IMF warns tariffs aren't the answer to global imbalances
In its annual External Sector Report, which assesses imbalances in the 30 largest economies, the IMF noted that external surpluses or deficits were not necessarily a problem, but could cause risks if they became excessive.
It said prolonged domestic imbalances, continued fiscal policy uncertainty, and escalating trade tensions could deteriorate global risk sentiment and elevate financial stress, hurting both debtor and creditor nations.
The report took aim at US President Donald Trump's imposition of higher import tariffs against nearly every trading partner, which his administration says is aimed at increasing revenues and righting longstanding trade deficits.
'A further escalation of the trade war would have significant macroeconomic effects,' it said, noting that higher tariffs would reduce global demand in the short term and add to inflationary pressures through rising import prices.
Rising geopolitical tensions could also trigger shifts in the international monetary system (IMS), which in turn could undermine financial stability, it said.
BT in your inbox
Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox.
Sign Up
Sign Up
This year's report, based on 2024 data, showed the widening of global current account balances was due largely to increased excess balances in the world's three largest economies – the United States, China and the euro area.
The deficit in the United States widened by US$228 billion to US$1.13 trillion or 1 per cent of global gross domestic product (GDP), while China's surplus increased by US$161 billion to US$424 billion and the euro surpluses expanded by US$198 billion to US$461 billion.
In an accompanying blog, IMF chief economist Pierre-Olivier Gourinchas said excessive surpluses or deficits stemmed from domestic distortions, such as overly loose fiscal policy in deficit countries and insufficient safety nets that caused excessive precautionary savings in surplus countries.
Changes aimed these domestic drivers – not tariffs – were needed, he said. That meant China should focus on boosting consumption, Europe should spend more on infrastructure and the US needed to reduce large public deficits and rein in fiscal spending, he said.
The report was based on data collected before approval of a massive tax cut and spending bill, which the Congressional Budget Office on Monday said would add US$3.4 trillion to the US deficit over 10 years, causing further pressure.
'Public deficits in the United States remain excessively large and the recent broad depreciation of the Chinese yuan – together with the US dollar – runs the risk of widening current account surpluses in China,' he wrote.
Rising tariffs had little impact on global imbalances, Gourinchas said since they tended to reduce both investment and savings in the tariffing country, leaving current account balances little changed.
Uncertainty about tariffs could also undermine consumer and business confidence, increase financial market volatility and lead to persistent appreciations of the US dollar, the IMF report said. However, it noted the dollar had depreciated 8 per cent since January, its largest half-year decline since 1973.
It acknowledged the continued dominance of the US dollar, but said growing geoeconomic fragmentation could pose risks in the future, and recent weaker demand for US Treasuries could reflect concerns about the US fiscal trajectory.
Increased use of China's yuan in international trade and finance, a 'softening in the United States' role as world banker and insurer' and the emergence of alternative payment systems and private digital assets could eventually lead to changes in the use of international currencies.
'While the risks of serious dislocation in the IMS remain moderate, rapid and sizable increases in global imbalances can generate significant negative cross-border spillovers,' Gourinchas wrote in the blog.
'A major risk for the global economy is that countries will instead respond to rising imbalances by further raising trade barriers, leading to increased geoeconomic fragmentation. And while the impact on global imbalances will remain limited, the harm to the global economy will be long-lasting.' REUTERS
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
an hour ago
- Business Times
China's 1.2 trillion yuan dam project lifts metals markets, but isn't a quick fix for glut
[SINGAPORE] China's launch of a 1.2 trillion yuan (S$218.5 billion) mega-dam project in Tibet has energised metal markets, though analysts warn that its long timeline and China's construction downturn would limit the impact of immediate demand. Ferrous markets rallied sharply this week following the Saturday (Jul 19) groundbreaking ceremony attended by Chinese Premier Li Qiang. Iron ore futures for October delivery on the Singapore Exchange surged as much as 4.9 per cent this week, and Shanghai steel futures jumped almost 4 per cent on Thursday from pre-announcement levels. As the world's largest and most costly hydropower dam, the output of the Yarlung Tsangpo River project would treble that of the Three Gorges Dam and generate an estimated 300 trillion watt-hours of electricity annually, supporting power demand in Tibet and the rest of China. The electricity generated each year would be more than five times the amount of electricity consumed in Singapore in 2024. According to estimates by Chinese ferrous markets trade monitor LGMI Steel, the dam is expected to drive six million tonnes of steel consumption – far surpassing the Three Gorges Dam's steel usage of 70,000 tonnes – due to the Tibetan Plateau's complex landscape and harsher climate conditions requiring greater steel intensity. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up Macquarie Group's commodities strategist Florence Sun estimated that demand for steel could be around three to five million tonnes, featuring a mix of rebar and various special steels, given the unique geographical environment. She also noted that the cost of the new dam would be 4.5 times that of the Three Gorges Dam. While the project will generate substantial demand for ferrous metals such as iron ore and steel, its five- to seven-year construction timeline on the Yarlung Zangbo River means the impact will be gradual rather than immediate, given staggered procurement over the build period, noted Edward Meir, senior metals analyst at Marex. He expects steel and cement to see the biggest demand boost from the project, with modest growth of copper demand for power transmission. Meanwhile, a struggling construction sector continues to drag on ferrous metal demand, said Sabrin Chowdhury, head of commodities at BMI. 'More such projects will be necessary to bring about a sustained rise in metals demand,' she noted. Similarly, in a note on Tuesday, Citi Research highlighted the long construction timeline and limited front-loaded demand, with the usage of metal to be spread over many years. However, the project still reflects China's medium to long-term plans for large-scale, long-distance power transmission infrastructure. 'Although precise copper and aluminium consumption from the associated transmission lines remains unclear, ultra-high voltage corridors, especially aluminium-intensive ones, will be needed to deliver power to eastern and southern China,' wrote the team. Power-grid related metals would thus see continued demand growth over the coming years, noted the team. 'Anti-involution' (fan nei juan) rhetoric Beyond the mega-hydropower project, the recent ferrous complex rally has been fuelled in part by China's 'anti-involution' campaign targeting industrial overcapacity. Over the past fortnight, iron ore, coking coal and coke all posted gains as markets anticipated supply-side reforms. Citi Research wrote in a Jul 15 note: 'The anti-involution campaign aims to break the cycle of destructive price wars and chronic overcapacity that have plagued Chinese industry profitability.' This policy push has drawn comparisons to the 2016-2017 supply reforms that sparked a historic iron ore rally. China's ferrous complex has been struggling with a persistent supply-demand imbalance, particularly as property sector weakness continues to weigh on demand for construction materials, while supply expands amid damaging price wars. With production capacity still outstripping demand, traders appear to be pricing in expectations that Beijing will force meaningful capacity rationalisation. However, the research team does not expect a repeat of the 2016-2017 playbook, given different fundamentals. 'We see the current rally in the steelmaking ingredient as unsustainable and short-lived.' China's policymakers have been advocating a more measured approach to urban planning and upgrades, which are expected to be less steel-intensive than the full demolitions and property upcycles that spurred the previous ferrous rally. The 'anti-involution' rhetoric has been emphasised directly by China's top leaders, underscoring the country's urgent need to break out of the deflationary cycle. In a meeting chaired by President Xi Jinping on Jul 1, the Central Finance and Economic Affairs Commission said Beijing needed to 'guide enterprises to improve product quality and promote the orderly exit of outdated production capacity'.

Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
Sustaining Sri Lanka's reforms critical to safe-guarding macroeconomic stability, IMF says
Find out what's new on ST website and app. Supported by a US$2.9 billion (S$3.7 billion) programme from the International Monetary Fund, Sri Lanka is gradually recovering from its worst financial crisis in decades, triggered by a record dollar shortage in 2022. WASHINGTON - Sustaining Sri Lanka's reform momentum is critical to safeguarding the country's macroeconomic stability, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) said on July 25 after its staff concluded a visit to the island nation. Supported by a US$2.9 billion (S$3.7 billion) programme from the global lender, Sri Lanka is gradually recovering from its worst financial crisis in decades, triggered by a record dollar shortage in 2022 . Sri Lanka's economy grew by 5 per cent in 2024, and the World Bank predicts it will post 3.5 per cent growth in 2025. But the island nation needs to tackle global headwinds from 30 per cent US tariffs, which could impact about $3 billion in exports . Colombo is in talks with Washington to attempt to reduce the tariff rate before it is implemented on Aug 1. 'While the economic outlook is positive, downside risks have increased on the back of potentially high tariffs on Sri Lanka's exports, persistent trade policy uncertainty, and heightened geopolitical tensions,' said Mr Evan Papageorgiou, IMF Mission Chief for Sri Lanka, said in a statement after wrapping up a visit to Colombo this week. Any shocks from the US tariffs will be addressed within the IMF programme, he added. Sri Lanka's upcoming budget, expected to be presented to Parliament in November, will need to include stronger tax revenues and lower public spending to maintain a primary balance target of 2.3 per cent of GDP in the medium-term, the IMF said. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore MRT service changes needed to modify 3 East-West Line stations on Changi Airport stretch: LTA Singapore HDB resale price growth moderates in Q2, more flats sold Singapore Etomidate found in blood of 2 people involved in fatal Punggol Road accident in May: HSA Asia Live: Thailand-Cambodia border clashes continue for second day Business Microsoft Singapore managing director Lee Hui Li dies while on sabbatical Singapore Private residential home prices up 1 per cent in Q2: URA Life Navigating tight carparks in bigger and bigger cars Singapore Kopi, care and conversation: How this 20-year-old helps improve the well-being of the elderly 'Monetary policy should remain prudent and prioritise price stability,' the statement said backing continued central bank independence. Sri Lanka held its benchmark interest rate steady at 7.75 per cent on July 23, but the central bank chief said further easing was possible as the island nation awaits the outcome of tariff talks with the US. Apparel, Sri Lanka's second-largest foreign exchange earner, is particularly exposed – the sector exports 40 per cent of its output to the US and brought in $4.8 billion in 2024. It employs around 300,000 people, most of them women. REUTERS

Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
China's premier tells EU leaders ‘we can't afford' massive industrial subsidies
Find out what's new on ST website and app. Chinese Premier Li Qiang with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen at the end of the EU-China Business leaders symposium in Beijing on July 24. BEIJING - Chinese Premier Li Qiang dismissed EU fears over Beijing's allegedly excessive subsidies to its industry, telling the bloc's leaders 'we can't afford it' in markedly candid remarks during a tense summit. Speaking during a roundtable with EU chief Ursula von der Leyen on July 24, Mr Li insisted that 'China is by no means doing what some call a subsidies policy or fiscal subsidies'. 'China is not as rich as Europe, and we can't afford it,' he said. 'We would not be stupid enough to use the fiscal funds accumulated through the government and the hard work of our people to sell our products to foreign consumers,' Mr Li added. Dr von der Leyen and European Council President Antonio Costa were in Beijing on July 24 for a summit dominated by tensions between the EU and China over trade and Russia's war in Ukraine. Chief among the bloc's concerns was its yawning trade deficit with China , which stood at around US$360 billion (S$461 billion) in 2024. The EU has also raised fears that Beijing's vast subsidies to its industry could help it undercut European competitors with a flood of cheap exports to the continent. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore MRT service changes needed to modify 3 East-West Line stations on Changi Airport stretch: LTA Singapore HDB resale price growth moderates in Q2, more flats sold Singapore Etomidate found in blood of 2 people involved in fatal Punggol Road accident in May: HSA Asia Live: Thailand-Cambodia border clashes continue for second day Singapore Private residential home prices up 1 per cent in Q2: URA Singapore Ex-cop faces 15 charges over sex offences involving at least 6 boys, allegedly made child porn Business Singapore factory output grows at faster pace of 8% in June, better than expected Singapore Kopi, care and conversation: How this 20-year-old helps improve the well-being of the elderly Mr Li, China's No. 2 official, rejected those claims in a roundtable with the EU's leadership. 'Some enterprises, especially manufacturing enterprises, feel more deeply that China's manufacturing capabilities are too strong, and Chinese people are too hardworking,' the Chinese premier said. 'Factories run 24 hours a day,' he said. 'Some people think this will cause some new problems in the balance of supply and demand in world production,' the Chinese premier said, admitting: 'We see this problem too.' Mr Li also rejected claims the Chinese economy – plagued by sluggish growth for years now – was in dire straits. 'Of course, there are difficulties and challenges, but it is difficult for us to say that China's economy is in a downturn,' he said. 'Our GDP growth rate is always above five per cent,' he insisted. AFP