ME sufferers 'feel invisible and ignored' as NHS review shows two-thirds more affected
Two-thirds more people are living with debilitating ME than was previously thought, an NHS review has found.
By middle age, women are six times more likely to have developed myalgic Encephalomyelitis (ME) - otherwise known as Chronic Fatigue Syndrome - than men. The little-understood syndrome is the subject of an NHS review following the landmark inquest of Maeve Boothby O'Neill last year. The 27-year-old died unable to speak and malnourished, having begged doctors for help to eat when her body shut down.
A review of NHS data in England indicates that 404,000 people have ME, which can leave sufferers bedbound with extreme fatigue. This is up 62% on the previously accepted figure of 250,000. The analysis by Edinburgh University also found white people are almost five times more likely to be diagnosed than other ethnicities.
Study lead Professor Chris Ponting, of the MRC Human Genetics Unit at the university, said: 'The NHS data shows that getting a diagnosis of ME/CFS in England is a lottery, depending on where you live and your ethnicity. There are nearly 200 GP practices – mostly in deprived areas of the country – that have no recorded ME/CFS patients at all. The data backs up what many people with ME/CFS say - that they feel invisible and ignored.'
ME sufferers have fought resistance from the medical establishment for decades due to a suspicion that the syndrome may be partly psychological. Symptoms have similarities with Long Covid and some suspect a virus may trigger the disease but scientists still do not know how.
The review by Edinburgh University, published in medical journal BMC Public Health, comes after Maeve Boothby O'Neill's death sparked a NHS review of the treatment of ME. Having suffered from ME since she was a teenager, by her mid-20s Maeve was left bedbound, unable to speak and malnourished. She begged for help to eat but doctors were unable to treat her illness. She chose to leave hospital and die in her home "in the care of those she loved" in 2021.
Last October the coroner looking into the death Deborah Archer issued the first ever 'prevention of future deaths report' for ME. She called on Health Secretary Wes Streeting and the NHS to take urgent action to address the "non-existent" care for ME and lack of funding for research.
ME's key feature is called 'post-exertional malaise' and is a delayed dramatic worsening of symptoms following minor physical effort, such as a walk to the shops. Other symptoms include pain, brain fog and extreme energy limitation that does not improve with rest. Causes are unknown and there is currently no diagnostic test or cure.
The analysis of NHS data from 62 million people in England found that lifetime chances of developing ME are up to 0.92% for women and 0.25% for men. Previous lower estimates came from the UK Biobank research project which contains disproportionately more people who are in better health.
Prevalence varied across England with Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly having the highest rates, while North West and North East London reported the lowest. The condition peaked around the age of 50 for women and a decade later for men. Women are six times more likely to have it than men by middle age.
Researcher Gemma Samms, ME Research UK-funded PhD student, said: 'People struggle to get diagnosed with ME/CFS. Diagnosis is important, because it validates their symptoms and enables them to receive recognition and support. Our results should now lead to improved training of medical professionals and further research into accurate diagnostic tests.'
The NHS last year announced an assessment of myalgic encephalomyelitis (ME) services across England after the death of Maeve Boothby O'Neill The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (Nice), which provides advice to improve healthcare, is also re-examining its guidance on feeding support for people with severe ME. Education of medical professionals about patients is also being ramped up.
Andrew Gwynne, the health minister, had pledged to improve research "with the aim of better understanding the causes, identifying new treatments and improving patient outcomes".
The new study was funded by the Government-backed National Institute for Health and Care Research, the Medical Research Council and the charity ME Research UK.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
25 minutes ago
- The Independent
Gut bacteria could help diagnose long Covid and chronic fatigue syndrome, researchers find
Bacteria in the gut could help diagnose long Covid and chronic fatigue syndrome, researchers have found. The debilitating condition, which can cause extreme tiredness, sleep problems, dizziness and brain fog, is often overlooked as there is no specific test to diagnose it. This means doctors have to simply rule out other illnesses. But research published in the journal Nature Medicine has looked at gut bacteria, immune responses and metabolism to find a way of diagnosing the condition. The findings, potentially relevant to long Covid due to its similarity with chronic fatigue syndrome, come from data on 249 individuals analysed using a new artificial intelligence (AI) platform that identifies disease biomarkers from stool, blood, and other routine lab tests. 'Our study achieved 90 per cent accuracy in distinguishing individuals with chronic fatigue syndrome, which is significant because doctors currently lack reliable biomarkers for diagnosis,' said study author Dr Derya Unutmaz, professor in immunology at the Jackson Laboratory in the US. 'Some physicians doubt it as a real disease due to the absence of clear laboratory markers, sometimes attributing it to psychological factors.' It is estimated that 404,000 people in the UK have chronic fatigue syndrome or ME, according to Action for ME. About half of the 1.9 million people in the UK with long Covid are also thought to have symptoms that are similar to ME. Although it is not yet known what causes chronic fatigue syndrome, there is evidence that certain infections, including but not limited to viruses, can trigger the illness. This new research, led by Dr Julia Oh, formerly at the Jackson Laboratory and now a microbiologist and professor at Duke University in North Carolina, investigates how the gut microbiome – the bacteria in your gut – and immune system interact in a patient with chronic fatigue syndrome. To conduct the study, researchers used data collected from the Bateman Horne Center, a leading ME/CFS, long Covid and fibromyalgia research centre in Salt Lake City, Utah. Dr Ruoyun Xiong, also a lead author on the study, developed a research tool called BioMapAI. This tool helped to compare gut bacteria, immune cells, blood test data, and clinical symptoms from 153 patients and 96 healthy participants over four years. Researchers found analysing immune cells proved the most accurate in predicting how severe the participants' symptoms were, but found data from gut bacteria helped predict participants' emotional symptoms and sleep disturbances. They found those with chronic fatigue had lower levels of butyrate, a beneficial fatty acid produced in the gut, along with other nutrients essential for metabolism, inflammation control, and energy. 'Despite diverse data collection methods, common disease signatures emerged in fatty acids, immune markers, and metabolites,' Dr Oh said. 'That tells us this is not random. This is real biological dysregulation. 'Our goal is to build a detailed map of how the immune system interacts with gut bacteria and the chemicals they produce. By connecting these dots, we can start to understand what's driving the disease and pave the way for genuinely precise medicine that has long been out of reach.'
The Guardian
26 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Doctors of my generation support this strike – you don't need a medical degree to see why
So there was no last-minute intervention by Wes Streeting and his team at Whitehall. Resident doctors in England (formerly known as junior doctors) are on the picket line from 7am today until 7am on 30 July, a full five-day walkout. And I'll be joining them, in solidarity. Though I'm a resident doctor by grade, I currently work for NHS England on a freelance (locum) basis, so I'll be supporting my colleagues by electing not to work on the aforementioned days, despite the sauteed carrot of 'enhanced strike rates'. Whenever doctors are engaged in a public pay dispute, our status as 'heroes' is lost to accusations of shirking and self-interest. These attitudes even play out within different generations of doctors. Discussing money in the sector has historically been taboo. When I was in medical school between 2011 and 2016, I can remember students being reprimanded by established doctors for any suggestion that they were pursuing medicine 'to make money'. Those with 'pound signs in their eyes' were advised to seek a career in the City instead. There was no need to discuss finances, as the understanding was that being a doctor was a challenging and noble vocation that, while it may never make you rich, would leave you more than financially secure. You could look to consultants as examples of such financial security. After years of arduous training, they've arguably reached the top of their profession, the pinnacle. Many of them are covering for resident doctor colleagues over the weekend so residents can strike safely, reportedly advised to demand up to £6,000 a shift. Some may balk at such fees, but how much would a top lawyer charge to work out of hours? With becoming a consultant no means a guarantee, debts of more than £100,000 and a rota that can be unforgiving, conditions for resident doctors are challenging. Then you throw in pay – 20% less in real terms compared with a doctor in 2008. Then, potentially, you can understand why morale is low among resident doctors. Last year, a study found that at least half of the British public thought new junior doctors, as they were still known then, were paid too little. Yet public support is now slumping, with 49% opposing the walkout, and a slew of tabloid headlines since the strikes were announced have painted us as wilfully hampering the NHS just to add more money to our bank accounts. Such concerns wouldn't be high on the British Medical Association's agenda, as it is its job to deliver the best deal for its members, and 90% of the resident doctors who cast their ballot voted in favour of industrial action. Not even the current government received such support at the last general election. A friend of mine coined the term 'gen Z BMA'. While I have no data on the generational makeup of BMA resident members, I would argue they're gen Z in their approach – they're fearless and resolute in their aims, and taboos around discussing money are a thing of the past. This current iteration of the BMA will probably shout: 'We are paid X and we definitely aren't worth less than colleagues of yesteryear who were paid Y.' This attitude is at odds with some older members'. We have had retired doctors publicly relinquish their BMA memberships, as they disagree with the approach of resident doctors. Of course, there are consultant and senior colleagues who do support their resident colleagues, but I do feel these generational disagreements are in line with wider societal disputes. Gen Zs and, to an extent, millennials, are often called workshy, and accused of not being willing to sacrifice or put in the graft their colleagues of yesteryear put in. But it could be argued that these younger generations know their worth and aren't willing to merely 'get on with it'. They are prepared to take a stand for what they believe in. Shouldn't that be commended? Some members of the public certainly don't think so. A cursory look online reveals a lot of criticism: what about other public servants? What about nurses, teachers or firefighters? Do they not deserve a pay rise? That, I would say respectfully, is a concern for those professions and their respective unions. Unions exist to represent their members and act in their best interests. Why would the BMA consider the interests of nurses, teachers or firefighters? That said, there should be solidarity among public servants – not a race to the bottom. Strike action is meant to be disruptive. However, studies have found no evidence that strike action has any significant impact on in-hospital patient mortality. Patients are no more at harm than on non-strike days. Some argue that doctors shouldn't be allowed to strike due to our vital role. So we are too valuable to strike, but not valuable enough to be paid appropriately? How does that make sense? Michael Akadiri is an award-winning standup comedian and resident doctor
Times
an hour ago
- Times
Doctors' strikes live: thousands start five-day walkout over pay
The leader of the British Medical Association previously claimed that Britain was becoming a fascist state where dissidents were labelled 'traitors and enemies of the people'. Dr Tom Dolphin, 46, chairman of the union behind the latest round of strikes, has made controversial comments including likening Luigi Mangione, the alleged murderer of a healthcare boss, to Jesus, and criticising Brexit. Dolphin, a former Labour Party activist, was elected to the post in June after developing a reputation as a hardliner over his two decades in the BMA. • Read in full: The leaders behind the 29 per cent pay demands Doctors already earn a 'good wage', Peter Kyle, the science, innovation and technology minister, has told Times Radio as the BMA strike action begins today. He said: 'I can't speak for the leadership of the British Medical Association sadly, but I do urge them to put the patient's interests at heart but also the interests of our entire country. 'People do not support this strike. A 28.9 per cent offer, which was agreed last year, is an astonishing achievement for those doctors. They should bank it, they should get to work … we need to fix the NHS and get it fit for the future.' Sir Keir Starmer made a last-minute appeal to resident doctors, saying the strikes would 'cause real damage'. 'The route the BMA resident doctors' committee have chosen will mean everyone loses. My appeal to resident doctors is this: do not follow the BMA leadership down this damaging road. Our NHS and your patients need you,' he wrote in The Times. • Read in full: Junior doctors should break ranks with the BMA leadership Thousands of resident doctors have begun a five-day strike after talks with the government collapsed over pay, with picket lines at Guy's Hospital in London, Royal Victoria Hospital in Newcastle, Addenbrooke's Hospital in Cambridge and Leeds General Infirmary. Members of the public have been urged to come forward for NHS care during the walkout, and are being asked to attend appointments unless told they are cancelled. GP surgeries will open as usual and urgent care and A&E will continue to be available, alongside NHS 111, NHS England said.
