Man alleges riot police beat him while he cycled to inspect Halloween fire
A jury has been sworn in at the
High Court
for the case of a
Dublin
man who alleges gardaí in riot gear beat him and broke his shoulder on Halloween night almost 17 years ago as he was cycling to investigate a fire next to his partner's home.
Gerard McCarthy (55) from Abbotstown Avenue in Finglas, Dublin, is suing the commissioner of
An Garda Síochána
, the Minister for Justice, Ireland and the Attorney General, claiming he was falsely imprisoned and assaulted by gardaí on Halloween, October 31st and November 1st, 2008.
The defendants deny the claims and on Tuesday at the High Court a jury of six men and six women was sworn in to hear the case in front of Mr Justice Alexander Owens.
Mr McCarthy was 38 at the time of the alleged assault and has submitted to the court he was with his partner in her home on Findlater Street, near O'Devaney Gardens, in north inner city Dublin, on the night.
READ MORE
Findlater Street backs on to what used to be the O'Devaney Gardens flat complex.
Mr McCarthy submits that on October 31st, 2008, two separate fires broke out on the other side of his partner's back wall at the apartment complex.
The plaintiff claims that the first fire happened at about midday, while the second fire began after dark in a large steel container close to the back of the Findlater premises.
He became concerned, he said, after smoke had billowed into the apartment through a rear extension. There was an electric shower in the extension and he was concerned it would catch fire, he said.
Mr McCarthy claims he cycled out to investigate and noticed gardaí in plain clothes nearby before he separately encountered gardaí in riot gear at the edge of O'Devaney Gardens. He said they charged him as he tried to turn his bicycle away.
The plaintiff claims he heard the words 'charge' from the riot gardaí, who numbered between 10 and 12. He said he was struck on both shoulders, his back and then legs while still on his bike in an attack that took between five and 10 seconds.
Mr McCarthy said he believes up to five riot police with shields and helmets struck him with their batons.
After the alleged assault, Mr McCarthy attended the Mater hospital that night but was anxious and dizzy and returned in the morning to have an X-ray.
Mr McCarthy claims his X-ray revealed a broken shoulder close to the collarbone. He said he was numb 'all over' with the pain and still in 'shock'.
The case continues on Thursday before Mr Justice Owens and is expected to last up to four days.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
2 hours ago
- Sunday World
Missing poker player lost €4k within hours of his arrival in Dublin, gardaí say
Investigation remains open after officers visit Iceland to interview people who knew the father of four Gardaí investigating the disappearance of Icelandic poker player Jon Jonsson 'haven't ruled anything out', including murder, suicide or an accident, according to the senior officer leading the probe. Mr Jonsson, a taxi driver, went missing on February 9, 2019, while attending the Dublin Poker Festival at the Regency Hotel (now renamed the Bonnington Hotel) on the northside of the city. Detective Superintendent Alan Brady led a delegation of five members of An Garda Síochána to the Icelandic capital, Reykjavik, last week to interview 46 people who knew the father of four. Among those interviewed were convicted criminals, as well as the missing man's family, friends and associates in the poker world. Gambling is illegal in Iceland, and Mr Jonsson was heavily involved in the scene in his homeland. Det Supt Brady, who is attached to Ballymun garda station, said: 'We formally interviewed 46 people. We will now go home and assess all the information we received, which was worthwhile for the investigation. 'We interviewed Jon's friends, family members and poker players. We interviewed some convicted criminals who knew him. There has been a lot of rumour about what happened to Jon in Dublin — that his death was linked to the poker community here. Even rumours of a hitman. Gardaí say they haven't ruled anything out 'We believe that whatever happened to Jon, happened in Ireland. But we also think that the answers to what happened to him lie among the Icelandic community.' The senior officer said the investigation remains open and has not been upgraded to homicide. 'We haven't ruled anything out. We're still looking at everything from murder, to suicide or an accident of some kind,' he added. Mr Jonsson's fiancee Kristjana Gudjonsdottir had arrived in Dublin just a few hours before he disappeared, having missed the first day of the poker tournament. Gardaí searched Santry Demesne last year after receiving anonymous letters regarding Jon Jonsson. Photo: Frank McGrath He left the hotel on foot at about 11am and was seen on camera by CCTV 200 metres away. Beyond that image, no trace of him has ever been uncovered, despite several intensive searches and gardaí following up more than 350 lines of enquiry. The 41-year-old did lose some money while playing poker in Dublin, but not a significant amount, Det Supt Brady said. 'Jon was playing poker in games where the buy-in was about €500. We believe he lost between €3,000 and €4,000. We've also established that the money he lost was sent over within a few hours from people in the poker scene in Iceland,' he said. 'It has been suggested to us by people that he could have come to some harm by people involved in criminality. We've followed up every avenue and there are lots of theories.' Gardaí also spoke to Mr Jonsson's family in Reykjavik. The family had previously criticised aspects of the garda investigation. 'We had meetings with some members of the family and also interviewed some of them. We built bridges. They have gone through huge heartbreak for the past six years. No family should have to go through that. We are here to try and get answers for them,' Det Supt Brady said. 'It is a joint investigation and the co-operation has been top class' 'Jon was a nice guy. He wouldn't harm a fly. He was a very big man but not an aggressive man. He was not an angry person. It doesn't appear feasible to us that he would have gotten into a fight.' Det Supt Brady praised the assistance gardaí received from the Icelandic police. 'It is a joint investigation and the co-operation has been top class. We sent a list to the Icelandic police investigators of the people we wanted to speak with, and we carried out 46 formal interviews out of the 58 people we identified,' he said. Missing Icelandic man Jon Jonsson News in 90 Seconds - June 28th The Sunday Independent previously reported about how an imprisoned criminal in Iceland played an 'instrumental' role in communicating a dramatic version of events to Icelandic police — which, it was claimed, culminated in the murder of the taxi driver. In 2020, police in Iceland were told that Mr Jonsson was killed 'by accident' by a fellow countryman, after a falling out over squandered gambling money. His family, meanwhile, believe he may have been murdered by a paid hitman in a case of mistaken identity. It is being examined whether this potential hitman intended to target a different Icelandic man who was visiting Ireland at the time. In April, gardaí in Dublin carried out four new searches with cadaver dogs. This followed the receipt of new information, after RTÉ aired a podcast series on Mr Jonsson's disappearance. 'I would still appeal to anyone who attended that poker tournament, or with any information, to come forward to gardaí or the Icelandic police,' Det Supt Brady said.
Irish Independent
7 hours ago
- Irish Independent
From the Kerry archives, June 30, 2000: A Sonny Knowles riot, King Puck statue & farewell to Mercy Sisters
A near riot breaks out at Sonny Knowles concert Sonnuy Knowles fans are still recovering from the shock of the near riot which broke out in the John Mitchel's clubhouse on Saturday night and which led to seven people being hospitalised. Fights broke out at the end of the concert while a local performer was on stage. Eye witnesses said that a group of young people, both men and women, suddenly turned on each other and began throwing bottles, ash trays and anything else they could find. Gardaí made one arrest on the night but witnesses said there was a core group of at least 15 people directly involved in the fighting. The incident, which occurred after Sonny Knowles had left the stage, was particularly shocking for the large number of middle aged, and elderly people who had expected an enjoyable night out. John Mitchels Chairman Denis Boyle said the club was sorry for anyone who was upset on the night. But he said the night was a success up to the point when fighting broke out. "The night was a success as far as we are concerned and we are going to be holding other nights for people in the locality. There are people who are prisoners in their own homes, so our price structure was right for them with £3 tickets,' Mr Boyle said. "We looked after people. We got taxis for them and we drove older people home and they were delighted. They didn't know what happened as it was only later on," the added. One woman in her fifties, who was caught up in the middle of the fighting with her friends, said it was the most 'terrifying experience that I have ever had.' "A large group of people just started fighting at the end of the concert, a disaster at the end of a lovely evening. It could have been a lot worse because of the age group alone. The majority of people were from 40 years old to 80 years old. For people of that age to be trampled is just not on,' she said. "My friend got a belt of an ashtray. Her her was pulled and her face was burned by the ashes. Another friend got hit by a bottle when she was coming out of the toilet and had to go to the hospital,' she said. The eyewitness said she was too scared to leave the building, even when the fight died down, in case she came across the aggressors. "There should have been more security, without a doubt, in such a packed hall,' she said. "At the moment, I am frightened to go out and I don't I will ever put my foot in John Mitchel's again,' she said. Killorglin to cast King Puck in bronze for millennium Killorglin's annual Puck Fair – which attracts huge numbers of tourists to the town every year – is to be greatly enhanced with the erection of a £32,000 bronze sculpture of King Puck in the town. The Killorglin Millennium committee applied to the government for funding for the statue under the national millennium project. But when the submission was not successful, the committee decided to go ahead with the plans to erect the bronze statue, which is one and a half times the size of a real goat. Valentia Island native Alan Ryan Hall – famous for his statues of Charlie Chaplin, and Charles, de Gaulle in, other areas of South Kerry – has been commissioned to sculpt the statue. According to Jacinta Browne, chairperson of the committee overseeing the project, the sculpture is expected to begin construction in the autumn. "Located as it is on the Ring of Kerry, this win be an emblem for the town when it is done. But it will take a lot of work and a lot of fundraising will have to be carried out," she said. Wonderful plans have been assembled .and the statue will be located on a huge boulder in front of the town which has made him King," she added. Ms Browne said that the idea was borne out of local people's views and aspirations for the town for the millennium year. A group was set up with the idea of coming up with a suitable project for the town and the result is the statue of King Puck. "We have an enthusiastic group of people behind us," Ms Browne said, "but we need a lot of money for the project. We have some promises of money and some has been collected to date but there has been no government money allocated so there is a lot to be collected still." She appealed to people to assist in the funding of what will be a landmark project for the town. She added that the visual impact of the sculpture will be stunning with the river, bridge and town as a backdrop, the McGillycuddy Reeks to the south and the Sliabh Mish mountains to the north of it. "As the sculpture stands at the gateway to South Kerry, it will enhance not only Killorglin, but the rest of the region as a place to be seen and explored," she said. The first main part of the fundraising will take place on August 4 at the Fishery restaurant when a Lord Mayor will be elected for the town. Three local men – Paudie Cronin, Brendan Moriarty and Kevin Goggin – will compete for the honour. A number of other fundraising events have been organised including the Flag Day, which will take place over the August Bank Holiday weekend. Puck Fair itself which runs from August 10 12 will incorporate a number of fundraising events, all which aim to come up with the money for the unique project for Killorglin. Last Mercy Sister Says Farewell An important chapter in the history of Ballybunion was brought to a close this week when the last Mercy Sister attached to St Joseph's primary school, Sister Maire NI Dhúbhda, said farewell to her former pupils and teaching colleagues. The Mercy Sisters have been associated with teaching the young people of Ballybunion both in St Joseph's primary school and secondary school since 1888, but the nuns announced last year that due to falling vocations, they would be closing their Ballybunion convent. Castlegregory born Sr Maire, who was principal of St Joseph's for eight years, was the last link between the Mercy Order and the school and as she told The Kerryman, it was a very emotional day for her. "The nuns have been gone from Ballybunion since last August and now that I have resigned as principal, the last link has been severed. But I would like to think that the Mercy ethos in the school lives on," she said. "Obviously it's a sad day but I have some lovely memories to keep me going. I always found it a very friendly school and I settled in here very quickly and made a lot of memories over the years.' The convent building at the rear of the school has been sold, but the school itself will remain open, with 130 pupils. Joan Lyons, the first lay teacher who was appointed at the school in 1967 has been appointed principal.
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
Value of sanctions against Irish landlords for breaches reaches highest rate ever, RTB figures show
The value of sanctions against Irish landlords for breaches of rental law has grown to its highest rate ever, according to new figures released by the Residential Tenancies Board (RTB). In 2024, it published 75 sanctions with a total value of €238,299. This is almost four times higher in monetary value than what it gathered in 2023, at €64,360. In July 2019, the RTB was given new powers to investigate and sanction landlords who engage in breaches of rental law, known as improper conducts. The significant increase in the value of sanctions issued against landlords last year came amid renewed focus within the RTB investigations unit on a smaller group of landlords seen to be repeatedly breaching rental laws. READ MORE In a statement to The Irish Times, the RTB said the work 'involved detailed investigations into complex company structures and rental arrangements that were designed to avoid detection and enforcement of rental law'. 'It involved prolonged investigative work to access properties, serve legal documents and to find tenants who were willing to speak with the RTB's authorised officers,' the spokeswoman said in response to questions. 'These investigations into deliberate and repeated offenders saw the RTB's independent decision makers award higher levels of sanctions than previously seen,' the board said. Among those sanctioned in 2024 was Marc Godart and his company Green Label Ltd, with eight different sanctions amounting to a total of €26,100 in penalties for various breaches, including failure to register a tenancy. [ Under the eye of landlord Marc Godart: how a tenant who objected to CCTV surveillance was evicted Opens in new window ] Another notable case from 2024 was that of Anuj Katyal, who received a sanction of €15,000 for a failure to comply with rent pressure zone (RPZ) requirements at an address in Liffey Valley Park, Lucan, Co Dublin. Landlords John and Patricia Keeling also received a sanction of €15,000 for a failure to comply with RPZ requirements at an address in Derham Park, Balbriggan, Co Dublin. The RTB has published 36 sanctions to date in 2025 with a total value of €102,490, including its highest value single sanction yet on a Dublin-based landlord. Sweet Home Accommodation Ltd, run by Renato Passos, was fined €22,000 for a breach of rental laws at six city centre properties under his control. Investigators established he had failed to register 20 tenancies in properties on Leeson Street, Middle Abbey Street and Upper Abbey Street. During the course of its investigation the RTB discovered Brazilian students were being targeted through language schools and on social media about properties Mr Passos did not actually own but was sub-letting. Investigators found there was extensive overcrowding at multiple properties run by him, with bunk beds crammed into makeshift apartments, mattresses laid on floors and livingrooms converted into bedrooms. In one property, there were 15 people sharing one kitchen. Former tenant Julia Langneck, who lived at a property sublet by Mr Passos on Bolton Street in Dublin 1, told The Irish Times 'it was not really human at all, it was really terrible'. She detailed sharing a room with four other people, all in bunk beds, and paying almost €400 a month in rent. When the house became infested with bedbugs and the landlord asked for tenants to pay to have them removed, Julia decided to move out. However, Mr Passos withheld her deposit. This led to her taking a case against him with the RTB, which ordered him to pay the deposit and damages as part of its dispute resolutions process. The RTB subsequently began its own independent investigation into Mr Passos when media reports detailed serious overcrowding and unstable tenancies in properties he was leasing on Leeson Street. This investigation then led to the €22,000 sanction.
