Kwagga says Boks did not meet their standards against Italy
Kwagga Smith says the Springboks even though they analysed Italy well during the week, they were still not up to scratch. Picture: Ashley Vlotman/Gallo Images
Springbok loose forward Kwagga Smith said there were several areas they needed to improve after their frustrating 42–24 victory against Italy on Saturday.
The world champions hosted the 10th-ranked side (which was also understrength) at Loftus, with the rugby world expecting a big win, even though Italy had been playing well.
They beat Namibia 73–6 a week ago. Additionally, since the start of last year, they have beaten Wales (twice), Georgia, Japan, Tonga, and Scotland, while drawing against France and losing to Ireland by five points and England by three.
The 18-point victory almost felt like a loss, however. While Springbok players and coach Rassie Erasmus were dejected after the game, the Italy squad were all smiles.
Boks did not meet their standards
'We want to be the best team in the world,' Smith said. 'You've got to be honest with yourself. If you know you didn't play to your ability and you didn't play well, although you win by 18 points, it doesn't matter. It's all about your standards and living up to those standards.'
He said the Springboks knew Italy would be physical after analysing them this week. 'They really did well, even though we knew it was coming. All credit to them.'
The scoreline would have looked different if not for Italy's disallowed try and another that was held up, while the Springboks had one try disallowed.
But it was Italy's try from a driving maul starting around the South Africans' 22, that silenced the crowd and appeared to emotionally hurt the Springboks, who are traditionally dominant in pack battles.
'We are disappointed in that. We never want to give away a maul try,' Smith added. 'I think in the last three years we didn't give away a lot of maul tries. So that obviously hurts. We will definitely look at that and see where we can rectify to be better next week.'
Springboks fail to maintain momentum against Italy
After leading 28–3 at the break, the Springboks lost all their momentum in the second half, scoring 14 points against Italy's 21 in that period.
It all seemed to change after Vincent Tshituka's try was disallowed for an earlier obstruction. Smith said the Springboks should have 'kept punching' after that.
'We allowed them in, and that obviously gave them a lot of confidence and momentum.' He said momentum is hard to stop when you cannot get continuity, 'and the breakdown is a mess every time, and the ball spits out. It is difficult because you are just playing scrappy rugby, literally just fixing mistakes the whole time.'
He said the South Africans would have to analyse how they lost the breakdown battle.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
an hour ago
- Daily Maverick
Springboks seek referee feedback after breakdown mess at Loftus
Frustrated members of the Springbok management team have asked referee Hollie Davidson and her team for clarity ahead of the decisive Test against Italy in Gqeberha on Saturday. Rassie Erasmus used the word 'frustrated' several times in the aftermath of the Springboks' 42-24 win against a weakened Italy at Loftus Versfeld last Saturday. The Bok coach lamented South Africa's lack of intensity in the second half, and went as far as to suggest that there would be consequences ahead of the next team announcement. In the same breath, Erasmus questioned the legality of Italy's breakdown approach and intimated that the officials were too lenient on the visitors. Both teams have since transferred to Gqeberha for the decisive Test of the series. While it's a new city subject to different weather and playing conditions, the Boks are determined to receive answers on some of the recent breakdown calls. These answers will have some bearing on the next game, as the same teams will feature and the same group of officials will be on duty at the Nelson Mandela Bay Stadium – although Andrew Brace will referee the match, with Hollie Davidson joining assistant referee Matthew Carley on the touchline. Feedback On Monday, the Boks made another strong statement on the matter when they sent laws and discipline adviser Jaco Peyper to the first media conference of the week. The former Test referee went out of his way to acknowledge the officials, before asking for clarity and consistency in their application of the laws. 'We think that Hollie and the rest of the team here in South Africa are good referees, and they're the type of referees who will give you feedback when you ask for feedback,' Peyper said. 'Regarding the weekend's game [at Loftus], there are one or two questions that we've raised. 'We respect the refs, we know that they go through their game reviews, and we are sure they will give us some honest feedback. 'That will put us all into a better position going into the next game.' The breakdowns were a mess in the latter stages of the first Test, with stray boots and hands edging the ball back towards the defensive side on numerous occasions. One could ask why a vastly experienced Bok team wasn't more street smart, or why they didn't exploit the refereeing interpretations to their benefit. Those who watched the game, of course, would have noted how the contest lacked rhythm and energy in the second half. Pressed for specifics, Peyper conceded that the management of the breakdown was the point of query. 'In rugby, when you carry dominant or when you tackle dominant, the little bit of grace sits with you. 'We have to make sure that we show the referee a picture that is easier to referee, and that we don't allow for too much interpretation or management. 'We need to know how we can adjust, and we need feedback – but it's a positive process, this is not bagging anyone. 'It's not about us being unhappy, it's a question of learning. We've got to make sure that we adjust to the referees. 'World Rugby sends out best practises [before the start of tournaments and international windows], and we need to know that we understand those correctly, and that we are training our players accordingly.' Some officials give a competing player a warning in order to keep the game flowing. Others are quick to penalise a player who is deliberately slowing the ball down at the ruck. Harsher As the interaction with Peyper progressed, it became clear that the Boks want the officials to be harsher on breakdown offenders in the coming match. 'It comes down to whether the ref sees an infringement, whether they ask the player to stop doing that, or whether the referee referees the infringement,' said Peyper. With regard to other areas of play, the Bok coaches and players admit that they were well below par at Loftus. Peyper went to bat for the officials as well as the opposition when it was suggested that Italians may have impeded in the lead-up to their maul-try in the second half. The Italy maul was set from some 20 metres out, yet the Boks – who pride themselves on this facet of play – failed to stop it. 'I don't think it's a law thing,' Peyper confirmed, 'It was just a really good maul by Italy that was poorly defended by us. 'That part of the game is part of our soul, so that was a big negative for us.' Bok prop Thomas du Toit – who was omitted from the lineup last week but looks set to play a role in the second Test – was equally honest about the team's shortcomings. 'We set high standards for ourselves in a match,' Du Toit said. 'When we review a game [as the Boks did on Monday morning], we compare ourselves to how we were the week before, and ask ourselves whether we were better. '[With regard to the last game] we have to look at ourselves in the mirror and say that we weren't. We've also got to acknowledge that Italy were very good.' The Bok team to play Italy will be announced at 3.15pm on Tuesday. DM
Daily Maverick
an hour ago
- Daily Maverick
NSPCA takes aim at Durban July and cruelty in SA's horse racing industry
A new campaign to clean up South Africa's horse racing industry started with a fashion statement that shocked glamorous guests at the country's premier horse race. The Durban July held last weekend was South Africa's most glamorous day of racing — a swirl of high fashion, Champagne flutes and big bets. Amid the spectacle, actress and activist Nirvana Nokwe stepped on to the red carpet dressed not to dazzle, but to disturb. Draped in an unsettling art piece paying tribute to racehorses abandoned and broken when they're no longer profitable, Nokwe's striking look was a wake-up call: the 'sport of kings' is built on suffering. Her bold statement launched the National Council of SPCAs' (NSPCA's) Rein in the Pain campaign — a challenge to the Durban July's glossy image and a call for South Africans to confront the cruelty that lurks behind the roar of the crowd. 'This isn't just about what happens on race day,' said Nokwe. 'It's about what we don't see — the tongue-ties, the brutal whipping, the strained tendons, the fractured legs, the bleeding lungs. Fashion can make a statement, and this one says: It's time to change.' The dark truth According to the NSPCA, behind the turf tracks, mint juleps and TV cameras is a brutal system. Thoroughbreds — the sleek, high-speed horses synonymous with the Durban July — are bred for explosive performance. They can hit 60km/h in just a few strides, but that speed often comes at the cost of broken bones, strained ligaments and shortened lives. Many horses begin racing before their skeletons are fully developed, leaving them prone to injuries that force early retirement, or worse. 'These magnificent animals are being silenced by a system that too often places profit above their welfare,' said Jacques Peacock, NSPCA communications manager. 'Tradition can't excuse cruelty.' Every year, the South African racing industry registers around 2,000 new thoroughbred foals, adding to a population of about 30,000. Only a fraction of these will ever make it to the big racecourses. Many of those that do will be cast aside when they stop winning — and their new lives are often far from the manicured paddocks they once knew. The 'lost horses' While some racehorses have second careers in showjumping or leisure riding, a disturbing number simply vanish. A Daily Maverick investigation into the thoroughbred world revealed that thousands slip into a welfare black hole when they no longer earn. Some end up in slaughterhouses, their meat sold for lion parks or game reserves. Many more fall into the unregulated world of 'bush racing', where abandoned racehorses are flogged to race for small stakes or illegal bets on potholed dirt roads and tarred township streets. In these informal races, dubbed 'community racing', the cruelty can be staggering. Saddles are often ill-fitted or non-existent, bits are replaced with wire that tears mouths, and exhausted horses collapse from injuries or overwork. When the NSPCA inspected an Eastern Cape race, they found more than 100 ex-thoroughbreds, many with injuries so severe they had to be euthanised on the spot. 'They used to be pampered, treated better than most humans,' said an NSPCA inspector. 'Now they're tossed away like old shoes at a jumble sale.' Racing's shaky foundations While informal bush racing booms, formal thoroughbred racing in SA is on the decline. Since 1990, the number of horses starting races has dropped by nearly a third. In 2022, when we did the investigation, half of the country's racecourses had shut down, and the number of breeders and stud farms had plummeted by more than 80%. Once a lucrative spectacle, thoroughbred racing now survives largely thanks to betting houses and bookies, who rake in billions while owners struggle to cover the spiralling costs of raising and training a winning horse. 'You have to be wealthy to own racehorses, but you're not likely to get wealthy racing them,' said an owner. 'You're lucky if a win covers a few months' stabling costs.' Yet the real losers aren't the owners — they're the horses. The NSPCA argues that the racing industry's obsession with breeding and speed is producing more animals than it can or will care for. And once these horses leave the formal tracks, the National Horseracing Authority (NHRA) admits it has almost no power to track what happens to them next. Bush racing pipeline From the plush paddocks of the Durban July to the dusty roads of rural racing, a hidden pipeline funnels discarded thoroughbreds straight into a world of unchecked suffering. Some are sold or simply given away when they can't win any more. Others are bought up by owners who lack the knowledge — or the resources — to care for such high-maintenance animals. 'The big problem is thoroughbreds,' says Stanley Adam of the Eastern Cape Horse Care Unit. 'They're like Ferraris — you can't take a Ferrari and drive it down a gravel road and expect it to blossom.' Traditional racing is deeply woven into rural life. For some, it's a point of pride, a cultural celebration. But the lack of regulation can leave horses exposed to horrific injuries, doping, malnutrition and abuse. And unlike formal races, there are rarely vets on site and no accountability. However, the NSPCA's Farm Animal Protection Unit tries to inspect every informal or community race that takes place in SA. 'We rely on donations and used to do inspections as far up as Kuruman,' said Theresa Hodgkinson of the Highveld Horse Care Unit. 'But funding dried up. Now we see more thoroughbreds sold into informal racing — and many are in terrible condition.' A roadmap for change The NSPCA's Rein in the Pain campaign isn't just about raising awareness — it's about fixing a system that, in the organisation's view, is built to fail the animals at its heart. It has drafted clear, practical amendments to the NHRA's rules, setting a minimum standard for change. Key demands include: Banning performance-enhancing drugs and masking agents used to push injured horses through races; Phasing out harmful equipment like tongue ties by the end of this year; Completely banning whips by 2029 — with strict limits and schooling for jockeys in the interim; Ensuring that horses are microchipped by six months old and properly tracked from birth to retirement and beyond; Prohibiting racing horses under three years old to prevent premature skeletal damage; and Enforcing lifetime care and accountability, with criminal charges and lifetime bans for repeat offenders. 'These reforms are the bare minimum,' said Peacock. 'They're not exhaustive, but they're a start. This is about public trust — people need to see the industry take real responsibility for the animals that make it possible.' For the NSPCA, the real test will be whether ordinary South Africans demand this change. It's calling on the public to sign its petition at and to hold racing's big players accountable for the animals behind the betting slips and fancy hats. 'Our goal is simple,' says Peacock. 'We want the industry to stop pretending that window-dressing measures and paltry fines are enough. It's time for meaningful change — and it starts with every one of us saying, 'Enough is enough.'' DM
TimesLIVE
8 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
Banyana sweat in the heat to see off Ghana in Wafcon opener
Banyana Banyana had to work hard in the heat for a 2-0 opening Women's Africa Cup of Nations (Wafcon) Group C victory at Stade d'Honneur in Oujda on Monday. Linda Motlhalo's 29th-minute penalty and Jermaine Seoposenwe's strike in the 35th gave the defending champions a 2-0 lead at the break in a match played in 34°C late afternoon Moroccan midsummer heat after a 5pm local-time kickoff (6pm in SA). Banyana were under a good deal more pressure in the second half, where Ghana rocked the woodwork twice, but also again had their chances as they managed the clash and scoreline to the end. South Africa coach Desiree Ellis will be delighted with the result — she said ahead of the game opening a tournament group stage with a win means everything. She might have some concerns over some of her team's defending and how they seemed to tire in the last half-hour. The South Africans meet Tanzania in their next fixture on Friday and complete their group campaign against Mali next week Monday, both also at Stade d'Honneur. Both those games are at 8pm in Oujda (9pm SA time), when temperatures might be marginally more manageable. Ghana's heyday in the Wafcon came in the late 1990s and early 2000s when they were runners-up three times, finished third twice and fourth once in six successive competitions, a period where they also reached three World Cups. They have been less successful in the seven tournaments since, which have yielded one semifinal, four group exits and two failures to qualify. Still, they are a competitive and pedigreed women's outfit in Africa. Banyana had to have their wits about them, with goalkeeper Andile Dlamini also a strong last line of defence, to keep their clean sheet on Monday, also working hard for their chances. Banyana took a two-goal lead to the break that was deserved on balance of play and the territory and possession the South Africans enjoyed, though they also had the odd nervous moment at the back. One of those came early on when Dlamini had to tip left-back Anasthesia Achiaa's lob over the bar. Banyana's opener came after a video assistant referee review rule Ghana defender Grace Asantewaa had made illegal contact with her knee into Noxolo Cesane, who went down under the challenge. The hugely experienced playmaker Motlhalo stepped up and calmly slotted low to the right of stationary goalkeeper Cynthia Konlan. The second came not long after that, right-back Lebohang Ramalepe played into space on the flank to slip an angled pass into the path of the perfectly-timed run of Seoposenwe, who stroked a low finish past Konlan. The South Africans had so much of the play they seemed to allow for some complacency at the back against a Black Queens attack that could produce dangerous moments. Near the break Asantewaa's strike from outside the box was palmed past the left upright by Dlamini, then Evelyn Badu was played into acres of space on the right and squared for Doris Boaduwaa, who was denied by the desperate challenge of defender Fikile Magama. Back from the change rooms Ghana continued to ask questions. On the hour Alice Kusi struck a thunderous drive from range into the crossbar, then striker Boaduwaa's effort from the rebound was stopped by Dlamini. In response Seoposenwe cantered down the right and struck inches wide across the face. Ghana opened the South Africans again in he final 10 minutes when Comfort Yeboah's cross found Badu to head onto the bar.
