AAIB slams global media for ‘irresponsible' reporting based on selective, unverified claims
Yugandhar said that the preliminary report only attempts to only provide information on what happened in the crash, and that it is too early to arrive at any definite conclusions, adding that the final report will contain the root causes of the crash. This is Yugandhar's first public statement since the fatal air crash, and comes at a time when speculation is rife over the probable causes of the accident—the worst aviation disaster involving an Indian airline in four decades.
'While the accident of this dimension has drawn public attention and shock, however, it needs to be appreciated that this is not the time to create public anxiety or angst towards safety of Indian Aviation Industry, particularly on the basis of unfounded facts,' Yugandhar said.
The AAIB DG also said that the AAIB will also publish updates of technical and public interest 'as and when required'. Scarce flow of official information, absence of regular updates and briefings on the investigation were flagged by a number of experts and industry watchers. According to the AAIB chief, the investigation into the crash—'the most devastating accident in recent aviation history'—is being undertaken in a 'rigorous and most professional manner' as per AAIB Rules and international protocols.
'It is essential to respect the sensitivity of the loss faced by family members of deceased passengers, crew of the aircraft and other deceased persons on ground. It has come to our attention that certain sections of the international media are repeatedly attempting to draw conclusions through selective and unverified reporting. Such actions are irresponsible, especially while the investigation remains ongoing. We urge both the public and the media to refrain from spreading premature narratives that risk undermining the integrity of the investigative process,' Yugandhar said.
The AAIB's preliminary investigation report, released a month after the accident, said that the Air India Boeing 787-8 aircraft crashed after both its engines were starved of fuel as the two fuel control switches transitioned from 'RUN' to 'CUTOFF' position within a second of each other moments after lift-off. From the cockpit voice recorder data, the preliminary probe report notes that one of the pilots asked the other why he cut off the fuel, to which the other pilot responded saying he did not.
To be sure, the report doesn't mention that fuel control switches—which allow and cut fuel flow to the plane's engines—moved physically, and uses the term 'transitioned' to describe the change of mode from RUN to CUTOFF. It also does not state these were moved by either of the pilots. However, the selective information presented in the report had many believing that it implicitly pointed a finger at the pilots.
'The purpose of the AAIB's investigation and preliminary report is to provide information about 'WHAT' happened. The preliminary report has to be seen in this light. At this stage, it is too early to reach to any definite conclusions. The investigation…is still not complete. The Final Investigation Report will come out with root causes and recommendations,' he added.
Top officials of the aviation ministry, experts, and industry insiders maintained that jumping to any conclusion at this early stage of the investigation just based on limited information in the initial report wouldn't be appropriate. There is a long way to go for the investigation and a lot could change as the probe progresses over the coming months, they said. The report, too, clearly mentions the disclaimer that it is based on 'preliminary facts and evidence', and that the information it contains is 'preliminary and subject to change'.
According to experts, the investigators should now focus on unearthing the cause behind the transitioning of the fuel control switches, which are used to allow and cut fuel supply to the engines. There is considerable speculation on whether the switches were flicked by one of the pilots—inadvertently or otherwise—or whether the transition signal to the system was due to any technical, mechanical, or software issue. The report did not issue any recommendation to other operators of the Boeing 787-8 aircraft and its GE engines, suggesting that at this stage, the investigators do not have a reason to believe that there was any issue with the plane or its engines.
Sukalp Sharma is a Senior Assistant Editor with The Indian Express and writes on a host of subjects and sectors, notably energy and aviation. He has over 13 years of experience in journalism with a body of work spanning areas like politics, development, equity markets, corporates, trade, and economic policy. He considers himself an above-average photographer, which goes well with his love for travel. ... Read More
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Wire
33 minutes ago
- The Wire
Fauja Singh: The ‘Turbaned Tornado' Who Stayed Committed to His Passion For Running Even at 114
Culture Fauja Singh's cremation will take place on Sunday, July 20, at his native village Beas in Jalandhar district, Punjab. Jalandhar: Fauja Singh, the 114-year-old turbaned Sikh, a global name that would remain etched in the history as the oldest marathon runner in the world, had a desire to breathe his last in his native village Beas Pind in Jalandhar district, a reason why he had started living there for the last five years post pandemic. ' Meri maut Punjab ch howe (I want to breathe my last in Punjab', he had been telling his family members who settled in the United Kingdom, Canada and the United States. Fauja Singh died in a hit and run case on the Jalandhar-Pathankot highway on Monday, July 14, after he was hit by a Toyota Fortuner driven by Canada-based NRI Amritpal Singh Dhillon. The cremation will take place on Sunday, July 20, at his native village. The plush house of Fauja Singh in the middle of fields at Beas Pind, Jalandhar. Photo: Kusum Arora While the Jalandhar Rural Police arrested the accused the very next day, Fauja Singh's family was heartbroken at the apathetic behavior of the accused. 'We are thankful to the police for acting swiftly in our case. The police tracked the accused within a day just because my father was a global figure. However, the fact is that had they been acting tough against the traffic violators, many accidents would haeve never taken place. The accused fled the spot without caring to save my father,' said Harbinder Singh, the son of Fauja Singh. Famously known as 'Turbaned Tornado' for completing nine full marathons and breaking his own records every time, Fauja Singh set benchmarks in life with commitment to values like humility, simple food, farming and the ability to overcome setbacks. Born in Beas village on April 1, 1911, Fauja Singh started running at the age of 89 in international marathon events. His first race was the London marathon in 2000. However, as a child he started walking at the age of five. From the year 2000 to 2012, he ran in London, Toronto and New York marathons. He was also the torch bearer of the 2012 London Olympics. Fauja Singh announced his retirement during the Hong Kong marathon in February 2013. He was awarded the British Empire Medal by Queen Elizabeth II in the year 2015 and Ellis Island Medal of Honour, by the National Ethnic Coalition, a US group in 2003. Family members of late marathoner Fauja Singh show a photograph of the latter meeting with late Queen Elizabeth II, at his native home, in Jalandhar, Punjab. Photo: PTI Coming from a family of farmers, Fauja Singh took to farming early in his life with his parents and picked life lessons. Behind his passion for running was the story of the loss of one of his sons, Kuldip Singh, who died after the dhaba roof they were constructing suddenly fell on him. Seeing him devastated after the sudden demise of his son and that of his wife Gian Kaur later, Fauja Singh's family decided to take him to the UK in 1993. It was in the UK that Fauja Singh started going for walks all alone, sometimes in a formal suit, an unusual sight, when a chance meeting with his coach Harmandar Singh brought a 180-degree shift in his life. After that, there was no looking back and Fauja Singh's name became synonymous with marathons. Talking to The Wire, Paramjit Singh, the US-returned nephew of Fauja Singh shared how post Covid-19, he had started staying in his village. He would say jokingly, 'I do not want to come back in a coffin (from abroad).' 'Fauja Singh went to Canada in March 2024 but came back within a fortnight telling everybody that he wants to go back to his village. At home, his routine included walking around the fields, running and meeting people in the village. Even at the ripe age of 114, he used to walk and run for eight to 10 hours every day, a feat which is next to impossible for any elderly person', he said. Paramjit Singh said that Fauja Singh was a brand ambassador of not just marathons but also simplicity. His life will serve as an inspiration for generations to come, he said. 'Despite being a UK citizen, he remained attached to his roots and ate simple vegetarian Punjabi food: in the morning he had alsi di pinni, which is flax seed ladoo made in desi ghee with dry fruits and jaggery and tea, then one chapati, dal, sabzi three times a day. He also had milch animals at his home, giving him the luxury of homemade curd, lassi and desi ghee', he added. Family and friends gather for condolence meeting at the courtyard of Fauja Singh's house in Beas Pind, Jalandhar. Photo: Kusum Arora With a sense of pride, Paramjit Singh mentioned that Fauja Singh was the first turban-wearing Sikh to win marathons in the world. 'There are many firsts attached to his name but he always remained grounded. He was also the oldest marathon runner to have ever appeared in an Adidas ad 'Impossible is nothing' in the year 2004 along with David Beckam and Mohamad Ali', he said, adding that he always attributed his success to rabb, the almighty. Highlighting his philanthropic side in an obituary in The Indian Express, former state information commissioner of Punjab, Khushwant Singh, who has also authored his biography titled Turbaned Tornado: The Oldest Marathon Runner Fauja Singh, shared how Fauja Singh donated the endorsement fee from Adidas-sponsored Marathon to a UK-based charity called Bliss. During the 2016 Mumbai Marathon, he sent the fee amount from the Nestle to Pingalwara Trust in Amritsar, a home for the orphans and the destitute, Khushwant Singh wrote. Not just the endorsement fees, he would also donate cash showered on him in various gurdwaras as a mark of honour in the cash box. Balbir Singh, a family friend of Fauja Singh, who was the first to rush him to the hospital after the accident, told The Wire that when People's Walk against Drugs was held in Jalandhar in December 2024, he ran and walked for 20 kilometres at the age of 113. 'We kept pleading him to stop and sit in the car but he was comfortable, astounding everybody with his stamina', he added. Harbinder Singh said that during the farmers' protest, as part of Doaba Kisan Sangharsh Committee, a farmer union, he stayed at Singhu border while Fauja Singh and other villagers donated a solar panel, when the government had snapped power supply to the farmers. 'Apart from ration and funds, we took a solar panel in a tractor to Singhu border ensuring power supply to the farmers', he shared. Fauja Singh's plush house in the middle of fields in Beas village was also a testimony to his love for farming and life in the lap of nature. His house adorned two Pilkan trees, under which he used to spend his summer days and a mango tree, where his mornings began by picking the best mangoes. Fauja Singh's shoes bearing his name, which he used to wear daily for walking and running in the village. Photo: Kusum Arora His granddaughter Japneet Kaur (16) shared how Fauja Singh was fond of mangoes, so much so that he used to hide them in the house for natural ripening but then forget quite often. 'We found a mango kept in his almirah in his clothes two days after his death. Every morning, he used to pick the best mangoes and hide them in the house for ripening,' she said. Japneet also shared that despite being illiterate, Fauja Singh could do his signature in Urdu language. 'He learned to sign in Urdu, a rare talent these days. For the past some time, I was teaching him English alphabets and he had learned it till 'H'. I also taught him how to pronounce the alphabets and he would keep repeating A, B, C, D whenever he saw me….,' she said with a smile on her lips and grief in her voice. Showing his marathon shoes bearing his name, which he used to wear daily, Japneet said, 'Quite often he would look at his shoes and point towards his name, Fauja Singh, with a smile. He loved walking and running and he left the world doing what he loved the most – a walk around the village.' The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Governor Kataria to attend Fauja Singh's cremation on July 20
Punjab governor Gulab Chand Kataria will attend the cremation of world-renowned marathoner Fauja Singh, who died at the age of 114 after being hit by a vehicle, at his native Beas village in Jalandhar district on Sunday. Fauja Singh, famously known as 'Turbaned Tornado' and 'Sikh Superman', was killed in a hit-and-run accident in Jalandhar district's Beas village on July 14. (HT) Kataria remained an admirer of Fauja Singh, attending anti-drug campaigns with him in Punjab in December last year. Fauja Singh, famously known as 'Turbaned Tornado' and 'Sikh Superman', suffered fatal head injuries on July 14 after a white Toyota Fortuner hit him while he was crossing a road in his village. He passed away later that day. Singh was the world's oldest marathon runner, and had become a global symbol of endurance and healthy aging. The accused driver, Amritpal Singh, 26, a Canada-based NRI from the nearby Dasupur village, was arrested by police on July 15. He is facing charges under Section 105 (culpable homicide not amounting to murder), 281 (rash driving) and 125-A (endangering life or personal safety of others) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita. Amritpal had come from Canada eight days before the accident and recently purchased the Toyota Fortuner (PB 20-C-7100) from a Kapurthala resident.
New Indian Express
an hour ago
- New Indian Express
Two arrested for duping doctor of around Rs 15 lakh in digital arrest scam
NEW DELHI: A 31-year-old former bank employee was arrested from West Bengal for arranging accounts for cyber fraudsters who duped a Delhi-based doctor of over Rs 14 lakh through a digital arrest call. Another person, who gave his account details, was also nabbed from Bengaluru. The accused have been identified as Mohammad Sahin Khan (31) and Buddhadev Hazara, both residents of West more such complaints —two from Maharashtra, two from Gujarat, two from Telangana, one from Delhi, one from Andhra Pradesh, one from Kerala and one from Karnataka —got linked to the account numbers of accused for fraud with the same modus operandi. A case of cyber fraud was reported in the Central district by a Delhi-based doctor who stated that he was deceived by an imposter posing as a government official. The victim reportedly received a fraudulent digital arrest call and was forced to transfer Rs 14.85 lakh under the threat of legal action. During the investigation, it was found that the cheated amount was transferred on February 26 to a bank account held in the name of SK Rice Wholesaler and Trading and another individual. Police traced the location of the accused in Bengaluru, Karnataka, and apprehended Khan on July 2 from near Victoria Hospital, a senior police officer said. The accused disclosed that he had provided his bank account details to Hazara. He received a commission of `Rs 1.5 lakh from Hazara, who was arrested in Kolkata. During interrogation, Hazara said that he initially worked in the loan departments of various banks. Later he met John from Barrackpore, West Bengal, and began arranging corporate accounts for online fraud on commission. Hazara earned `3 lakh for facilitating Khan's account and split the amount equally with him, according to the officer. Further investigation is underway to locate John and to trace other suspects linked to the racket. Efforts are being made to recover the cheated money and examine the financial trail.
