Committee urges action from Scottish and UK governments to save Alexander Dennis
Holyrood's Economy and Fair Work Committee urged the administrations north and south of the border to do all they can to stop the closure of Alexander Dennis in Scotland.
Some 400 workers are at risk of redundancy as the company proposes moving its manufacturing from Falkirk and Larbert to Scarborough in North Yorkshire.
Colin Smyth, the Labour MSP who convenes the committee, has written to Finance Secretary Shona Robison and Scottish Secretary Ian Murray asking them to set out their plans to save the jobs and wider industry.
He said the loss of so many highly-skilled job would be 'devastating' to the local community and country as a whole.
'The committee is clear that the situation is so serious that every possible effort must be made to retain these jobs in Scotland,' he told Ms Robison.
Alexander Dennis has said it needs up to 100 bus orders this year and up to 400 next year to avoid the closure of its factories in Scotland.
Mr Smyth urged the Finance Secretary to explain what she is doing to bring new orders forward and stimulate demand for the sector.
He urged Ms Robison to strengthen procurement to ensure that local firms are prioritised.
The SNP has come under fire from opposition politicians for the number of Scottish buses being built in countries like China, rather than at home, which they say has contributed to the company's decision to move to England.
Mr Smyth also expressed concerns around reports that £20 million in support from Scottish Enterprise for Alexander Dennis to research and develop net-zero buses may no longer result in any vehicles being built in the country.
The committee has written separately to Scottish Enterprise over the funding.
He said to Ms Robison: 'Given the strategic importance of Alexander Dennis, the high quality of its workforce and the role of manufacturing in Scotland's future economy, it is vital that every possible action is taken to retain manufacturing, and the jobs it provides.
'The committee urges the Scottish Government to do all it can, working with partners at every level, to secure a positive outcome.
'Ministers must act with urgency and ambition to help keep these jobs and avoid a world-class manufacturer shutting its doors in Scotland.'
In his letter to the Scottish Secretary, the committee convener described Alexander Dennis's potential loss as 'deeply concerning'.
He said co-operation between Westminster and Holyrood would be 'essential if a viable and sustainable future is to be secured for bus manufacturing in Scotland'.
He added: 'I know you agree that the potential end of bus manufacturing in Scotland — with the direct loss of 400 jobs and further losses across the domestic supply chain—would be devastating for the area and for Scotland.
'This is all the more concerning given the growing UK and European demand for buses to support climate, transport, and industrial goals.'
He said that while a cross-governmental working group on the issue has already met several times, it was 'clear that urgent decisions are required' as the the redundancy consolation process is set to wrap up on August 15 – something that has already been extended by two weeks.
Mr Smyth again raised concerns around the procurement process, saying: 'During our evidence sessions, the Committee heard concerns that, in practice, local content is not being adequately recognised or prioritised in the tendering process.'
He added: 'The committee understands that the UK Subsidy Control Act does allow social value to be considered when evaluating bids, enables direct awards, and permits some differential treatment in awarding subsidies.'
And he asked Mr Murray to set out what action the UK Government is taking to ensure to ensure domestic manufacturing is prioritised.
He said: 'Given the scale of potential job losses in Scotland, the importance of maintaining a strong manufacturing base in the UK, and the proven capability of the workforce at Alexander Dennis Ltd, the Committee believes that urgent and coordinated action is essential.
'We therefore urge the UK Government to use every lever at its disposal – particularly through procurement, investment, and industrial strategy — to help secure a future for bus manufacturing in Scotland and protect these skilled jobs.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
7 hours ago
- Times
Ferguson chief says shipyard needs ferry contract with no competition
The Ferguson shipyard faces a 'very difficult' future unless ministers hand it a ferry replacement contract, the chief executive has warned. Graeme Thomson said he had already lobbied for the Inverclyde yard to be given the mandate to build the successor to MV Lord of the Isles. That vessel normally sails from Lochboisdale on South Uist to the mainland at Mallaig. Fiona Hyslop, the transport secretary, said in April that money was available for a replacement to be built with CMAL, the procurement agency, looking at designs. The yard has been in public hands since 2019 after it ran out of cash building the Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa ferries. Holyrood ministers decided in March this year that they could not legally find a way to directly award Ferguson the work to build seven electric ferries for the small vessels replacement programme and that went to the Polish yard Remontowa. Thomson, who started at Ferguson in May, told the Scottish affairs committee at Westminster that the state-owned yard could not compete on price with overseas rivals. A direct award would mean Ferguson being given the contract without it having to go through procurement. Thomson said he had 'lobbied for a direct award' and believed the Scottish government was considering whether it was possible. He said: 'I'm not aware of what might be challenges or blockers to that.' Asked by MPs what the future might hold if the yard did not win that contract, he said: 'It would be very difficult for us and very challenging.' Thomson argued there was a need to give UK yards a better chance to win domestic work with about 150 non-navy vessels due to be built over the next 30 years. He said: 'As long as there is a situation that international yards can do it cheaper than us, whether because of labour rates or tax breaks, then we will never be playing on a level playing field. We need to move the conversation away from a race to the bottom on price.' Ferguson recently won a contract from BAE Systems to build structural steel blocks for HMS Birmingham as part of the Type 26 programme. Thomson is hopeful that the scope of work could be expanded in the future, while it is also looking into bids to build pilot boats and tugs. He said: 'If the portfolio starts with smaller boats, then we get back into larger boats, then I'm very content we would protect as much of the workforce as we can.' Thomson told MPs he was confident that Glen Rosa, which is already seven years late and vastly over budget, would be ready for handover in the second quarter of next year. Separately, Shona Robison, the finance secretary, said that the Scottish government continued to talk with bus operators and transport authorities to establish demand levels for double-decker buses as part of its efforts to find a future for Alexander Dennis. The bus builder is proposing to shut its Scottish manufacturing division, with 400 jobs at risk across Falkirk and Larbert.
The Independent
8 hours ago
- The Independent
Why Trump's Scotland golf course won't get the Open anytime soon
Donald Trump 's Turnberry golf course will not host the British Open in the near future, according to the R&A's new chief executive, Mark Darbon. The primary reasons for Turnberry not hosting are significant logistical challenges, including transportation and infrastructure issues, rather than political considerations. Turnberry has not been removed from the list of potential British Open venues, and the R&A has held constructive discussions with Trump Golf representatives. The R&A maintains that the decision on where to stage the Open rests solely with them, independent of any influence from the British government. The R&A prioritises courses capable of accommodating large crowds and modern Open requirements, a factor also affecting other Scottish courses like Muirfield.
The Independent
9 hours ago
- The Independent
Trump's Turnberry course in Scotland faces issues ahead of British Open return
Donald Trump 's Turnberry golf course will not host the British Open in the near future, with the R&A's new chief executive, Mark Darbon, stating that logistical challenges, rather than political considerations, are the primary obstacle. Turnberry, widely regarded as one of the most picturesque links courses on the Open rotation, is situated along the Ayrshire coast in Scotland, opposite the iconic Ailsa Craig. It last staged the Open in 2009, prior to Mr Trump's acquisition of the resort. Mr Darbon, who succeeded Martin Slumbers at the R&A this year, clarified that Turnberry has not been removed from the list of potential British Open venues. However, significant transportation and other infrastructure issues must be addressed. "I think we've been extremely clear on our position in respect of Turnberry. We love the golf course but we've got some big logistical challenges there," he explained. "You see the scale of their setup here and we've got some work to do on the road, rail and accommodation infrastructure around Turnberry." Mr Darbon confirmed that the R&A held constructive discussions with Eric Trump and other leaders from Trump Golf a few months ago. "I think they understand clearly where we're coming from. We talked through some of the challenges that we have so we've got a good dialogue with them," he added. This follows previous comments from Mr Slumbers, who indicated the R&A would not return to Turnberry until the focus was solely on golf, rather than the owner. Despite speculation that Donald Trump might seek intervention from the British government to bring the Open back to Turnberry, Mr Darbon stated that the decision rests with the R&A. "We have an ongoing dialogue with the UK government given that we're a major event that creates significant value into the UK economy," he said. "We've spoken to them specifically about Turnberry and I think they've made it clear that the decision around where we take our championship rests with us." He added: "I would find it difficult to predict whether there will be any discussion on The Open if the President is making a visit here." Turnberry has only hosted the British Open four times, notably the 1977 "Duel in the Sun" between Tom Watson and Jack Nicklaus. However, the Open has grown considerably, and the existing road infrastructure around Turnberry is limited. Turnberry is not the only Scottish links course currently overlooked by the R&A. Muirfield, located along the Firth of Forth east of Edinburgh, is considered one of the purest links courses, having hosted 15 Opens since 1892, most recently in 2013. Only St Andrews has hosted more Opens. However, Muirfield has not been revisited since 2013 as the R&A prioritises courses capable of accommodating large crowds. While 142,000 spectators attended the last Open at Muirfield, Royal Portrush is expected to draw 278,000 this week, second only to St Andrews in attendance figures. The Open will head to Royal Birkdale next year, followed by St Andrews in 2027, with the 2028 venue yet to be announced. Muirfield has historically never gone more than 11 years between Opens, excluding wartime interruptions. "We love the golf course at Muirfield. We're in a discussion with the venue right now," Mr Darbon confirmed. "There's some things that we need to evolve at Muirfield — the practice ground in particular is a challenge for us with a modern Open and there's some work we need to do with the venue to facilitate some of the infrastructure that we require. But it's a good dialogue and we'd love to be back there in the future." ___
