Political violence in KwaZulu-Natal: Why Moerane Commission recommendations remain unimplemented
Image: Bongani Hans
The recommendations of the Moerane Commission, which investigated the spate of political killings in KwaZulu-Natal, are gathering dust without being implemented seven years after they were released, while the killings continued unabated.
Former premier Willies Mchunu said one of the recommendations was the establishment of an independent panel, which was to forge peace within and among political parties.
Mchunu established the Advocate Marumo Moerane SC-led commission in October 2016 during the peak of political killings, which at the time exceeded 150, to identify their root cause and how they could be eliminated.
He said Moerane suggested that the panel should help politicians, who would normally kill each other for tenders and positions.
However, the establishment of the panel would require funding.
'Only the government, which keeps taxes, should be doing this,' he said.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Premier Thami Ntuli and the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) in the province had not yet responded to requests for comment.
Mchunu, who was the premier between 2016 and 2019, said he could not establish this panel because his term of office was running out.
The issue of political killings after the commission's recommendation was topical at the Pietermaritzburg High Court on Monday when the NPA and defence lawyers debated it during Sibusiso Ncengwa's mitigation of sentence.
Ncengwa will be sentenced next Monday after he confessed to the killing of the former ANC Youth League secretary-general, Sindiso Magaqa, who was an ANC councillor at the Mzimkhulu Municipality when he was gunned down in 2017.
In his affidavit, Ncengwa confessed that he and his fellow hitmen were hired by the former mayor of the Mzimkhulu Municipality, Mluleki Ndobe, who was also ANC's Harry Gwala Region chairperson, and other senior officials, including a municipal manager, to eliminate Magaqa.
Magaqa's sin was that he was about to spill the beans on the corrupt-riddled tender to build a local memorial hall.
He was executed in broad daylight at a car wash on July 13, 2017. Other councillors who were with him survived with bullet wounds.
The assassins were paid a total of R620,000 and also promised a R1 million tender.
The State and the defence had agreed to a jail sentence of less than life on condition that Ncengwa would soon testify against the people his affidavit implicated.
Ndobe committed suicide on November 6, 2020, while the assassin, Jabulani Mdunge, who allegedly shot Magaqa with an AK-47 obtained from a crime intelligence officer, was later killed in a shootout with police.
Mchunu said the political killings in the province would not end as long as there are political parties' elective conferences, and general, local government, and by-elections, because politicians were greedy for power and material benefits.
'For those things (power and benefits), they will continue to fight one another to the extent of even killing one another.
'That is why there should be an independent programme to teach those who are participants in politics about how to conduct themselves civilly.'
Mchunu said the provincial government should consult Moerane and the African Centre for the Constructive Resolution of Disputes (ACCORD) for advice on how to establish the peace-making body.
During the court proceeding on Monday, NPA's Advocate Elvis Gcweku and Ncengwa's advocate, Andrew Matlamela, spoke about the political killings continuing after the Moerane Commission.
People who testified at the commission about Magaqa's murder were lined up as witnesses in the murder trial.
'When I perused the commission's report, there was an opening quotation that says, 'something is rotten in the state of Denmark'.
'That commission was clearly describing the state of KwaZulu-Natal in respect of the political killings,' said Ngcweku.
He said the commission concluded that Magaqa's killing was linked to the corruption in Mzimkhulu Municipality, whose hall's construction took a long time than expected to be completed, while money had already been spent.
Magaqa demanded progress in the construction and also proposed forensic investigations, and that the matter be debated at the council.
'What is common about the killing of politicians in KwaZulu-Natal is the issue of tenders and corruption within the municipalities,' said Ngcweku.
He cited the killing of Sduduzo Magwaza, an ANC chairperson in Ward 102, north of Durban, as an example that, after Moerane had concluded his work, killings continued.
Magwaza's murder in November 2021 was also connected to tenders.
'Similarities between this case (Magaqa) and that case (Magwaza) are that the comrades kill other comrades using hitmen,' Ngcweku said.
Matlamela said the ANC was rotten when it came to political killings, which the party has refuted.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
2 hours ago
- IOL News
Mathews Phosa: They did not call David Mabuza 'The Cat' for nothing
The ANC top six which emerged from the 54th ANC national conference in 2017 - deputy secretary-general Jessie Duarte, secretary-general Ace Magashule, chairperson Gwede Mantashe, president Cyril Ramaphosa, deputy president David Mabuza and treasury-general Paul Mashatile. Image: Picture: Motshwari Mofokeng/IOL Former Mpumalanga premier, Dr Mathews Phosa, has paid tribute to former deputy President David Dabede Mabuza who also hailed from Mpumalanga and also previously served as premier of the province from 2009 to 2018. IOL reported on Thursday that Mabuza died in hospital at the age of 64. He served as deputy president during President Cyril Ramaphosa's first term at the Union Buildings. On Friday, as tributes continue to pour for the man nicknamed 'The Cat' in South African politics due to his survival instinct, Phosa described Mabuza as a shrewd politician who contributed significantly to South Africa. 'He was a very shrewd politician. They call him the cat, not for nothing, he had many political tricks which entertained people. It got him where he got at the end of the day,' Phosa said in an interview with broadcaster Newzroom Afrika. As tributes pour in, many people are remembering Mabuza for his skillful maneuvering at the African National Congress (ANC) 2017 elective conference at Nasrec in Johannesburg, where the then Mpumalanga premier became kingmaker in Ramaphosa's path to the Union Buildings. Widely believed to be a backer of contender Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma, Mabuza at the last minute threw his decisive weight behind Ramaphosa, a move which earned him the second-in-command position in South Africa. Reminiscing on the thriller conference, Phosa said Mabuza consulted him before making the tough decision. 'DD was initially standing with Nkosazana. I remember when we stood outside the conference room, he said what do I do? I said we have thrown our lot with comrade Cyril. He said he was being pulled this way and that way. I said to him it is a democracy and he had a right to choose, and he must decide and follow his heart. He supported comrade Cyril Ramaphosa," said Phosa. 'That is how the whole vote was swung against Nkosazana.' Mabuza and Phosa did not always have a rosy relationship. In 2017, IOL reported that Mabuza, then premier of Mpumalanga, lost his R10-million defamation lawsuit against Phosa, who is also former ANC treasurer-general. Former ANC treasurer-general, Mathews Phosa. Newspapers. Image: Timothy Bernard / Independent Judge Bill Prinsloo in the High Court in Pretoria not only dismissed the claim, but he also slapped Mabuza with a punitive costs order. Mabuza claimed Phosa defamed him in a spy report, which was published in the media, when he was already the premier of Mpumalanga. He claimed Phosa was the author of the report in which the premier was made out to be an apartheid spy. It contained claims that Mabuza was involved in the murder of former ANC activist Portia Shabangu. She was assassinated in the 80's by the controversial head of Vlakplaas, Eugene de Kock. Phosa earlier testified that he never compiled the so-called spy report. He said an unmarked envelope was found on the veranda of his White River farmhouse. Inside the envelope was a document which later became known as the so-called spy report. 'I was shocked by its content and worried about it, as it referred to the premier. The allegations were so serious that I decided to hand it over to the ANC top structures. If the allegations were true, the report could harm the ANC leadership. Only a traitor of the ANC would hide it from them.' Phosa said he forwarded the report to then ANC secretary-general Jessie Duarte, as before this she had visited him to discuss party issues. At the end of the meeting Duarte, out of the blue, asked him 'who is this David Mabuza', he said. Former deputy secretary general of the ANC, Jessie Duarte. Image: Nhlanhla Phillips/Independent Media 'When I held office as premier of Mpumalanga, I appointed Mabuza as education MEC and he served under me as part of my executive cabinet.' After this Phosa did not hear anything until a reporter phoned and asked him whether he knew that Mabuza was going to sue him. Phosa denied that he had anything to do with the report and said his former butler, Jan Venter – who is at the centre of this dispute – lied when he implicated him (Phosa). Venter testified that he overheard Phosa 'concocting' the spy allegations against Mabuza. But the controversial butler twice switched sides. In the end, Judge Prinsloo ruled that he could not find that Phosa was the author of the document. Meanwhile, President Ramaphosa has also paid tribute to his former deputy, Mabuza. Ramaphosa conveyed his condolences to Mabuza's family. "On behalf of government and the nation, I offer my profound condolences to the late deputy president's wife, Mrs Mabuza, and their children. I extend my condolences to deputy president Mabuza's friends and the people of Mpumalanga whom he served as Premier from 2009 to 2018, and previously as a member of the executive council of Mpumalanga across a range of portfolios." He said Mabuza had a deep commitment to the liberation struggle and to the nation's development as an inclusive, prosperous, democratic state.
Daily Maverick
3 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Political entrepreneur and provincial boss — The Cat with nine lives, David Mabuza, has died
David Mabuza excelled as a political entrepreneur and provincial boss, building a foundation for what he hoped would eventually propel him to the Union Buildings as president. South Africa's former deputy president David Mabuza has died at 64 years old in Mpumalanga after a short illness, President Cyril Ramaphosa announced on Thursday, 3 July 2025. As deputy president to Ramaphosa until early 2023, Mabuza left no particularly remarkable legacy that is publicly and widely acclaimed. But Ramaphosa praised his 'leadership and mobilisation abilities in his role as the Leader of Government Business in Parliament; leading the South African National Aids Council (and) coordinating anti-poverty initiatives'. Ramaphosa also praised Mabuza's lifelong activism: he was a student activist with the Azanian Students Organisation (Azaso) and later became a teacher in what would later become Mpumalanga. The province is where his political life is written as premier and where he rose to national prominence. Herein lies his true political obituary too. Mabuza excelled as a political entrepreneur and provincial boss, building a foundation for what he hoped would eventually propel him to the Union Buildings as president. For a while, it looked like that would happen, but Mabuza died defeated by the very political chess game he was once master at. A teacher by profession, Mabuza perfected the art of power politics once the ANC came to power and when provinces became fiefdoms for regional politicians. With unprecedented access to provincial fiscal capital, he, along with the Free State's Ace Magashule and the North West's Supra Mahumapelo, turned this capital to power and the three became what was known as the Premier League of the ANC. Because constituencies in the ANC are crafted by how many branches are built at ward, regional, district and provincial structures, the more you blow up branches and sign-ups, the greater your power. Mabuza clicked to this and ballooned the relative ANC backwater province to its second largest after KwaZulu-Natal, thus propelling himself into a national power-broker position in the party. He was reverentially called 'DD' by his comrades who were in awe of his money, power and tactics as a different culture gripped the ANC once it fell victim to the sins of power and incumbency. It mattered nothing to his admirers and those who emulated him that the province was beset by the grand corruption that would later become known as State Capture for the entire time he was premier from 2009 to 2018. Mpumalanga is now a beautiful basket case, as are the Free State and North West, all testimony to how the Premier League refashioned their stewardships for mass extraction and enrichment that has never yet properly been tallied. The outcomes are however clear in the development deficits in the hinterland where all the provincial fiscal transfers should have made more meaningful dents in rural poverty. Mabuza seemed untouchable despite multiple scandals, thus earning him the moniker 'The Cat'. He claimed an assassination attempt or attempts and was treated in Russia for alleged poisoning 10 years ago and then again in 2021, according to reports. It would fill many pages to go into full detail of what his political reign is renowned for. As an education provincial minister in 1998, the province suddenly grew its matric pass rate in utterly implausible multiples from 51% to 72%. This earned it the moniker 'Mamparalanga' for the wool that the politicians tried to pull over the country's eyes. Political assassinations of whistle-blowers started in earnest in Mpumalanga in the run-up to the 2010 World Cup when corruption around the Mbombela Stadium construction cost. In 2009, a substantial amount of cash (between R4-million and R14-million) was stolen from Mabuza's home in a crime not yet fully explained. In 2018, the New York Times published a long-form investigation into school building corruption in the province. The businessman Fred Daniels has campaigned for more than a decade, alleging Mabuza used his position to usurp land by organising sham protests and occupations. The list goes on and on. The most devastating account of Mabuza's reign as Mpumalanga premier is by the journalist Sizwe Sama Yende who covered most of the late politician's time in office. He writes in the book 'Eerie Assignment' about the growth of political assassinations and the climate of fear that gripped the place. Sama Yende himself faced an attempted hit. Mabuza contested and won the deputy presidency by throwing in his lot with the reformist Ramaphosa in 2017, who, with The Cat's support, then trounced Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma, an RET (radical economic transformation) candidate. Mabuza changed his game as his big prize — the Presidency — came into view. He became a more conventional politician, sometimes even showing statesmanlike qualities. The deputy president was loyal to Ramaphosa, taking on assignments with performative diligence if without political enthusiasm — he was also ill for a large part of his tenure. But Mabuza wasn't cut out for straight-up governance and seemed to thrive instead in the cloak and dagger of regional politics. His desire for the top job was cut short by a campaigning Paul Mashatile who became ANC deputy president in 2022, leaving Mabuza an also-ran. Mabuza quit soon after, returning to his Mpumalanga farm. His family foundation is well known for its philanthropy and support for differently abled people. David Dabede Mabuza was born in Phola, Mpumalanga, on 25 August 1960 — he died on 3 July 2025 and is survived by his wife Nonhlanhla Patience Mnisi and his children. He served as South Africa's deputy president from February 2018 until his resignation in February 2023. DM
The Herald
3 hours ago
- The Herald
You should have withdrawn from GNU: Mbeki's open letter to Steenhuisen
Former president Thabo Mbeki has penned a scathing open letter to DA leader John Steenhuisen, saying he would have found it logical for the DA to withdraw from the GNU. Mbeki labelled Steenhuisen and DA federal council chair Helen Zille 'arrogant' after the party's decision to pull out of the national dialogue. In the 11-page letter, Mbeki said it was clear that the DA had serious problems with President Cyril Ramaphosa and the ANC concerning the functioning of the GNU after Ramaphosa removed deputy minister of trade, industry and competition Andrew Whitfield of the DA. 'It is also obvious that despite this you and the DA decided that you will not withdraw from the GNU and it is established that instead with the final straw ... you and the DA have decided not to participate in the national dialogue,' he said. Mbeki criticised Zille's statements that the dialogue was an ANC campaign strategy. He said the dialogue had absolutely nothing to do with Zille's 'fertile imagination of an ANC's 2026 election campaign, or what you called an ANC-run national dialogue'. 'And as you know, Zille, and therefore presumably the DA's view, is that the absence of the latter from the 'Parliament of the People' will make the Parliament 'a sham' and 'a hollow exercise'. It is very good that, at last, Zille has openly expressed her eminently arrogant and contemptuous view of the masses of the people, that these cannot think and plan their future correctly, without the DA. 'That, presumably, is also the view of the federal leader of the DA who must have felt very proud when he announced that effective immediately, the DA will therefore 'have no further part in this process. We will also actively mobilise against it.' I hope that in time the DA will explain to the people why it signed up to the commitment in the statement of intent of the parties in the GNU that parties commit to an all-inclusive national dialogue process, whereas, as Zille said, she had been very opposed to it from the start.' Mbeki said he would like to assure Steenhuisen that representatives of South Africans would attend the dialogue, adding that he was confident the dialogue would make historic and seminal contribution to the efforts to chart a way forward for the country. 'I sincerely hope that all political leaders and the parties they lead will recognise the inalienable reality that the people are our country's sovereign authority ... As I have said I have no doubt that the DA acts against its own direct interests when it decides to isolate itself from its sovereign authority when the latter decides to engage in a national dialogue to determine our countries (sic) future,' he said. He said the national dialogue was borne (sic) out of a 2016 agreement by the FW de Klerk, Thabo Mbeki, Helen Suzman, Desmond and Leah Tutu, Kgalema Motlanthe and Robert Sobukwe foundations who formed the National Foundations Dialogue Initiative with the dialogue as one of its objectives. He said while the ANC had agreed to a national dialogue, he advised the party that civil society would not agree to participate in the process led by the ANC and the GNU, proposing that instead the matter should be led by foundations. Ramaphosa then constituted a group of 4/5 people to engage the foundations, he said. He added that the national dialogue preparatory task team, made up of Nedlac executives, the foundations and four presidency officials, will cease to exist after it hands over the reins to the national convention in August. Mbeki said the ministry of finance should provide the funds necessary to hold the dialogue over and above donations from interested parties. 'In fact, the costs of the preparations to date have been borne by the foundations themselves while the day-to-day work relating to the national dialogue has been carried out by volunteers who are committed to building a better South Africa. These are men and women who are ready to lead the way in ensuring that citizens claim their agency,' he said. He said that the preparatory team believed that various matters would arise during the dialogue which will require action from government without having to wait for the dialogue's conclusion. This, he said, was why Ramaphosa appointed an interministerial committee to be on standby to act on those matters. 'It would seem to me that the DA is also saying that the people have forfeited the confidence to the DA. Perhaps the DA ... should distribute leaflets along the Nelson Mandela Boulevard in Cape Town telling the people that they should redouble their efforts to win back the confidence of the DA or face dissolution,' he said.
