November 2022, 67% of California voters supported a ballot measure enshrining abortion rights in the state Constitution. Newsom spent $100,000 from his campaign coffers to plant billboards in seven states with some of the nation's most restrictive laws: 'Need an abortion?' reads one billboard. 'California is here to help.' 'What you do in California sets the standard for everyone else,' Mini Timmaraju, national president of NARAL Pro-Choice America, said at a 2022 fundraiser for Proposition 1 in San Francisco that Hillary Clinton attended. 'I want to take that package of legislation and this proposition and see it copied nationwide.' Ultimately, all those California laws and all that state funding weren't enough to keep the Mar Monte clinics open. They never could be as long as there isn't the national right to an abortion that Roe provided and as long as women's health clinics are reliant on federal funds to remain open. Planned Parenthood estimates that 200 clinics nationwide could close. To meet this reality, California needs a new 'West Coast offensive.' It needs to draw up a new 'road map for other states to stand up for women.' It would be best if clinics were funded privately, insulating them from partisan federal cuts. But that is harder now. California is the state with the most millionaires and billionaires. Now is the time for wealthy individuals and foundations to stand up and backfill these losses so clinics can continue to provide access to women's health care. But will those individuals step forward? Or will they be cowed like the wealthy law firms and Ivy League universities that have bowed to Trump's intimidation? Even if they do step up, is there enough private money in California to keep federally funded women's health clinics open until Democrats regain control of at least one lever of power in Washington and can curb his fascistic policies? That possibility looks bleak. For starters, it would probably require hundreds of millions of dollars, said Shannon Olivieri Hovis, former NARAL Pro-Choice California director who is now vice president of public affairs at Essential Access Health. 'I think the honest answer is, we don't know yet. We're talking about a huge hole.' Theresa Cheng, a professor of emergency medicine at UCSF and a member of the school's Bixby Center for Global Reproductive Health, said it will be difficult for the private sector to patch up all the new holes punctured in the social safety net by the Trump administration. 'That's going to be really difficult because the Trump administration has cut so broadly in so many social systems,' said Cheng, who is in touch with private donors through her work with several nonprofit organizations. 'Food insecurity. Homelessness. Immigration. There are a lot of needs out there now.' Relying on private donations isn't going to help clinics across California's chasm of wealth inequality, Ziegler said. 'If you're depending partly on individual donors, that's going to look very different in Beverly Hills or Marin County than it is in Gilroy or other areas where there are few people to give private donations,' Ziegler said. Until political change happens in Washington, Cheng urged Californians to 'stay stalwart in protecting reproductive health. So much of this will have to be settled out in the courts. That will at least buy us some more time.'
Time Business News
8 hours ago
- Time Business News
Building Bridges: The Power of Public Relations in Modern Marketing
In today's fast-moving digital world, public relations marketing plays a big role in how companies connect with people. Whether it's a small business or a large healthcare provider, using PR (public relations) in marketing helps build trust and strong relationships. It's like building a bridge between the company and the public. This is especially true in industries like healthcare and dentistry, where people need to trust the services being offered. One great example is how Medicaid offers dental benefits for children and how spreading that information can benefit families through smart public relations marketing. Public relations marketing is the mix of public relations (PR) and marketing strategies to promote a brand, product, or service. PR focuses on building a good image and trust with the public, while marketing aims to sell or promote services and products. When used together, they create a powerful message that reaches more people and builds stronger relationships. For example, a dentist can use PR to show how they help low-income families through Medicaid. Then, they can use marketing tools like social media and flyers to spread that message even more. This creates a full circle where trust and promotion work together. People today are smarter buyers. They search for information, read reviews, and ask others before choosing a service. That's where public relations marketing becomes important. It helps build a brand's image by showing honesty, care, and value. In the case of dental services, showing how a clinic helps children through Medicaid dental benefits builds trust with families. Good PR helps answer questions like: Is this service reliable?Do they care about my needs?Are they helping the community? When people believe in the answers, they are more likely to choose that service. Medicaid is a government health program that helps low-income families, especially children. When it comes to dental care, Medicaid covers dental services for all child enrollees as part of a complete set of benefits. These benefits are called Early and Periodic Screening, Diagnostic and Treatment (EPSDT). Here's what EPSDT means: Early: Finding health problems Regular Checking for issues before they become Understanding what's wrong. Treatment: Getting the right care. This means children under Medicaid can get dental checkups, cleanings, fillings, and even emergency treatments when needed. It's a full package to make sure children have healthy teeth and gums. Many families don't know they qualify for free dental care under Medicaid. This is where public relations marketing becomes powerful. Dental clinics and government programs can work together to spread this message. They can use local newspapers, school events, or community centers to educate parents. Here are a few ways to promote this using PR marketing: Success Stories: Share real stories of children whose health improved with Medicaid dental Events: Offer free dental checkups and talk to families about their Releases: Send news updates to local media about new Medicaid programs or Media Campaigns: Use platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube to reach more people. By doing this, more families will understand their options and trust the clinics that care about their health. One of the biggest challenges in healthcare is the communication gap. Patients may not understand what services are available, or they may not trust providers. Public relations marketing helps fix this by building clear and caring communication. For dentists and clinics working with Medicaid, the goal should be to explain:What services are free or to apply for to go for help. This can be done through printed materials, radio ads, school newsletters, or even dental health workshops in local communities. When providers speak clearly and kindly, patients feel more connected and confident. Healthcare is a sensitive field. It's about trust, care, and human connection. That's why public relations marketing is more than just promotion—it's about showing that you care. When dental clinics use PR strategies, they can: Improve their image in the support for families in preventive dental dental emergencies by promoting regular checkups. It's a win-win situation for everyone. Families get the care they need, and clinics build a reputation for being helpful and caring. Today, technology helps public relations grow faster. Clinics can use websites, blogs, and videos to explain Medicaid dental benefits. Online reviews also play a big role in building trust. Tips for using technology in PR marketing: Create Simple Videos: A short video explaining Medicaid dental benefits can reach thousands of people Blog Articles: Share tips for children's dental health and how to use for Reviews: Encourage happy patients to leave reviews on Google or Newsletters: Send regular updates to families about checkup reminders or new services. These digital tools help reach more people in less time and cost less than traditional marketing. Public relations marketing isn't just for big companies. It's a powerful tool for small clinics, especially in healthcare and dentistry. By spreading the word about helpful services like Medicaid's dental benefits for children, providers can create stronger relationships with families in their communities. It's all about building bridges—bridges of trust, care, and understanding. When marketing is done with kindness and clarity, everyone wins. In the world of modern marketing, public relations marketing stands out as a way to build strong and meaningful relationships. By using honest communication, real stories, and smart promotion, clinics and healthcare providers can reach more families and help them get the care they deserve. Medicaid's dental services for children are a perfect example. Many families don't know the benefits that are available to them. Through strong PR marketing, dental providers can spread the word, build trust, and make a real difference in their communities. In the end, public relations is not just about selling—it's about serving. And when service meets strategy, bridges are built that can last a lifetime. TIME BUSINESS NEWS
