
Nine Irish players could feature in Lions Test XV, but one Leinster star could miss out
On Wednesday morning, Andy Farrell's side hit a half-century mark for the second time in four days against midweek opposition as the Queensland Reds – after a bright start – wilted and suffered the same fate as Western Force in Perth.
Once again, it was a mixed bag from the tourists. When the Lions hit their stride, they looked potent and threatening in the wide channels, scoring eight tries and leaving a few more out on the Suncorp Stadium pitch. Andy Farrell's side hit a half-century mark for the second time in four days. Pic:But there were some familiar issues, namely a flurry of handling errors as well as scrum and lineout malfunctions.
Farrell and his backroom team will be confident that a lot of those problems will be ironed out in time for the Test series.
The Lions boss is beginning to get some clarity on selection, too. There are still plenty of spots up for grabs in the matchday 23 to face Australia on July 19. The Lions boss is beginning to get some clarity on selection. Pic: Brendan Moran/Sportsfile
Some players cemented that status on Wednesday while others are beginning to drift from the first-team picture…
Thrall back through the many, many 'predicted Lions Test XVs' in the years and months leading up to this tour and the all-Irish frontrow of Andrew Porter, Dan Sheehan and Tadhg Furlong was a familiar sight. Few would have argued with such predictions either.
Porter is one of the premier loosehead props on the planet, Sheehan is 'World XV' material while Furlong had started six consecutive Lions tests spanning tours of duty in New Zealand (2017) and South Africa (2021). Porter is one of the premier loosehead props on the planet. Pic:With every passing week, the likelihood of the Leinster trio getting the nod to pack down against the Wallabies pack is looking increasingly unlikely, however.
Sheehan remains a frontrunner. The fact he was handed the captaincy on his first Lions cap against the Force spoke volumes and the Leinster hooker duly produced a typically busy and dynamic performance. He's nailed on for Game One in Brisbane.
Porter, however, will be feeling the heat from Ellis Genge, especially after Wednesday's shaky scrumming performance against the Reds. Dan Sheehan scoring a try against Western Force last Saturday. Pic: Colin Murty/AFP via Getty Images
And Furlong is far from assured of a starting spot at tighthead. The Wexford native, who has endured an injury-disrupted two years, has not looked his usual rampaging self in Oz. England's Will Start didn't make a compelling case on Wednesday either.
Could Finlay Bealham, who didn't make the cut initially, be emerging as the Lions Test tighthead? He's likely to get another opportunity to state his case against the Waratahs on Saturday.
For a player who has clocked up more than 2,200 minutes of competitive action, for club and country, this season, Maro Itoje didn't look like a player who needed a breather in Brisbane.
The England lock delivered a superb, all-action display. It was a real captain's performance. Itoje is a class act and will be central to the Lions' chances in this looming series.
Who will partner the Saracens second row remains to be seen. Joe McCarthy has made the biggest impression thus far and another muscular display against the Waratahs will put the Leinster lock firmly in the frame. If Itoje and McCarthy get the nod then Tadhg Beirne is likely to shift across to the blindside flank. Maro Itoje didn't look like a player who needed a breather in Brisbane. Pic:Given the lineout yips in recent weeks, Farrell will be keen to have three lineout jumpers in his starting Test pack.
Right now, Ollie Chessum looks to have the edge on James Ryan and Scott Cummings for a spot on the bench.
Beirne moving into the backrow is only going to increase the competition in the backrow and one player in particular has really put his hand up for further inclusion.
Josh van der Flier is a former World Player of the Year and the Leinster openside was the favourite to start the Test series before the Lions departed for Sydney late last month.
Van der Flier knew that he had serious competition long before this tour squad was named. And the Ireland flanker knows he needs to deliver a massive display next time after Jac Morgan's relentless shift against the Reds. The Ospreys flanker was everywhere. Whether he was winning turnovers, making big tackles or running smart lines, Morgan made a big impression on the Lions management. Jac Morgan put in a relentless shift against the Reds. Pic:Henry Pollock's manic energy and Ben Earl's versatility – with the Saracens flanker doing a late shift at centre on Wednesday – are tailor-made for a power-packed 6-2 bench split in the Test series.
If Farrell, as expected, goes for a big unit like Beirne on the blindside and Jack Conan at No8, then openside flanker looks the only position still up for grabs. Van der Flier v Morgan is going to be fascinating in the coming weeks. There was plenty of pragmatism from Gibson-Park during some dicey moments in the first half. Pic:Jamison Gibson-Park and Finn Russell looked like first-choice half backs on Wednesday. Both players were a joy to watch in full flight. Crucially, there was plenty of pragmatism from Gibson-Park during some dicey moments in the first half. The Leinster scrum-half is known for his full-throttle attacking approach but Gibson-Park can slow things down and play the percentages as well. Russell is looking the part at No10, too. The Northampton Saints pair of Alex Mitchell and Fin Smith are locked in as the back-up options as the bench. Bundee Aki tackles Queensland Reds' Tim Ryan. Pic: David Gray/AFP via Getty Images
Bundee Aki and Huw Jones grew into this game. Both centres looked most effective when they ran hard at the line, rather than trying the intricate stuff out the back. Sione Tuipulotu and Garry Ringrose remain the favourites to start the Test series, mind. Freeman looks like a frontrunner for the right wing. Pic:Tommy Freeman and Duhan van der Merwe needed big games in Brisbane. James Lowe and Mack Hansen are firm favourites of Farrell and both excelled in Perth.
Van der Merwe looked suspect in defence on several occasions. The Scotland wing is a serious athlete but the Wallabies will target him. Freeman still looks like a frontrunner for the right wing. Van der Merwe is a serious athlete but the Wallabies will target him. Pic:Otherwise, the back three slots are wide open. Hugo Keenan fell further behind after withdrawing late through illness. His replacement Elliot Daly, virtually ever-present on the last three Lions tours, was having another impressive outing before that concerning late arm injury.
Blair Kinghorn, a late arrival on tour following his Top14-winning exploits with Toulouse, will get a chance to impress in Sydney. The Scot looks primed to make a late surge into the Test reckoning.
B Kinghorn; T Freeman, G Ringrose, S Tuipulotu, M Hansen; F Russell, J Gibson-Park; E Genge, D Sheehan, F Bealham; M Itoje (capt), J McCarthy; T Beirne, J van der Flier, J Conan.
Reps: R Kelleher, A Porter, T Furlong, B Earl, H Pollock, A Mitchell, F Smith, B Aki.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Irish Independent
22 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Ireland captain Éanna McCarthy warns ahead of U-20 clash: ‘Italy are going to bring a different challenge'
First ever Six Nations loss to Italians in Treviso in March still weighs heavily on Irish minds Ireland captain Éanna McCarthy is wary of the task facing Neil Doak's side in Viadana today when they take on hosts Italy in the second round of the World Rugby U-20 Championship (6.30pm). Italy scored a first U-20 Six Nations victory over Ireland in March, when they won 15-12 in Treviso, and McCarthy said while they were boosted by their 35-28 opening-round win over Georgia, he knows this will be a bigger test.


RTÉ News
2 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Ireland fall to Italian defeat at U-20s World Championships
Italy U-20s 18-16 Ireland U-20s Ireland fell to a narrow defeat to hosts Italy at the World Rugby U-20 Championships in Viadana today. In stifling conditions, Ireland nearly came away with a draw when replacement flanker Oisín Minogue crossed the tryline in the 82nd minute, but out-half Sam Wisniewski was unable to land his conversion from the right with the final act of an ill-disciplined game. The defeat, following the 35-28 opening-round victory over Georgia, means Ireland must beat New Zealand in their third and final game of Pool C next Wednesday and hope other results go their way to be in with a chance of a semi-final. Italy, who also got the better of Ireland in this year's U20 Six Nations campaign, took the lead in the 12th minute through Italian No 8 Nelson Casartelli. Temperatures reached 33 degrees at Stadio Luigi Zaffanella where Ireland out-half Tom Wood and Italian full-back Edoardo Todaro traded penalties to ensure Italy led 8-3 at the break. Piero Gritti's try just short of the hour mark appeared to send the hosts well on their way, but the visitors responded four minutes later when replacement hooker Mikey Yarr touched down in the corner with the Italians temporarily down to 14 after the sin-binning of Casartelli for a high tackle on full-back Charlie Molony. Irish lock Billy Corrigan soon followed to the sin-bin with Italy adding another penalty to make it 18-11 with nine minutes remaining. Ireland fought to the end and got over with the clock in the red, but Minogue's miss ensured a home win. Italy: E Todaro; A Drago (R Ioannucci 62), F Zanandea, R Casarin, J Ducros (G Pietramala 68); R Fasti, N Beni (M Bellotto 74); S Pelliccioli (S Mistrulli 54), N Corvasce (A Caiolo-Serra 54), N Bolognini (L Trevisan 53); M Midena (E Opoku Gyamfi 53), P Gritti; G Milano, C Bianchi (A Miranda 57), N Casartelli. Ireland: C Molony; P Farrell, C Mangan, E Smyth, D Moloney; T Wood (S Wisniewski 60), W Wootton (C Logan 64); A Usanov (B Bohan 53), H Walker (M Yarr 53-78), A Mullan (T McAllister 53) M Ronan (C Kennelly 48), B Corrigan; E McCarthy, B Power (O Minogue 62), L Murphy.

The 42
2 hours ago
- The 42
Waratahs huge underdogs as Farrell asks for more Lions progress
ENGLISHMAN JAMIE ADAMSON will play for the Waratahs against the Lions in tomorrow's match in Sydney and then head off to Canberra to wear a Lions jersey for the tourists' clash with the Brumbies on Wednesday. Adamson will be in the stands with his family supporting the Lions next week. The 25-year-old, who is on the bench for the Waratahs tomorrow [KO 11am Irish time, Sky Sports], was released by the Great Britain 7s back in 2023 and decided to go on an adventure to Australia to play club rugby. Adamson won the Shute Shield with Sydney's Easts but then moved back home to England in the hope of returning to the 7s fold. Just a couple of weeks later, Waratahs boss Dan McKellar asked him to join the Sydney franchise on a trial basis. It went well. Adamson has racked up 11 appearances in Super Rugby this year and now he gets a chance to take on the Lions, a team he has supported all his life and probably once hoped to play for. Many others in the Waratahs' matchday 23 have intriguing stories of their own, even the famous players. 29-year-old Taniela Tupou was seen as one of the best tightheads in rugby only a few years ago but his form fell away drastically. In May, he told the Sydney Morning Herald about the mental struggles he's been dealing with. Tupou is still in the Wallabies set-up, but he has been released to the Waratahs for tomorrow's game in a bid to show that he has what it takes to face the Lions in a couple of weeks. Waratahs flanker Charlie Gamble. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo At the other end of the scale in terms of experience, 21-year-old Waratahs loosehead prop Jack Barrett should get the chance to scrummage against Tadhg Furlong at Allianz Stadium tomorrow. Openside flanker Charlie Gamble is a New Zealand native who moved to Sydney in 2018. Initially, he was playing so-called 'Subbies' amateur rugby and working as a delivery driver for an alcohol supplier. Advertisement He swiftly rose through the grades in Sydney rugby to secure a contract with the Waratahs in 2020 and five years later, he gets the opportunity to plays against the Lions. 21-year-old out-half Jack Bowen has only started two games in Super Rugby and he's preferred to Wallabies-capped Tane Edmed as the number 10 for tomorrow's game. Every single one of these Waratahs will be proud and pumped up to play against the Lions but with seven of their key players remaining in Wallabies camp, there are fears that they will struggle to compete, especially if Andy Farrell's side can deliver something closer to an 80-minute performance. There are some good pros in the Waratahs 23. Lock Fergus Lee-Warner spent time in the Premiership, skipper Hugh Sinclair has a hard edge, blindside Rob Leota has 21 Wallabies caps, wing Andrew Kellaway has been released by Joe Schmidt along with Tupou, and clever centre Lalakai Foketi has reportedly signed for the Chiefs in New Zealand. It should help that Mike Catt is the Waratahs' attack coach and will have helped to prepare them well for facing an Andy Farrell team. But the reality is that there is a major gulf in quality between the two teamsheets for tomorrow. The Tahs are massive underdogs for this one. Lions head coach Farrell has rung the changes again after Wednesday's win over the Reds, but he saw more to like in that performance in Brisbane. Now he wants things to go up another level against the Waratahs. Mack Hansen at the Lions' captain's run in Sydney. Billy Stickland / INPHO Billy Stickland / INPHO / INPHO 'A bit more continuity, a bit more putting things together,' is what he hopes to see in Sydney. 'There's a bit of a stop-start nature with our outcomes… just lacking a bit of staying in the moment as much as we possibly can. 'But having said that, I think it's getting better. There's always things to fix in every single game but we've been pleased with some of our progression. 'Our breakdown work was great the other night, our transition work – whether it be defence to attack, attack to defence – was pretty good as well. 'So, yeah, we want to keep improving our defence because that's the main thing you'd want to stand for. I know defence has been pretty good, but there's still room for improvement.' The Brumbies game in Canberra was always going to be the Lions' toughest challenge against the Aussie Super Rugby sides because they've been consistently the best for years now. The hope is that the Waratahs' obvious emotion and delight at getting a shot at the Lions helps them to deliver a credible, competitive performance tomorrow. If not, we could be in for a rout that does nobody any good. WARATAHS: Lawson Creighton; Andrew Kellaway, Lalakai Foketi, Joey Walton, Darby Lancaster; Jack Bowen, Teddy Wilson; Tom Lambert, Ethan Dobbins, Taniela Tupou; Fergus Lee-Warner, Miles Amatosero; Rob Leota, Charlie Gamble, Hugh Sinclair (captain). Replacements: Mahe Vailanu, Jack Barrett, Daniel Botha, Matt Philip, Jamie Adamson, Jack Grant, Tane Edmed, Henry O'Donnell. LIONS: Hugo Keenan; Mack Hansen, Huw Jones, Sione Tuipulotu, Blair Kinghorn; Fin Smith, Alex Mitchell; Pierre Schoeman, Luke Cowan-Dickie, Finlay Bealham; Tadhg Beirne (captain), James Ryan; Henry Pollock, Josh van der Flier, Ben Earl. Replacements: Dan Sheehan, Ellis Genge, Tadhg Furlong, Joe McCarthy, Scott Cummings, Jac Morgan, Ben White, Marcus Smith. Referee: Paul Williams [New Zealand].