Valparaiso officials: City can keep ARPA funds used to buy land for now-defunct plans for sports complex
City officials say no, a point they emphasized during Monday's City Council meeting, which stretched almost five hours and drew hundreds of people to City Hall with concerns about the potential data center.
Council President Ellen Kapitan, D-At-large, called the issue a 'red flag' during the council meeting, adding it led to a lot of questions, including whether the city would be on the hook for repaying the funds.
'Is this legal?' she asked Patrick Lyp, the city attorney.
'The simple answer is yes,' he said, adding an outside law firm from Indianapolis helped the city work through the details.
If the Redevelopment Commission sells the property, he said, 'there would be no prohibition or covenant on the money.' The funds, he added, would return to the RDC.
The tenets of ARPA funding offer exemptions for paybacks of funds under $10 million, as long as they are used for public purposes, Lyp said. There also is no prohibition on the sale or use of the property.
'There's no obligation that would be tied to ARPA funds,' said Councilman Robert Cotton, D-2nd.
The city received $7,681,979.52, according to an amended resolution for ARPA spending passed by the City Council on July 25, 2022.
That included $4,717,278.92 for land acquisition 'for future Park related activities,' according to the resolution, and includes the parcels for the proposed sports complex.
The breakdown on the use of the rest of the funding, according to the resolution, included $1 million for the demolition of the former Whispering Pines facility and two adjacent residential structures on North Calumet Avenue, as well as site remediation, for a then-proposed adult enrichment center; $663,147.68 in premium pay for eligible city employees; $575,000 for several nonprofit agencies; $500,000 for the replacement of sidewalks, walking paths and other infrastructure; $40,000 for consultant fees and reserve funds for future audits, all related to disbursement of the ARPA funds; and $25,000 each to the police and fire departments, for various upgrades.
The brunt of the spending, including the parkland purchase, fell under ARPA's 'Provision of Governmental Services using Revenue Loss Funds,' per the council's resolution, which is the most flexible of categories for ARPA spending.
In emails to the Post-Tribune before the City Council meeting and Mayor Jon Costas' statement that the city would no longer pursue the data center proposal because of the public outcry, Lyp and George Douglas, the city's development director, offered further insight into the transfer of funds before the 248 acres, comprised of four parcels between County Roads 500 North and 400 North east of Indiana 49, was purchased for parkland.
According to the option agreement signed in January between the RDC and the data center developer, Agincourt Investments LLC, the RDC would have sold 180 acres of that property for just over $9 million, almost twice what the RDC paid for the land.
'The Valparaiso Redevelopment purchased the properties in 2022 with available cash funds. The City Council did approve the use of ARPA funds to reimburse the RDC for the full purchase price in August of 2022,' Douglas said in his email.
He added he didn't believe anything happens to the ARPA funds once they have been used to reimburse the RDC for the land purchase and if the RDC were to sell the property, the commission could use the proceeds for any of its permissible expenditures.
'The ARPA funds were used for an allowed purpose when the City reimbursed the RDC,' Lyp said in his email. 'If the land is sold, the proceeds would be paid to the RDC and used by the RDC consistent with Indiana law.'
Jennifer Hora, a political science professor at Valparaiso University who focuses on state and local government, agreed that the ARPA funds come with flexibility but said that flexibility is supposed to come with accountability and responsibility.
She summed up her concerns as 'the spirit of the law vs. the letter of the law.'
City officials dropped the plans for the park when, according to then-Mayor Matt Murphy, bids for the project, slated for $30 million, came in $7 million over budget. Costas said in an interview with the Post-Tribune last month that the city was going to invest more in its current parks instead and scuttle the plans for the sports complex.
City officials, Hora said, 'threw their hands up' and walked away from the sports complex proposal when it came in over budget and proposed using that land for the data center.
The future of the land purchased with those funds is unknown.
'This is not transparency,' she said. 'This is definitely not the spirit of ARPA law.'
alavalley@chicagotribune.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
3 hours ago
- New York Post
Bill de Blasio and his former aides are advising Zohran Mamdani — and clamoring to get back to City Hall
Former Big Apple Mayor and groundhog killer Bill de Blasio and his aides are clamoring to become relevant again — by sucking up to socialist and Democratic nominee Zohran Mamdani in the hopes of scoring a position in his potential administration, The Post has learned. The three-term ex-mayor — a vocal supporter of the Queens assemblyman — has been whispering in Mamdani's ear as an informal adviser, sources said. Blaz's former influential aide, Patrick Gaspard, has also carved out a role in the millennial candidate's campaign, helping him to navigate the various voter blocs unsettled by his nomination in the shocking primary upset. 3 Ex-Mayor Bill de Blasio wants to be relevant again in City Hall. Andrew Schwartz / However, insiders say that the advice and guidance is more a play by de Blasio and crew to become 'relevant' — and they don't wield much influence over Mamdani's campaign. 'My understanding is that the Mamdani people are letting anyone chime in, and the de Blasio people are providing advice, but they aren't really making campaign decisions, seemingly just trying to get their names in the paper, make some calls, be relevant,' one source told The Post. 'Technically, they are advising, but not to the extent they are boasting.' Still, Gaspard was the key architect in arranging Mamdani's appearance at the National Action Network with Rev. Al Sharpton after his stunning win over former Gov. Andrew Cuomo — a noted foe of de Blasio, whom the former mayor vowed to do everything in his power to stop. Gaspard — who also served as a political director of the influential SEIU 1199 union, a US Ambassador to South Africa and as Obama's White House Director of Political Affairs — has deep ties with the Big Apple's black communities, labor unions and the larger Democratic Party. Sources told The Post that Gaspard has been pushing hard for a job in the potential administration as he carves himself out a role in the campaign. Camille Rivera, another former adviser to de Blasio who runs the political firm New Deal Strategies, has also been pitching in. Meanwhile, other cronies of the failed presidential candidate that have either been advising Mamdani or have been floated as potential campaign or administration aides include former Deputy Mayor Emma Wolfe, former city council legislative director and universal pre-k architect, Josh Wallach, and former deputy director of the New York City Census office, Amit Bagga. 3 de Blasio's aides have now sucked up to Democratic nominee Zohran Mamdani in the hopes of getting a political position in his administration. Christopher Sadowski But Big Apple political operatives are warning that welcoming de Blasio's former aides back into City Hall could derail his pledge to remake the Big Apple. 'They need to be careful about measuring the drapes too early,' a source quipped. 'He has a real opportunity to bring in fresh energy and thinking to build a more modern government for NYC. That will never happen with de Blasio retreads.' De Blasio, who Mamdani praised as 'the best mayor in his lifetime' in a New York Times interview, did not respond to multiple requests for comment. Both the ex-mayor and his girlfriend, Nomiki Konst, a political commentator and former candidate for public advocate, have been vocal about their support for the upstart socialist on social media. 'If they want to remind everyday New Yorkers that @ZohranKMamdani is on their side, this is the PERFECT way to do it,' de Blasio recently posted on X, in response to a Wall Street Journal article about Big Apple financiers trying to stop the lefty pol. Konst also scoffed at a New York Times article questioning the 33-year-old Mamdani's resume and experience. Keep up with today's most important news Stay up on the very latest with Evening Update. Thanks for signing up! Enter your email address Please provide a valid email address. By clicking above you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Never miss a story. Check out more newsletters 'At this point in the race, anyone in this piece quoted is only helping Cuomo, who has no ideas and a horrible track record with people [and] should be nowhere near government ever again,' she wrote on X. 'At least Zohran has a vision and has confirmed he'll bring in folks who've been successful at Gracie.' The quest for relevance for some of de Blasio's former aides comes as Mamdani's team scrambles to beef up its ranks for the coming general election, where he will square off against Mayor Eric Adams, GOP nominee Curtis Sliwa, Jim Walden, and Cuomo. 'They're overwhelmed right now,' one source close said. 'Very reminiscent of de Blasio.' 3 The former Big Apple mayor has been a vocal supporter of Mamdani with sources saying he's been acting as an informal adviser. Matthew McDermott The campaign, meanwhile, recently made a huge shift in leadership, moving communications director Andrew Epstein to oversee video and replacing him with Jeffrey Lerner, a former aide to Cuomo and political director to the Democratic National Committee. In the final stretch of the primary and the days that followed, Epstein had struggled to keep up with the deluge of media requests from local and national media looking to cover the massive upset. Other City Hall hawks have also been pitching in to help as a go-between for the campaign to connect with business communities, including Kathy Wylde, president and CEO of the non-profit organization Partnership for New York. Wylde is one of the city's most powerful power brokers and has spoken more positively about the candidate in recent weeks. 'His qualifying comments have identified the capitalist system as promoting income inequality. A lot of people in business agree with him on that,' Wylde said in a recent interview with the Wall Street Journal.
New York Post
5 hours ago
- New York Post
Don't fall for the ‘blue-washing' drive to hide Mamdani's cop hate
Democratic bigs hoping to blue-wash Zohran Mamdani's anti-cop record are hinting that he might retain tough-on-crime NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch if he takes City Hall in November. File that under 'Blowing Smoke Up Our Collective Rear Ends.' Tisch has made it clear that the drop in shootings and murders on her watch relies on tight cooperation between City Hall and One Police Plaza. Advertisement 'When the critics called to cut funding,' she declared recently, Mayor Eric Adams 'chose to cut crime. When the pressure came to back down — he chose to double down. And when others tried to make headlines — he chose to make a difference.' The commissioner has a duty to avoid politics, so she can't spell it out, but Mamdani has always been one of those critics — and plainly wouldn't choose to do what's needed to cut crime: His approach is fundamentally opposed to Tisch's hallmark policies of proactive, quality-of-live policing. In pretending he could keep the commissioner on, Mamdani proxies such as state Attorney General Tish James and city Comptroller Brad Lander are simply trying to blur away his long and terrible record on public safety. Advertisement 'Defund the police' isn't just a slogan for Mamdani, it's central to his worldview: Let's go to the tape. In Dec. 2020, Mamdani called the NYPD so 'wicked & corrupt' that there is no hope of reforming it. The only solution is to 'Defund it. Dismantle it.' 'Defunding the police is a feminist issue,' he posted in June 2020. Oh, and 'queer liberation means defund the police.' Instead, he insisted, we must rely on social workers, 'violence interrupters' and 'neighborhood change agents.' Advertisement In case we didn't get the point, that same month, after then-Gov. Andrew Cuomo suggested that 'Defund the Police' mostly means something else, Mamdani commented: 'No, we want to defund the police.' Mamdani and his fellow Astoria socialist, City Councilwoman Tiffany Caban, jointly issued a 2022 resource guide for handling street violence that doesn't include the numbers 9-1-1. Instead, it suggests that you 'give the person causing harm the chance to correct their behaviors' — and if that kumbaya approach doesn't dissuade, say, a knife-wielding maniac, Mamdani and Caban advise you to 'distract' your assailant by 'spilling your soda.' Advertisement And if that doesn't work, ask your attacker, 'Hey, didn't I go to high school with you?' It's sure to stop that subway shover! Our would-be mayor is on record that getting rid of the police isn't enough: Jails and prisons must go, too: 'The entire carceral system is an unreformable public health hazard,' he fumed in Dec. 2020. 'Defund & dismantle.' Where do these freed cons go once Mamdani closes down the jail system? Well, you've probably got space in your apartment, Comrade! People 'going through' domestic violence — weasel words for battered women and kids — don't need 'an individual with a gun' to help them, Zohran advised in July 2020; he wants to send social workers instead. Insane: One in every three NYC female murder victims has been killed by her intimate partner. Surely we can trust abused women who call 911 to know what they are doing and are calling for a cop. Advertisement Lefties fantasize that social workers can replace the work of cops in dangerous, violent situations. They have been trying this for decades, but no social worker is equipped to defuse these incidents — which is why they don't volunteer to do it. Zohran Mamdani's surrogates have a whisper campaign to deceive the voters about how radical he really is. But you can believe them or your own lying ears.
New York Post
6 hours ago
- New York Post
Zohran Mamdani ‘laundering' defund-the-police past by toying with keeping NYPD Commish Tisch if elected mayor: critics
Socialist mayoral frontrunner Zohran Mamdani was accused of 'laundering' his vocal defund-the-police stances by cynically toying with keeping tough-on-crime Jessica Tisch as NYPD commissioner if elected. The simultaneous behind-the-scenes and public pushes to keep Tisch comes as many Big Apple elites hope Mamdani — who trounced former Gov. Andrew Cuomo in the Democratic primary and leads general election polls — can sand off his far-left rough edges. And Mamdani seemingly has been only too happy to keep the door open for Tisch, despite her diametrically opposed stances on bail reform, discovery laws and other public safety issues – all matters for which the socialist firebrand has left a long trail of incendiary tweets. 'He's laundering his radical stances, that's what he's doing,' said political operative Ken Frydman. 'But he needs his defund-the-police voters to turn out again and cop-hating Tiffany Cabán is lurking,' Frydman continued, referring to a firebrand fellow Democratic socialist on the City Council being floated as Mamdani's police commissioner. 3 Zohran Mamdani is considering keeping Jessica Tisch as NYPD commissioner if elected. Paul Martinka for NY Post 3 Tisch's tough-on-crime positions are at odds with Mamdani's past criticism of police and support for bail reform. Andrew Schwartz / Tisch, a well-regarded public servant and billionaire heiress, has tried to stay above the partisan fray, despite a number of politicians trying to use her as a pawn. Mayor Eric Adams picked Tisch in November to rebuild the NYPD's standing — and his own — after his first three police commissioners respectively flamed out amid infighting, scandal and more infighting. The appointment worked so well that lefty mayoral candidate and city Comptroller Brad Lander — who, like Mamdani, had pushed to defund the police — vowed to keep Tisch as commissioner if he was elected. Indeed, Lander's move arguably laid the groundwork for his cross-endorsement ally Mamdani's one-sided political flirtation with Tisch, whose leadership he has praised. 3 Brad Lander paved the way for a lefty to embrace Tisch as a way to burnish their public safety bona fides. AP Likewise, Kathy Wylde, who heads the powerful business group Partnership for New York City, confirmed she has recommended to Mamdani that he keep Tisch. 'I believe that it's premature to make any personnel commitments at this time, but it's a consideration that is real — and it's in keeping with the city that we're fighting for,' Mamdani recently said of keeping Tisch. But Mamdani and Tisch would make strange bedfellows, even beyond their respective socialist and billionaire backgrounds. Before running for mayor, Mamdani riddled his social media accounts with lashing criticism of police brutality and cops' lack of accountability to the public they serve. 'There is no negotiating with an institution this wicked & corrupt,' he tweeted about the NYPD in 2020. 'Defund it. Dismantle it. End the cycle of violence.' As a mayoral candidate, Mamdani walked back his call to defund the police and acknowledged their role in public safety. But Mamdani, a Queens state assemblyman, has also been an enthusiastic backer of bail reform, changes to discovery laws and the 'Raise the Age' law — all of which Tisch has respectively blamed for rising recidivism, waves of criminals going free on technicalities and skyrocketing youth violence. 'I will not vote for any budget that rolls back bail reform, discovery reform, or Raise the Age,' Mamdani tweeted in 2022. While Tisch arguably could be a bulwark against Mamdani's radical impulses, Democratic political operative Hank Sheinkopf said ultimately she'd be hamstrung by the fact she ultimately serves at the pleasure of the mayor. Her role, for now, might actually be providing reassurance for rank-and-file cops, Sheinkopf said. 'Here you have the opponent of [Adams] saying he wouldn't change the department, but his rhetoric says otherwise,' Sheinkopf said. 'Police officers are in panic and they will leave in droves — Tisch is the only way to stop that.' Other insiders argued that Mamdani actually risks more by keeping Tisch around. 'Mamdani will get clobbered by his cop-hating groupies if he retains Tisch as police commissioner,' said political operative Ken Frydman. 'If he doesn't retain her, Mamdani risks serious crime increasing and getting blamed for the spike. 'Checkmate.' Adams, for his part, has also tried to capitalize on Tisch's sterling reputation. He recently ran a campaign ad that leaned heavily on Tisch's comments praising him during an event last week highlighting drops in major crimes across the city. 'Not only did we ignore the noise from the Mamdanis of the world who recklessly called to defund the police, but we doubled down on our support,' Adams tweeted. When The Post tried to reach Tisch for comment, an NYPD spokesperson responded with the same words from the commissioner that Adams' campaign ad used. 'When the critics called to cut funding — he chose to cut crime,' Tisch said about Adams last week. 'When the pressure came to back down — he chose to double down. And when others tried to make headlines — he chose to make a difference.' Additional reporting by Carl Campanile and Amanda Woods
