logo
Most education reformers have no idea what parents and kids want — and they don't care

Most education reformers have no idea what parents and kids want — and they don't care

The Hill2 days ago
Most education reformers — especially those interested in low-income communities — rightly focus on the needs and interests of students, whether they are discussing short-term outcomes like standardized testing results, or longer term results like rates of college acceptance and graduation.
But the most important question they should be asking is: What do the parents in these communities want for their children? What do their extended family, mentors and pastors want?
Unfortunately, even the best-intentioned reformers rarely entertain this question.
Parents are the most important stakeholders in matters of education after the children themselves, yet reformers' ideological and emotional interests consistently take precedence over those of the parents and the local community.
All too often, the education of poor or marginalized children gets lost in ideological battles between groups of elites who are completely removed from the communities they purport to defend.
Elitist social justice initiatives — such as tossing out commonsense academic and behavioral standards because of supposed racial justice concerns — are a prime example of this 'soft bigotry of low expectations.' Is it acceptable to lower standards for certain children even if their parents want them to be held to a higher standard?
Respect and consideration of parental priorities is one of the major reasons that indigenous, community-oriented and community-generated educational projects produce objectively excellent and even superior outcomes to top-down interventions from reformers outside the community.
Take the Rosenwald schools: Booker T. Washington of the Tuskegee Institute and Julius Rosenwald, then-president of Sears Roebuck, joined to create one of the most remarkable educational successes of American history — yet remarkably few people know that they ever existed.
Noting the dire lack of funding for education of Black children in the Jim Crow-era South, the Rosenwald Fund contributed $4.3 million — matched and exceeded by $4.7 million raised by Black communities themselves — to build over 5,000 schools, shops and associated homes across the segregated South.
The Rosenwald schools were both very successful and indigenous projects: The seed money empowered local men, women and children to narrow the racial literacy gap in the Jim Crow-era American South by a stunning 40 percent. Within a generation, a three-year racial education gap shrank to well under a year. These highly localized, community-driven projects succeeded in the face of widespread, bitter discrimination.
A modern-day example of indigenously led excellence can be seen in the Piney Woods School, a challenging preparatory school serving underprivileged children that was founded by Laurence Clifton Jones in 1909.
Piney Woods serves a student body that wouldn't otherwise have access to a high-quality education, and relies largely on the generosity of donors to fund the scholarships for many of those who attend.
But these kids, and their families, don't want a handout. They don't want low expectations. They want a challenge. And a challenge is what they receive. The school emphasizes self-responsibility, self-government and empowerment from within the communities and families it serves rather than from outside or 'above' them.
Every student commits to working an on-campus job — in fact, the bulk of the campus buildings were built by students themselves. And their families donate or contribute to the school. They aren't looking to be accommodated or coddled. They don't want to be excused, and never have — even in the face of clear racism.
There is a cautionary tale of reform, however, and it is the charter school movement. Charter schools are an increasingly common and often promising mode of educational reform, but they often flounder on the simple fact that reformers eventually rely on politics, rather than community interests, to guide their decisions.
Former inner-city public school teacher Robert Pondiscio, in his recent review of Steve Wilson's book 'The Lost Decade,' briefly recounts the rise and fall of the 'no excuses' charter school model.
In its ascendant years, the model allowed urban and underprivileged students to excel beyond anyone's expectations. But then it failed, catastrophically, under the growing weight of social justice culture.
The schools that offered an irreplaceable chance at academic excellence — and long-term professional success — to Black students all over the country were sabotaged by the anxieties of political elites locked in pointless ideological battles over 'whiteness.' White guilt became more important than Black excellence.
These charter schools abandoned the 'no excuses' standards that had helped lift students up from disadvantaged backgrounds as outdated or racist, replacing them with 'equity' initiatives that are leading today to low scores and low achievement. But no one asked the community leaders, who stand to gain or lose the most, if they were on board with these changes.
Parents are stakeholders. Children are stakeholders. Siblings, aunts and uncles, mentors, pastors — anyone invested in these kids' lives are stakeholders. And that is the only real safeguard that communities have here: direct participation in and influence over the well-being of the children.
If we want to build a more just society, we can and should begin by abandoning the top-down, ideologically-motivated model of educational reform. We must stop letting the elites destroy the strongest chance our most vulnerable children have at improving their station in life.
Indigenous projects are the very best of our past — and they will be the very best of our future.
Bob Woodson is the founder and president of the Woodson Center, and editor of the book ' A Pathway to American Renewal: Red, White, and Black Vol II. ' Will Crossley is the executive vice president of the Woodson Center and president of the Piney Woods School.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

RFK Jr. cuts $500 million in mRNA vaccine contracts, dealing major blow to promising area of research
RFK Jr. cuts $500 million in mRNA vaccine contracts, dealing major blow to promising area of research

NBC News

time43 minutes ago

  • NBC News

RFK Jr. cuts $500 million in mRNA vaccine contracts, dealing major blow to promising area of research

The Trump administration is terminating 22 contracts focused on developing mRNA vaccines and winding down additional federal investments in mRNA technology, Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. announced Tuesday. Many scientists and infectious disease experts swiftly denounced the move as a broadside on an area of research seen as particularly promising after its use in rapidly developing Covid vaccines. The projects that are being axed were funded by the Biomedical Advanced Research and Development Authority (BARDA), a Department of Health and Human Services program that works with the pharmaceutical industry to develop vaccines and other countermeasures for public health emergencies. 'This isn't just about vaccines,' Rick Bright, who directed BARDA from 2016 to 2020, said in a text message. 'It's about whether we'll be ready when the next crisis hits. Cutting mRNA development now puts every American at greater risk.' 'The Covid pandemic showed us what's possible when science moves fast,' he added. 'Dismantling that momentum now is like disbanding the fire department because the fire's out.' Kennedy said Tuesday that the terminated contracts were worth nearly $500 million. Among them is an award to the University of Texas Medical Branch and the biotechnology company Moderna to develop an mRNA-based vaccine for H5N1, the strain of bird flu that has infected dozens of people in the United States. "After reviewing the science and consulting top experts at NIH and FDA, HHS has determined that mRNA technology poses more risks and benefits for these respiratory viruses," Kennedy said in a video announcement on X. "Let me be absolutely clear, HHS supports safe, effective vaccines for every American who wants them," he added. "That's why we're moving beyond the limitations of mRNA for respiratory viruses and investing in better solutions." The move adds to mounting evidence that Kennedy, a high-profile figure in the anti-vaccine movement who softened his rhetoric after the presidential election and in confirmation hearings, is pursuing an aggressive anti-vaccine agenda that includes gutting a crucial vaccine advisory committee and cutting $2 billion from a program that supports vaccines for vulnerable children. Kennedy has referred to Covid shots as the 'deadliest vaccine ever made,' a claim contradicted by reams of studies that have found them to be safe. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention estimates the vaccines saved more than 200,000 lives in the United States and prevented more than 1.5 million hospitalizations in the first 10 months they were available. Many pharmaceutical companies have prioritized mRNA research because the platform can easily be updated to target new viruses or variants, and scientists see it as an important tool to prepare for future pandemics. But mRNA technology has become a primary target for anti-vaccine activists who have argued — despite ongoing and sizable research — that it represents a massive safety threat. Children's Health Defense, the anti-vaccine group founded by Kennedy, applauded defunding mRNA vaccine projects under BARDA on Tuesday. "While we believe that the mRNA shots on the market are unsafe and should be off the market, this is a welcome step in the right direction. The pandemic preparedness industry as it exists today is a threat to human welfare," CEO Mary Holland said in a statement on X. In his announcement Tuesday, Kennedy suggested that mRNA vaccines fail to sufficiently protect against Covid and flu, that they can be rendered ineffective by a single mutation and that they can even prolong pandemics. But infectious disease and vaccine experts said he grossly mischaracterizes the science. "That's exactly why mRNA is so valuable: It's the only platform where you can actually update the vaccine really quickly," said Dr. Jake Scott, an infectious disease specialist at Stanford Medicine. Terminating mRNA contracts under BARDA is "a very misguided, irresponsible and I would say reckless move," Scott said. "It really does reveal a fundamental misunderstanding of how vaccines work and how a vaccine against a respiratory virus in particular should be expected to work." Kennedy said Tuesday that the BARDA funding would be shifted 'toward safer, broader vaccine platforms that remain effective even as viruses mutate," such as whole-virus vaccines, which use weakened or deactivated versions of viruses to trigger immune responses.

Administrator Loeffler Leads Presidential Delegation to the Republic of Poland
Administrator Loeffler Leads Presidential Delegation to the Republic of Poland

Business Upturn

timean hour ago

  • Business Upturn

Administrator Loeffler Leads Presidential Delegation to the Republic of Poland

By GlobeNewswire Published on August 6, 2025, 04:20 IST Washington, Aug. 05, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — Today, President Donald J. Trump announced that U.S. Small Business Administration (SBA) Administrator Kelly Loeffler will lead a Presidential Delegation to the Republic of Poland to attend the inauguration of Polish President-Elect Karol Nawrocki. In addition to attending the inaugural ceremonies, the Delegation will meet with key senior counterparts to reinforce the United States' steadfast commitment to advancing joint security priorities and expanding economic opportunity. 'It is an honor to lead the U.S. Delegation to Poland on behalf of President Donald J. Trump for the inauguration of President-Elect Karol Nawrocki,' said Administrator Loeffler. 'This occasion celebrates Poland's commitment to freedom and independence while reinforcing the strong bilateral partnership of our two nations. I look forward to deepening America's strategic alliance with the Republic of Poland and to affirming our shared commitment to economic prosperity and national security.' This visit is Administrator Loeffler's second trip as part of a Presidential Delegation. In 2019, President Trump designated Administrator Loeffler to the U.S. Presidential Delegation to the FIFA Women's World Cup in France. About the U.S. Small Business Administration The U.S. Small Business Administration helps power the American dream of entrepreneurship. As the leading voice for small businesses within the federal government, the SBA empowers job creators with the resources and support they need to start, grow, and expand their businesses or recover from a declared disaster. It delivers services through an extensive network of SBA field offices and partnerships with public and private organizations. To learn more, visit Disclaimer: The above press release comes to you under an arrangement with GlobeNewswire. Business Upturn takes no editorial responsibility for the same. Ahmedabad Plane Crash GlobeNewswire provides press release distribution services globally, with substantial operations in North America and Europe.

Heritage groups accuse Zohran Mamdani of Italian-American ‘hate' over Columbus stance
Heritage groups accuse Zohran Mamdani of Italian-American ‘hate' over Columbus stance

New York Post

time2 hours ago

  • New York Post

Heritage groups accuse Zohran Mamdani of Italian-American ‘hate' over Columbus stance

Democratic socialist mayoral nominee Zohran Mamdani was accused of Italian-American 'hate' after he called to tear down Christopher Columbus statues. The Columbus Heritage Coalition — which includes 40 Italian-American groups — referenced a resurfaced 2020 Mamdani tweet showing him giving the middle finger to a Columbus statue in Astoria and declaring 'take it down.' 'By now it should be obvious to all people of good will that Italian-Americans have zero tolerance for hate,' Angelo Vivolo, president of the coalition said in the scathing statement obtained by The Post. 'So why does the Democratic candidate for mayor hate us and our heritage? Advertisement 3 The Columbus Heritage Coalition has accused Democratic mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani of Italian-American 'hate' over his calls to tear down statues of Christopher Columbus. Matthew McDermott 'For those who are late to this most recent outrage, candidate Zohran Mamdani is prominently and publicly expressing his hatred in a most crude and clear manner for all to see on social media.' The statement accused Mamdani, a Queens Assemblyman and frontrunner to win the mayoralty in November, of insisting on his 'right' to hate and those who disagree must bend to 'his view of who we are.' Advertisement In recent years, the famous Italian explorer has come under fire for resorting to violence and slavery and the forced conversion of native peoples to Christianity during his voyages some five centuries ago. Columbus Day, a federal holiday, is still widely celebrated across the US but each year, more and more municipalities are opting to celebrate Indigenous Peoples' Day instead or at least, commemorate both occasions on the same day. 'Zohran Mamdani supports the destruction of memorials honoring the singular achievements of Christopher Columbus, and he supports terminating Columbus Day, a longtime national holiday,' Vivolo said. 3 Mamdani posted a picture of himself giving a Columbus statue the middle finger in 2020. Zohran Mamdani/X Advertisement 'These are symbols that hold deep meaning for many, especially within the Italian-American community,' he went on. 'His divisive rhetoric and polarizing ideology threaten to deepen the fractures in our city at a time when unity and pragmatic leadership are desperately needed.' He also accused Mamdani — who supports the boycott, divestment and sanctions movement against Israel — of fueling the rise of antisemitism by refusing to denounce the controversial phrase 'globalize the intifada' — a rallying cry many believe calls for violence against Jews. Following criticism, Mamdani recently said he would 'discourage' the use of the term. Advertisement 'You may disagree with actions by countries,' Vivolo said. 'But discrimination against people from those countries who live here is an entirely different matter. Our great and diverse city can only succeed if we are respectful and tolerant of racial, religious and ethnic differences. 'When you offend one ethnicity, one religion, one race, you offend all.' The letter urges Mamdani to 'drop the hate, retract his hurtful remarks, curb his divisive behavior and reach out to all constituencies.' 3 Angelo Vivolo, president of Columbus Heritage Coalition, said Mamdani's rhetoric on Columbus will 'deepen the fractures in our city.' Christopher Sadowski 'If not, Italian-Americans and all informed, thoughtful voters will see the dangers of a Mamdani administration and instead rally behind a candidate committed to practical solutions, shared values, and a genuine desire to improve life for every New Yorker,' Vivolo said. The Italian-American leaders met recently to discuss Mamdani's opposition to honoring Columbus. Mamdani's campaign didn't immediately respond to a request for comment. Mamdani convincingly won a ranked-choice Democratic Party primary in June but will still face In November Republican Curtis Sliwa as well as former Gov. Andrew Cuomo and current Mayor Eric Adams, who are running as independents.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store