logo
Letby barrister: US death row inmates have better shot at freedom than wrongfully convicted Britons

Letby barrister: US death row inmates have better shot at freedom than wrongfully convicted Britons

Telegraph05-04-2025
Mark McDonald is sitting in the Great Hall refectory at Lincoln's Inn, demolishing a jerk chicken, surrounded by a 'Who's Who' of barristers and judges.
Since taking on the case of Lucy Letby, the barrister has been rocking boats in the legal establishment with a string of press conferences protesting the nurse's innocence and is refusing to keep a low profile.
'I have a black-tie reception here tonight with Lady Justice Thirlwall,' he says, speaking of the judge conducting the public inquiry into how Letby could have been stopped.
'Let's see if she talks to me.'
Mr McDonald believes keeping the case in the public eye is the only way to beat a system that is wholly stacked against those who are wrongly convicted. For him, the mills of justice are not just grinding slowly but are often coming to a complete standstill.
Letby is serving 15 whole-life orders after she was convicted of killing seven babies and attempting to murder seven others at the Countess of Chester Hospital between 2015 and 2016. She has already been in jail for five years.
This week, Mr McDonald submitted a 700-page report from a panel of world-leading experts to the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC), which deals with potential miscarriages of justice.
The experts insist there were no murders or attacks, simply a perfect storm of poor care, prematurity and natural illness. The Telegraph is now calling for the CCRC to send the case back to the Court of Appeal.
'If I cannot prove, with all these experts, that these convictions are unsafe, then the criminal justice system is in a poor state of affairs,' said Mr McDonald.
'What it would mean is that if you're innocent and wrongly convicted in this country, you've got no chance.
'I spent a lot of time working in America with inmates on death row, and I am reaching the conclusion that if I was wrongly convicted I'd rather be an American than an English person.
'They have an effective court of appeal, because if they get it wrong someone dies. We all thought things would get better after the Birmingham Six or the Guildford Four. But it didn't, it actually got worse.'
If Mr McDonald is not toeing the line like a traditional barrister it is because he isn't one. He grew up on an inner-city council estate in Birmingham and left school at 16 to become a sheet-metal worker.
He later trained as an operating theatre assistant, working for the NHS for 14 years, which he says gave him first-hand experience of how things can go wrong in hospitals. He had to put himself through night school to gain the A-levels needed to study law.
In 2007 he founded the London Innocence Project, a non-profit working to exonerate those wrongfully convicted and helped found Amicus, a charity working to represent inmates on death row in the US.
After working in Palestine with the Bar Human Rights Committee he founded the Labour Friends of Palestine and the Middle East, and made an unsuccessful bid to become MP for Stoke in 2019.
He recently adopted two children with his wife Sarah Macken, the chief executive of Telespazio UK, who herself has stood as a Conservative candidate in Wolverhampton and East Ham.
The Letby case is a natural fit for Mr McDonald, who is also defending Ben Geen, a nurse serving 30 years for killing two of his own patients and harming 15 others at Horton General Hospital in Banbury in 2003 and 2004.
He has also fought hard to clear Michael Stone, who was convicted of the murders of Lin and Megan Russell and the attempted murder of Josie Russell in Chillenden, Kent in 1996.
Serial killer Levi Bellfield has confessed to the murders on two occasions, giving explicit details of the attacks, and a case review is ongoing. But Stone is still in prison despite there being no supporting forensic or witness evidence.
Similarly, nobody saw Letby do anything. Doctors became suspicious because she was on duty when each of the babies collapsed or died.
' There was no direct evidence, no forensic evidence, no CCTV evidence, no motive, no post-mortems identifying any issues and everything that happened at the time was seen to be a natural death,' said Mr McDonald.
'This is not the case where something went wrong at trial and the convictions are unsafe because of a problem with the way that the jury were directed, or something like that.
'This is a case where no crime was actually committed, which means she's innocent.'
Since her conviction, dozens of doctors, nurses, statisticians, law experts and scientists have come forward to criticise the way evidence was presented to the jury, including Lord Sumption, the former Supreme Court judge, who last weekend said Letby was 'probably innocent'.
Letby has already been denied the leave to appeal on two occasions, and the barrister is anticipating a lengthy review process. But he believes if the case is referred back to the Court of Appeal, the prosecution will have a far tougher job than last time.
His panel of experts includes Prof Neena Modi, a former president of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, Prof Mikael Norman, the founder of the International Society of Evidence-Based Neonatology, and Prof Helmet Hummler, the senior medical director for the European Foundation for Care of Newborn Infants.
'They're going to have to get experts of a far better quality than they had at trial to match that of the experts that have come forward because I have 24 of them, and I will call all of them because we have to expose what's gone wrong here,' he said.
'I mean, if you're a neonatologist working at Leicester Royal Infirmary would you want to go up against this lot? Because I'll fly them over from Tokyo and Sweden and Germany and Canada. I will call them all.'
Chester Police and the Crown Prosecution Service argue that Letby's original defence team could have called experts at her trial to make all the points that are now being raised.
Mr McDonald says it is not so simple. Experts are frightened to get involved in contentious cases, particularly baby killings, and some have been referred to the General Medical Council for speaking up in Letby's defence.
'In these types of cases you cannot use experts in England, they won't go against the establishment,' he argues.
'So you have to go to North America, you have to go to mainland Europe and unless you know that you are always going to get the wrong experts. They will do a report for you but they will always ultimately agree with the prosecution.'
It is notable that while Mr McDonald has been the public face of the campaign, Letby herself has remained largely in the background. She has never spoken about the case outside of the trial and police interviews and has refused requests to meet or correspond with journalists.
'She has read every report and she is on top of this completely, and she is feeling more hopeful,' he said.
'I've not gone down the path of talking about her as a person because that's what happened throughout the trial, they focused on her rather than focusing on the evidence.
'The evidence is she was one of the most experienced nurses on that unit. She loved her job. She worked all the hours God sends and did extra shifts.
'So yes, she was always there because that is what she did, that was her job, and yes she got the sickest babies because she was asked to look after the sickest babies, because she was one of the most experienced nurses.'
He added: 'I think one of the most concerning things is there but for the grace of God go any of us.
'Your child falls over and you take it to A&E and you get someone saying 'well I think this is a non-accidental injury', your child dies in the middle of the night and someone is saying you did it.
' Nurses don't want to work any more and frankly, I don't blame them.'
The CCRC can only refer cases to the Court of Appeal if there's a 'real possibility' that a conviction or sentence will be overturned.
But the Law Commission is consulting on whether that bar is too high and looks set to recommend that reviewers should focus on their own view, rather than trying to predict the court's response. The dial may be about to shift in Letby's favour.
The changes could not come soon enough for Mr McDonald.
'The criminal Court of Appeal needs massive reform, and I believe that there are innocent people in prison who are being failed by our system,' he said.
'There is still a reluctance to overturn what a jury has decided.
'I'm hoping now that in Letby they will see what I think many people in the country now see, that this is a concerning, unsafe conviction that needs to be overturned.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Ibiza Rocks events resume just days after second Scot plunges from balcony
Ibiza Rocks events resume just days after second Scot plunges from balcony

Daily Record

timean hour ago

  • Daily Record

Ibiza Rocks events resume just days after second Scot plunges from balcony

Evan Thomson from Aberdeen, and Gary Kelly from Dundee, both died this month after falling from their hotel balconies in Ibiza. Ibiza Rocks have resumed their events just days after a second Scot plunged to his death from a balcony at the hotel. ‌ Evan Thomson, from Aberdeen, fell to his death from his balcony on Monday July 7. The 26-year-old tragically fell from the sixth floor while on holiday celebrating his birthday. ‌ Just two weeks later, on Monday, Gary Kelly, 19, from Dundee died after he fell from the third-floor of the hotel just after midnight. ‌ Following their tragic deaths, Ibiza Rocks announced they would be suspending all events. We told on Thursday, however, the hotel were still selling party tickets despite saying they were pausing future events. ‌ And bosses have now confirmed investigations have concluded - with their schedule set to resume tomorrow. A statement from Ibiza Rocks read: "Over the past week, we've focused on supporting those sadly affected by recent incidents and paused our events programme out of respect for that process. "During this time, we've taken the opportunity to review the strong safety measures already in place across the hotel and look at where we can go further. As we always have, we continue to work with independent inspectors, external experts and listen to feedback from our team, guests and the wider community to keep improving and strengthening our approach. ‌ "We're also being clearer about our expectations around respectful behaviour and personal responsibility. A safe and positive environment is something we all contribute to, so we're encouraging all guests to look out for their friends, trust their instincts and speak to a member of the team if they need help. " This week, the hotel has remained open, but with a pause on events during initial investigations, which have now concluded. We will begin to resume our scheduled events programme from tomorrow, Saturday July 26. "We're grateful to our guests for their patience and understanding and to our team for their continued care and hard work during this difficult time. ‌ "All ticket holders to events that were suspended have been contacted with information about their ticket(s)." Dizzee Rascal was scheduled to play at the hotel on Wednesday as part of the venue's '20th birthday celebrations' but that was postponed. However, Rudimental are still set to perform on July 30 for the anniversary, with tickets still available to purchase online. ‌ Following Evan's death his loved ones raised questions about the hotel safety, slamming how the party destination handled the situation. Friend Blair Robertson slammed the hotel, saying they tried hard to 'get things back to normal' following the death. ‌ He added: 'Security took us away to front desk. Paramedics didn't arrive for about 30 minutes. Forensic officers didn't speak English. We were just standing there, not knowing what was going on. Reception gave us false hope. "We heard the jet washes cleaning the ground where Evan died. That was the worst thing for us." Meanwhile Evan's sister Teila said there needed to be 'higher safety precautions', adding: "Once it did happen, the hotel's response was just completely heartbreaking; almost as if it never happened. I pray no other family has to go through this." ‌ On Wednesday, Ibiza Rocks issued a safety notice on their social media following the deaths, saying their thoughts 'remained with the families' of Evan and Gary. They wrote: "The tragic incidents of the past few weeks have deeply affected many. We continue to work closely with the authorities and our thoughts and support remain with everyone impacted. ‌ "Much of the hard work that goes into safety and security in hotels and venues across the world happens behind the scenes. With thousands of guests passing through our doors every summer, it takes a collective effort from our team, security and local partners to maximise safety for all. "In times like these, care matters - but so does action. We have zero tolerance for any behaviour that puts our guests or our team at risk and we are building on the strong work we already do to go even further. "Out of respect and privacy for the people involved, we don't usually comment on individual reports posted online, but that certainly doesn't mean we're not always listening. We're committed to working with anyone who raises solid concerns so that we can establish the facts and take the appropriate steps." ‌ Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. The hotel also noted it is working to improve balcony safety. They continued: "Balcony safety is something we take very seriously, and our hotel meets all the applicable building regulations. "Alongside that, we're introducing further safety measures and working to raise more guest awareness to help encourage responsible use and keep everyone safe."

Prime Video fans are bingeing 'high stakes' courtroom drama that makes them 'trust no one'
Prime Video fans are bingeing 'high stakes' courtroom drama that makes them 'trust no one'

Daily Mirror

timean hour ago

  • Daily Mirror

Prime Video fans are bingeing 'high stakes' courtroom drama that makes them 'trust no one'

All eight episodes are available to stream on Prime Video Prime Video fans are binge watching a high stakes court drama that makes them "trust no-one". ‌ Justice on Trial is a gripping new series from judicial icon Judge Judy Sheindlin. Premiering on July 21, fans have already binge watched the show, which sees Judge Judy Sheindlin putting the justice system on trial. ‌ With eight episodes, fans have branded it a must watch for fans of true crime. Judge Sheindlin herself said of the show: "Judges do not make law. They interpret the law. Judges are people. Sometimes they get it wrong. Then what happens? ‌ "When and how long will it take to get it right? I've put justice on trial. I couldn't be more proud of this series. Everybody who watches it will come away a little smarter. Mission accomplished." The judge will visit one of the most personal and complex cases of her career, a diplomatic immunity battle, as well as recreating the chilling case of Archie Dixon, who confessed to murdering his roommate and burying him alive. ‌ A Prime Video synopsis reads: "Judge Judy Sheindlin puts the American justice system on trial in a true crime high-stakes courtroom drama, as she and her expert legal team recreate the trials from notorious cases where following the letter of the law did not necessarily feel 'just.' "Season 1 spans from the 1925 Scopes Monkey Trial to a case in which the convicted killer is currently on Death Row." ‌ And the series has been a hit with fans already. One fan wrote: "Justice on trial is really good, this is just the first episode I'm on, very compelling." Another added: "Check out the show #JusticeOnTrial on @‌PrimeVideo it's a great show." While a different viewer commented: "Justice on trial is really good, this is just the first episode I'm on, very compelling." Elsewhere, another show watcher put: "I enjoyed this show. It is a nice change from civil suits" while a different account put: "This case had my mouth dropping open! We immediately watched the next one!!"

Top Boy actor Micheal Ward charged with rape and sexual assault
Top Boy actor Micheal Ward charged with rape and sexual assault

Metro

time2 hours ago

  • Metro

Top Boy actor Micheal Ward charged with rape and sexual assault

Bafta-nominated actor Micheal Ward has been charged with rape and sexual assault, the Metropolitan Police said. The Jamaican-born English actor and former model, 27, is best known for films Blue Story and The Old Guard and also starred as Jamie in Netflix's Top Boy. In 2020, he was awarded the Bafta rising star award. He is accused of offences against one woman in January 2023, according to police. The force said he is charged with two counts of rape and three counts of sexual assault. Ward, of Cheshunt, Hertfordshire, will appear at Thames Magistrates' Court on August 28, the Crown Prosecution Service said. In a statement, Catherine Baccas, deputy chief crown prosecutor for CPS London South, added: 'Having carefully reviewed a file of evidence, the Crown Prosecution Service has authorised the Metropolitan Police to charge Micheal Ward, 27, with two counts of rape, two counts of assault by penetration, and one count of sexual assault against a woman in January 2023. More Trending 'He will appear at Thames Magistrates' Court on Thursday, 28 August 2025. 'We remind all concerned that proceedings against the suspect are active and he has a right to a fair trial. 'It is vital that there should be no reporting, commentary or sharing of information online which could in any way prejudice these proceedings.' Reps for Micheal Ward have been contacted for comment. This is a breaking news story, more to follow soon… Check back shortly for further updates. If you've got a celebrity story, video or pictures get in touch with the entertainment team by emailing us celebtips@ calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff page – we'd love to hear from you. For more stories like this, check our entertainment page. Follow Entertainment on Twitter and Facebook for the latest celeb and entertainment updates. You can now also get articles sent straight to your device. Sign up for our daily push alerts here. View More »

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store