Helen Gregory murder trial: Why police didn't buy Julia DeLuney's accident claim
Julia DeLuney in the High Court.
Photo:
RNZ / Mark Papalii
A detective giving evidence in the DeLuney trial says inconsistencies in the accused's story led police had to investigate the death as a manslaughter, rather than an accident.
Julia DeLuney is accused of murdering her 79-year-old mother, Helen Gregory, and the trial, expected to take at least four weeks, is in its fourth day.
The Crown's case is that DeLuney violently attacked her mother on the evening of 24 January 2024, at Gregory's home in Khandallah.
But the defence claims Gregory fell from the attic, and while DeLuney left her in a bedroom to drive back to her Kāpiti home to collect her husband Antonio DeLuney to help - as her mother didn't like hospitals - a third person caused those fatal injuries.
The defence's case is that police investigation developed "tunnel vision" in its pursuit of DeLuney, and it failed to properly investigate other options.
Under cross examination by defence lawyer Quentin Duff, Detective Sergeant Guilia Boffa said police were told Gregory'd had a fall, but things didn't add up.
"And there was information that was important that was missing from the accounts that were being provided around changing clothing and a number of areas travelled to that we were picking up that we were not being told about."
Namely, she stopped at a petrol station and, the Crown asserts, changed clothes a number of times that evening.
Detective Constable Kristina O'Connor, under cross examination for the second time after previously guiding the jury through a virtual walk-through of the address, began telling the court about her methodical search of the property for disturbances in the greenery or objects out of place.
Her evidence continues this afternoon.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
24 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Khandallah murder trial: Blood splatter found around the kitchen sink
The Khandallah house where Helen Gregory died, and where evidence of blood splatter was found around the kitchen sink. Photo: RNZ / Ashleigh McCaull A forensic scientist giving evidence in the Khandallah murder trial says there was evidence of blood around the kitchen sink, as though someone tried to clean up. Helen Gregory, 79, was killed at home in January last year, and her daughter Julia DeLuney is on trial for her murder at the High Court in Wellington. The Crown says DeLuney attacked her mother before staging it to look like she had fallen from the attic , but the defence says someone else caused those injuries in the 90 minutes in which she had gone to get help. Glenys Knight from ESR told the court on Monday that in her opinion, it appeared someone had washed blood-stained hands or an object in the kitchen sink. There was some visible blood on the bench around the sink when the scene was examined, and a Luminol test revealed extensive blood spattering. Knight told the court she had attended more than 150 scenes, many of which were homicides, including several multiple homicides and high profile cases, and she carried out the scene examination at Gregory's home at 8 Baroda Street. Pieces of detached hair and flesh were preserved , along with a broken nail, which had small blood stains on it. She said visible blood was found on a number of items and doorways in multiple rooms, and its presence was confirmed with different tests, including the Kastle-Meyer test, the Combur test and Luminol testing, in which a chemical reagent reacts with blood and glows blue in low light. The court heard in earlier evidence the street lights in the area were turned off to allow for Luminol testing. Areas in and around the sink lit up strongly during testing. "In my opinion, these were most likely created by diluted blood being flicked or splashed and then left to dry," Knight said. "From the position of these stains around the sink, it would appear likely that someone has washed blood-stained hands or a blood-stained item in the kitchen sink." Julia DeLuney is on trial for her mother's murder at the High Court in Wellington Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii Next to the sink, in a Wild Bean Cafe paper bag, sat an uneaten pastry. Blood was also found on the doorframe and door handle of the patio door, the tap in the laundry, the handle of the fridge, a mug on the kitchen table and on the kitchen floor - in Knight's opinion, all were transfer stains from another object - along with the extensive blood in the bedroom Gregory was found in, and the hallway. It was also found on her personal alarm, normally worn on the wrist but instead found sitting on the television cabinet in the sitting room. "Some blood stains, which in my opinion appeared dilute were detected on the front and back of the face and strap of the NevaAlone personal alarm," Knight said, reading from her report. That alarm was also sampled for trace DNA, but Knight did not speak about the results of that test. No blood was found on cleaning products in the cleaning cupboard, or its handles. There were also two circles of "probable" blood on the white tile next to the stove - only classed as probably as they reacted with luminol but the other, less sensitive tests did not confirm its presence. Those circles matched a number of items in the house, including some crockery, lamps, candle holders and a metal bucket under the sink, but there were no traces of blood found on any of those items. Knight said the bloody footprints on the kitchen floor were unusual, in that the soles did not have a detailed pattern on the bottom, indicating they might be from slippers or dress shoes which usually had featureless sole patterns. In separate evidence, a neighbour told the court that on the night of Gregory's death, the lights in her home were off and the blinds left open. The neighbour said she went to bed about 10pm, and at that point, the house was in darkness and nobody had closed the blinds. But she said she woke up around 2am to see lights on in Gregory's house, which were shining into her own bedroom. She said she did worry something had happened, and the next day, a police officer knocked on her door to take her statement. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Person dies after crash in Waikato
One person was reported to be injured, police said. Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon A person has died after a crash involving a truck and car on Cambridge Road in Waikato. Police said the crash was reported at 11.25am Monday. "Despite the best efforts of first responders, the driver of the car died at the scene," a police spokesperson said. "Police are providing support to the person's family." The crash blocked the road and emergency services were on site. Cambridge Rd remains closed between Storey Rd and Cox Rd, and the Serious Crash Unit is carrying out a scene examination. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Teen Myah still missing from Auckland home
Police are asking for the public's help in finding Myah, who has been reported missing from the Red Beach area. Photo: NZ Police Police still have concerns for a teenage girl who was reported missing from her Auckland home on Friday. They believed 17-year-old Myah was likely in the North Shore area and were asking anyone who may have seen her to get in contact. Police said she had the mental ability of a 12-year-old. She was last seen in Albany on Friday, after leaving her home in Red Beach. Police believe it is likely she is still in the North Shore area. If you have seen Myah or have any information that might help find her, please contact Police on 105 and reference file number: 250627/9755. Meanwhile, missing teenager Whetu Bennett had been found safe and well after being missing for four days.
