Arrest made in 2016 homicide without witnesses; state seeks pretrial detention
On July 21, State Attorney Amira Fox, accompanied by Fort Myers Police Chief Jason Fields, announced her office has filed second-degree murder charges against Joseph Carrozza, 33, of Fort Myers.
Carrozza remained in custody without bond set by publication for the Oct. 6, 2016, slaying of a 22-year-old man. Jail records indicate authorities arrested him July 18.
Murder conviction reaffirmed: Judge reaffirms murder conviction of Fort Myers man who shot neighbor days after argument
Police found the victim on the sidewalk at Cypress Court Apartments, off Veronica S Shoemaker Boulevard.
According to Fox, Carrozza shot the victim several times on the stairs that led to his apartment.
"There were no witnesses to this actual shooting, but there were other information from other witnesses that helped piece the crime together," Fox said.
Fox said the State Attorney's Office's Cold Case Homicide Unit had been working the case for more than a year with police, taking statements from witnesses and analyzing evidence gathered by police and prosecutors.
They also worked with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement to analyze cellphone devices.
"Joseph Carrozza was a dangerous violent offender that has finally been brought to justice to answer for this crime," Fields said. "Even after his arrest, this case will remain active to ensure a complete and thorough investigation."
Court records show that on July 19, Assistant State Attorney Leena Marcos filed a motion for pretrial detention, where prosecutors will present evidence, hoping Carrozza will remain in custody without bond until his trial. The hearing is set July 22 before Lee Circuit Judge Bruce Kyle.
Tomas Rodriguez is a Breaking/Live News Reporter for the Naples Daily News and The News-Press. You can reach Tomas at TRodriguez@gannett.com or 772-333-5501. Connect with him on Threads @tomasfrobeltran, Instagram @tomasfrobeltran, Facebook @tomasrodrigueznews and Bluesky @tomasfrodriguez.
This article originally appeared on Fort Myers News-Press: Nine years, no witnesses, but arrest made in 2016 Fort Myers murder
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
5 minutes ago
- Yahoo
The MSNBC host described how pro-Trump AI bots are 'malfunctioning' over what to say about the Epstein files.
A network of MAGA bots has no idea what it's supposed to say about Jeffrey Epstein, much to the amusement of Rachel Maddow. The MSNBC host on Tuesday unpacked new reporting from NBC News about hundreds of X accounts that use artificial intelligence to send automated replies showing support for right-wing messaging. With Trumpworld deeply divided on the so-called 'Epstein files,' the bots, which are supposed to mimic MAGA talking points, have been glitching out. Some would post contradictory messages from the same account, calling for the release of the documents while also calling for the matter to be put to bed.
Fox News
8 minutes ago
- Fox News
Colorado dentist drugged wife years before alleged poisoning murder, friend testifies
Angela Craig's lifelong best friend took the stand Monday as the Colorado murder trial of dentist James Craig entered its second week, telling jurors that the mother of six was never the kind of woman who gave up easily. "She wasn't a risk-taker. She wasn't manipulative," Nicole Harmon told the court. "And she never said anything — ever — about wanting to die." Dr. James Toliver Craig, 47, is charged with first-degree murder in the March 2023 death of his wife, 43-year-old Angela Craig. Her cause of death was determined to be lethal doses of cyanide and tetrahydrozoline. On March 9, 2023, approximately one week before the 43-year-old was pronounced brain-dead, Angela texted Harmon asking for help checking her blood sugar. When she arrived, she found Angela curled up. "She hadn't eaten. She couldn't stand," Harmon said, telling the jury that James had made his wife a shake that morning. When the friend texted and asked what was going on, she testified, James brushed it off. "Post-COVID," he texted. "Not diabetes." Not once, she told jurors, did he mention poison. "Angela never knew what was killing her," the witness said. Harmon shared that she and her husband, Mike, had known the Craigs since the 2000s. Angela was hospitalized for five days. Through Angela's prolonged hospital stays, Harmon said that she never expressed that she wanted to die. Harmon's testimony went back to 2019, when the witness said James made a confession to her and her husband. He told them in 2019 that he planned to inject himself with a lethal substance and had drugged Angela first so she wouldn't stop him. David Gelman, a criminal defense attorney who has been following the case, told Fox News Digital that the drugging incident could help the prosecution "because it shows that James was predisposed to drugging Angela before." "It required intent and thought. The same motive that the prosecution has now for James," he said. "That is an aspect I would really hammer if I'm the prosecution." James also admitted to the Harmons that he, in 2019, was dealing with a "sexual addiction," and told them that he was in therapy, she testified. Angela, her friend said, never brought it up. Harmon testified that she sent Angela a message later: "I'm sorry. I didn't know you were dealing with this." Angela replied: "You weren't there when I needed you." From that moment, the decades-long friendship fractured. "She was angry," Harmon said. "Really mad at her life and how it was turning out. And I was OK with that. I was OK with her taking it out on me." Gelman said the years-long gap in communication between Angela and her best friend doesn't undermine the witness's reliability. "It doesn't hurt her credibility. She can only testify by what she has observed and her conversations with Angela," he said. "Obviously, she is not privy to the inner workings of the marriage with James since the relationship fractured, but her credibility is still intact since she was not confused or crossed up on the stand." The longtime friend testified that Angela never opened up about the inner workings of her marriage. "She had all the chances," the witness said. "She never told me. She didn't want me to see her husband differently." READ THE INCIDENT REPORT – APP USERS, CLICK HERE GET REAL-TIME UPDATES AT THE FOX NEWS TRUE CRIME HUB Investigators alleged in court documents obtained by Fox News Digital that, in the weeks before his wife's hospitalization and death, James used a dental office computer to search for "undetectable poisons" and how to obtain them (later purchasing arsenic and cyanide by mail), "how many grams of pure arsenic will kill a human" and "is arsenic detectable in an autopsy?" Alongside these online searches, investigators alleged he made YouTube queries such as "how to make poison" and "Top 5 Undetectable Poisons That Show No Signs of Foul Play." Fox News Digital has reached out to James Craig's lead attorney, Lisa Fine Moses, for comment.
Fox News
8 minutes ago
- Fox News
Progressive DA who dismissed alleged sex offender's attempted kidnapping charges faces recall petition
A dispute over crime policies in Aurora, Colorado, has led to the recall attempt of a newly-elected district attorney. Aurora Councilwoman At Large Danielle Jurinsky is attempting to have Arapahoe County District Attorney Amy Padden removed from office after several high-profile instances of what she says are inadequate crime policies, including the recent dismissal of charges against Solomon Galligan, an alleged registered sex offender who is accused of trying to kidnap a child on video. "What has been going on over the past six months, several different things," said Jurinsky. "She has dismissed cases that absolutely should have been prosecuted. She has given out a lot of probation for felony crimes, misdemeanor crimes, crimes that should have warranted several years in prison." Galligan, 33, faced one count of attempted kidnapping after he allegedly tried to snatch an 11-year-old boy from a playground at a local elementary school. Aurora police previously reported that Galligan is a registered sex offender, with his registration tied to the Pueblo County Sheriff's Office. He was found incompetent to stand trial, which in the state of Colorado, means he must be released from custody, Padden's office told Fox News Digital earlier this month. "From what I understand is that I don't know how else to put it, but that Amy Padden went shrink shopping to find someone to make sure that they would say that Solomon Galligan was not fit to stand trial," Jurinsky, an Aurora native, military veteran and business owner told Fox News Digital. "My knowledge of this individual is they have been found mentally incompetent multiple times on previous criminal cases in different judicial districts outside [Arapahoe County]," Ross said. "So there is a history of documented mental illness. It's not like this is a one-and-done where this person has never been on anyone's radar, and they found somebody to write them a note to say that they're mentally incompetent." "And instead of coming out and saying that Amy Padden is at least going to hold this individual in the state mental health hospital, she just makes a statement that charges are going to be dismissed, and this individual is going to be released," said Jurinsky. "She is trying to now walk that back and say that Solomon is going to go to the state mental health hospital, but not giving a timeline, not giving any information." Eric Ross is the Public Information Officer for the Arapahoe County District Attorney's Office. "Regarding the Galligan case, we cannot take a case to trial when a defendant has been deemed mentally incompetent," he told Fox News Digital. "We are required to adhere to state law which requires charges be dismissed. With that said, the defendant is being permanently committed to a mental institution." However, Jurinsky said Galligan's release isn't the only issue, noting that she's been observing a pattern of soft-on-crime policies since Padden took office six months ago. "The situation with Kaitlyn Weaver, beautiful 24-year-old Aurora resident, was on her way home from work, broad daylight, was T-boned by a 15-year-old in this country illegally with two small children in the back of the van as well," Jurinsky noted as another example. "He stole the van from his mother. Kailtyn Weaver was killed instantly." The unnamed teen was offered a plea deal and given probation for the crime. "The original charge was for vehicular homicide and the guilty plea was for Vehicular Homicide," Ross said. "Contrary to what the general public may think, vehicular homicide charges do not carry the same penalties as first or second-degree murder." He said citizens can petition their elected leaders if they want "stricter penalties for these types of cases." As for the recall, which will be formally announced Tuesday, Padden says everything is in place. "We have formed our committee. We have registered it with the secretary of state. It has been approved with the county clerk," she said. "And then at that moment, we will begin raising money. We don't need a lot of money for this effort, but we will need some to print the petition packets and probably hire some signature gatherers. And then we will be well underway. I will be the first signature on that petition, and we will be underway to getting 75,000 [signatures] out of Arapahoe County." The 75,000 mark is the threshold for officially recalling Padden. Jurinsky and her supporters have 60 days to acquire the signatures. If they succeed, Padden will have five days to decide whether she will resign, or whether she will run for her seat again. Jurinsky said she doesn't think garnering the signatures will be a challenge, and plans on hosting events and even going door-to-door as part of the effort. "If you hurt somebody in the city of Aurora, I'm an Aurora City Council member," she said. "I need to be standing up for the people of Aurora. And that means protecting them. That means focusing on public safety. So I take on a lot of extra duties, if you will. And sometimes that's alone. I'm OK with that." Ross says he's reached out twice to Jurinsky seeking other examples of cases she believes were not handled properly, but has not heard back. In 2024, Aurora was also subject to a suspected Tren de Aragua gang takeover of an apartment complex, which became a rallying point for then-candidate Donald Trump's reelection bid. A spokesperson for the city of Aurora said neither the city nor its Mayor Mike Coffman, a former Republican congressman, have anything to do with the recall, and declined to comment further. Padden did not return a comment request.
