Talk of coup in South Africa unrealistic, say experts
'One reason is that intelligence in general has been politicised. People talk about it being 'weaponised'. It's used in internal ANC politics to compromise people and gather information, not necessarily for national security reasons.'
Kotze said the report Ntshavheni based the risk of a coup on does not identify a coup as an immediate or short-term risk. 'I think it's a bit of an overstatement to say a coup is imminent based on what's in the actual document. From what I see in the assessment, it's not stated in that way,' he said.
Advocate Sipho Mantula, a law expert, said South Africa would be able to respond to any threats. He said a coup is normally led by the military.
'What I read there was more about the idea that if the president takes action against Lt-Gen Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi [KwaZulu-Natal police commissioner] or proceeds with the case against him, it might cause unrest similar to what we saw in the July 2021 unrest.'
He said Ntshavheni should have detailed what sort of coup she was talking about. 'So you can't just come out and say those things. I think the issue of the special task force wearing uniforms that resemble military attire was perhaps a misunderstanding.'
SowetanLIVE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald
an hour ago
- The Herald
Much at stake in how you cast your vote
And so it starts. In just over a year's time, South Africans will vote in the 2026 local government polls , the country's seventh such election since the dawn of democracy. This week, Nelson Mandela Bay got a taste of what's to come. In what was widely viewed as a litmus test ahead of next year's elections, residents in the Bay's Ward 34 went to the polls on Wednesday in a by-election after the death of DA councillor Johnny Arends in April. While six parties contested, including the National Alliance, ANC, EFF and PAC, the PA and DA were seen as the front-runners in what was expected to be a hotly contested election. In the end, it was just 188 votes that separated the two, with the DA securing 2,382 votes (46.56%) to beat the PA with its 2,194 votes (42.89%). In the 2021 local government elections, the DA won the ward with 63.14% of the votes, followed by the National Alliance (17.12%) and PA (2.78%). So what, you might ask? For those who do not fully understand the difference between the national and municipal elections , these are the elections that determine who will represent us at a grassroots level, possibly for the next five years if there are no by-elections in between. These are the ward councillors, in particular, who will take our concerns — literally from our streets — and place it on the municipal agenda. Our first port of call as citizens as far as service delivery is concerned, these are the councillors — we hope — who will ensure our concerns are addressed. As we edge closer to next year's elections, we expect the campaigning of the past three months in this ward will only intensify as parties vie for the support of voters — and spread to other wards across the Bay. And as they campaign, remember this: the outcome of these municipal elections have the most immediate and visible impact on our daily lives, from the overgrown grass in our parks, to the street lights lining our roads and so much else in between. Take the time over the next few months to understand what political parties offer and reflect on what they have already delivered — or not — as you decide who deserves your vote. But, whatever you do, just vote. The Herald
IOL News
2 hours ago
- IOL News
Are we now supposed to stay awake at night watching out for coup plotting bogeymen?
South Africans live under the constant threat of crime. Should we now worry about a possible coup against the current government? I must admit, after that media briefing by Ntshavheni, which was supposed to be about 'the national security strategy in light of the recent budget debate concerning the State Security Agency', I had a good night's sleep. I even had some lovely dreams, including one where a new government had suddenly come to power and begun rescuing our beautiful but beleaguered Mzansi from all the crime, corruption, unemployment, poverty and inequality. Should the citizenry sleep better at night going forward knowing that President Cyril Ramaphosa and his trusted minister are taking care of business? Or, should we be worried, afraid that the atrociously performing government is at risk of being suddenly replaced? This week's 'startling' comments by Minister in the Presidency Khumbudzo Ntshavheni about the "risk" of a coup raise a number of questions. A coup d'état is not always a bad thing. It depends on the new leadership's intentions or programmes for the country and its citizens. So, don't let the minister scare you. The people of Libya saw an improvement in their lived reality after Muammar Gaddafi's coup, which is why the 1969 takeover is also known as a revolution – the 1 September Revolution. And there are many different kinds of coups, including a version that is increasingly becoming more common in recent times – self-coups. Unlike the standard violent and illegal ones launched by small groups for their own narrow benefit, self-coups are where a legally installed leader decides to stay in power illegally, renders the national legislature powerless and assumes dictatorial powers. In some cases self-coups or autocoups happen when, as seen at the beginning of the Trump 2.0 administration with Donald Trump and Elon Musk, the leader assumes and uses powers not given to him or her by the constitution and other laws. It is that kind of coup that Mzansi must be afraid of. I wasn't startled or shook by Ntshavheni's briefing. But why did she decide to burden poor fellow South Africans with such weighty matters? We already sleep with one eye open because of crime. And we have that real-life bogeyman in the White House threatening to destroy our economy every week. Are we now supposed to keep our weary eyes peeled looking out for coup plotters too?
IOL News
3 hours ago
- IOL News
Mashatile calls for increased Chinese investment as trade deficit with China surges
Deputy President Shipokosa Paulus Mashatile delivers a keynote address at the South Africa-China Investment Forum, as part of his working visit to the People's Republic of China. Banele Ginidza Deputy President Paul Mashatile has issued a compelling invitation to Chinese corporations, advocating for increased investment in South Africa. Speaking at the South Africa-China Investment Forum in Beijing on Thursday, Mashatile highlighted a significant shift in the trade dynamics between the two nations, revealing that the trade deficit with China has escalated dramatically from less than $1 billion in the period between 1988 and 2000 to an alarming $9.71bn by 2023. Mashatile said ddressing these challenges necessitated expanding South Africa's export portfolio, encouraging value-added exports, and establishing a more balanced trade relationship. "We need to develop a more coordinated and strategic approach. We need to address challenges such as access to the Chinese market due to factors like tariff and non-tariff barriers, distance, and competition from other countries," Mashatile said. The essence of this trade imbalance, as Mashatile pointed out, stems from the current nature of the economic relationship where South Africa primarily exports raw materials and minerals while predominantly importing manufactured and capital goods from China. This disparity has raised concerns regarding the sustainability of such a model, particularly as both South Africa and China navigate increasing tariff barriers imposed by the United States. "As South Africa-China relations continue to deepen, new opportunities emerge for Chinese businesses seeking to enter the South African market, particularly in sectors such as renewable energy, green hydrogen, energy storage, infrastructure and logistics, our Special Economic Zones (SEZs), pharmaceuticals and medical devices, and the beneficiation of critical minerals, as well as in the digital economy," he said. Mashatile said South Africa sought to attract investments to increase greenfield investments, infrastructure investments, unlock funding or financial support, partnerships with SOEs, technology transfer and innovation partnerships, investments in SEZs and industrial parks, black industrialist partnerships, as well as capacity and technical assistance for SEZs. "Our SEZs offer an internationally competitive value proposition for the country with an attractive suite of incentives," Mashatile said. "They are located across the country, and each SEZ has unique offerings for investors, some of which could include tax relief, reduced corporate rate taxes and reduced costs for key inputs such as land, water and electricity." Mashatile highlighted the infrastructure investment plan as being in place to drive a range of projects in energy, water and sanitation, transport, digital infrastructure, human settlements, and agriculture and agro-processing. "The plan is supported by an Infrastructure Fund, offering investment opportunities in water development and irrigation projects across nine provinces, a road network expansion, a rehabilitation and maintenance program for construction companies, and high-demand spectrum," he said. Mashatile said South Africa's mineral exports, agricultural commodities, and manufactured items have achieved significant penetration in the Chinese market, aided by a steady flow of investment from Chinese companies since the announcement of President Cyril Ramaphosa's investment mobilisation drive. He said some of the existing partnerships included a major significant investment by the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China (ICBC), which purchased a 20% stake in the assets and earnings of Standard Bank for $5.5bn. Another major Chinese electronics manufacturer, Hi-Sense, entered the South African market in 1997. In 2013, the company established an industrial park. Mashatile cited other Chinese flagship companies such as Zhong Xing Communications (ZTE) and Huawei Technologies that were also expanding their presence in South Africa. "Over the last decade, 48 Chinese companies invested in South Africa with a capital investment of over $11.69bn," he said. BUSINESS REPORT
