Trans ruling has 'changed landscape' of tribunal after nurse suspended in single-sex spaces row
The head of a women's rights group has said the Supreme Court ruling on the definition of a woman has 'changed the landscape' of the ongoing tribunal involving nurse Sandie Peggie.
Maya Forstater, chief executive of campaign group Sex Matters, was speaking during a visit to Holyrood with Ms Peggie on Wednesday, where the pair met a number of politicians to discuss the impact the legal proceedings have had on Ms Peggie.
The nurse, who has worked at the Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy for 30 years, was suspended by NHS Fife after she complained about having to share a changing room with transgender medic Dr Beth Upton.
She took the health board and Dr Upton to an employment tribunal, lodging a complaint of sexual harassment or harassment related to a protected belief under Section 26 of the Equality Act 2010.
The visit to Holyrood also came shortly after a letter from Sex Matters to the Scottish Government threatening legal action if they did not implement April's Supreme Court judgement on biological sex in equalities law.
The ruling stated said the words 'woman' and 'sex' in the Equality Act 2010 refer to a biological woman and biological sex, which has implications for access to single-sex spaces.
Asked how the judgment had affected the ongoing tribunal, Ms Forstater said: 'I think it's really changed the landscape. You can't ignore it. But in practical terms, it was only about people with Gender Recognition Certificates (GRCs), and the doctor in this case didn't have a GRC.
'So, what NHS Fife was doing was unlawful before the Supreme Court judgment (and) it's definitely unlawful now. And I think everyone can see that.'
She said of Wednesday's meetings that it had been 'important' for politicians to hear what Ms Peggie had been through as as result of 'bad policies that NHS Fife, NHS Scotland and the Scottish Government (are) still sticking with'.
She went on: 'All the politicians we met really understand the human impact of this on women. That Sandie's rights at work were abused because of bad policies, bad decisions, right from the top. And what they heard was the real human impact on her.'
She added that there was 'really no excuse' for delaying the implementation of the Supreme Court judgment. 'The law is clear from the moment that the Supreme Court gave their judgment, the Scottish Government, all public bodies, all private employers, were obliged to act,' she said.
Ms Peggie's solicitor Margaret Gribbon also took part in the visit. Afterwards she said: 'Politicians needed to hear directly from Sandie to understand how the sheer depth of the discrimination and harassment she and women like her have endured in workplaces – in her case, as a nurse with 30 years' unblemished service, simply because she objected to having to undress in front of a man.
Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community!
Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today.
You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland.
No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team.
All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in!
If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'.
We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like.
To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.
If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
'We were grateful for the politicians' time and welcomed the opportunity to share insights into how misguided actions by public bodies such as NHS Fife have devastating real-life consequences and come at great expense to the Scottish taxpayer.
'We had productive meetings, and the door is always open for any politicians who were unable to meet Sandie today.'
Tribunal hearings took place in February and it will resume in July. Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay was one of the politicians that Sandie Peggie met during her visit.
Commenting afterwards, he said: 'It was a privilege to meet Sandie Peggie and to hear a first-hand account of her appalling ordeal. It is outrageous that a dedicated NHS nurse's career has been destroyed and her life consumed by a suffocating legal process simply because she stood up for women's rights.
'Sandie has paid a massive price for her brave and principled stand against the SNP Government's promotion of gender politics which now infects Scotland's entire public sector. NHS Fife should stop squandering vast sums of taxpayers' cash on this nonsense and every state agency in Scotland must now respect the law and women's rights.'
A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'The Scottish Government has been clear that we accept the Supreme Court judgment. We are reviewing policies, guidance and legislation potentially impacted by the judgment.
'This will prepare us to take all necessary steps when the regulator of the Equality Act 2010, the Equality and Human Rights Commission, publishes its revised Statutory Code of Practice and associated guidance for services, public functions and associations.
'The EHRC is currently consulting on this revised Code of Practice. The Scottish Government's approach is aligned with that of the UK Government and Welsh Government in awaiting the EHRC's revised Statutory Code of Practice. We will respond to the letter in due course.'
The spokesperson added that it would be inappropriate to comment on Ms Peggie's case while judicial proceedings in an employment tribunal are ongoing. NHS Fife has been approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
18 hours ago
- Daily Record
Cancer waiting times in Forth Valley dubbed "ticking timebomb" by MSP
The figures revealed that 71 per cent of patients in the region received treatment within the 62 day target after an urgent referral for cancer. The state of cancer waiting times in the region has been labelled a 'ticking timebomb' — as new figures reveal one patient waited more than five months to begin treatment. The issue has been put in the spotlight after data was published by Public Health Scotland. This highlighted the compliance of Scotland's health boards with national targets related to the wait time between patients being urgently referred over a suspicion of cancer to kicking off treatment. A Scottish Government target states that 95 per cent of patients should be seen within 62 days of that urgent suspicion of cancer referral. But only a single health board — NHS Lanarkshire — met that goal from January 1 to March 31. In Forth Valley, the figure sat at 71.7 per cent, with 203 people being seen within the 62 day guideline. The average wait time for patients was within the target at 42 days - but one unlucky person was forced to wait 163 days. Conservative Mid Scotland and Fife MSP Alexander Stewart took aim at the Scottish Government's handling of waiting times — and said more money must be dedicated to fixing frontline services. Mr Stewart said: 'These shocking statistics point to a ticking timebomb of cancer cases in NHS Forth Valley and across Scotland as a whole. 'While there appears to be a slight improvement over the national average here, Forth Valley's 71 per cent average is still woefully poor and way under the nationalists' own 95 per cent target. 'One patient waiting this long for is one too many, but on the SNP's watch far too many patients are suffering potentially deadly delays. 'Early diagnosis is crucial to a patient's chances of survival and my thoughts are with any patient and their families in Forth Valley who are dealing with these delays. 'NHS Forth Valley's and our wider NHS's exceptionally dedicated, hard-working staff are trying their best against considerable headwinds, however consistency is key to bringing waiting times down. 'The SNP have been missing in action and are presiding over a cancer care crisis. 'Vital resources are being squandered on backroom bureaucracy and pen-pushing while frontline services in Forth Valley are completely overwhelmed. In response, an NHS Forth Valley spokesman highlighted its positive performance in the 31-day target — the period between decision to treat to first cancer treatment. Ten of Scotland's 15 health boards complied with the 95 per cent target under that measurement. The spokesman said: 'NHS Forth Valley consistently meets or exceeds the national cancer treatment target which aims to ensure 95 per cent of patients diagnosed with cancer start their treatment within 31 days of a decision to treat. 'Our recent performance in relation to the 62-day cancer target is also above the Scottish average and the third highest NHS Board in Scotland. 'However, we recognise that there is more to do to further improve performance and we continue to work closely with regional colleagues to reduce waiting times for local patients who require specialist tests and treatment in centres out with Forth Valley.' The national struggles with cancer waiting times were put to First Minister John Swinney at last week's First Minister's Questions at Holyrood. Mr Swinney expressed his 'regret' over the lack of compliance with the waiting times target and added: 'The [Scottish] Government is focusing on improving the activities and the investment that is made in individual boards to ensure that the performance can be improved. 'We are able to demonstrate, as the data shows, that, in parts of the country, the target is being met. 'It is being met in Lanarkshire; the model of care in Lanarkshire, which is achieving both the 62-day target and the 31-day target, is meeting the standard. 'We are ensuring that learning from NHS Lanarkshire is being applied in other boards around the country to ensure that improved performance is achieved. 'That is the approach that the Government is taking to ensure that the needs of patients are met and that we can move at the earliest possible opportunity to address any concerns about cancer in the population.'
STV News
2 days ago
- STV News
Scottish farmers warned of new cross-border bluetongue virus restrictions
Scottish farmers have been warned of new cross-border bluetongue virus restrictions for livestock travelling up from England. From July 1, any farmer wishing to move cattle and sheep from England into Scotland must now apply for a movement licence from the Animal and Plant Health Agency (APHA). It's part of the new UK Government rules to control the spread of the bluetongue virus among livestock, and the National Farmers Union of Scotland has made clear that the measures will have 'significant consequences' for Scottish producers and farmers. The union said Scottish producers who regularly market stock at English sales may now face 'costly and complex return protocols'. Bluetongue is a virus spread by biting midges which impacts livestock such as cattle, sheep and goats. One of the key symptoms of the disease is a blue, swollen tongue, and concerns are growing as the summer months approach. It can also affect deer and llamas, but humans and food safety are not at risk. In rare cases, dogs can catch bluetongue if they eat infected material, such as the placenta or other birthing tissue of an animal with the disease. The UK Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA) announced the restricted zone for bluetongue has been extended to cover all of England. Farmers and producers will now need a movement licence issued by APHA to move animals to Scotland, which confirms the animals have: a valid pre-movement test, or vaccination with the Boehringer Bultavo-3 vaccine (for cattle only). Sheep cannot move to Scotland without a negative BTV-3 pre-movement test from the National Reference Laboratory (Pirbright), even if they're vaccinated. 'Vaccination remains a vital tool in protecting animal health,' NFU Scotland animal health and welfare policy manager Penny Middleton explained. 'All available vaccines provide effective protection against the symptoms of BTV-3, but manufacturers are currently unable to demonstrate that any vaccine prevents transmission of BTV-3 in sheep. 'For that reason,the Scottish Government will continue to require pre-movement testing of all sheep moving into Scotland, regardless of vaccination status.' NFU Scotland has made clear that these measures will have 'significant consequences' for cross-border trade, but the union has consistently opposed Scotland joining the BTV-3 Restricted Zone, citing the need to maintain strong disease prevention measures. NFU Scotland has promised to keep its position under review with members as the situation progresses. Further updates, guidance and frequently asked questions on the bluetongue virus have been made available on the NFU Scotland website. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Edinburgh Reporter
2 days ago
- Edinburgh Reporter
Scottish Government appoints new Chief Scientific Adviser
The Scottish Government has appointed a new Chief Scientific Adviser who will take up his new position on 5 August. Professor Calum Semple, OBE, is appointed for an initial three year term. Professor Semple is a Consultant in Paediatric Respiratory Medicine at Alder Hey Children's NHS Foundation Trust and became Professor of Outbreak Medicine and Child Health at the University of Liverpool in 2018. He has helped the UK Government through the Swine Flu pandemic in 2009, and was on the World Health Organisation Scientific Advisory Committee during the Ebola Emergency and as a member of the Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies during the Covid pandemic. Business Minister Richard Lochhead said: 'Science is the bedrock of our society and economy and at the heart of government decision making. From health to the economy to the environment and everything in between, it is a fundamental part of our everyday lives. 'I am delighted to welcome Professor Semple to the role of Chief Scientific Adviser and look forward to his valuable insight and advice as the Scottish Government continues to work with our world leading science sector to highlight Scotland's strengths as a science nation and ensure it is front and centre of everything we do.' Professor Semple said: 'I am thrilled to have this opportunity to work for the people and government of Scotland, providing evidence and scientific advice to support our policymakers. I particularly look forward to collaborating with Scotland's vibrant communities of scientists and engineers in our schools, universities and industries, who inspire and drive the innovation essential for future economic growth. I will ensure that science and evidence remain at the heart of how we shape a fairer, greener, and more prosperous Scotland. 'I would like to thank my wife, friends, and colleagues at the University of Liverpool and Alder Hey Children's Hospital who support my career and enabled this important appointment. Their encouragement and collaboration have been vital to my journey.' Professor Semple will advise the government with independent scientific advice on 'issues of strategic importance'. He will also have a role in inspiring new scientists and championing the country's leading science and research base. He qualified from Oxford with a PhD in Clinical Virology at University College London and a Bachelor's Tripos in Cell Pathology, immunology and virology at Middlesex Hospital Medical School. He became Consultant in Paediatric Respiratory Medicine at the University of Liverpool and Alder Hey Children's Hospital in 2002. He is also Professor of Outbreak Medicine and Child Health at the University of Liverpool. He will retain these posts although his principal appointment will be with The Scottish Government. He was appointed OBE in 2020 for his contributions to the COVID-19 response and was elected a Fellow of the Faculty of Public Health by distinction in 2022. Like this: Like Related
