Watchdog rebukes government for blocking Times FoI request
Internal correspondence showed staff at the Attorney General's Office (AGO), the government's legal advisory office, had intervened to 'maximise the delay' in having to disclose how often the former minister Suella Braverman had forwarded official correspondence to private email addresses.
After a lengthy legal battle, The Times was able to reveal last year that she had done so on 127 occasions, which a former head of the National Cyber Security Centre described as posing a 'clear vulnerability'.
The Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) said it was 'highly concerning behaviour for an organisation with the AGO's role and remit to take this approach', adding that it must take action to ensure requests from journalists are not mishandled in future.
Braverman was later forced out as home secretary for using such private emails by Liz Truss, before being reappointed by Rishi Sunak.
The intervention came as the government was being widely criticised for its approach to transparency.
Last week it was revealed that the government had maintained a superinjunction to prevent disclosure of information about a leak of thousands of names of Afghans who were seeking to flee to the UK for two years, and the efforts to protect those affected, despite the clear public interest in scrutiny.
• Juliet Samuel: Afghan cover-up shows secrecy is addictive
The ICO said the correspondence about Braverman 'strongly implies that the AGO anticipated their refusal would be overturned and aimed to delay the publication of information that it believed it should release under The Freedom of Information Act'.
It said that it 'should not require the commissioner and then the tribunal to instruct them to disclose information which they know they should disclose', which was a 'waste of their own, the commissioner's, the tribunal's and ultimately the taxpayer's limited resources'.
The transparency watchdog further criticised the AGO for allowing senior officials to intervene to water down the response to ensure what was disclosed would not be 'easily quotable in a newspaper', with it being clear that 'the quality of the response the requester received was likely to be affected by their status as a journalist'.
It said it was also of concern, given the role of the AGO in supporting the government's compliance with the law, that staff also revealed the response was written with reference to concerns that 'HO Spads [Home Office special advisers]/No 10 may wish to spin this'.
The internal correspondence, the ICO said, raised concern about 'the underlying culture at the AGO in relation to transparency', concluding that it was 'clearly not in the spirit of the act that a request made at the end of 2022 for information that should have been released at the time does not result in disclosure of information until 2024.'
The AGO was approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
12 minutes ago
- The Independent
Swinney welcomes bringing Gaza children to UK but ‘regrets' it wasn't sooner
First Minister John Swinney has criticised the UK Government for not acting sooner to bring children from Gaza to the UK for medical treatment. Mr Swinney welcomed reported plans that up to 300 children could be flown from Gaza to be treated on the NHS. But he said he regretted the action did not come sooner. The SNP leader said he had written to Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer on July 9 urging such action to be taken. He said: 'We have been consistently clear that the suffering being inflicted on the people of Gaza is beyond any justification. 'People in Gaza are being bombed and left to starve by Israel on a massive scale. 'I wrote to the Prime Minister on 9 July to request support from the UK Government in meeting the call from Unicef to provide medical care for children from Gaza. 'If the UK Government is prepared to evacuate Palestinians for medical treatment it would be entirely welcome. 'My only regret is the UK Government has taken this long to act. 'I urge the UK Government to do everything in its power to move swiftly so that lives can be saved. And Scotland will play our part.' The evacuation plans are reportedly set to be announced within weeks. A parent or guardian will accompany each child, as well as siblings if necessary, and the Home Office will carry out biometric and security checks before travel, the Sunday Times reported. This will happen 'in parallel' with an initiative by Project Pure Hope, a group set up to bring sick and injured Gazan children to the UK privately for treatment. More than 50,000 children are estimated to have been killed or injured in Gaza since October 2023, according to Unicef. Sir Keir said last week that the UK was 'urgently accelerating' efforts to bring children over for treatment. A UK Government spokesperson said: 'We are taking forward plans to evacuate more children from Gaza who require urgent medical care, including bringing them to the UK for specialist treatment where that is the best option for their care. 'We are working at pace to do so as quickly as possible, with further details to be set out in due course.'
Telegraph
12 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Fringe venue ‘breaking law' by letting biological men use women's toilets
Women's rights activists have accused an Edinburgh Fringe venue of breaking the law by allowing biological men to use women's toilets. Underbelly Bristol Square, which is home to multiple small theatres, posted a disclaimer below the sign for the female bathroom telling attendees to 'use whichever toilet best fits your identity or expression'. The men's toilets display a similar disclaimer but individual cubicles appear to still be labelled 'gents'. The accusation comes after the Supreme Court said transgender women are not legally women in a landmark ruling. The ruling by Britain's most senior judges in April prompted new guidance from the Equality and Human Rights Commission, stating that although it is not compulsory for public services to have single-sex facilities such as toilets, it could be indirect sex discrimination against women if the only toilets provided are mixed-sex. The case was brought to the Supreme Court by the gender-critical campaign group For Women Scotland after two Scottish courts rejected its arguments that the Equality Act's definition of a woman was limited to people born biologically female. The photo was posted on social media by Alex McDonald, who said: 'My wife is incredibly upset by this. Maybe @edfringe could act and just remove them before @PoliceScotland get involved.' Mr McDonald added on X: 'Supporters of trans women in women's spaces and sports are generally holders of luxury beliefs; they've never been affected by what they believe in and are too removed from reality and what many people go through to care.' Susan Smith, from For Women Scotland, who brought the gender case to the Supreme Court, told The Telegraph: 'This is plainly unlawful. You can't have a sign like that. You can either have a mixed-sex space or a single-sex space. It's not possible to have both at the same time. It's either one or the other.' 'I think Underbelly is on rocky ground because something could happen in those toilets, like a sexual assault or someone even recording an individual undertaking their business. 'The law isn't optional; it's not something that you can elect to follow or not. 'Underbelly should remove these signs as soon as possible. If they fail to do so, then they could be flouting the law.' Helen Joyce, director of advocacy for human-rights charity Sex Matters, which campaigns for clarity about biological sex, added: 'The For Women Scotland judgment clarified the law concerning permissible sex discrimination in services and employment: it means biology, not paperwork or identity. 'There's no lawful basis for putting up male and female signs – for toilets, changing rooms and so on – and then declaring that you mean something other than sex. 'Organisations that fail to get this right risk enabling sexual harassment and ultimately being sued.' On Sunday, Underbelly Bistro Square included 57 events with genres ranging from children's shows, theatre, comedy, musicals, opera, cabaret and variety. Earlier, pro-Palestinian protesters disrupted a Fringe Festival event featuring John Swinney. The Scottish First Minister was being interviewed on Saturday by comedian Susan Morrison when the event was disrupted five times by six different groups of protesters. They called for an end to funding arms companies through Scottish Enterprise, the Scottish Government's economic agency. Mr Swinney told the crowd: 'I am absolutely aware of the horrors going on in Gaza. 'I use every opportunity to advance the arguments for a ceasefire and to get humanitarian aid and end the suffering of the people of Gaza.'
BreakingNews.ie
12 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
'The working class must take back what is ours': Imagining James Connolly's Ireland
James Connolly is well-known for being a socialist and revolutionary leader in the fight for Irish independence, as well as a champion for the working class. "A revolution will only be achieved when the ordinary people of the world, us, the working class, get up off our knees and take back what is rightfully ours," is one of his famous quotes. Advertisement According to Dictionary of Irish Biography, Connolly arrived at a view that the future for socialism and the working class in Ireland lay in an independent republic rather than in continued union with Britain or in a federal arrangement involving home rule. This was quickly reflected in his and his colleagues' decision to disband the Dublin Socialist Club and to establish in its place the Irish Socialist Republican Party (ISRP). His manifesto for the new party was radical and ahead of its time, calling for free education and child health care, nationalisation of transport and banking, and a commitment to the further extension of public ownership. Connolly spent seven years (1903-1910) in the United States and, during that time, was instrumental in the development of the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) militant labour organisation. Advertisement The group promoted the ideology of revolutionary syndicalism or industrial unionism, recruiting among the huge mass of unskilled and general labour in the USA. Connolly recruited Irish and Italian workers in New York for the IWW. Promoting socialism in Ireland The Dictionary of Irish Biography said Connolly's commitment to promoting socialism among the Irish was evident in his foundation of the Irish Socialist Federation in 1907. It was through its agency that he began to re-establish links with socialists in Ireland, notably with his former ISRP colleague, William O'Brien. By 1908, both he and O'Brien's Dublin socialists were considering the possibility of his coming back to be organiser for the newly emerging Socialist Party of Ireland (SPI). Advertisement The period after his return from the US saw much of the most significant theoretical and practical work of his life. In 1910, he published the important tract Labour, nationality and religion, written to rebut the attacks of the Jesuit Father Kane on socialism and to contest the notion that catholicism and socialism were irreconcilable. In the same year he also brought to publication his most famous work, Labour in Irish History. This was the first substantial exposition of a Marxist interpretation of Irish history. Highly original in some if its findings, the Dictionary of Irish Biography said it argued for the continuity of a radical tradition in Ireland, and sought to debunk nationalist myths about Ireland's past and to expose the inadequacies of middle-class Irish nationalism in providing a solution for Ireland's ills. Advertisement Easter Rising: Connolly the revolutionary During a period of time spent in Belfast, Connolly hoped to inspire union growth and socialist progress, but this agenda was quickly overtaken by the events of the lockout and general strike in Dublin from August 1913. He was summoned to Dublin to assist Larkin in the leadership of this conflict, and, when the struggle was lost and Larkin left for America in 1914, Connolly took over as acting general secretary of the defeated Transport Union. To the disastrous defeat of the locked out and striking workers was now added the calamitous outbreak of world war. This drove Connolly into an advanced nationalist position and, though he never abandoned his socialist commitment, the social revolution took a back seat. The Dictionary of Irish Biography said the growing militancy of Ulster unionist opposition to home rule, the British government's postponement of plans for home rule in the face of unionist opposition, the growing prospect of the partition of Ireland, the outbreak of world war, and the consequent collapse of international socialism, all contributed to his adopting an extreme nationalist stance. Advertisement As he wrote in Forward in March 1914: "The proposal of the Government to consent to the partition of Ireland . . . should be resisted with armed force if necessary." Connolly said that the "carnival of slaughter" that was the world war drove him to incite "war against war", and to make tentative overtures to the revolutionary IRB. By late 1915, his increasing militancy at a time when the IRB had decided on insurrection caused them in turn to approach him; by late January they and he had agreed on a joint uprising. The Transport Union headquarters at Liberty Hall became the headquarters of the Irish Citizen Army as he prepared it for revolt. The Dictionary of Irish Biography pointed out that it was ironic that Connolly, who had always argued that political freedom without socialism was useless, now joined forces with militant nationalists in an insurrection that had nothing to do directly with socialism. It seems that Connolly believed national freedom for Ireland in the circumstances was a necessity before socialism could advance. In the event, he led his small band of about 200 Citizen Army comrades into the Easter Rising of 1916. His Citizen Army joined forces with the Volunteers, as the only army he acknowledged in 1916 was that of 'the Irish Republic'. As commandant general of the Republic's forces in Dublin, he fought side by side with Patrick Pearse in the General Post Office (GPO), until surrendering on April 29th. Connolly was badly injured in the foot, and was court-martialled along with 170 others. He was one of 90 to be sentenced to death, and was the last one of the 15 to be executed by firing squad. He was shot dead, seated on a wooden box, in Kilmainham Gaol on May 12th, 1916. Connolly was buried in the cemetery within Arbour Hill military barracks, and his wife and six of his children survived him. James Connolly's vision for Ireland would make the country a very different place to live in today. While all the participants in the Easter Rising shared the goal of Irish independence, each had their own ideas about what kind of Ireland should emerge afterward. If he had survived and lived beyond 1916, possibly becoming Taoiseach, it is fair to say Connolly's Ireland would be more socialist, secular, and worker-led in structure. He had envisioned a workers' republic where industry and land were publicly owned and democratically managed, and was not just simply fighting for Irish independence, but for the Irish working class.
