Don't let TNSTC buses cross toll plazas in south Tamil Nadu, Madras High Court directs four NHAI concessionaires
Justice N. Anand Venkatesh said, he had no choice but to take the extreme step of preventing public transportation through the toll plazas since the State transport department had not taken steps to settle arrears of ₹276 crore to the four National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) concessionaires.
'Deploy police'
Conscious of passing a shocking order that could lead to law and order situation, the judge directed the Director General of Police/Head of Police Force (DGP/HoPF) to ensure deputation of adequate police force at Kappalur, Etturavattam, Salaipudhur and Nanguneri toll plazas to prevent untoward incidents.
The judge directed the High Court Registry to mark a copy of his interim order to the DGP as well as the Inspector General of Police (south zone) for compliance in letter and spirit and decided to take stock of the situation on July 15.
The concessionaires
Madurai-Kanniyakumari Tollway Private Limited, Kanniyakumari-Etturavattam Tollway Private Limited, Salaipudur-Madurai Tollway Private Limited and Nanguneri-Kanniyakumari Tollway Private Limited had approached the court last year by filing individual writ petitions.
Senior counsel Sathish Parasaran, representing the writ petitioners, contended that his clients had been suffering huge losses due to the failure of Tamil Nadu government buses to pay toll charges despite using the national highways for transporting their passengers.
No Fastag
He said, most of the government buses also do not have Fastag facility in violation of the rules framed by the Centre. Mr. Parasaran said, the toll plaza staff could not dare to stop the buses, for non-payment of toll, because of the fear of it snowballing into a law and order situation.
It was brought to the notice of the court that the State transport corporations had settled only about ₹48.5 crore and that still ₹276 crore (including the principal amount of ₹116 crore apart from penalty and interest) was yet to be paid to the four NHAI concessionaires.
After recording the submissions, Justice Venkatesh said, the amount might end up growing to over ₹300 to ₹400 crore if the transport corporations continue to prolong the issue without quickly sitting across the table with the concessionaires in order to settle the dues.
He also observed the government officials may not understand the seriousness of the issue and act swiftly unless an extreme step of stopping the buses at the toll plazas was resorted to. He said, the corporations had brought such a precarious situation upon themselves thereby adversely affecting the common people.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
21 minutes ago
- Business Standard
Custodial torture cannot be considered police duty: Kerala High Court
The Kerala High Court recently ruled that police officers accused of custodial torture cannot be exonerated solely due to the absence of government sanction, reported Bar and Bench. Justice Kauser Edappagath made these remarks while hearing a revision petition filed by a woman named Sudha, who had previously worked as a housemaid. She was accused by her employers of stealing gold sovereigns and was subsequently taken to the police station, where she alleged she was subjected to custodial torture, the report added. She was beaten and tortured by police officers for over three hours before her employers admitted the missing gold had been found at home. Sudha later filed a private complaint before a Magistrate Court, which found enough grounds to proceed against both the employers and the police under various provisions of the IPC and the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act. However, a sessions court discharged all the accused—citing lack of prima facie evidence against the employers and absence of prior sanction to prosecute the police—prompting Sudha to challenge the decision in the High Court through a revision petition. Custodial torture not protected under CrPC The High Court noted that custodial torture cannot be considered part of the official duties of the police. Therefore, it should not be shielded by legal provisions requiring prior government sanction for prosecution. 'The act of custodial torture inflicted by a police officer without justification on an arrestee cannot be shielded under the protective mantle of Section 197 of CrPC,' the judgment stated. 'It can never be said that a police officer acts or purports to act in discharge of his official duty when he inflicts custodial torture on an arrestee.' Section 197 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) mandates prior government approval before prosecuting public servants for actions committed in the course of their official duties. 'Worst kind of violence' The court also noted that custodial torture represents a grave violation in any society governed by the rule of law. Highlighting the broader implications, the judgment stated: "The courts must not lose sight of the fact that custodial torture is perhaps one of the worst kinds of crime in a civilised society, governed by the rule of law and poses a serious threat to an orderly civilised society. Police excesses and the maltreatment of detainees/undertrial prisoners or suspects tarnish the image of any civilised nation and encourage the men in 'Khaki' to consider themselves to be above the law and sometimes even to become law unto themselves," as quoted by Bar and Bench. It further urged the court to deal with such in a realistic manner and with the sensitivity that they deserve. "Otherwise, the common man may lose faith in the judiciary itself," it noted. Normalisation of torture within police forces A recent study revealed that a significant proportion of police personnel in India view the use of physical force during interrogation as justified. According to the Status of Policing in India Report 2025 by Common Cause and Lokniti-CSDS, over half of police personnel surveyed believe it is important to use tough methods, including violence, to instil fear among criminals. Around 30 per cent justify the use of third-degree torture in serious cases. It also highlighted that 22 per cent of police personnel believe that killing 'dangerous criminals' is better than giving them a legal trial. Many officers surveyed held the view that methods such as beatings were effective in extracting confessions or maintaining order. The study also indicated that a considerable number of officers did not see the use of torture as a violation of human rights.
The Hindu
2 hours ago
- The Hindu
Madras High Court puts on hold order barring TNSTC buses from crossing NHAI toll plazas in south T.N.
The Madras High Court on Thursday (July 10, 2025) kept in abeyance till July 31, 2025, an order passed by it on Tuesday (July 8), directing four National Highway Authority of India (NHAI) concessionaires in the southern districts of Tamil Nadu not to let Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation (TNSTC) buses pass through their toll plazas due to the non-payment of toll arrears of ₹276 crore. Justice N. Anand Venkatesh kept his order in abeyance after Additional Advocate General J. Ravindran informed the court that the Transport Secretary had called for a meeting on Thursday with the NHAI concessionaires and hopefully, some solution would be found, though the government had reservations about the quantum of arrears. The judge said, the issue of fixing Fastag in the TNSTC buses could also be resolved since it had now become mandatory for all motor vehicles, and failure to fix them could lead to the levy of penalty. He also took into consideration the hardship that would be caused to those who use public transport before deciding to keep his previous order in abeyance. Madurai-Kanniyakumari Tollway Private Limited, Kanniyakumari-Etturavattam Tollway Private Limited, Salaipudur-Madurai Tollway Private Limited, and Nanguneri-Kanniyakumari Tollway Private Limited had filed a batch of writ petitions in 2024, accusing the TNSTC of not having settled a huge amount of toll arrears. Passing interim orders on the petitions on Tuesday, the judge had directed them not to permit TNSTC buses to ply through the Kappalur, Etturavattam, Salaipudhur, and Nanguneri toll plazas, and directed the Director General of Police as well as Inspector General of Police (south zone) to deploy adequate police force at those plazas.
NDTV
2 hours ago
- NDTV
UP Police Deploys With Drones, Parliamentary Forces For Kanwar Yatra Security
Lucknow: The Uttar Pradesh Police have deployed the Rapid Action Force (RAF), Quick Response Team (QRT), and Anti-Terror Squad to ensure the secure conduct of the Kanwar Yatra, which begins on July 11. According to the guidelines issued by Director General of Police (DGP) Rajiv Krishna, 587 Gazetted Officers, 2040 Inspectors, 13,520 Sub-Inspectors, 39,965 Head Constables and Constables, 1,486 Women Sub-Inspectors, 8,541 Women Head Constables and Constables, 50 Companies of Central Police Force and Pradeshik Armed Constabulary (PAC) and 1,424 Home Guards have been deployed. Arrangements are being made for 24/7 active patrolling. UP-112 personnel have been briefed in this regard, and their vehicles have been arranged. Local divers have been deployed on the banks of rivers and canals after proper briefing and training. Barricading and danger signs are also being put up on the banks of rivers. A total of 395 drones have been set up for the smooth conduct of the Yatra. Instructions have been given to make available the mobile numbers of all police officers and station in-charge, the traffic diversion scheme and other important information to the devotees through barcodes in newspaper advertisements, hoardings and social media. 1,845 water service centres, 829 medical camps, 1,222 police help centres and control rooms have been set up on the main Kanwar route. According to the guidelines by the DGP, the administration has installed 29,454 CCTV cameras on the Kanwar route and in all the camps after an anti-sabotage check. Real-time monitoring will be done using the CCTV camera and drones. An eight-member team has been formed at the Social Media Centre of DGP Headquarters, which will send all the inputs received on social media related to the Kanwar Yatra to the concerned district. The team will debunk fake news and take action against those spreading rumours. Another eight-member team has been formed at the DGP headquarters, which will remain alert 24 hours a day and monitor the inputs received from electronic media, UP-112 and all other sources. An inter-state WhatsApp group has been created to coordinate between officials from UP, Uttarakhand, Haryana and Rajasthan, to exchange real-time information regarding the status of routes, security arrangements and crowd control, the guidelines by the DGP stated. For traffic management, adequate lighting, electronic signboards, and indicator signs have been installed at major intersections and routes. Various highways have been identified for traffic diversion due to congestion on the Kanwar route. According to the DGP, the proposed barricading and route diversion scheme is being rehearsed. Traffic diversion information will be released on time through press releases, various newspapers, local channels and social media. The devotees are being made aware not to run vehicles at a rapid pace, the guidelines said. Instructions have been given to make the Kanwariyas move only on the left side of the highways and to allow the Bhandaara or a camp to operate only on the left side at a distance of 20 feet from the road. According to the guidelines, adequate arrangements have been made for the safety of women kanwariyas. Immediate action will be taken if any information is received regarding indecent behaviour with them by any person or other kanwariya group. Hotels and dhabas on the Kanwar route will be monitored in coordination with the food department to maintain the quality. Also, the rate list of food items will be displayed so that the shopkeepers cannot overcharge.
