The Irish Independent's View: It's up to Housing Minister James Browne to sort out scarcity of zoned land
'F' stands for finance being available for developers to build; 'E' is for expertise in trades and the necessity to address the shortage of carpenters, plumbers and electricians; 'L' represents the availability of land for housing; 'I' is the infrastructure to service the zoned land; 'P is for the planning system, shortening the time taken to get building and reducing the amount of developments being appealed to An Bord Pleanála and then judicially reviewed, which also costs money; and finally, 'E' is engineering and availing of modern methods of building to enhance construction productivity.
'To me, if you solve those six issues, you have gone a long way towards trying to help resolve the situation,' Mr McDonagh told the Oireachtas Finance Committee last week.
Easier said than done. But then this cohort of parties in Government has had the best part of a decade to address much of the 'Felipe' framework.
After saying goodbye to the Troika, Fine Gael told us it wanted to keep the recovery going. Fianna Fáil joined them loosely in partnership in 2016, before a formal marriage in 2020. Now the two Civil War parties have ditched the Green Party and replaced them with the Independents.
It's been evident throughout this period that fixing society and providing housing was equally as important as repairing the economy.
The first step in solving any problem is recognising there is one. We're a long way past that stage now and yet we still don't seem to have moved into the solutions phase. Instead, the problem is still being discussed. The latest contribution to the debate has been the 'L' in 'Felipe' being picked up on and teased out. Three of the country's biggest home builders say that the limited availability of residentially zoned land for housing is the key driver of property inflation.
Supply and demand means that prices are being sent rocketing by a chronic shortage of homes to buy at a time of strong demand, according to a KPMG report. The industry says the lack of zoned land to meet demand is driving up prices, according to the report.
Rather than leaving it to local councils, Housing Minister James Browne is promising to step in and zone more land, particularly in areas near critical infrastructure like road, public transport, electricity and water services. It can't come soon enough.
However, Mr Browne made a hames of the appointment of the housing tsar. Now the minister will just have to clean up the mess himself, rather than sub-contracting the job out.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Dublin Live
11 hours ago
- Dublin Live
It will be hard to stop child homelessness topping 5,000, Housing Minister admits
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info Housing Minister James Browne has conceded that it will be difficult to stop the number of children living in emergency accommodation from rising above 5,000. The Department of Housing published its May homelessness report last week and recorded 4,844 children in emergency accommodation. This was an increase of 69 on the previous month. In total, homelessness figures for May stood at 15,747 people, another record increase. At a press conference after Tuesday's Cabinet meeting, Minister Browne acknowledged that the number of children considered homeless is increasing towards 5,000. He said: "Well, the sense of direction, unfortunately, has been upwards and we're very close to that 5,000. "I don't want to see that threshold crossed, but it's gonna be very difficult to prevent crossing over that 5,000, considering how close we are. We're going to look at more measures of how we can prevent that child homelessness. "We have seen a significant increase in homelessness. We're seeing a significant increase in people becoming homeless moving from IPAS centres. "We've got very different categories of how people are becoming homeless, some people who need real support from health services, mental health services. Then you'll have people coming from high IPAS who no longer have the ability to stay in our IPAS centre because they've been regulated and don't have anywhere to live. "Then you have families who are becoming homeless as well. We want to focus on those families and how we can increase those preventative measures for families going in and getting back out as quickly as possible." Minister Browne stated that 40 per cent of families moving into homelessness accommodation are the recipients of notices to quit, something he said will be protected by new Rent Pressure Zone Legislation. The Minister's comments on child homelessness were criticised by Sinn Féin's housing spokesman Eoin Ó Broin, who branded it an "utterly appalling admission of failure". He said: "Government have the power to take emergency action to tackle homelessness. That they choose not to take action is the reason why so many children are in emergency accommodation. They are not bystanders in this crisis." Elsewhere, Minister Browne confirmed reports in the Sunday Times suggesting that people will need to be considered habitual residents in Ireland to access social housing and emergency homeless accommodation. Mr Browne said that the Government will seek to pass legislation that it approved last year to "regularise habitual residents in this country who would be entitled to housing in line with the current rules around Social Protection and in line with European rules in relation to EU criteria." This, he said, will be done to "prioritise those who are actually living in the country". The Irish Mirror understands that additional proposals will go back to Cabinet in the coming weeks that will exempt children from the residency requirement and clarify that where an EU citizen is ineligible for social housing supports, the local authority is not required to provide homeless services. Under EU Law, a 'right to residence' for longer than three months is available to EU citizens who have sufficient resources for themselves and their family members not to become a burden on the host member state. The May homelessness report notes that 21 per cent of people in emergency accommodation were from the European Economic Area or the UK, while 28 per cent were non-EEA. The remaining 51 per cent were Irish citizens. Mr Browne said EU citizens who cannot financially support themselves will be returned home. However, he denied that this was an attempt to reduce the homelessness figures by removing non-Irish citizens from the list. He added: "We're talking about people who might have arrived in the country, who haven't been working here, who haven't been living here, and then seek social housing supports. It's people who have been here very, very short term." The Irish Mirror understands that the planned legislation will only be for new people coming into the system and anyone living in emergency accommodation will not be reassessed and it should not impact the current emergency accommodation figures. A Department of Housing spokesperson added: "Homelessness is a hugely complex issue and the Department does not speculate on fall or increase in numbers. "The information collected and published by the Department shows that there are many and varied reasons that households present to homeless services in local authorities and enter emergency accommodation. It is important that local authorities have a robust legal framework to assess households for homeless provision, and changes to the legislation are being considered on that basis." Join our Dublin Live breaking news service on WhatsApp. Click this link to receive your daily dose of Dublin Live content. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice . For all the latest news from Dublin and surrounding areas visit our homepage.
Extra.ie
a day ago
- Extra.ie
Housing Minister announces new measures to speeding up social homes
Developers who use the State's new standardised design templates for social homes will be granted planning permission 'an awful lot quicker', the Housing Minister has said. James Browne's comments came as he brought to Cabinet yesterday a suite of new measures aimed at speeding up the delivery of social homes. Among the plans approved by ministers is a proposal to condense the approval process for social housing projects from four stages to one. The measures will also mandate the use of specific design layouts for all new-build social housing projects being delivered by public bodies, to achieve 'value for money, and to promote greater use of Modern Methods of Construction' (MMC). Developers who use the State's new standardised design templates for social homes will be granted planning permission 'an awful lot quicker', the Housing Minister has said. Pic: Sam Boal/Collins Photo Mr Browne said yesterday that local authorities and approved housing bodies will be able to choose from a portfolio of 60 design templates, with the new arrangements to take effect from quarter three of this year. The Housing Minister said the designs are of 'very high quality' and will deliver 'uniformity' in the sector. 'Where delays come in [in social housebuilding] is where local authorities want a piece of vernacular, or want to change the number of windows, for example. That sounds fine except it leads to extraordinary delays, because then every window has to be measured by the Department of Housing. 'And I would be actually hoping that private builders would copy these designs as well, because they should be able to get through planning an awful lot quicker,' Mr Browne said. Pic: Getty Images The minister said that when the Government delivered large amounts of social housing in the past, there was a level of 'consistency' nationwide in terms of how the houses were designed. 'And that's really important for builders who want to tender for these projects, but also for MMC,' he said. MMC is a broad term that captures a diverse range of building processes and products. The term is generally used to describe construction which takes place in a factory setting as opposed to on-site. It includes the construction of full 3-D units or modules. According to Mr Browne, the widespread use of MMC will help speed up the delivery of housing and reduce the environmental impact of the residential construction sector. 'I believe that this can be a game changer in terms of that delivery from social housing,' he said.
The Journal
a day ago
- The Journal
Renaming An Bord Pleanála - and letting everyone know - has cost €77,000
THE RENAMING OF An Bord Pleanála to An Coimisiún Pleanála (ACP) has cost the State planning watchdog nearly €77,000. New figures provided by An Coimisiún Pleanála show that the renaming has cost the State's flagship planning agency €76,921. The largest component is a €22,045 spend on the installation of external signage over its entrance and two corner projection signs with the new name at the agency's Marlborough Street HQ in Dublin 1. The €76,921 outlay also included a spend of €18,450 on architect consultancy which provided design, coordination and project management services for internal ground floor signs and external signage. The spend also included €18,450 on a radio ad campaign, €5,380 on a new sign installation cancellation fee, €6,363 on newspaper notices and €3,637 on the change of name on the corporate seal and rubber stamps. Sinn Féin housing spokesperson Eoin Ó Broin today described the spend as 'completely unnecessary as there was no need to change the name of An Bord Pleanála'. When first mooted in 2023 in wake of scandals at An Bord Pleanála, trade union FORSA expressed its opposition to plans to change the name as it would amount to a 'collective punishment'. Advertisement In correspondence with then Minister for Housing Darragh O'Brien, assistant general secretary at FORSA, Ian McDonnell said that the Forsa branch within An Bord Pleanála had passed a motion 'expressing their opposition to this proposed name change'. McDonnell said that the proposed chance 'reflects negatively on all who work in the organisation' and is akin to 'collective punishment of all (past and present) in the organisation who have worked and continue to work diligently and conscientiously in accordance with public sector values of impartiality and integrity'. Ó Broin said that as a member of the Oireachtas Housing Committee he tabled an amendment to the then Planning and Development Bill to have the name of An Bord Pleanala retained but this was rejected by Government. Asked about staff's attitude to the name change, a spokesman for An Coimisiún Pleanála today said: 'In terms of staff feeling on the name change, while there was some unhappiness about the changing of the name when it was first suggested in early 2023, now the name change has taken place, the staff and planning commissioners of the Commission have embraced and accepted the name change. He stated that 'good developments are built on solid foundations and An Coimisiún Pleanála is built on the most solid of foundations which is down to the part played by all former staff and Board members who have served with An Bord Pleanála over the last 48 years'. As part of the bid to reduce backlog in appeals, the number of senior planning inspectors at An Coimisiún Pleanála totals 60 at the end of June 2025 compared to 45 at the end of December 2023. The appeals board now has two Directors of Planning while the number of planning inspectors has reduced from 39 at the end of last year to 35 now though five new appointees are due to start in July and August. The most recent quarterly figures show that the number of cases on hand at the end of March this year was 1,369, which was down 39% on the 2,247 cases on hand at the end of March 2024.
