
Could Nio's Safety-Certified Yoke Steer-By-Wire be Safer Than Tesla's?
0:00 / 0:00
First Level Redundancy
At this level, all computer controls, communication, and electromechanical controls are duplicated. This much everybody does. Nio also uses separate electrical architecture zones to control the twin communication and power paths, with an independent monitor comparing signals. In the event of a discrepancy, the monitor determines a 'winner.' Nio, and many others offering steer-by wire use a single motor with multiple phases in the winding, wired to the disparate control systems—either of which has sufficient power to steer the vehicle (other systems provide for a fail-safe mechanical shaft connection). There are separate DC-DC converters, separate CAN bus connections, multiple steering torque sensors, and steering-yoke position sensors.
See All 6 Photos
Tesla Rear Steering Rack
Second Level Redundancy
Here's where we believe the Nio approach deviates from Tesla's in following aviation's lead. The separate zones and their communications networks were developed by different teams and sourced from different suppliers whenever possible. This helps minimize the chance of a common failure mode or use-case scenario crippling both systems at the same time.
See All 6 Photos
Tesla Cybertruck showing front and rear tires at max turning angle.
Third Level Redundancy
In an absolute worst-case scenario when a steering order fails to be executed by either of these disparate control, communication, and execution systems, the computer is programmed to utilize other approaches to execute the intended steering request. This can include activating the rear steering (which the ET9 and Cybertruck are both equipped with), and/or heavily braking one or both inside wheels on the side in which the car is intended to steer.
See All 6 Photos
Nio ET9 luxury sedan steering wheel.
Measuring Results
During the lengthy development of the Nio ET9's steering system, the company and the homologation reps from the government considered the job done when recorded failures could be measured in events-per-trillion-hours of operation. We're eager to learn more about the various layers of redundancy Tesla employs, and we'd love to know how Tesla's system would fare if subjected to this same new Chinese homologation testing, but for now the Cybertruck's form factor is disallowed in China.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
22 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Is Now a Good Time To Invest in Uber? Here's What Experts Say
Uber Technologies has been one of the best stocks on Wall Street so far in 2025, with shares rising by about 50% year-to-date to far outpace the broader markets. I'm a Financial Advisor: Read Next: The rideshare company's stock hit a record high of $97.71 in early July. Some analysts see the price reaching $120 by year's end — meaning it could be a good time to invest in Uber. Much of the optimism is based on Uber's strong financial results, which include double-digit revenue growth and a continued uptick in bookings. 'A Real Business' One expert with a positive take on Uber is Edward Corona, a Florida-based trader and publisher of The Options Oracle Newsletter. He's targeting a $107 stock price for the rest of the year as long as the company's current positive trends hold. 'Uber is finally acting like a real business — free cash flow is solid, margins are improving, and they've become the default app for way more than just rides,' Corona told GOBankingRates. Although Uber faces a competitive risk from Tesla's robotaxi, Corona calls that a '2026 problem.' For now, Uber's stock chart has 'been in a steady uptrend, and I like it long here,' he added. How To Turn $100K Into a Million: Is Now A Good Time To Buy? Most experts are upbeat about Uber and recommend buying the stock. The vast majority of analysts polled by MarketWatch — 41 out of 57 — have a 'Buy' rating on the stock. The others rate it either 'Overweight' (4 analysts) or 'Hold' (12). As of July 23, the consensus rating is 'Buy' and the average target price is $101.10. A recent analysis from Motley Fool recommended buying Uber shares 'like there's no tomorrow' and cited the following company strengths: Strong revenue growth driven by double-digit increases in gross bookings for mobility and delivery. Competitive advantages from Uber's 'network effect' and ability to leverage 'vast amounts of data.' Although Uber already operates in more than 15,000 cities worldwide, it's still 'not even close' to reaching its full potential. The stock price is still relatively affordable at less than $100 a share. Among the analysts with a particularly bullish take on Uber is Ken Gawrelski of Wells Fargo. As AInvest noted, Gawrelsk recently maintained his 'Overweight' rating on the stock, and raised his price target to $120 from $100. More From GOBankingRates Are You Rich or Middle Class? 8 Ways To Tell That Go Beyond Your Paycheck This article originally appeared on Is Now a Good Time To Invest in Uber? Here's What Experts Say Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data


Forbes
an hour ago
- Forbes
The All-New Tesla Model Coming Soon Is Not What You Think
A new Model Y driving in LA (Photo by MEGA/GC Images) So, is there a new, more affordable Tesla in the pipeline? Apparently yes, and it's not what you think. Last week, on a second-quarter Tesla earnings call, the man himself, Elon Musk let the cat out of the bag when he said, 'It's just a Model Y.' Really? What does that mean? Could it mean that it's just a stripped down Model Y? And what about the future of the federal tax credit? Let's face it: Tesla is the only American automaker capable of producing a high-end, realistic, appealing electric vehicle for less than $30,000. And if they have to bring the car back to bare bones to make it sell, then that's what they'll do, apparently. People just don't have enough money to buy Teslas now Musk expanded by saying that, 'The desire to buy our cars is very high. It's just that people don't have enough money in the bank to buy them. That's the issue. So the more affordable we can make the car th Tesla CEO Elon Musk says new car is Model Y. (Photo by Odd ANDERSEN / AFP) (Photo by ODD ... More ANDERSEN/AFP via Getty Images) Then he revealed how potential buyers can possibly offset the purchase price of their car by 'releasing their car to the fleet and have it earn money for them,' suggesting that people may 'lend' their cars back to Tesla in a type of robotaxi relationship perhaps. Musk then went out on a limb by saying he's confident that 'I think this will happen next year in the U.S. at least.' His comments though raise more questions than provide answers. By saying 'it's just a Model Y,' does he mean a 'new' Y with upgraded parts but based on the old platform, which would help to keep costs down? What we do know is that the more affordable Model Y, as referred to by Musk, should be surfacing in Q4 this year. But that will be long after the $7,500 federal tax credit ends—which will make it even tougher for Tesla to get the price down to the sub-$30,000 level that Musk seems to be alluring to. Let's have a quick look at Tesla's current pricing. Today, the Model Y rear-wheel drive variant costs $44,990, which when you factor in the $7,500, drops the price to $37,490. But with that tax credit gone, and we expect it to disappear very soon under the Trump Administration, the price for a current model Y will hover around $44,000. So for Musk to achieve his goal of achieving a sub-$30,000, he will need to find $15,000 worth of savings in specs and features. The question is—which features to strip back? If it's going to be used as some kind of robotaxi, then it will need all of its AutoPilot features. And given that the Y has been rated as one of the safest on the road by Euro NCAP, ANCAP and IIHS, Tesla would not want to skimp on safety features in any way—which would make it difficult to reduce pricing. But Musk has pushed the boundaries of car tech in the past and redefined the genre, so we will give him some latitude and wait for further updates even if his car sales are hurting all over the planet.

Engadget
an hour ago
- Engadget
China calls for the creation of a global AI organization
China wants to work with other countries and has laid out its plans for the global governance of artificial intelligence at the World Artificial Intelligence Conference (WAIC) in Shanghai. Li Qiang, the country's premier, warned about "technological monopolies" and said that AI could become "an exclusive game for a few countries and companies." As such, he proposed the creation of a "world AI cooperation organization" during the event. Li didn't specifically mention the United States when he talked about monopolies, but the US restricts AI chip exports to his country. NVIDIA had to develop chips that are only meant for China and conform to export rules so it wouldn't lose the Chinese market completely. Meanwhile, Chinese companies like Huawei are developing their own AI systems to make up for China's lack of access to more advanced AI chips from American firms. Li also made the statement a few days after the Trump administration revealed its AI Action Plan, which seeks to limit state regulation of AI companies and which aims to ensure that the US can beat China in the AI race. The Chinese premier said his country would "actively promote" the development of open source artificial intelligence and that China is "willing to provide more Chinese solutions to the international community" when it comes to AI. He also said that his country was eager to share AI technologies with developing countries in the global south. "Currently, overall global AI governance is still fragmented. Countries have great differences, particularly in terms of areas such as regulatory concepts [and] institutional rules," Li said. "We should strengthen coordination to form a global AI governance framework that has broad consensus as soon as possible."