‘Lowballing' for big public projects to be tackled by new Dáil infrastructure committee
Sean Fleming
, a long-serving Fianna Fáil TD with ministerial experience, has said one area he would focus on would be preventing huge disparities that emerge between the projected cost at the beginning of a project and the actual costs when it is completed.
Examples include the Shannon to Dublin water pipeline, the long-running plan to establish a Metrolink line in Dublin, and the national children's hospital, which is set to cost about four times its initial estimate of €600 million.
Mr Fleming, a TD for Laois, said the practice of lowballing 'undermines public confidence in big projects'.
READ MORE
'Those planning a project will come in with a low figure for a big project, say €500 million. That will allow it to get through the system because it is politically acceptable. The problem is it is not realistic. It does not take into account inflation, or changing standards, or design changes that they should have known would be needed,' he said.
'And then the costs begin to escalate and it ends up costing €2 billion.'
Mr Fleming said that 'with scarce resources they probably feel they can get it through in dribs and drabs rather than as a whole'.
'It's not a good way of doing it. It leads to higher costs and to delays and it angers the public,' he said.
Mr Fleming said he wanted the public to get accurate information on the costs of big projects, their timelines, specifications and completion dates before the project starts.
[
Children's hospital 'never-ending saga', says Opposition after completion delayed until September
Opens in new window
]
His committee, which will also look at all National Development Plan projects, has a wide remit to examine all big public capital and infrastructure projects at the conception stage. He says its purpose is essentially to ensure the public is not led astray on the cost of such big public projects.
He said his committee would be the flip side of the Public Accounts Committee, the public spending watchdog.
'They look back at what was spent or misspent. We are looking forward, making sure we have accountability every step of the way,' said Mr Fleming.
He said the secretary general of the Department of Public Expenditure, David Moloney, would be the first person invited to attend.
The committee would be looking to understand what was involved with every step of big public projects, he said.
He said he was also keen to call in representatives of An Bord Pleanála and the Court Services to examine why significant delays occur when appeals are made against large projects during the planning process.
The committee will be able to examine projects commissioned under all 15 Government departments.
Labour's housing spokesman Conor Sheehan has already written to Mr Fleming asking for the new committee's first action to be issuing an invite to Minister for Housing James Browne to set out his proposals for the Housing Activation Office, the new Government office aimed at speeding up the building of homes to ease the housing crisis.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
18 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Kenmare to take up to $125m charge amid uncertain titanium minerals pricing
Kenmare Resources shares fell on Wednesday as the titanium minerals miner said it expects to take an impairment charge of as much as $125 million (€107.7 million) against its mining assets in Mozambique as it lowered its future revenue assumptions. The Dublin-listed company, which abandoned takeover talks with its former managing director Michael Carvill and Abu Dhabi private equity firm Oryx Global Partners last month, said that pricing for its main product, ilumenite, fell in the first quarter of this year, though it has stabilised since then. The price of zircon and rutile have continued to decline so far this year, Kenmare said in a statement. Shares in Kenmare were down 5.8 per cent in midday trading in Dublin, bringing it close to levels seen before news of the bid approach emerged in early March. READ MORE Ilmenite and rutile are used in the manufacture of everything from paints and plastics to ceramics and textile. Zircon is widely used in the foundry industry. Davy analyst Colin Grant noted that Kenmare booked a $64.8 million impairment charge in the previous commodity price downcycle in 2014. 'Global demand for titanium feedstocks remained robust, supported by improved sentiment among pigment producers outside of China,' Kenmare said. 'This followed the introduction of anti-dumping duties on Chinese pigment producers, which Western producers responded to by increasing plant utilisation rates, leading to anticipated stronger margins and bolstering demand for Kenmare's products.' However, the company, which operates the Moma mine in Mozambique, said uncertainty regarding market conditions in the medium term led it to lower its long-term pricing assumptions and take a charge against its assets. 'While this is disappointing, it will be a non-cash charge with no anticipated impact on our operations, projects or financing facilities or the company's ability to pay dividends,' said chief executive Tom Hickey. Carvill and Oryx's original offer of £5.30 per share – or £473 million (€545.6 million) – was rejected by Kenmare's board in March as undervaluing the company. However, the company allowed the consortium access to its books to carry out due diligence, with a view to improving its bid. Kenmare withdrew from the talks when the consortium indicated last month that it planned to reduce its offer. Mr Carvill, who founded Kenmare in 1986 and stepped down last August, told The Irish Times the that lower proposal was partly down to concerns about titanium minerals prices as the global economic outlook has deteriorated since the initial bid approach, amid concerns about the Trump administration's trade policies and escalating conflict in the Middle East. It also reflected how the Mozambique government is seeking higher mineral processing and exporting royalties from Kenmare, he said. Mr Hickey met with the president of Mozambique in Juen and said that 'constructive discussions' with the government are continuing regarding the extension the royalties contract, or so-called Moma implementation agreement.
Irish Times
18 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Catherine Connolly launches presidential bid saying she wants ‘empower people to find their own voices'
Independent TD Catherine Connolly has launched her bid to become president, saying 'we're at a critical state in our country' and she is standing to 'empower people to find their own voices'. The Galway West TD made the announcement outside Leinster House on Wednesday, flanked by politicians from the Social Democrats and People Before Profit as well as independents who are set to nominate her to appear on the ballot paper. During a press conference she spoke about her vision for the presidency and also defended her record including a trip she took to Syria during dictator Bashar al-Assad's time in power Announcing her election bid, she said: 'I do so with the deep conviction that together, we can make this country better, and that we can make this country live up to its name, the Republic, and show that there is a different way.' READ MORE She said: 'We're at a critical state in our country', and added she was standing 'to enable people, to empower people to find their own voices, to stand up and be counted, to say there is a different way.' Ms Connolly said: 'We must deal with climate change. We must be a voice for peace. We have to stop the normalisation of war and violence. We have to stop the normalisation of homelessness. We have to say that these problems are not inevitable.' She added: 'They are man-made, policy driven, and we can have a different type of country and a different type of world. 'That is what motivates me'. Since it emerged last week that she would be throwing her hat in the ring, a trip she took to Syria in 2018 along with then-TDs Clare Daly , Mick Wallace and Maureen O'Sullivan has resurfaced. At the time, al-Assad was still in office and engaged in a brutal civil war. Asked about the visit, she said she funded the trip herself, its purpose was 'fact-finding' with fellow TDs and activists and she 'met no member of government'. She said she visited a refugee camp outside Damascus and 'saw firsthand the destruction of a whole city', adding: 'I mean, my idea, up to then, of a refugee camp wasn't up to scratch really.' Ms Connolly said they were shown around by Palestinians and 'we stayed with them all of the time'. They travelled to Aleppo and met the Chamber of Commerce and also had a meeting with Unicef as well as visiting a convent. Catherine Connolly launching her presidential bid outside the Dáil on Wednesday. Photograph: Alan Betson Catherine Connolly answering questions from members of the media outside the Dáil on Wednesday. Photograph: Alan Betson Catherine Connolly with supporters as she launches her presidential bid outside the Dáil on Wednesday. Photograph: Alan Betson 'On no occasion had I anything to do with the government, nor did I ever utter one word of support for Assad,' she said. Asked about a perception that she has a combative political style, Ms Connolly said she disputed that and said she would 'rephrase' it, adding: 'I think I've been very straight, honest and direct. I think I'm a very hard worker.' 'If as a society we don't value hard work and straight and blunt talking without any spin, then we're in trouble. 'I don't think I've set out to stir things or to be that type of politician.' She pointed to her time as Leas Cheann Comhairle in the last Dáil, saying: 'I've shown that I've been fair, that I'm able to put aside my strong opinion and function as a Leas Cheann Comhairle.' She said: 'I'm a democrat to my fingertips.' Earlier, she told RTÉ Raidió na Gaeltachta's Adhmhaidin programme that she did not make the decision to contest the election overnight and was doubtful enough about the move, but was convinced by correspondence she got from people asking her to run. 'I was taken aback by the support I received, I wasn't expecting that level of support from people across the country, in English and Irish,' she said speaking in Irish. On Tuesday, Fine Gael's Mairead McGuinness became the first official nominee in the presidential race to replace Michael D Higgins after his term comes to an end in the autumn. Ms McGuinness, who was a TV presenter and farming journalist before becoming an MEP and EU commissioner, is the nominee to become Fine Gael's presidential candidate. [ Profile: The outspoken left-wing campaigner running for president Opens in new window ] The election to succeed Mr Higgins is set to take place in late October or early November. Prospective candidates need the support of 20 Oireachtas members to get on the ballot paper. Fianna Fáil has not clarified if it will run a candidate and is to make a decision in the early autumn. Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald has also refused to rule herself out of the running. Ms Connolly has received the backing of the Social Democrats and People Before Profit, with the Labour Party to 'very seriously' consider backing her. Ms Connolly worked as a barrister and a clinical psychologist before becoming a councillor for 17 years and spending a term as Galway mayor until 2005. She resigned from the Labour Party in 2006 after being turned down to be a running mate of then incumbent TD Michael D Higgins. She was first elected to the Dáil as an independent candidate for Galway West in 2016. Speaking on Wednesday, she said she did not 'fall out' with the Labour Party and said she understood that Labour and Sinn Féin were considering support her, adding she already had the support of more than 20 Oireachtas members. - additional reporting PA
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Family were in ‘complete disbelief' after €250m EuroMillions win as they claim Ireland's biggest ever prize
A family syndicate has officially claimed the largest EuroMillions prize in Irish history, saying they were in 'complete disbelief' when they discovered they had won €250 million. Travel, homes for their children and a potential Rolex are on the cards for the family, they said, though they do not have anything 'outrageous' planned yet. The winners, who have chosen to remain anonymous, purchased a ticket at Clifford's Centra on Shandon Street in Cork City after seeing a sign advertising the €250 million jackpot while picking up a 'few messages'. Although a regular player, one family member said they had not bought a ticket for the previous two draws, adding that they 'didn't think much of it' after purchasing the ticket. While watching the news, the ticketholder saw that someone in Ireland had won. [ The Irish syndicate that beat the Lotto: 'It wasn't illegal to do what they did' Opens in new window ] 'So naturally, I got my ticket and scanned it on the National Lottery app, and a message popped up, 'You've won big, contact the National Lottery.' 'I must have checked it 4 more times, I just couldn't believe my eyes,' they said. The ticketholder ran upstairs to their wife and woke her up before the pair subsequently checked the numbers multiple times on the website. 'We were in total shock, complete disbelief,' they said. They subsequently rang the National Lottery the next morning and received confirmation after several minutes that they had won €250 million. 'Those few minutes felt like the longest of my life,' the winner said, adding that they were in 'total shock all over again,' after it was confirmed. They kept the winning ticket carefully hidden inside an A4 sheet beneath a pile of folded laundry until it could be handed over, they said, while carrying on with their daily routines 'as normally as possible.' Once the winning ticket was handed over, they followed advice to seek independent legal and financial guidance. Travel and homes for their children will form part of their plans with the winnings, they said, adding that they 'won't let this win change us' and plan to remain in Ireland. 'We're absolutely going on a family holiday. We love to travel and there's so many amazing trips we've always dreamed of that we can now make a reality. We're already looking at holiday homes somewhere in the sun.' 'We also feel incredibly fortunate now to be in a position where we can buy homes for our children too,' they said. They also plan to support wider family members and several charities, they said, adding that they do not have anything 'outrageous' planned for themselves yet. One member of the syndicate said they always dreamed of owning a Rolex watch, adding that they went 'window shopping last week'.
