Calgary homeowner livid after city proposes bylaw change mid-fight
When Evgeny Zhuromsky won the right to appeal a major infill development next door, he thought he finally had a chance.
He figured the company developing a nine-unit row house on his next-door neighbour's land would be forced to pause until he finally got his day in court.
Now the rules could change.
Calgary city council is being asked to vote Tuesday on a bylaw change that would allow homebuilders to proceed with a project even if it's before the Alberta Court of Appeal. And Zhuromsky feels it's desperately unfair.
"Residents of Calgary … are penalized for not following or breaking bylaws, like, for example, if you over park or do not shovel your sidewalk on time," said Zhuromsky.
"That's a double standard because they require you and me and all Calgarians to follow bylaws and they allow themselves not to."
Zhuromsky lives in Windsor Park, one lot in from the corner. He lost his appeal to the Subdivision and Development Appeal Board, then won the right to have his appeal heard at the provincial court. But the developer has already dug a hole and started laying the foundation for the row house next door after the city recently released the permit, despite Zhuromsky's appeal.
These developments are happening across the city, one year after city council passed blanket rezoning last spring. They're mainly being built in inner-city neighbourhoods like Bowness, but they're starting to pop up in established communities farther from the city centre, too.
Many are being appealed to the Subdivision and Development Appeal Board, a quasi-judicial board that can revoke individual city permits. But that process can take months, and it's even longer if it's brought to court. And for developers, that means costly delays.
That could change if council approves this move on Tuesday. But lawyers warn that will make it much more expensive and difficult for Calgarians who want to stop a development that affects them.
Delays cost up to $500 a day
The designer of the row house development, Designhaus Studio, declined to comment on behalf of its client, Best Investment Group, since the case is before the courts.
The Calgary Inner City Builders Association, a group of more than 200 developers, didn't know about the proposed bylaw change. But chair Shameer Gaidhar has had concerns about the cost of appeals for a long time.
He said the appeal process is important — Calgarians deserve that right. But it costs an average of $200 to $500 per day when a project sits empty, he said.
"It costs money for the appellant, it costs money for the developer. In the end, there's a cost. That cost gets passed on to the end user. Let it be the renter, let it be the buyer. Whatever it is, someone has to pay for it. So we're eroding affordability," said Gaidhar.
Gaidhar said he needs to learn more about the bylaw change before commenting on what it means for developers.
Councillors, city decline to comment
Ward 11 Coun. Kourtney Penner, whose ward includes Windsor Park, wouldn't comment on the situation because it's related to Zhuromsky's appeal before the courts.
Coun. Sonya Sharp's ward is hot with development. Her team reached out to city administration to get clarity on the bylaw change, however they couldn't give an answer — but indicated all councillors would receive an update ahead of the public hearing. So the Ward 1 councillor declined to comment.
The city also declined to comment on the particular part of the proposed bylaw change that would allow development permits to be released, even when a provincial appeal is underway.
"The City of Calgary believes that Calgarians are an important part of building a great city. Throughout the planning process Calgarians can provide feedback and comments for consideration. More information on how Calgarians can get involved in the planning process can be found in the Community Involvement Toolkit."
'A disastrous effect'
Randi Collins, a Calgary lawyer whose specialty includes real estate, said as the land use bylaw stands today, the city can't release development permits while a provincial appeal is underway. But she said it's well within the city's right to change its bylaw.
If it's approved, Collins said anyone who wants to stop a development from going ahead would have to go through another complicated and costly process: going to court and obtaining an injunction.
"It is actually a disastrous effect, in my opinion," said Collins.
"Essentially, the average person is going to have little recourse without expending large sums of money and navigating a very difficult legal system to do anything about it, which is concerning."
Collins said it speaks to a larger issue.
"Sometimes if the municipality is on board with a development, there's going to be little that you can do about it," she said.
"Municipal governments actually have quite a lot of rights and a lot of power, and the court system does hesitate to intervene unless there's a clear abuse of that power. So it's unfortunate for the average person."
Running out of time
It's been a long, difficult and expensive process for Zhuromsky to fight his next-door development, and he feels like he's running out of time.
The engineer, who's lived in his home in Windsor Park for 10 years, is still waiting for a court date to be set so his appeal can be heard. Until then, all he can do is watch construction proceed.
"[The developers] aren't doing anything that they're not supposed to be doing. It's the City of Calgary that … allowed them," said Zhuromsky.
While he considered applying for an injunction, he just doesn't think it's practical. So he's hanging on to hope that he'll win the appeal.
"I hope that if I win and they have to reapply, they will change the design so the structure that they are building now as we speak is per the municipal development plan, is complementary, sensitive and compatible with the rest of the community."
In the meantime, he plans to attend the public hearing on Tuesday to ask city councillors to say no to the change.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Calgary Herald
3 days ago
- Calgary Herald
With federal funding, city says it will exceed its goal of 42,000 new housing units by next year
A partnership with the federal government will see new homes for 100,000 Calgarians, as the City of Calgary announced Wednesday that it has blown past housing benchmarks set with the Housing Accelerator Fund. Article content The original target set alongside the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation aimed for just under 42,000 new housing units under way by fall of 2026. That target was later revised to 42,667 new units. Article content Article content Article content Since receiving the $228.5 million investment in October 2023, the city says it has incentivized 44,276 new units — 104 per cent of the revised targets — more than a year ahead of schedule. Article content Article content 'At the time, there's a lot of people who wondered if that target was maybe too ambitious. Today, I'm proud to stand here and say not only have we met the target, we have exceeded it more than a year ahead of schedule,' said Mayor Jyoti Gondek, speaking about the targets at the site of development recently approved through the fund. Article content 'These are futures that are made possible. It's a powerful reminder of what happens when different orders of government come together, where we collaborate, great things can happen, and that when we put funding in the hands of municipalities, we take action,' Gondek said. Article content In March, Calgary was awarded an additional $22.8 million, thanks to 'high performance under the HAF program thus far.' Article content Article content That funding will feed into two new initiatives, Backyard Suites and Accessory Dwellings Program, and the Downtown Complete Community Housing Program. The former will assist homeowners in developing secondary dwellings on their property, referred to by Gondek as a 'gentle density' initiative. Article content The latter includes several goals, namely the conversion of downtown office space into housing. Article content Housing targets in the program were further broken down by housing type. Reid Hendry, chief housing officer of the City of Calgary, said 'to date we've achieved 103 per cent of our multi-unit target and 152 per cent of our multi-unit near transit target.' Article content The targets for non-market housing are lagging behind the other two success stories, although the city says that those housing types are still on track for the original goalposts. The aim of non-market units sets at 746. 'To the end of June 2025, we're now at 301,' Hendry said.
Calgary Herald
16-07-2025
- Calgary Herald
City adjusts Stephen Avenue construction schedule changed to avoid disrupting summer business
Construction on the Stephen Avenue Revitalization Project is set to begin on Monday, July 21, after last week's brief but tense delay. Article content The updated timeline follows a wave of concern from business owners along the iconic downtown corridor, with the date originally set for July 14. Article content Article content The city hit pause on its long-awaited infrastructure overhaul after more than two dozen local businesses voiced frustration over a lack of consultation, threatening to pursue legal action if the city didn't listen to their demands. Article content Article content Timing was also a key concern, with the original construction date set just after the Stampede and in peak season for foot traffic in the area. Business owners feared that the planned 3-metre pedestrian access paths would divert potential customers away and would complicate the process of bringing inventory into their businesses. Article content Article content Now, after additional meetings with local business owners, the city has rolled out a revised plan that aims to strike a better balance. Article content 'Calgary's economy is growing, and as we invest in the future of our downtown, we remain committed to minimizing disruption to local businesses,' said Michael Thompson, general manager of infrastructure services with the City of Calgary, in a news release on Wednesday. Article content 'This updated construction plan reflects that balance by supporting summer patio operations while keeping the revitalization project on track,' he said. Article content Article content The new plan will begin with work on the east side of the 100 block S.E., between 1 Street S.E. and Centre Street. Then, starting on Sept. 2, more work including critical utility upgrades will expand to the west side of the street. Article content According to the city, the updated plan will allow most restaurant patios to remain open through the busy summer months. Article content The city now anticipates substantial completion of the block by June 2026 — just in time for next year's Stampede — with utility work along Centre Street continuing late into next year. Construction will come to a halt again next summer during July and August to reduce further disruption. Article content The project as a whole set to include several updates to underground infrastructure, including work on its electrical systems, stormwater pipes and century-old water mains. Article content At street level, Stephen Avenue will receive a full makeover aimed at improving accessibility, aesthetics and flexibility for outdoor businesses. Visually, Calgarians can expect to see upgrades to surfaces, foliage and additional site furnishings. Article content The project dovetails with other major downtown investments including renovations to the Glenbow Museum, Arts Commons and Olympic Plaza.
Calgary Herald
14-07-2025
- Calgary Herald
Calgary Stampede's Weadickville riding into sunset
A sleek coffee-coloured house — the prize of winning a lottery — stood behind Stampede's entry gates, drawing scores of people on July 8, all eager to grab a look at what a stroke of luck can offer them. Article content Tucked behind the Stampede Rotary Dream Home, facing the innumerable rides, vendors and raffle stalls and standing in solitude, save for a few teenagers on their cellphones, was a relic representing the city's foundation. Article content Article content Article content A shack constructed from round and roughly hewn logs stood beside another structure with a white exterior made of lumber bearing the initials N.W.M.P. for the North-West Mounted Police. The agency, the predecessor of the RCMP, was the first among European settlers to set up shop in the region, paving the way for the creation of Calgary. Article content The area, now a shell of its former self, is named after Guy Weadick, one of the founders of Stampede. The space, built in the mid-20th century as a replica of the streetscape in 1912 and a callback to the festival's roots, has been a popular spot for Calgarians who would visit the place for its shooting range, ice cream shops, or for solace from the chaos of Stampede. Article content Article content Soon, however, that space will give way to a 13-storey, 320-unit hotel with sweeping views of downtown, 14,000 square feet of food and beverage offerings and a south-facing terrace with a whirlpool tub and activity pool. Article content The project came to life when Calgary Municipal and Land Corporation and Calgary Stampede struck a praetorship with hotelier Truman, which will develop the hotel by 2028. Article content As a result, the former NWMP Morley detachment will be disassembled, stored and reassembled at a later date and in a different location, according to Calgary Stampede CEO Joel Cowley.
