Crying cowboy builder on benefits can't repay victims but wants to go on holiday
Mark Carey swindled people who contacted his MTC Landscaping and Solutions business on Facebook.
It was estimated he caused six victims a loss of more than £11,000 in total by promising work by either never showing up or delivering a substandard service.
READ MORE: Judge accuses mum of getting pregnant to avoid jail in blast over contraception
The 42-year-old, from Hazelwell Drive, Kings Heath, broke down in tears in the dock at Birmingham Crown Court as he was spared jail on Monday, June 30.
He was handed an 11-month sentenced suspended for two years including 30 days rehabilitation activity and a two-month electronically tagged curfew between the hours of 10pm and 7am.
Recorder Fiona Clancy asked if the latter requirement would cause any difficulty to Carey.
Joey Kwong, defending, explained that 'before his family found about this case' a relative had booked a flight for Carey to depart the UK tomorrow to attend his nephew's wedding.
He said: "Mr Carey is well aware he does not deserve to go on this trip but for the sake of his nephew..."
At that stage Recorder Clancy interjected and told him: "There is absolutely no way this defendant is going on a holiday abroad when he has defrauded those individuals.
"He is lucky to keep his liberty, there's no way. The electronically monitored curfew is going to be imposed."
The judge had earlier declared she was 'disgusted' by Carey's offending and expressed 'surprise' he had attended court without belongings to take to prison.
She told him he had avoided being jailed by 'the skin of your teeth' after hearing the loss of an unborn child had caused a significant downturn in his mental health, prompting him to abuse alcohol and painkillers at the time.
Recorder Clancy also stated she was 'displeased' she could not order Carey to pay compensation to his victims or contribute towards prosecution costs because he was currently not working and only receiving Universal Credit.
She reserved any future breaches of the suspended sentence order to herself and said: "If I find out he has breached the order he can attend next time with his bags packed."
Addressing Clarey directly Recorder Clancy added: "You are incredibly fortunate not to be going down the stairs today, incredibly.
"You turned up without bags, there must have been some expectation of not going down the stairs today.
"Don't in any way have sympathy to yourself for the fact you are missing out on a holiday. That's the punitive element required."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Bloomberg
38 minutes ago
- Bloomberg
UK Trial by Jury Faces Axe for Serious Financial Crime Cases, Judge Says
The UK criminal justice system is set for its biggest shakeup in decades after a government ordered review recommended getting rid of jury trials in complex white collar crime. The jury system has been the mainstay of the UK's justice system for centuries but record high case backlogs, crumbling infrastructure and a shortage of judges and criminal lawyers has forced a rethink.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Sean 'Diddy' Combs trial juror breaks silence on verdict: 'I understand'
For the first time, a juror who took part in Sean "Diddy" Combs' eight-week trial is speaking out. George, one of the 18 people – which included six alternates – who served on Combs' jury, spoke with both CNN and The New York Times a day after Combs was found guilty of only two of the five criminal charges he faced. The man, who was one of the alternates and therefore was not privy to the 12-person jury's approximately two days of deliberations, told the news outlets "I understand" the verdict. On July 2, Combs was convicted of two counts of transportation to engage in prostitution but acquitted of the most serious charge of racketeering, as well as two sex trafficking counts. "Reading all my notes and looking back at the evidence, I probably would have reached the same conclusion as the other jurors," George told CNN anchor and chief legal analyst Laura Coates of the racketeering charge. "I think there was always a little bit of doubt in people's minds. I think it was a tough case to prove, especially the first (charge of racketeering). There was always a little bit of doubt there, even from the beginning." George, who said he was aware of Combs before the trial but didn't know his music, also said Combs' defense team managed to make Dawn Richard appear "very not credible." "I even wrote in my notebook it was like a takedown," George said. The man described being impressed by the defense's work in court and noted Combs was very attentive in the courtroom. "He was fighting for himself," George said. In court for Diddy's verdict: Judge stops celebration short by denying bail; Cassie calls Diddy a threat George told The Times he wasn't convinced by the prosecution's assertions that Cassie Ventura Fine and the anonymous ex-girlfriend "Jane" were sex trafficked — counts two and four, of which Combs was not found guilty. "I don't think it was forced," George said of the women's sexual encounters with escorts, which he not only watched footage of but also heard about during testimony. He added they seemed to be "willing participants," telling CNN the defense showed text messages from Ventura Fine in which she didn't seem "forced" to participate in sexual activities. However, George told CNN that "I think we did" believe Ventura. He added she gave "very credible" testimony and said, "She wouldn't have done all this just to come up there and lie about everything." 'A heartbreaking verdict': The Jurors' decision — and its impact on assault survivors Ventura Fine testified about her experiences over four days while nearly due to give birth to her third child, and Jane was in court for six days. They both told jurors they felt coerced into fulfilling Combs' sexual desires, either motivated by a need to make him happy or fear of his retribution. As for Jane, George told CNN, "I did believe her. Some parts didn't add up as much. It seemed a little strange." He specifically referred to her testimony about the incident in which Combs allegedly physically assaulted her in 2024. George also downplayed the so-called "freak off" videos that were shielded from public view. He revealed the footage involved sexual activity, but it wasn't as graphic as some speculated. Diddy trial testimony bombshells: What his inner circle said about baby oil, 'freak offs' "It was actually pretty tame; it was just a lot of rubbing oil and stuff. It wasn't anything too graphic," he told CNN. Despite not seeing Combs as guilty of the most aggressive criminal charges – racketeering conspiracy and sex trafficking – George told Coates he is not eager to have any communications with the former hip-hop icon. "To be honest, I really wouldn't want to talk to (Combs) or anyone really associated with that," he said. This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Diddy trial juror reveals himself, explains verdict
New York Post
2 hours ago
- New York Post
Albany mayor and progressives owe ex-DA Soares an apology
After yet another epic weekend of teen gun crime in Albany, local Democrats are implicitly admitting that longtime District Attorney David Soares was right after all — a year after the party machine ousted him for refusing to shut up about how state 'reforms' fuel the violence. Amid generally slamming overbroad criminal-justice changes for New York's rising crime, Soares relentlessly fingered the Raise the Age law for teaching teens all the wrong lessons — angering the Legislature's leaders enough that they got the Albany party to deny him the party line in last year's election. The 2017 Raise the Age law upped the age of criminal responsibility to 18 — mandating that nearly all 16- and 17-year-olds, even those charged with violent offenses or caught with loaded guns, go to Family Court and so walk right out with barely a slap on the wrist. Now, after teen shootings left 10 wounded and (thanks to a flare gun) set a house ablaze, Albany Mayor Kathy Sheehan is echoing Soares: 'This is not about needing more youth basketball,' she fumed. 'These are some of the hardest kids to reach.' Albany is 'flooded with guns,' she declared last month after two teens were shot near the Governor's Mansion. 'At what number will the body count be enough to prompt action?' Soares asked after two fatal shootings in 2023. Two years later, the body count continues to rise. And the carnage will continue unless and until Democrats representing communities plagued by youth gun crimes demand an end to the Legislature's failed criminal-justice experiments.
